A phenomenological model for disparitions brusques followed by flarelike chromospheric brightenings

The study of the disparitions brusques to flarelike brightening process in Paper I led to many specific characteristics that appear to agree with the observations. Therefore, I test the consequences of the model for active-region flares as well. As in Paper I, I find agreement between the predictions of the model and the available observational data.The class III flare of 28 August 1966 is discussed in detail.I also consider the possibility that the gravitational infall-chromospheric impact mechanism may be the source of energy for other chromospheric phenomena, such as the bright network seen in CaiiK₂, plages, normal flares, etc.The available data certainly indicate that the infall-impact mechanism should be studied further, but no firm conclusions as to its overall importance can be drawn at the present time.The prominence destabilization mechanism and its significance to flare predictability is explored in a somewhat speculative manner. Changing multipole fields appear to yield the necessary space and time behaviors to fit the observed behavior of eruptive prominences.As in Paper I, the major conclusion is that the model looks good, but we need specific and detailed observations to test the model.     

Remote flare brightenings and type III reverse slope bursts

We present two large flares which were exceptional in that each produced an extensive chain of H emission patches in remote quiet regions more than 10⁵ km away from the main flare site. They were also unusual in that a large group of the rare type III reverse slope bursts accompanied each flare.The observations suggest that this is no coincidence, but that the two phenomena are directly connected. The onset of about half of the remote H emission patches were found to be nearly simultaneous with RS bursts. One of the flares (August 26, 1979) was also observed in hard X-rays; the RS bursts occurred during hard X-ray spikes. For the other flare (June 16, 1973), soft X-ray filtergrams show coronal loops connecting from the main flare site to the remote H brightenings. There were no other flares in progress during either flare; this, along with the X-ray observations, indicates that the RS burst electrons were generated in these flares and not elsewhere on the Sun. The remote H brightenings were apparently not produced by a blast wave from the main flare; no Moreton waves were observed, and the spatially disordered development of the remote H chains is further evidence against a blast wave. From geometry, time and energy considerations we propose: (1) That the remote H brightenings were initiated by direct heating of the chromosphere by RS burst electrons traveling in closed magnetic loops connecting the flare site to the remote patches; and (2) that after onset, the brightenings were heated by thermal conduction by slower thermal electrons (kT1 keV) which immediately follow the RS burst electrons along the same loops.     

Hα line profile observations of solar flares with high temporal resolution

H line profile observations of solar flares with high temporal resolution are an important tool for the analysis of the energy transport mechanism from the site of the flare energy release to the chromosphere. A specially designed instrument (imaging spectrograph) allows two-dimensional imaging of an active region simultaneously in 15 spectral channels along the H line profile with a temporal resolution of 5.4 s. Two flares have been observed in November 1982. The first one shows H signatures which one would typically expect in the case of explosive chromospheric evaporation produced by massive injection of non-thermal electrons. The observations of the other flare indicate that the heating of the upper chromosphere is dominated by thermal conduction, although during the impulsive hard X-ray burst there are also signatures of heating by non-thermal electrons.     

On the solar tsunami

Some problems of qualitative theory of solar tsunami caused by rapid magnetic disturbances are discussed. The energy of tsunami is found sufficient to produce oscillations of quiescent prominences, facular brightenings after flares and also some flares and also some flares of moderate intensity. Coronal plasma satisfied the condition of incompressibility, but in the chromosphere the effects of incompressibility, but in the chromosphere the effects of compressibility generally must be taken into account. Long gravity waves with the wave-length of 10⁵ km can propagate on distances comparable with solar radius without sensible damping and dissipation. The solution of tsunami problem for a model of two-component ocean consists of two long gravity waves moving with different velocity in the chromosphere and corona. The effect of encounter of tsunami with magnetic fields are discussed.     

The initial development of solar flares

The extent to which the early phases of solar-flare development can be accounted for by a simple high-temperature chromospheric explosion model is investigated without involving a particular energy source. A model is developed in which it is shown that a point explosion in the lower chromosphere can be treated as a virtually instantaneous release of energy throughout a volume of radius R 100 km, which subsequently expands as a classical hydrodynamic blast wave in which R~ t ( < 2/3). This model is in substantial agreement with areal growth-rate observations of disk flares. An explanation for the fact that limb-flare observations can imply > 2/3 is suggested by considering the effects of the large atmospheric density gradient in the lower chromosphere on an upward travelling shock wave.     

On a possible explanation of chromospheric line asymmetries of solar flares

We discuss the relationship between the chromospheric downward motions and the line asymmetries in solar flares by using a simple model. It is found that both the blue asymmetry and red asymmetry of the H line can be caused by downward motions, as long as the moving material is confined to different heights in the chromosphere. The Ca ii K line, however, mainly shows a red asymmetry. The results can qualitatively explain some observations.     

The footpoints of giant arches

We have detected chromospheric footpoints of the giant post-flare coronal arches discovered by HXIS a few years ago. H photographs obtained at Big Bear and Udaipur Solar Observatories show chromospheric signatures associated with 5 sequential giant arch events observed in the interval from 6 to 10 November, 1980. The set of footpoints at one end of the arches consists of enhancements within a plage at the northeast periphery of the active region and the set of footpoints at the other end of the arch consists of brightenings of the chromosphere south of the active region. Both sets of footpoints show very slow brightness variations correlated in time with the brightness variations of the X-ray arches. Current-free modelling of the coronal magnetic field by Kopp and Poletto (1989), based on a Kitt Peak magnetogram, confirms the identification of the two sets of footpoints by showing magnetic field lines connecting them.The brightenings appear as a succession of point-like enhancements whose individual lifetimes are of the time-scale of minutes but which continue to occur for periods of several hours. This behaviour allows us to infer a fine structure in the coronal arches, undetectable in the X-ray images. The discovery of these brightenings and their location at the periphery of the active region also alters our conception of the relationship of the giant arches to the flares that begin concurrently with them. The giant arch phenomenon appears now to be either: (1) a long-lived, semi-permanent, coronal structure which is revived and fed with plasma and energy by underlying dynamic flares, or alternatively (2) a system of high-altitude loops which open at the onset of every such flare and subsequently reconnect over intervals of many hours.     

Chromospheric downflow velocities as a diagnostic in solar flares

We explore the dynamics of chromospheric condensations driven by evaporation during the impulsive phase of solar flares. Specifically, we find that the maximum chromospheric downflow speed obeys the approximate relation _d = 0.4 (F/ _ch )^1/3, where F is that part of the flare energy flux driving chromospheric evaporation, and _ch is the mass density in the preflare chromosphere just below the preflare transition region. This implies that chromospheric downflows as measured by H asymmetries may be a powerful probe of flare energetics.     

X-ray bright point flares due to magnetic reconnection

Ground-based optical observations coordinated with Yohkoh/SXT X-ray observations of an old, disintegrating bipolar active region AR NOAA 7493 (May 1, 1993) provided a multiwavelength data base to study a flaring active region X-ray bright point (XBP) of about 16 hr lifetime, and the activity related to it in different layers of the solar atmosphere. The XBP appeared to be related to a new minor bipole of about 10²⁰ Mx. Superposed on a global evolution of soft X-ray brightness, the XBP displayed changes of brightness, lasting for 1–10 min. During the brightenings the XBP apparently had a spatial structure, which was (tiny) loop-like rather than point-like. The X-ray brightenings were correlated with chromospheric activity: (i) brightenings of underlying chromospheric faculae, and (ii) appearance of strong turbulent velocities in the arch filament system. We propose that the XBP brightenings were due to reconnection of the magnetic field lines (sketched in 3D) between the new bipole and a pre-existing plage field induced by the motion of one of the new pores (v = 0.2 km s^–1) towards the plage, and that the XBP itself was a reconnected hot loop between them.     

Comments on filament-disintegration and its relation to other aspects of solar activity

Studies of disparitions brusques in solar cycles 19 and 20 (to 1969) indicate that such events occur frequently. Approximately 30% of all large filaments in these cycles disintegrated in the course of their transit across the solar disk. Major flares occurred with above average frequency on the last day on which 141 large disappearing filaments were observed (1958–60; 1966–69). Relationships between a disintegrating filament on July 10–11, 1959, a prior major flare, a newly formed spot, and concomitant growth of H plage are presented. Observation of prior descending prominence material apparently directed towards the location of the flare of 1959 July 15^d19^h23^m is reported. The development of the filament-associated flare of February 13, 1967 is described.Visiting Astronomer, McMath-Hulbert Observatory.     

Physical properties of solar chromospheric plages

We compute a new grid of plage models to determine the difference in temperature versus mass column density structure T(m) between plage regions and the quiet solar chromosphere, and to test whether the solar chromosphere is geometrically thinner in plages. We compare partial redistribution calculations of Mg ii h and k and Ca ii K to NRL Skylab observations of Mg ii h and k in six active regions and Ca ii K intensities obtained from spectroheliograms taken at approximately the same time as the Mg ii observations. We find that the plage observations are better matched by models with linear (in log m) temperature distributions and larger values of m ₀ (the mass column density at the 8000 K layer in the chromosphere), than by models with larger low chromosphere temperature gradients but values of m ₀ similar to the quiet Sun. Our derived temperature structures are in agreement with the grid originally proposed by Shine and Linsky, but our analysis is in contrast to the study by Kelch which implies that stellar chromospheric geometrical thickness is not affected by chromospheric activity. We conclude that either the stellar Mg ii observations upon which the Kelch study was based are of poorer quality than had been assumed, or that the spatial averaging of inhomogeneous structures, which is inherent in the stellar data, does not lead to a best fit one-component model similar in detail to that of a stellar or a solar plage.Visiting Astronomer at Kitt Peak National Observatory, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under contract with the National Science Foundation.Staff member, Quantum Physics Division, National Bureau of Standards.     

Soft X-ray observations of large-scale coronal active region brightenings

One-hundred fifty-six large-scale enhancements of X-ray emission from solar active regions were studied on full-disk filterheliograms to determine characteristic morphology and expansion rates for heated coronal plasma. The X-ray photographs were compared with H observations of flares, sudden filament disappearances, sprays and loop prominence systems (LPS). Eighty-one percent of the X-ray events were correlated with H filament activity, but only forty-four percent were correlated with reported H flares. The X-ray enhancements took the form of loops or arcades of loops ranging in length from 60 000 km to 520 000 km and averaging 15 000 km in width. Lifetimes ranged from 3 hr to >24 hr. Event frequency was 1.4 per day. X-ray loop arcades evolved from sharp-edged clouds in cavities vacated by rising H filaments. Expansion velocities of the loops were 50 km s^-1 immediately after excitation and 1–10 km s^-1 several hours later. These long-lived loop arcades are identified with LPS, and it is suggested that the loops outlined magnetic fields which were reconnecting after filament eruptions. Another class of X-ray enhanced loops stretched outside active regions and accompanied sprays or lateral filament ejections. H brightenings occurred where these loops intersected the chromosphere. Inferred excitation velocities along the loops ranged between 300 and 1200 km s^-1. It is suggested that these loops outlined closed magnetic fields guiding slow mode shocks from flares and filament eruptions.     

Flare model chromospheres and photospheres

Homogeneous plane-parallel model atmospheres for solar flares have been constructed to approximately simulate observations of flares. The wings of the Ca II lines have been used to derive flare upper photosphere models, which indicate temperature increases of ～100 K over the temperature distribution in the pre-existing facula at a height of 300 km above τ₅₀₀₀ = 1. In the case of flares covering sunspots the temperature rise seems to occur much higher in the atmosphere. We solve the transfer and statistical equilibrium equations for a three-level hydrogen atom and a five-level calcium atom in order to obtain the chromospheric flare models. The general properties of flares, including n _e, N ₂, linear thickness, and Lyman continuum intensity are approximately reproduced. We find that with increasing flare importance the height of the upper chromosphere and transition region occur lower in the solar atmosphere, accounting for the factor of 60–600 increase in pressure in these regions relative to the quiet Sun. The Ca II line profiles agree with observations only by assuming a macro-velocity distribution that increases with height. Also the chromospheric parts of flares appear to be highly inhomogeneous. We show that shock and particle heated flare models do not agree with the observations and propose a thermal response model for flares. In particular, it appears that heating in the photosphere is an essential aspect of flares.     

Detection of Hα Intensity Oscillations in Solar Flares

We report here the first direct evidence for detection of H intensity oscillations in two extended flares of 15 November 1989 and 20 April 1991. The relative intensity variations measured with time at 18 different flare and chromospheric locations were analysed to obtain the oscillation modes. The analysis shows prominent 5- and 3-min modes in flares in addition to their existence in the chromosphere. However, there exists a frequency difference between the flare and chromospheric modes. This frequency deviation of about 300 µHz is proposed as an influence of higher magnetic field, location of the measurements (height) in chromosphere, and high temperature in the flare.     

Physical processes determining the chromospheric temperature distribution

Calculations performed with several models of the solar chromosphere support Ulmschneider's conclusion that relatively short period acoustic waves heat the low chromosphere in the region just above the temperature minimum. However, these same short period waves (10 period P80 s) are not able to maintain chromospheric temperatures at heights where _5000Å(normal) < 10^-6. The calculations also show that an earlier conjecture stating that the H₂ population might influence the non-LTE chromospheric H^- population is probably not correct, due to lower values of the ratio n _e/n _H inferred from more recent observations. Finally, the calculations support Athay's contention that the Cayrel mechanism alone cannot produce the observed temperature rise, because the magnitude of the radiative cooling in the lines is too great.     

The development of X-ray flare onsets near active region filaments

Skylab X-ray images of the early phases of six active region transient brightenings were compared with simultaneous H images to study the spatial relationships between filaments and the X-ray brightenings. When the X-ray loops were roughly perpendicular to the axes of the H filaments, the filaments did not disappear. X-ray loops which appeared nearly parallel to the filaments were generally associated with the disappearances of those filaments. It is suggested that the perpendicular loops correspond to the class I X-ray flares of Pallavicini et al. (1977) while the parallel loops are the early phases of their class II flares characterized in the decay phases by arcades of large loops with low energy densities. Both kinds of X-ray flares can be associated with impulsive phases.     

Permanent changes in filaments near solar flares

High resolution H images obtained before and after 57 importance 1N or larger flares have been examined for changes in the magnetic fields (B ) transverse to the line of sight. It was assumed that H chromospheric structures outline B . In 37% of the cases, there was a reconfiguration of segments of filaments or of chromospheric fibrils. Examination of data from 21 non-flare intervals shows such changes in 24% of cases. When changes of any kind, including total disappearance and length changes, are included, the proportions for flare and non-flare intervals increase to 58% and 52%, respectively. It is concluded that flares do not cause enduring magnetic field changes in the chromosphere.     

On some transient Hα features associated with metric type III bursts

The question of the chromospheric features type III association is reconsidered by using Hα filtergrams both on and off band. A set of 44 metric type III groups, for which an association can be ascertained with a high degree of confidence leads to the following results:

1. The type III's have a dual chromospheric association. Sometimes they are related to a flare, sometimes to a perturbation of a different kind. The latter is seen in absorption in the Hα core and ±0.75 Å away. It is interpreted as a rather dense and cool material in motion in the chromosphere or the low corona. A part of which moves downward, the other upward. The type III's are more closely related to the downward motion.
2. The type III associated absorbing features take place at the border of an active center and along an H_∥ = 0 line. At the present time this appears as the most conspicuous property for marking them off from the great variety of the Hα absorbing features commonly observed on the Sun.
3. Most of the type III associated flares are related to an absorbing feature of the same kind, which appears before the flare itself. This indicates that the initial instability which is responsible for the type III emission is basically the same, whether the bursts are flare associated or not.

Our observations give good evidence that an efficient acceleration of 10–100 keV electrons occur also in the absence of flares. Furthermore the chromospheric perturbation involved in this acceleration is, in many cases, clearly associated to the triggering of a flare. A tentative model is proposed. We assume that in relation with the Hα absorbing feature a stream of fast electrons is accelerated which in turn, under suitable conditions, triggers both the flare and the type III's at the same time.     

The Origin of Sequential Chromospheric Brightenings

Sequential chromospheric brightenings (SCBs) are often observed in the immediate vicinity of erupting flares and are associated with coronal mass ejections. Since their initial discovery in 2005, there have been several subsequent investigations of SCBs. These studies have used differing detection and analysis techniques, making it difficult to compare results between studies. This work employs the automated detection algorithm of Kirk et al. (Solar Phys. 283, 97, 2013) to extract the physical characteristics of SCBs in 11 flares of varying size and intensity. We demonstrate that the magnetic substructure within the SCB appears to have a significantly smaller area than the corresponding \(\mbox{H}\upalpha\) emission. We conclude that SCBs originate in the lower corona around \(0.1~R_{\odot}\) above the photosphere, propagate away from the flare center at speeds of \(35\,\mbox{--}\,85~\mbox{km}\,\mbox{s}^{-1}\), and have peak photosphere magnetic intensities of \(148\pm2.9~\mbox{G}\). In light of these measurements, we infer SCBs to be distinctive chromospheric signatures of erupting coronal mass ejections.     

Electron beams and associated rapid fluctuations in solar flares

Recent observations show that the rapid fluctuations in radio, hard X-ray, and H emissions are closely associated with type III and microwave (or decimetric) bursts during the impulsive and/or preimpulsive phases of solar flares.In order to clarify the physical processes of these observed phenomena, this paper proposes a tentative model of two acceleration regions A (source of type III bursts) and B (source of microwave or decimetric bursts) formed in the neutral sheet and at the top of a flaring loop, respectively; and also suggests that the electron beams streaming from region A and/or region B downward to the chromosphere are responsible for the rapid fluctuations in the different emissions mentioned above during the impulsive and/or pre-impulsive phases of solar flares.