The stability of inner collinear equilibrium points in the photogravitational elliptic restricted problem

The linear stability of the inner collinear equilibrium point of the photogravitational elliptic restricted three-body problem is examined and the stability regions are determined in the space of the parameters of mass, eccentricity and radiation pressure. The case of equal radiation factors of the two primaries is considered and the full range of values of the common radiation factor is explored, from the caseq ₁ =q ₂ =q = 1/8 at which the triangular equilibria disappear by coalescing on the rotating axis of the primaries transferring their stability to the collinear point, down toq = 0 at which value the stability regions in theµ - e plane disappear by shrinking down to zero size. It is found that radiation pressure exerts a significant influence on the stability regions. For certain intervals of radiation values these regions become qualitatively different from the gravitational case as well as the solar system case. They evolve as in the case of the triangular equilibrium point considered in a previous paper. There exist values of the common radiation factor, in the range considered, for which the collinear equilibrium point is stable for the entire range of mass distribution among the primaries and for large eccentricities of their orbits.     

Resonance stability of triangular equilibrium points in elliptical restricted three body problem under the radiating primaries

The main aim of this paper is to study the existence of resonance and linear stability of the triangular equilibrium points of the planar elliptical restricted three body problem considering the photo gravitational effect of both the primaries in circular and elliptical case. A practical application of this case could be the study of the dynamical system around the binary systems. For this the Hamiltonian function, convergent in nature and describing the motion of the infinitesimal body in the neighborhood of the triangular equilibrium solutions is derived. Also, the Hamiltonian for the system is expanded in powers of the generalized components of momenta. Further, canonical transformation has also been used to study the stability of the triangular equilibrium points. The study primarily focuses on establishing the relation for determining the range of stability at and near the resonance frequency ω ₂=1/2 around the binary systems using simulation technique. It is observed that the parametric resonance is only possible at the resonance frequency ω ₂=1/2 in both circular and elliptical cases.     

Linear stability of equilibrium points in the generalized photogravitational Chermnykh’s problem

The equilibrium points and their linear stability has been discussed in the generalized photogravitational Chermnykh’s problem. The bigger primary is being considered as a source of radiation and small primary as an oblate spheroid. The effect of radiation pressure has been discussed numerically. The collinear points are linearly unstable and triangular points are stable in the sense of Lyapunov stability provided μ<μ _Routh =0.0385201. The effect of gravitational potential from the belt is also examined. The mathematical properties of this system are different from the classical restricted three body problem.     

Stability of the photogravitational restricted three-body problem with variable masses

This paper investigates the stability of equilibrium points in the restricted three-body problem, in which the masses of the luminous primaries vary isotropically in accordance with the unified Meshcherskii law, and their motion takes place within the framework of the Gylden–Meshcherskii problem. For the autonomized system, it is found that collinear and coplanar points are unstable, while the triangular points are conditionally stable. It is also observed that, in the triangular case, the presence of a constant κ, of a particular integral of the Gylden–Meshcherskii problem, makes the destabilizing tendency of the radiation pressures strong. The stability of equilibrium points varying with time is tested using the Lyapunov Characteristic Numbers (LCN). It is seen that the range of stability or instability depends on the parameter κ. The motion around the equilibrium points L _i (i=1,2,…,7) for the restricted three-body problem with variable masses is in general unstable.     

Numerical Exploration of Chermnykh’s Problem

We study the equilibrium points and the zero-velocity curves of Chermnykh’s problem when the angular velocity ω varies continuously and the value of the mass parameter is fixed. The planar symmetric simple-periodic orbits are determined numerically and they are presented for three values of the parameter ω. The stability of the periodic orbits of all the families is computed. Particularly, we explore the network of the families when the angular velocity has the critical value ω = 2√2 at which the triangular equilibria disappear by coalescing with the collinear equilibrium point L₁. The analytic determination of the initial conditions of the family which emanate from the Lagrangian libration point L₁ in this case, is given. Non-periodic orbits, as points on a surface of section, providing an outlook of the stability regions, chaotic and escape motions as well as multiple-periodic orbits, are also computed. Non-linear stability zones of the triangular Lagrangian points are computed numerically for the Earth–Moon and Sun–Jupiter mass distribution when the angular velocity varies.     

Linear stability of the triangular equilibrium points in the photogravitational elliptic restricted problem,II

The linear stability of the triangular equilibrium points in the photogravitational elliptic restricted three-body problem is examined and the stability regions are determined in the space of the parameters of mass, eccentricity, and radiation pressure, in the case of equal radiation factors of the two primaries. The full range of values of the common radiation factor is explored, from the gravitational caseq ₁ =q ₂ =q = 1 down to the critical value ofq = 1/8 at which the triangular equilibria disappear by coalescing on the rotating axis of the primaries. It is found that radiation pressure exerts a significant influence on the stability regions. For certain intervals of radiation values these regions become qualitatively different from the gravitational case as well as the solar system case considered in Paper I. There exist values of the common radiation factor, in the range considered, for which the triangular equilibrium points are stable for the entire range of mass distribution among the primaries and for large eccentricities of their orbits.     

Periodic orbits in the generalized perturbed restricted three-body problem

This paper studies the existence and stability of equilibrium points under the influence of small perturbations in the Coriolis and the centrifugal forces, together with the non-sphericity of the primaries. The problem is generalized in the sense that the bigger and smaller primaries are respectively triaxial and oblate spheroidal bodies. It is found that the locations of equilibrium points are affected by the non-sphericity of the bodies and the change in the centrifugal force. It is also seen that the triangular points are stable for 0<μ<μ _c and unstable for m_c ￡ m < \frac12\mu_{c}\le\mu <\frac{1}{2}, where μ _c is the critical mass parameter depending on the above perturbations, triaxiality and oblateness. It is further observed that collinear points remain unstable.     

Non-symmetric doubly-asymptotic orbits at the outer collinear equilibrium pointL 3

In the framework of the solar system case (with only the larger primary radiating) of the photogravitational restricted three-body problem we compute and present some non-symmetric asymptotic orbits connecting the outer collinear equilibrium pointL ₃ with the neighbourhood of one of the triangular equilibrium pointsL _{4, 5}. Such orbits have not been found previously in the restricted problem.     

Motion Around The Triangular Equilibrium Points Of The Restricted Three-Body Problem Under Angular Velocity Variation

We study numerically the asymmetric periodic orbits which emanate from the triangular equilibrium points of the restricted three-body problem under the assumption that the angular velocity ω varies and for the Sun–Jupiter mass distribution. The symmetric periodic orbits emanating from the collinear Lagrangian point L ₃, which are related to them, are also examined. The analytic determination of the initial conditions of the long- and short-period Trojan families around the equilibrium points, is given. The corresponding families were examined, for a combination of the mass ratio and the angular velocity (case of equal eigenfrequencies), and also for the critical value ω = 2

Stability of L4 and L5 against radiation pressure

The restricted three-body problem is generalized with the inclusion of solar radiation pressure. For small particles (typically 1 m to 1 mm) the familiar equilibrium triangular points L₄ and L₅ no longer exist. However libration orbits are not completely destroyed, although an effect of resonance causes their amplitude to be very large, for a particle initially at rest at either of the triangular point. Finally the results of a study of the linearized equations of motion, supplemented by a numerical integration, rule out the possibility of an accumulation of dust at the Earth-Moon lagrangian triangular points.     

Equilibrium points and stability in the restricted three-body problem with oblateness and variable masses

The existence and stability of a test particle around the equilibrium points in the restricted three-body problem is generalized to include the effect of variations in oblateness of the first primary, small perturbations ϵ and ϵ′ given in the Coriolis and centrifugal forces α and β respectively, and radiation pressure of the second primary; in the case when the primaries vary their masses with time in accordance with the combined Meshcherskii law. For the autonomized system, we use a numerical evidence to compute the positions of the collinear points L _2κ , which exist for 0<κ<∞, where κ is a constant of a particular integral of the Gylden-Meshcherskii problem; oblateness of the first primary; radiation pressure of the second primary; the mass parameter ν and small perturbation in the centrifugal force. Real out of plane equilibrium points exist only for κ>1, provided the abscissae x < \fracn(k-1)b\xi<\frac{\nu(\kappa-1)}{\beta}. In the case of the triangular points, it is seen that these points exist for ϵ′<κ<∞ and are affected by the oblateness term, radiation pressure and the mass parameter. The linear stability of these equilibrium points is examined. It is seen that the collinear points L _2κ are stable for very small κ and the involved parameters, while the out of plane equilibrium points are unstable. The conditional stability of the triangular points depends on all the system parameters. Further, it is seen in the case of the triangular points, that the stabilizing or destabilizing behavior of the oblateness coefficient is controlled by κ, while those of the small perturbations depends on κ and whether these perturbations are positive or negative. However, the destabilizing behavior of the radiation pressure remains unaltered but grows weak or strong with increase or decrease in κ. This study reveals that oblateness coefficient can exhibit a stabilizing tendency in a certain range of κ, as against the findings of the RTBP with constant masses. Interestingly, in the region of stable motion, these parameters are void for k = \frac43\kappa=\frac{4}{3}. The decrease, increase or non existence in the region of stability of the triangular points depends on κ, oblateness of the first primary, small perturbations and the radiation pressure of the second body, as it is seen that the increasing region of stability becomes decreasing, while the decreasing region becomes increasing due to the inclusion of oblateness of the first primary.     

Comment on the paper “On the triangular libration points in photogravitational restricted three-body problem with variable mass” by Zhang, M.J., et al.

In a recent paper, published in Astrophys. Space Sci. (337:107, 2012) (hereafter paper ZZX) and entitled “On the triangular libration points in photogravitational restricted three-body problem with variable mass”, the authors study the location and stability of the generalized Lagrange libration points L ₄ and L ₅. However their study is flawed in two aspects. First they fail to write correctly the equations of motion of the variable mass problem. Second they attribute a variable mass to the third body of the restricted three-body model, a fact that is not compatible with the assumptions used in deriving the mathematical formulation of this model.     

Stability of triangular equilibrium points of oblate infinitesimal influenced by oblate and radiating primaries in Elliptic Restricted Three Body Problem based on Floquet’s theory

This paper deals with the stability analysis of the triangular equilibrium points for the generalized problem of the photogravitational restricted three body where both the primaries are radiating. The problem is generalized in the sense that the eccentricity of the orbits and the oblateness due to both the primaries and infinitesimal are considered. The stability in the case of linear resonance are analyzed based on the Floquet’s theory for finding the characteristic exponent for a system containing periodic coefficients. It was found that the critical value of μ for the stability boundary for parametric excitation is dependent on the oblateness of the primaries as well as infinitesimal.     

Motion around L 4 in the perturbed relativistic R3BP

This paper studies the motion of a test particle (infinitesimal mass) in the neighborhood of the triangular point L ₄ in the framework of the perturbed relativistic restricted three-body problem (R3BP). The problem is perturbed in the sense that a small perturbation is given to the centrifugal force. It is found that the position and stability of the triangular point are affected by both the relativistic factor and a small perturbation in the centrifugal force.     

Equilibrium points and stability under effect of radiation and perturbing forces in the restricted problem of three oblate bodies

This paper presents a generalized problem of the restricted three body studied in Abdul Raheem and Singh with the inclusion that the third body is an oblate spheroidal test particle of infinitesimally mass. The positions and stability of the equilibrium point of this problem is studied for a model in which the primaries is the binary system Struve 2398 (Gliese 725) in the constellation Draco; which consist of a pair of radiating oblate stars. It is seen that additional equilibrium points exist on the line collinear with the primaries, for some combined parameters of the problem. Hence, there can be up to five collinear equilibrium points. Two triangular points exist and depends on the oblateness of the participating bodies, radiation pressure of the primaries and a small perturbation in the centrifugal force. The stability analysis ensures that, the collinear equilibrium points are unstable in the linear sense while the triangular points are stable under certain conditions. Illustrative numerical exploration is given to indicate significant improvement of the problem in Abdul Raheem and Singh.     

Stability of Co-Orbital Motion in Exoplanetary Systems

The stability of co-orbital motions is investigated in such exoplanetary systems, where the only known giant planet either moves fully in the habitable zone, or leaves it for some part of its orbit. If the regions around the triangular Lagrangian points are stable, they are possible places for smaller Trojan-like planets. We have determined the nonlinear stability regions around the Lagrangian point L₄ of nine exoplanetary systems in the model of the elliptic restricted three-body problem by using the method of the relative Lyapunov indicators. According to our results, all systems could possess small Trojan-like planets. Several features of the stability regions are also discussed. Finally, the size of the stability region around L₄ in the elliptic restricted three-body problem is determined as a function of the mass parameter and eccentricity.     

Nonlinear stability of equilibrium points in the restricted three-body problem with variable mass

The nonlinear stability of the equilibrium points in the restricted three-body problem with variable mass has been studied. It is found that, in the nonlinear sense, the collinear points are unstable for all mass ratios and the triangular points are stable in the range of linear stability except for three mass ratios, which depend upon β, the constant due to the variation in mass governed by Jeans’ law.     

Motion close to the Hopf Bifurcation Of the vertical family of periodic orbits of L4

The paper deals with different kinds of invariant motions (periodic orbits, 2D and 3D invariant tori and invariant manifolds of periodic orbits) in order to analyze the Hamiltonian direct Hopf bifurcation that takes place close to the Lyapunov vertical family of periodic orbits of the triangular equilibrium point L₄ in the 3D restricted three-body problem (RTBP) for the mass parameter, μ greater than (and close to) μ_R (Routh’s mass parameter). Consequences of such bifurcation, concerning the confinement of the motion close to the hyperbolic orbits and the 3D nearby tori are also described.     

On the triangular libration points in photogravitational restricted three-body problem with variable mass

This paper investigates the triangular libration points in the photogravitational restricted three-body problem of variable mass, in which both the attracting bodies are radiating as well and the infinitesimal body vary its mass with time according to Jeans’ law. Firstly, applying the space-time transformation of Meshcherskii in the special case when q=1/2, k=0, n=1, the differential equations of motion of the problem are given. Secondly, in analogy to corresponding problem with constant mass, the positions of analogous triangular libration points are obtained, and the fact that these triangular libration points cease to be classical ones when α≠0, but turn to classical L ₄ and L ₅ naturally when α=0 is pointed out. Lastly, introducing the space-time inverse transformation of Meshcherskii, the linear stability of triangular libration points is tested when α>0. It is seen that the motion around the triangular libration points become unstable in general when the problem with constant mass evolves into the problem with decreasing mass.     

Existence of equilibrium points and their linear stability in the generalized photogravitational Chermnykh-like problem with power-law profile

We consider the modified restricted three body problem with power-law density profile of disk, which rotates around the center of mass of the system with perturbed mean motion. Using analytical and numerical methods, we have found equilibrium points and examined their linear stability. We have also found the zero velocity surface for the present model. In addition to five equilibrium points there exists a new equilibrium point on the line joining the two primaries. It is found that L ₁ and L ₃ are stable for some values of inner and outer radius of the disk while other collinear points are unstable, but L ₄ is conditionally stable for mass ratio less than that of Routh’s critical value. Lastly, we have studied the effects of radiation pressure, oblateness and mass of the disk on the motion and stability of equilibrium points.