Marcasite precipitation from hydrothermal solutions

Pyrite and marcasite were precipitated by both slow addition of aqueous Fe²⁺ and SiO₃²⁻ to an H₂S solution and by mixing aqueous Fe²⁺ and Na₂S₄ solutions at 75°C. H₂S₂ or HS₂⁻ and H₂S₄ or HS₄⁻ were formed in the S₂O₃²⁻ and Na₂S₄ experiments, respectively. Marcasite formed at pH < pK₁ of the polysulfide species present (for H₂S₂, pK₁ = 5.0; for H₂S₄, pK₁ = 3.8 at 25°C). Marcasite forms when the neutral sulfane is the dominant polysulfide, whereas pyrite forms when mono-or divalent polysulfides are dominant. In natural solutions where H₂S₂ and HS₂ are likely to be the dominant polysulfides, marcasite will form only below pH 5 at all temperatures.The pH-dependent precipitation of pyrite and marcasite may be caused by electrostatic interactions between polysulfide species and pyrite or marcasite growth surfaces: the protonated ends of H₂S₂ and HS₂ are repelled from pyrite growth sites but not from marcasite growth sites. The negative ions HS₂ and S₂²⁻ are strongly attracted to the positive pyrite growth sites. Masking of 1π_g^* electrons in the S₂ group by the protons makes HS₂ and H₂S₂ isoelectronic with AsS²⁻ and As₂²⁻, respectively (Tossellet al., 1981). Thus, the loellingitederivative structure (marcasite) results when both ends of the polysulfide are protonated.Marcasite occurs abundantly only for conditions below pH 5 and where H₂S₂ was formed near the site of deposition by either partial oxidation of aqueous H₂S by O₂ or by the reaction of higher oxidation state sulfur species that are reactive with H₂S at the conditions of formation e.g., S₂O₃²⁻ but not SO₄²⁻. The temperature of formation of natural marcasite may be as high as 240°C (Hannington and Scott, 1985), but preservation on a multimillion-year scale seems to require post-depositional temperatures of below about 160°C (Rising, 1973; McKibben and Elders, 1985).