Comparative toxicity of drilling muds: role of chromium and petroleum hydrocarbons

Samples of used drilling muds collected during the course of a single well drilling operation exhibited different degrees of acute toxicity to sheepshead minnows and grass shrimp. For moulting grass shrimp, Palaemonetes pugio, the 96-h LC₅₀'s were 360 to 14 560 ppm (μl/litre); many of these values were considerably lower than those reported from previous drilling mud assays. However, when some of the muds used in this study were tested on sheepshead minnows, Cyprinodon variegatus, the resulting 96-h LC₅₀'s (6300 to 100 000ppm) were well within the range of previously reported values.Although a number of the drilling mud samples had relatively high amounts of chromium due to the addition of sodium chromate, there was a low correlation between chromium concentration and toxicity. In only three drilling muds could chromium content alone account for the observed toxicities. Furthermore, chemical analyses revealed the presence of No. 2 fuel oil like petroleum hydrocarbons in the mud samples. Based on the results of toxicity tests with No. 2 fuel oil and the concentrations of oil present in the muds, the toxicity of the mud samples to grass shrimp appears to be largely attributable to the petroleum hydrocarbon content.