Planetary ENA imaging: Effects of different interaction models for Mars

We present and compare energetic neutral atom (ENA) images that are calculated from plasma parameters given by three different simulation models of the interaction between the solar wind and Mars. The images are calculated by combining a model for the ion flow with a model of the neutral atmosphere using the cross-sections for the charge exchange collisions. The three ion models are: an empirical model that is based on Phobos 2 measurements; a three-dimensional hybrid simulation; and a three-dimensional MHD simulation. For the empirical and MHD models the images are obtained by integration of the ENA emission along lines of sight to a virtual ENA instrument. In the case of the hybrid model images are obtained by summing the contributions from all ions, whose positions, velocities, and weights are saved in files at regular intervals.Differences between the models can be detected in the images, for example the hybrid model produces ENA emissions from a larger region than the MHD model does. An asymmetry in the oxygen ion density develops in the hybrid model and can be seen in the oxygen ENA images. The images are influenced by finite gyro radius effects, which are included in the hybrid model but not in the other two. The total production rates of hydrogen ENAs are , , and for the empirical, hybrid and MHD models respectively.This study shows the importance of considering both the type of simulation model used and the proper inclusion of relevant physical phenomena and boundary conditions, when modelling the interaction between planets and the solar wind. Although the different models agree fairly well in terms of macroscopic plasma parameters they produce ENA images that differ substantially.