Reply to Edward Anders: A discussion of alternative models for explaining the distribution of moderately volatile elements in ordinary chondrites

The high observed abundances of Na and Cu in chondrules indicate that the amount of loss during chondrule formation was minor and possibly negligible, consistent with the view that loss was controlled by diffusion kinetics rather than equilibrium volatility, and that the surface of the chondrule quickly cooled to temperatures at which diffusional transport was negligible. Ordinary chondrite/CI abundance ratios appear to be randomly distributed in the range 0.9-0.1. Very few values are observed in the 0.36–0.70 range, but this is not statistically significant, nor is it predicted by the two-component (chondrule-matrix) model.If CI chondrite abundances are representative of mean solar-system material, the very low chondrule content in CM chondrites (<5% of high-temperature materials) indicates that the observed volatile distribution resulted from incomplete accretion of volatile carriers (perhaps a fine aerosol). At the ordinary chondrite formation location the fraction of an element sited in unaccreted carriers increased with decreasing condensation temperature. At the CM location a similar trend is observed for elements less volatile than S, but the unaccreted fraction of more volatile elements was nearly constant.     

Chlorinated cooling waters in the marine environment: Development of effluent guidelines

The effects of free chlorine and chloramine on stage I lobster larvae and juvenile killifish were investigated in continuous flow bioassay units. In comparing mortality and changes in standard respiration rates during and after exposure to either chlorine form, significant respiratory stress was observed with exposure to sublethal levels. Sublethal responses to free and combined chlorine should be considered when establishing regulations for chlorine residuals in cooling waters.     

Two-feldspar geothermometry in granulite facies metamorphic rocks

A geothermometric technique based on equilibria between coexisting plagioclase and alkali feldspar was applied to quartzo-feldspathic granulites from Salvador, BA, Brazil. The conditions of metamorphism were determined to be in the range 750 ° C–800 ° C, 4–8 Kb, by comparison with experimental data on the stabilities of sapphirine, phlogopite and other minerals occurring in the associated rocks. Selected feldspar data gives temperatures near, but slightly below, this range. Several variants of the Wood and Banno model, as well as an empirical two-pyroxene geothermometer, were also tested and found to give temperatures which were apparently 50 °–100 ° high. The solubility of Al₂O₃ in orthopyroxene indicates temperatures which are about 200 ° to high, suggesting that Fe in the natural assemblages significantly changes relationships observed experimentally in MgO-Al₂O₃-SiO₂ systems.     

Mechanical twinning in diopside Ca(Mg,Fe)Si2O6: Structural mechanism and associated crystal defects

Diopside twins mechanically on two planes, (100) and (001), and the associated macroscopic twinning strains are identical (Raleigh and Talbot, 1967). An analysis based on crystal structural arguments predicts that both twin mechanisms involve shearing of the (100) octahedral layers (containing Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺ and Fe²⁺ ions) by a magnitude of c/2. Small adjustments or shuffles occur in the adjacent layers containing the [SiO₄]^4? tetrahedral chains. While the (100) twins are conventional with shear parallel to the composition plane, this analysis predicts that (001) twins form by a mechanism closely related to kinking. A polycrystalline diopside specimen was compressed 8% at a temperature of 400° C, a pressure of 16 kilobars, and a compressive strain rate of about 10^?4/s. Transmission electron microscopy on this specimen has revealed four basic lamellar features:

1. (100) mechanical twin lamellae;
2. (100) glide bands containing unit dislocations;
3. (001) twin lamellae;
4. (101) lamellar features, not as yet identified.

The (001) twins often contain remnant (100) lamellae of untwinned host. Twinning dislocations occur in these (100) lamellae and in the (001) twin boundaries with very high densities. Diffraction contrast experiments indicate that the twinning dislocations associated with both twin laws glide on (100) with Burgers vector b=X [001] where X is probably equal to 1/2 on the basis of the structural analysis. Parallels are drawn between mechanical twinning in clinopyroxenes and clinoamphiboles. The exclusive natural occurrence of basal twins in shock-loaded clinopyroxenes and of analogous ( \(\bar 1\) 01) twins in clinoamphiboles is given a simple explanation in terms of the relative difficulty of the “kinking” mechanism as compared to direct glide parallel to the composition plane.     

Trace element distribution in mineral separates of the Allende inclusions and their genetic implications

Concentrations of the REE, Sc, Co, Fe, Zn, Ir, Na and Cr were determined by instrumental neutron activation and mass spectrometric isotope dilution analysis for mineral separates of the coarseand fine-grained types (group I and II of Martin and Mason's classification) of the Allende inclusions.These data, combined with data on mineral/liquid partition coefficients, oxygen isotope distributions and diffusion calculations, suggest the following: (1) Minerals in the coarse-grained inclusions (group I) crystallized in a closed system with respect to refractory elements. On the other hand, differences in oxygen isotope distributions among minerals preclude a totally molten stage in the history of the inclusion. Group I inclusions were formed by rapid condensation (either to liquid or solid) in a supercooled solar nebula; extrasolar pyroxene and spinel dust were included but not melted in the condensing inclusions, thus preserving their extrasolar oxygen isotope composition. REE were distributed by diffusion during the subsequent heating at subsolidus temperatures; because oxygen diffuses much more slowly at these temperatures, the oxygen isotope anomalies were preserved. (2) The fine-grained (group II) inclusions were also formed by condensation from a super-cooled nebular gas; however, REE-rich clinopyroxene and spinel were formed early and REE-poor sodalite and nepheline were formed later and mechanically mixed with clinopyroxene and spinel to form the inclusions. The REE patterns of the bulk inclusions and the mineral separates are fractionated, indicating that REE abundances in the gaseous phase were already fractionated at the time of condensation of the minerals. (3) Pre-existing Mg isotope anomalies in the coarse-grained inclusions must have been erased during the heating stage thus resetting the ²⁶Al-²⁶Mg chronometer.     

Fatty acids and Pb-210 geochronology of a sediment core from Buzzards Bay,Massachusetts

Four sections of a Pb-210 dated core of 62 cm length from Buzzards Bay, Massachusetts, were analyzed for fatty acids. A comparison of fatty acids extracted by Soxhlet extraction (unbound fatty acids) with fatty acids extracted by subsequent saponification extraction of the same sample (bound fatty acids) showed the former did not undergo diagenetic loss any faster than the latter. However, compositional differences between bound and unbound fatty acids were apparent in the top section of 1–2 cm and were less apparent in the 54–58 cm section. At least 14% of the bound fatty acids are esterified to non-solvent extractable material. The net conversion of fatty acids to other compounds is 32 μ/g dry weight sediment over the first 30 yr after deposition.     

Armalcolite stability as a function of pressure and oxygen fugacity

The stability of synthetic armalcolite of composition (Fe_0.5Mg_0.5Ti₂O₅ was studied as a function of total pressure up to 15 kbar and 1200°C and also as a function of oxygen fugacity (?O₂) at 1200°C and 1 atm total pressure. The high pressure experiments were carried out in a piston-cylinder apparatus using silver-palladium containers. At 1200°C, armalcolite is stable as a single phase at 10 kbar. With increasing pressure, it breaks down ($\text{dT}\text{dP}\text{= 20°C/}\text{kbar}$), to rutile, a more magnesian armalcolite, and ilmenite solid solution. At 14 kbar, this three-phase assemblage gives way ($\text{dT}\text{dP}\text{= 30°C/}\text{kbar}$) to a two-phase assemblage of rutile plus ilmenite solid solution.A zirconian-armalcolite was synthesized and analyzed; 4 wt % ZrO₂ appears to saturate armalcolite at 1200°C and 1 atm. The breakdown of Zr-armalcolite occurs at pressures of 1–2 kbar less than those required for the breakdown of Zr-free armalcolite. The zirconium partitions approximately equally between rutile and ilmenite phases.The stability of armalcolite as a function of ?O₂ was determined thermogravimetrically at 1200°C and 1 atm by weighing sintered pellets in a controlled atmosphere furnace. Armalcolite, (Fe_0.5Mg_0.5)-Ti₂O₅, is stable over a range ?O₂ from about 10^?9.5to 10^?10.5 atm. Below this range to at least 10^?12.8 atm, ilmenite plus a reduced armalcolite are formed. These products were observed optically and by Mössbauer spectroscopy, and no metallic iron was detected; therefore, some of the titanium must have been reduced to Ti³⁺. This reduction may provide yet another mechanism to explain the common association of ilmenite rims around lunar armalcolites.     

Late-Pleistocene and Holocene remains of Hysterocarpus traski (Tule Perch) from Clear Lake,California, and inferred Holocene temperature fluctuations

The remains of scales of Hysterocarpus traski Gibbons (Tule perch) were found throughout a 27.44-m core from Clear Lake. Most scales occurred between the mud surface and deposits approximately 11,000 years old. Changes in growth rates of the animals were examined by measuring scale annuli and applying an empirically established regression of fish length on scale radius. The data indicate a pattern of accelerating growth rates, reaching a peak between ?4000 and 2800 BP. After ?2800 BP, growth rates decline markedly. Because the growth rates of these animals are essentially dependent on temperature, the changes observed in the patterns of growth probably reflect changes in climate in the northern Coast Range. The general pattern of inferred temperature increase during the early and middle Holocene, ending between ?4000 and 2800 BP, is consistent with evidence from tree-line studies and palynology indicating higher temperatures in parts of the western United States during this period.