Comparison of the structural,spectroscopic and phenanthrene binding characteristics of humic acids from soils and lake sediments

The structural, spectroscopic and phenanthrene binding characteristics were compared for humic acids (HA) extracted from two different sources: eight soils and six lake sediments. The elemental analysis revealed that HA from sediments had higher H/C, N/C, and (N + O)/C ratios compared to HA from soils, reflecting a lower degree of humification and more autochthonous organic input upon the formation of the HA for lake sediments versus soil environments. HA from soils exhibited a higher content of aromatic carbon structures than the sediment HA based on ¹³C NMR results. The source of HA was easily distinguished by comparing the synchronous fluorescence spectra of each HA group. The presence of a protein like fluorescence was prominent for the HA from sediment while it was minor for the HA from soil. Irrespective of the HA source, however, humification index (HIX) exhibited a common positive correlation with the aromatic content, and a negative correlation with O-alkyl carbon structures of the HA. The correlations were consistent with the general structural trends of humification processes, suggesting that HIX may serve as a source independent predictor to describe the structural information and humification degree of terrigenous HA. Aromatic carbon structures did contribute to enhancing the phenanthrene binding for both sources of HA. However, the primary structures associated with non-ideal phenanthrene binding (i.e., non-linear sorption isotherm) appear to differ by the HA source because the opposed correlations were obtained between aromaticity and the isotherm linearity for the two HA groups. Our results suggest that the HA structural function associated with specific non-linear sorption for hydrophobic organic contaminants (HOCs) may be more strongly governed by the HA source than by the apparent physico-chemical properties.