Mode Mixing by a Shallow Sunspot

Sunspots are strong absorbers of f and p modes. A possible absorption mechanism is direct conversion to slow magnetoacoustic waves. Calculations based on vertical magnetic field models show that this works well for f modes, but is inadequate for p modes. Using a very simple shallow spot model, in which the effects of the magnetic field are accounted for solely by a surface condition, we investigate the possibility that p modes first scatter into f modes inside the spot, which are then more susceptible to conversion to slow modes. We find that the coupling between an incident p mode and the internal f mode is unlikely to be strong enough to account for the observed absorption, but that the incident modes do couple strongly to the acoustic jacket in some cases, leading to a region immediately around the sunspot where a significant fraction of the surface velocity is due to the jacket modes.     

Time-Distance Seismology and the Solar Transition Region

Time-Distance ‘travel time’ perturbations (as inferred from wave phase) are calculated relative to the quiet-Sun as a function of wave orientation and field inclination in a uniform inclined magnetic field. Modelling indicates that the chromosphere-corona Transition Region (TR) profoundly alters travel times at inclinations from the vertical θ for which the ramp-reduced acoustic cutoff frequency ω _c cosθ is similar to the wave frequency ω. At smaller inclinations phase shifts are much smaller as the waves are largely reflected before reaching the TR. At larger inclinations, the shifts resume their quiet-Sun values, although with some resonant oscillatory behaviour. Changing the height of the TR in the model atmosphere has some effect, but the thickness and temperature jump do not change the results substantially. There is a strong correspondence between travel-time shifts and the Alfvén flux that emerges at the top of the modelled region as a result of fast/Alfvén mode conversion. We confirm that the TR transmission coefficient for Alfvén waves generated by mode conversion in the chromosphere is far larger (typically 30 % or more) than for Alfvén waves injected from the photosphere.     

Probing sunspot magnetic fields with p-mode absorption and phase shift data

Long-standing observations of incoming and outgoing f- and p-modes in annuli around sunspots reveal that the spots partially absorb and substantially shift the phase of waves incident upon them. The commonly favoured absorption mechanism is partial conversion to slow magneto-acoustic waves that disappear into the solar interior channelled by the magnetic field of the sunspot. However, up until now, only f-mode absorption could be accounted for quantitatively by this means. Based on vertical magnetic field models, the absorption of p-modes was insufficient. In this paper, we use the new calculations of Crouch & Cally for inclined fields, and a simplified model of the interaction between spot interior and exterior. We find excellent agreement with phase shift data assuming field angles from the vertical in excess of 30° and Alfvén/acoustic equipartition depths of around 600–800 km. The absorption of f-modes produced by such models is considerably larger than is observed, but consistent with numerical simulations. On the other hand, p-mode absorption is generally consistent with observed values, up to some moderate frequency dependent on radial order. Thereafter, it is too large, assuming absorbing regions comparable in size to the inferred phase-shifting region. The excess absorption produced by the models is in stark contrast with previous calculations based on a vertical magnetic field, and is probably due to finite mode lifetimes and excess emission in acoustic glories. The excellent agreement of phase shift predictions with observational data allows some degree of probing of subsurface field strengths, and opens up the possibility of more accurate inversions using improved models. Most importantly, though, we have confirmed that slow mode conversion is a viable, and indeed the likely, cause of the observed absorption and phase shifts.     

Three-Dimensional MHD Wave Propagation and Conversion to Alfvén Waves near the Solar Surface. I. Direct Numerical Solution

The efficacy of fast?–?slow MHD mode conversion in the surface layers of sunspots has been demonstrated over recent years using a number of modelling techniques, including ray theory, perturbation theory, differential eigensystem analysis, and direct numerical simulation. These show that significant energy may be transferred between the fast and slow modes in the neighbourhood of the equipartition layer where the Alfvén and sound speeds coincide. However, most of the models so far have been two dimensional. In three dimensions the Alfvén wave may couple to the magnetoacoustic waves with important implications for energy loss from helioseismic modes and for oscillations in the atmosphere above the spot. In this paper, we carry out a numerical “scattering experiment,” placing an acoustic driver 4 Mm below the solar surface and monitoring the acoustic and Alfvénic wave energy flux high in an isothermal atmosphere placed above it. These calculations indeed show that energy conversion to upward travelling Alfvén waves can be substantial, in many cases exceeding loss to slow (acoustic) waves. Typically, at penumbral magnetic field strengths, the strongest Alfvén fluxes are produced when the field is inclined 30°?–?40° from the vertical, with the vertical plane of wave propagation offset from the vertical plane containing field lines by some 60°?–?80°.     

Physical Properties of Wave Motion in Inclined Magnetic Fields within Sunspot Penumbrae

At the surface of the Sun, acoustic waves appear to be affected by the presence of strong magnetic fields in active regions. We explore the possibility that the inclined magnetic field in sunspot penumbrae may convert primarily vertically-propagating acoustic waves into elliptical motion. We use helioseismic holography to measure the modulus and phase of the correlation between incoming acoustic waves and the local surface motion within two sunspots. These correlations are modeled by assuming the surface motion to be elliptical, and we explore the properties of the elliptical motion on the magnetic-field inclination. We also demonstrate that the phase shift of the outward-propagating waves is opposite to the phase shift of the inward-propagating waves in stronger, more vertical fields, but similar to the inward phase shifts in weaker, more-inclined fields.     

Magnetohydrodynamic tube waves and high speed solar wind streams

It has been widely conjectured that magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) waves may provide the extra momentum or energy required to explain the high speed solar wind streams that originate in coronal holes. Although the magnetic structuring inherent in this problem has been incorporated into models of the bulk flow, this is not generally true of the associated treatments of wave propagation. In particular, as pointed out by Davila (1985), we might generally expect the magnetic geometry to substantially modify those waves whose wavelength is comparable to the hole width. Using both a geometrical optics and an eigenmode approach, Davila addressed the question of wave propagation in a simple uniform width flux slab model of a coronal hole and concluded

1. the hole may act as a ‘leaky wave guide’, i.e., waves travelling along it may leak into the surrounding corona, but
2. the group velocity of waves with periods in a physically relevant range (around 100 s) is downward, indicating that such waves cannot carry energy into the solar wind and therefore cannot be driving it.

We agree with (i) but argue that (ii) results from a mistaken interpretation of a dispersion relation, and is incorrect. Furthermore, we apply the cylindrical tube leaky wave approach of Cally (1986) to a simple coronal hole model, and find two wavetypes with substantial upward energy fluxes. However, of these, we argue that the so-called ‘trig modes’ (geometry modified fast waves) leak so profusely that they are unable to transport energy over the distance required; the non-axisymmetric ‘thin tube’ modes, though, do not suffer from this disability.     

Phase Jumps in Local Helioseismology

Helioseismic rays trapped in a nonmagnetic acoustic cavity suffer a +90° phase jump at their lower (Lamb) turning point and −90° at the upper (acoustic cutoff) reflection point. That the two cancel allows helioseismologists to effectively assume that phase is locally continuous along a ray path joining two surface points. However, in strong surface magnetic field, as found in sunspots, it is shown – for an isothermal model with uniform magnetic field – that the phase jump for fast magnetoacoustic rays that penetrate the acoustic/Alfvénic equipartition level (c=a) is around −120°. Moreover, there are further negative phase jumps on the upgoing and downgoing legs at c=a that add to the net phase change. Neglecting these effects can lead to a misinterpretation of helioseismic data in terms of travel-time shifts.     

Nonlinear Evolution of Axisymmetric Twisted Flux Tubes in the Solar Tachocline

We study the periodicity of twisting motions in sunspot penumbral filaments, which were recently discovered from space (Hinode) and ground-based (SST) observations. A sunspot was well observed for 97 minutes by Hinode/SOT in the G-band (4305 Å) on 12 November 2006. By the use of the time?–?space gradient applied to intensity space?–?time plots, twisting structures can be identified in the penumbral filaments. Consistent with previous findings, we find that the twisting is oriented from the solar limb to disk center. Some of them show a periodicity. The typical period is about ≈?four minutes, and the twisting velocity is roughly 6 km s^?1. However, the penumbral filaments do not always show periodic twisting motions during the time interval of the observations. Such behavior seems to start and stop randomly with various penumbral filaments displaying periodic twisting during different intervals. The maximum number of periodic twists is 20 in our observations. Studying this periodicity can help us to understand the physical nature of the twisting motions. The present results enable us to determine observational constraints on the twisting mechanism.     

From Gigahertz to Millihertz: A Multiwavelength Study of the Acoustically Active 14 August 2004 M7.4 Solar Flare

We carried out an electromagnetic acoustic analysis of the solar flare of 14 August 2004 in active region AR10656 from the radio to the hard X-ray spectrum. The flare was a GOES soft X-ray class M7.4 and produced a detectable sun quake, confirming earlier inferences that relatively low energy flares may be able to generate sun quakes. We introduce the hypothesis that the seismicity of the active region is closely related to the heights of coronal magnetic loops that conduct high-energy particles from the flare. In the case of relatively short magnetic loops, chromospheric evaporation populates the loop interior with ionised gas relatively rapidly, expediting the scattering of remaining trapped high-energy electrons into the magnetic loss cone and their rapid precipitation into the chromosphere. This increases both the intensity and suddenness of the chromospheric heating, satisfying the basic conditions for an acoustic emission that penetrates into the solar interior.