Oral histories in meteoritics and planetary science—XXIV: William K. Hartmann

In this interview, William Hartmann (Bill, Fig.  1 ) describes how he was inspired as a teenager by a map of the Moon in an encyclopedia and by the paintings by Chesley Bonestell. Through the amateur journal “Strolling Astronomer,” he shared his interests with other teenagers who became lifelong colleagues. At college, he participated in Project Moonwatch, observing early artificial satellites. In graduate school, under Gerard Kuiper, Bill discovered Mare Orientale and other large concentric lunar basin structures. In the 1960s and 1970s, he used crater densities to study surface ages and erosive/depositional effects, predicted the approximately 3.6 Gyr ages of the lunar maria before the Apollo samples, discovered the intense pre‐mare lunar bombardment, deduced the youthful Martian volcanism as part of the Mariner 9 team, and proposed (with Don Davis) the giant impact model for lunar origin. In 1972, he helped found (what is now) the Planetary Science Institute. From the late 1970s to early 1990s, Bill worked mostly with Dale Cruikshank and Dave Tholen at Mauna Kea Observatory, helping to break down the Victorian paradigm that separated comets and asteroids, and determining the approximately 4% albedo of comet nuclei. Most recently, Bill has worked with the imaging teams for several additional Mars missions. He has written three college textbooks and, since the 1970s, after painting illustrations for his textbooks, has devoted part of his time to painting, having had several exhibitions. He has also published two novels. Bill Hartmann won the 2010 Barringer Award for impact studies and the first Carl Sagan Award for outreach in 1997.

Figure 1 Open in figure viewer PowerPoint William K. Hartmann taken 2010 Aug 2 (Photo: Gayle Hartmann).

DS

Bill thank you very much for doing this. I would like to start with a very general question. What is the one incident in your life above all others that has determined the nature of your career?

WKH

I would say that what initially stirred my excitement for this topic were the books I stumbled across as a teenager. One event I recall was that my brother, who was 8 years older than I was, had a young person's encyclopedia called the Book of Knowledge. One day I was looking at that book and there was this map of the Moon. Craters, mountains, plains, all sorts of features. That blew me away. The concept that there was this other land, not just a shining thing in the sky, but a geological body, a new geographical place. There was also a book by Willy Ley and Chesley Bonestell, Conquest of Space, which had all these marvelous paintings by Bonestell, visualizing what it was like on other planets. It came out in 1949. I am fond of my copy of that book because my father somehow managed to get Willy Ley, a German expatriate colleague of von Braun's, a writer and popularizer for space, to come to our town and give a talk and autograph my book. Many years later I met Chesley Bonestell and got him to autograph the book. There are not very many copies of that book with the signatures of both authors! The paintings gave me a real desire to want to know what it would be like on other worlds.

     

Radial thresholding to mitigate laser guide star aberrations on centre-of-gravity-based Shack–Hartmann wavefront sensors

Sodium laser guide stars (LGSs) are elongated sources due to the thickness and the finite distance of the sodium layer. The fluctuations of the sodium layer altitude and atom density profile induce errors on centroid measurements of elongated spots, and generate spurious optical aberrations in closed-loop adaptive optics (AO) systems. According to an analytical model and experimental results obtained with the University of Victoria LGS bench demonstrator, one of the main origins of these aberrations, referred to as LGS aberrations, is not the centre-of-gravity (CoG) algorithm itself, but the thresholding applied on the pixels of the image prior to computing the spot centroids. A new thresholding method, termed 'radial thresholding', is presented here, cancelling out most of the LGS aberrations without altering the centroid measurement accuracy.     

A Shack–Hartmann wavefront sensor projected on to the sky with reduced focal anisoplanatism

A method for producing a laser guide star wavefront sensor for adaptive optics with reduced focal anisoplanatism is presented. A theoretical analysis and numerical simulations have been carried out and the results are presented. The technique, named Sky-Projected Laser Array Shack–Hartmann (SPLASH), is shown to suffer considerably less from focal anisoplanatism than a conventional laser guide star system. The method is potentially suitable for large telescope apertures (∼8 m), and possibly for extremely large telescopes.     

A spectroscopic method for identifying terrestrial biocarbonates and application to Mars

Searching for traces of extinct and/or extant life on Mars is one of the major objectives for remote-sensing and in situ exploration of the planet. In previous laboratory works we have investigated the infrared spectral modifications induced by thermal processing on different carbonate samples, in the form of fresh shells and fossils of different ages, whose biotic origin is easily recognizable. The goal was to discriminate them from their abiotic counterparts. In general, it is difficult to identify biotic signatures, especially when the organisms inducing the carbonate precipitation have low fossilization potential (i.e. microbes, bacteria, archaea). A wide variety of microorganisms are implicated in carbonate genesis, and their direct characterization is very difficult to evaluate by traditional methods, both in ancient sedimentary systems and even in recent environments.In the present work we apply our analysis to problematic carbonate samples, in which there is no clear evidence of controlled or induced biomineralization. This analysis indicates a very likely biotic origin of the aragonite samples under study, in agreement with the conclusion previously reported by Guido et al. (2007) who followed a completely different approach based on a complex set of sedimentary, petrographic, geochemical and biochemical analyses. We show that our method is reliable for discriminating between biotic and abiotic carbonates, and therefore it is a powerful tool in the search for life on Mars in the next generation of space missions to the planet.     

A Late Amazonian alteration layer related to local volcanism on Mars

Hydrated minerals on Mars are most commonly found in ancient terrains dating to the first billion years of the planet’s evolution. Here we discuss the identification of a hydrated light-toned rock unit present in one Chasma of the Noctis Labyrinthus region. Stratigraphy and topography show that this alteration layer is part of a thin unit that drapes pre-existing bedrock. CRISM spectral data show that the unit contains hydrated minerals indicative of aqueous alteration. Potential minerals include sulfates such as bassanite (CaSO₄·1/2H₂O) or possibly hydrated chloride salts. The proximity of a smooth volcanic plain and the similar crater model age (Late Amazonian, <100 Myr) of this plain and the draping deposits suggest that the alteration layer may be formed by the interaction of water with ash layers deposited during this geologically recent volcanic activity. The alteration phases may have formed due to the presence of snow in contact with hot ash, or eventually solid-gas interactions due to the volcanic activity. The relatively young age of the volcanic plain implies that recent alteration processes have occurred on Mars in relation with volcanic activity, but such local processes do not require conditions different than the current climate.     

A systematic spectroscopic study of eight hydrous ferric sulfates relevant to Mars

Ferric sulfates were observed on Mars during orbital remote sensing and surface explorations. These observations have stimulated our systematic experimental investigation on the formative conditions, stability fields, phase boundaries, and phase transition pathways of these important minerals. We report here the results from the first step of this project: eight synthesized anhydrous and hydrous crystalline ferric sulfates and their structural characters reflected through spectroscopic studies. A few phenomena observed during the 150 sets of on-going experiments for stability field study are also reported, which reveal the structural distortions that can happen under environmental conditions relevant to Mars.     

Altered basaltic glass: A terrestrial analog to the soil of Mars

Analyses of Martian surface soil by Viking and Earth-based telescopes have been interpreted as indicating a regolith dominated by the weathering products of mafic or ultramafic rocks. Basaltic glass has previously been proposed as a more likely precursor than crystalline rock, given the low efficiency of surface weathering under present Martian conditions. On Earth large volumes of basaltic glass formed by quenching of magma by water. A similar interaction, between magma and ground ice, may have been a common occurrence on Mars. On the basis of this scenario palagonite, the alteration product of basaltic sideromelane glass, was studied as a possible analog to Martian soil. Samples from Iceland, Alaska, Antarctica, Hawaii, and the desert of New Mexico and Mexico were examined by optical and scanning electron microscopy, electron microprobe analysis, X-ray diffraction, spectrophotometry, and magnetic and thermogravimetric analysis. We suggest that palagonite is a good analog to the surface soil of Mars in chemical composition, particle size, spectral signature, and magnetic properties. Our model for the formation of fine-grained Martian surface soil begins with eruptions of basaltic magma through ground ice, forming deposits of glassy tuff. Individual glass shards are then altered by low-temperature hydrothermal systems to palagonitic material. Dehydration and aeolian abrasion strip the alteration rinds from the glass, and wind storms distribute the silt-sized palagonitic fragments in a planet-wide deposit.