Oxygen isotopic heterogeneities,their petrological correlations,and implications for melt origins of chondrules in unequilibrated ordinary chondrites

Ten whole chondrules separated from the Dhajala (H3, 4), Hallingeberg (L3), and Semarkona (LL3) chondrites were individually analyzed for bulk element composition by instrumental neutron activation with half of each chondrule subsequently sacrificed for oxygen isotopic analysis and half retained for petrographic and electron microprobe analysis. On a three-isotope plot (δ¹⁷O vs. δ¹⁸O), the chondrules neither cluster near their respective chondrite hosts nor in the vicinities of previously recognized chondrite group averages. Instead, they define a trend resolvable into mixing and fractionation components but dominated by mixing in a manner similar to that previously observed for clasts from the LL3 chondrite ALHA76004. Covariations of chondrule isotopic mixing and fractionation parameters with petrological parameters were sought by two-variable linear least-squares regression analyses. However, the only two isotopic/petrological correlations significant at the 95% confidence level were δ¹⁷O vs. total bulk Fe (r = ?0.68) and mixing parameter,m¹⁸, vs. bulk weight ratio (CaO + Al₂O₃)/MgO (r = +0.67). Other correlations of apparent statistical significance were found by treating the chondrules as separate porphyritic (3 porphyritic olivine-pyroxene, 1 porphyritic olivine, 1 barred olivine) and non-porphyritic (4 radial pyroxene, 1 granular pyroxene/cryptocrystalline) textural subgroups. The reliability of the trends, based on so few samples, is not clear but the results at least indicate that possible existence of distinct isotopic/petrological subgroups of chondrules should be further investigated. Absence of certain isotopic/petrological trends expected as condensation effects argues against direct nebular condensation as the dominant process of chondrule formation. Instead, a model involving melting of heterogeneous solids, followed by various degrees of liquid/gas exchange, is favored. In any case, chondrule oxygen isotopic evolution was dominated by two-component mixing; fractional vaporization was, at most, a second-order effect. In addition to chondrules, parent bodies of unequilibrated ordinary chondrites must have also incorporated a¹⁶O-rich component which might have been fine-grained “matrix”.