Experimental determination of U and Th partitioning between clinopyroxene and natural and synthetic basaltic liquid

Clinopyroxene-silicate liquid partition coefficients for U and Th have been determined by particle track radiography from 1 atm crystallization experiments at controlledfO₂. Two natural basaltic and one synthetic composition were studied atfO₂ values from the NiNiO oxygen buffer to 1 log unit more oxidizing than FeFeO (IW+ 1). Over the range offO₂ values and compositions studied,D_U^cpx/liq = 0.0034–0.015,D_Th^cpx/liq = 0.008–0.036, andD_ThD_U= 3.4–1.1. With decreasingfO₂,D_ThD_U can decrease by up to a factor of 3 for a given composition, primarily from an increase inD_U^cpx/liq, which we interpret as resulting from an increase in the proportion of tetravalent U in the system with decreasingfO₂. This demonstrates that crystal-liquid UTh fractionation isfO₂ dependent and that U in terrestrial magmas is not entirely tetravalent.D_Th^cpx/liq appears to decrease in the two basalts at the lowestfO₂, possibly as a result of changes in composition withfO₂.

Our data show the sense of UTh fractionation by clinopyroxene-liquid partitioning is consistent with previous experimental determinations, in thatD_Th^cpxD_U^cpx> 1 in all cases. This indicates that, during partial melting, the liquid will have aTh/U ratio less than the clinopyroxene in the source. The observed²³⁸U²³⁰Th disequilibrium in MORB requires that the partial melt should have aTh/U ratio greater than the bulk source, and, therefore, cannot result from clinopyroxene-liquid partitioning. Further, the magnitudes of the measured partition coefficients are too small to generate significant UTh fractionation in either direction. Assuming that clinopyroxene contains the bulk of the U and Th in MORB source, our results indicate that²³⁸U²³⁰Th disequilibrium in MORB may not be caused by partial melting at all.