Comment on “The nature and origin of ureilites” by J. L. Berkley et al.

The record of primordial noble gases in ureilites imposes serious constraints on models of ureilite petrogenesis. It is argued that the inhomogeneous distribution between different mineral phases and the low ${}^{40}\text{Ar}{}^{36}\text{Ar}$ ratio in particular can only be satisfied with difficulties in the model proposed by Berkley et al.