Cometary impacts with the Sun: Physical and dynamical considerations

D. J. Michels, N. R. Sheeley, Jr., R. A. Howard, and M. J. Koomen (Science215, 1097–1102, 1982) observed a comet which appears to have impacted the Sun. Z. Sekanina (Astron. J..87, 1059–1072, 1982) showed that the comet, 1979XI, was probably a member of the Kreutz group of sungrazing comets. The sungrazers typically have perihelia of 1.2–1.9 solar radii but Sekanina found q = 0.35 R_⊙ for 1979XI. It is interesting to speculate how the perihelion may have been reduced to this small value. The change in perihelion can not be explained by planetary, stellar, or nongravitational perturbations. Tidal splitting of the nucleus on a previous perihelion passage is also ruled out, through a random splitting event near aphelion of the comet's orbit is a remote possibility. The most plausible explanation is collision with another body, most likely a comet, at large heliocentric distance. However, the expected probability of such an event is exceedingly small. Another aspect of the problem is whether the nucleus of 1979XI sublimated completely before impacting the Sun. Assuming a water ice nucleus, it is shown that a surface layer of only 5–15 m thickness would be sublimated prior to impact. Although it is likely that the nucleus tidally disrupted after crossing the solar Roche limit, the ultimate destruction of the nucleus probably resulted from the shock of hitting the denser regions of the solar atmosphere, just above the photosphere.