Zircon and sphene as fission track geochronometer and geothermometer: A reappraisal

The data published earlier on zircon and sphene fission track ages and annealing are discussed in the light of different etching conditions used for age determination and annealing experiments in order to explain the age discordances of some zircon and sphene pairs, as well as numerous closing temperatures obtained for individual minerals. Using the new set of simple etching conditions, zircon (KOH melt) and sphene (HF+HCl), the annealing experiments indicate that tracks in sphene are annealed more easily than in zircon. The closing temperature of zircon and sphene have been calculated at 300° and 250° C respectively. The study reveals that both the fission track age and the closing temperature of a mineral can vary considerably if different etchants are used. For different etching conditions the closing temperatures (T) of sphene have the following order: ^T NaOH> ^T HF+HCl+HNO₃+H₂O> ^THF+HCl>^THCl. An alternative method can be used to obtain thermal histories of rocks by selectively applying various etchants on the same mineral.