Hamilton Harbour, Ontario: 8300 years of limnological and environmental change inferred from microfossil and isotopic analyses

Limnological changes in Hamilton Harbour, Lake Ontario, over the Holocene were investigated by using proxy evidence from diatoms and other siliceous microfossils in a radiometrically dated sediment core (HH26comp), together with environmental data derived from sediment pollen and oxygen and carbon isotope analyses. The evidence demonstrates that the site of Hamilton Harbour has changed over the past 8300 y from a shallow, separate waterbody, to a deep embayment of Lake Ontario. The earliest evidence, from 8300 BP to 7000 BP, is of a mesotrophic pond of moderate alkalinity, warmer than present, and probably with an extensive marginal wetland. An initial transitory connection with the rising water level of Lake Ontario was established at c. 7000 BP, possibly via a deep outlet channel. This connection is 2000 y earlier then previously estimated. Permanent confluence with Lake Ontario was established at c. 6200 BP, causing a decline in inferred trophic level and water temperatures. Microfossils reach a minimum at 4400 BP coincident with the Nipissing Flood. Decreased mixing of Lake Ontario water from about 4000 BP following the Nipissing Flood highstand is evidenced in isotopic and diatom data. Three isolated shifts in the diatom spectrum at c. 4900 BP, 4500 BP, and 3500 BP may be associated with extreme turbidity or storm deposit events. Between 3200 BP and 280 BP, Hamilton Harbour was evidently a moderately alkaline embayment of Lake Ontario, oligotrophic to mesotrophic, and relatively cooler than present. The final 280 y sedimentary record reveals the magnitude of anthropogenically induced changes to the harbour, including eutrophication and organic pollution.