Correlated chemical and isotopic zoning in carbonates in the martian meteorite ALH84001

The meteorite ALH84001, a sample of the ancient martian crust, contains small quantities (1%) of strongly chemically zoned carbonate. High spatial resolution (10 μm) ion microprobe analyses show that the chemical zoning is strongly correlated with variations in oxygen isotope ratios. Early formed Ca,Fe-rich cores have δ¹⁸O 7‰ increasing to 22‰ SMOW in the more Mg-rich outer cores and magnesite rims. Isolated areas of ankerite appear to be isotopically lighter with δ¹⁸O 1‰. The large range in δ¹⁸O requires a significant range in either fluid isotopic composition, or temperature, or both, in the course of the deposition sequence. Our data are inconsistent with formation of the zoned carbonates by closed system Rayleigh fractionation. There is no unique interpretation of the oxygen data, but the recent observation of existence of Δ¹⁷O excesses in the carbonate appears to rule out models which involve high temperature isotopic exchange with silicate. Comparison with terrestrial analogues suggests that ALH84001 carbonates formed in a hydrothermal system with T<400°C, and which, at least in the early stages of formation, may have involved water with δ¹⁸O < 0‰ SMOW. The later stages of deposition probably occurred at temperatures below 150°C, a conclusion which does not preclude the co-existence of thermophilic bacteria; temperatures during earlier stages of deposition are less likely to have been hospitable to bacteria.