Application of the 227Th230Th method to dating Pleistocene carbonates and comparison with other dating methods

The ${}^{227}\text{Th}{}^{230}\text{Th}$ dating method is described in detail and its usefulness investigated by comparing ages of sixteen Pleistocene carbonates (mainly cave deposits) with those determined by the ${}^{231}\text{Pa}{}^{235}\text{U}$ and ${}^{230}\text{Th}{}^{234}\text{U}$ methods. The ${}^{227}\text{Th}{}^{230}\text{Th}$ ages are found to be critically dependent on corrections for decay of ²²⁷Th prior to alpha counting and ingrowth of daughter isotopes of ²³²Th derived from clastic detritus. Of nineteen sets of ages determined for the sixteen samples, good agreement is found for only seven sets. Differences are attributed to low U content of some samples and the possibility of excess ²²⁷Th in the calcite of samples younger than ~50 ky, possibly due to the coprecipitation of ²³¹Pa during formation. Calculated “negative” ${}^{227}\text{Th}{}^{230}\text{Th}$ ages may be a direct result of this process and the fact that, unlike the other methods, the activity ratio is non-zero at zero age. Nevertheless, the ${}^{227}\text{Th}{}^{230}\text{Th}$ is found to be a useful alternative dating technique for carbonates which are between ~50 and 300 ky, because no spiking is required. It also serves as a check for partial concordancy with ages dated by the other methods.