Synthetic dumortierite: its PTX-dependent compositional variations in the system Al2O3-B2O3-SiO2-H2O

Dumortierite, generally simplified as Al₇BSi₃O₁₈, was synthesized in the pure system Al₂O₃–B₂O₃–SiO₂–H₂O (ABSH) using gels with variable Al/Si ratios mixed with H₃BO₃ and H₂O in known proportions as starting materials. Synthesis conditions ranged from 3 to 5 and 15 to 20 kbar fluid pressure at 650° to 880°C. On the basis of analyses, synthetic dumortierite shows relatively narrow homogeneity ranges with regard to Al/Si which, however, vary as a function of pressure: at low pressures (3–5 kbar) Al/Si is 2.77–2.94 versus 2.33–2.55 at high pressures (15–20 kbar). Outside of these homogeneity limits, dumortierite was found to coexist with quartz or corundum, depending on the starting composition. Whereas synthetic dumortierite invaribly contains 1.0 boron atom per formula unit (p.f.u.) based on 18 oxygens, the water contents vary drastically as a function of pressure and temperature (1.32–2.30 wt.% H₂O or 0.85–1.47 H p.f.u.). H₂O is an essential component in dumortierite. Structural formulae based on complete chemical analyses of the dumortierites synthesized reveal that there is invariably an Si-deficiency against the ideal number of 3.0 p.f.u. In the calculation procedure used here, this deficiency is balanced by assuming tetrahedral Al. The remaining Al, taken to occupy the octahedral sites, is always below the ideal number of 7.0 p.f.u. Charge-balancing the structure with the hydrogen found analytically leads to two different mechanisms of H incorporation: (1) 3H⁺ + octahedral vacancy for Al^6]; (2) H⁺ + tetrahedral Al for Si^4]. Dumortierite synthesized at high fluid pressure contains little Al^4] and, thus, little H⁺ of type 2; its hydrogen is predominantly present as type 1. Conversely, dumortierite formed at low fluid pressures is high in Al^4] and hydrogen type 2. The amounts of hydrogen type 1 in low-pressure dumortierites decrease with rising temperatures of synthesis. Typical structural formulae are: (Al_6.670.33)Al_0.49Si_2.51–O_13.53(OH)_1.47](BO₃) for a low-pressure product, and (Al_6.680.32)Al_0.09Si_2.91O_13.94(OH)_1.06](BO₃) for a high-pressure product. Independently of the synthesis conditions, dumortierite was found always to be orthorhombic, with b₀/a₀ deviating slightly, but significantly from the valid for hexagonal lattice geometry. As a function of increasing Al/Si in the synthetic crystals, their a₀, c₀, and V₀ rise, whereas b₀ decreases. Thus b₀/a₀ decreases most sensitively with rising Al/Si and also with growing Al^4]. More experimentation is required before the compositional variations of dumortierite found here can be applied successfully to geothermobarometry of natural rocks.