Quenching of the beam-plasma instability by large-scale density fluctuations in 3 dimensions

A model is presented to explain the highly variable yet low level of Langmuir waves measured in situ by spacecraft when electron beams associated with type III solar bursts are passing by; the low level of excited waves allows the propagation of such streams from the Sun to well past 1 AU without catastrophic energy losses. The model is based, first, on the existence of large-scale density fluctuations that are able to efficiently diffuse small-k beam-unstable Langmuir waves in phase space, and, second, on the presence of a significant isotropic non-thermal tail in the distribution function of the background electron population, which is capable of stabilizing larger k modes. The strength of the model lies in its ability to predict various levels of Langmuir waves depending on the parameters. This feature is consistent with the high variability actually observed in the measurements. The calculations indicate that, for realistic parameters, the most unstable, small k modes are fully stabilized while some oblique mode with higher k and lower growth rate might remain unstable; thus a very broad range of levels of Langmuir waves is possible from levels of the order of enhanced spontaneous emission to the threshold level for nonlinear processes. On the other hand, from in situ measurements of the density fluctuations spectrum by ISEE-1 and 2 in the vicinity of the Earth, it is shown that measured 100 km scale fluctuations may be too effective in quenching the instability. If such strong density fluctuations are common in the solar wind, we show they must be highly anisotropic in order to allow the build-up of Langmuir waves to the observed mV m^–1 range. Moreover, the anisotropy must be such that the strongest variations of density occur in a plane perpendicular to the magnetic field.