A search for a nonbiological explanation of the Viking Labeled Release life detection experiment

The Viking Labeled Release (LR) data obtained on Mars satisfy the criteria established for a biological response. The importance of the issue, especially when viewed against the harsh environment on Mars, requires careful consideration of possible nonbiological reactions that may have produced false positive results. A $\text{3}\text{1}\text{2}\text{-}\text{year}$ laboratory effort to investigate possible chemical, physical, and physicochemical agents or mechanisms has been concluded. Among nonbiological possibilities, hydrogen peroxide, putatively on Mars, emerged as the principal candidate. When placed on analog Mars soils prepared to match the Viking inorganic analysis of the Mars surface material, hydrogen peroxide did not duplicate the LR Mars data. When other materials were used as substrate, hydrogen peroxide could be made to evoke the type of responses obtained by the LR Mars experiment. However, essential criteria concerning the formation, accuumulation, and preservation of hydrogen peroxide to qualify it as the active agent on Mars have not been met and new data show it to be essentially absent from the Mars atmosphere. The presence of a biological agent on Mars must still be considered. This interpretation of the LR results is strengthened by a recent report that the Viking organic analysis instrument (GCMS) failed to detect organics in an Antarctic soil in which the LR instrument had demonstrated the presence of microorganisms.