Improved absolute calibration of LOPES measurements and its impact on the comparison with REAS 3.11 and CoREAS simulations

LOPES was a digital antenna array detecting the radio emission of cosmic-ray air showers. The calibration of the absolute amplitude scale of the measurements was done using an external, commercial reference source, which emits a frequency comb with defined amplitudes. Recently, we obtained improved reference values by the manufacturer of the reference source, which significantly changed the absolute calibration of LOPES. We reanalyzed previously published LOPES measurements, studying the impact of the changed calibration. The main effect is an overall decrease of the LOPES amplitude scale by a factor of 2.6 ± 0.2, affecting all previously published values for measurements of the electric-field strength. This results in a major change in the conclusion of the paper ‘Comparing LOPES measurements of air-shower radio emission with REAS 3.11 and CoREAS simulations’ published by Apel et al. (2013) : With the revised calibration, LOPES measurements now are compatible with CoREAS simulations, but in tension with REAS 3.11 simulations. Since CoREAS is the latest version of the simulation code incorporating the current state of knowledge on the radio emission of air showers, this new result indicates that the absolute amplitude prediction of current simulations now is in agreement with experimental data.     

Lofar

H01 A first glance at LOFAR: Experience with the Initial Test Station H02 The Square Kilometer Array (SKA) – Status and Prospects H03 LOFAR calibration: confrontation with real WSRT data H04 Simulations of magnetic fields in the cosmos H05 RM structure in the polarized synchrotron emission from our Galaxy and the Perseus cluster of Galaxies H06 Mapping the Reionization Era through the 21 cm Emission Line H07 Spiral galaxies seen with LOFAR H08 Software Infrastructure for Distributed Data Processing H09 The Low Frequency Array (LOFAR) – Status and Prospects H10 Coincident cosmic ray measurements with LOPES and KASCADE‐Grande H11 Radio relics in a cosmological cluster merger simulation H12 Detection of radio pulses from cosmic ray air showers with LOPES H13 Geosynchrotron radio emission from extensive air showers H14 Imaging capabilities of future radio telescopes H15 Digital signal processing system of Multi‐Beam Meter Wavelengths Array. H16 The Multi‐Beam Meter Wavelengths Array H17 Monitoring of the Solar Activity by LOFAR H18 Calibration of LOPES30 H19 An Outreach Project for LOFAR and Cosmic Ray Detection H20 Galactic tomography based on observations with LOFAR and Effelsberg H21 150 MHz observations with the Westerbork and GMRT radio telescopes of Abell 2256 and the Bootes field: Ultra‐steep spectrum radio sources as probes of cluster and galaxy evolution H22 Experience of simultaneous observations with two independent multi‐beams of the Large Phased Array H23 GRID Computing at Forschungszentrum Karlsruhe suitable for LOFAR     

The shape of the radio wavefront of extensive air showers as measured with LOFAR

Extensive air showers, induced by high energy cosmic rays impinging on the Earth’s atmosphere, produce radio emission that is measured with the LOFAR radio telescope. As the emission comes from a finite distance of a few kilometers, the incident wavefront is non-planar. A spherical, conical or hyperbolic shape of the wavefront has been proposed, but measurements of individual air showers have been inconclusive so far. For a selected high-quality sample of 161 measured extensive air showers, we have reconstructed the wavefront by measuring pulse arrival times to sub-nanosecond precision in 200 to 350 individual antennas. For each measured air shower, we have fitted a conical, spherical, and hyperboloid shape to the arrival times. The fit quality and a likelihood analysis show that a hyperboloid is the best parameterization. Using a non-planar wavefront shape gives an improved angular resolution, when reconstructing the shower arrival direction. Furthermore, a dependence of the wavefront shape on the shower geometry can be seen. This suggests that it will be possible to use a wavefront shape analysis to get an additional handle on the atmospheric depth of the shower maximum, which is sensitive to the mass of the primary particle.     

Prospects for radio detection of ultra-high energy cosmic rays and neutrinos

The origin and nature of the highest energy cosmic ray events is currently the subject of intense investigation by giant air shower arrays and fluorescent detectors. These particles reach energies well beyond what can be achieved in ground-based particle accelerators and hence they are fundamental probes for particle physics as well as astrophysics. One of the main topics today focuses on the high energy end of the spectrum and the potential for the production of high-energy neutrinos. Above about 10²⁰ eV cosmic rays from extragalactic sources are expected to be severely attenuated by pion photoproduction interactions with photons of the cosmic microwave background. Investigating the shape of the cosmic ray spectrum near this predicted cut-off will be very important. In addition, a significant high-energy neutrino background is naturally expected as part of the pion decay chain which also contains much information.Because of the scarcity of these high-energy particles, larger and larger ground-based detectors have been built. The new generation of digital radio telescopes may play an important role in this, if properly designed. Radio detection of cosmic ray showers has a long history but was abandoned in the 1970s. Recent experimental developments together with sophisticated air shower simulations incorporating radio emission give a clearer understanding of the relationship between the air shower parameters and the radio signal, and have led to resurgence in its use. Observations of air showers by the SKA could, because of its large collecting area, contribute significantly to measuring the cosmic ray spectrum at the highest energies. Because of the large surface area of the moon, and the expected excellent angular resolution of the SKA, using the SKA to detect radio Cherenkov emission from neutrino-induced cascades in lunar regolith will be potentially the most important technique for investigating cosmic ray origin at energies above the photoproduction cut-off.     

Coherent radio emission from cosmic ray air-showers in the turbulent atmosphere

Coherent electromagnetic erenkov radiation is produced by cosmic ray air showers passing through the atmosphere. This radiation is detected by radio telescopes. We demonstrate here that the effect of random spatial fluctuations in the refractive index of air, about a mean exceeding unity, causes the airshower to emit not only the spontaneous coherent radio emission described elsewhere by Kahn and Lerche, but also an induced radiation field which can exceed the spontaneous field in certain frequency bands. Further the conditions for emission of the coherent radio erenkov radiation are altered by the presence of the refractive index fluctuations. And the Earth's magnetic field gives rise to the dominant term in the far-field radiation, be it spontaneous or induced, since it causes a systematic separation of electrons and positrons in the shower which, for parameters currently acceptable for air showers, is the major factor in determining the far-field radiation pattern. Also we suggest that the coherent 500 Mc/sec radiation seen from occasional showers is probably a reflection of an atmospheric correlation length of order 15 cm at the time the shower passes through the atmosphere.     

Comparison of measured and simulated lateral distributions for electrons and muons with KASCADE

Lateral distributions for electrons and muons in extensive air showers measured with the array of the KASCADE experiment are compared to results of simulations based on the high-energy hadronic interaction models QGSJet and SIBYLL. It is shown, that the muon distributions are well described by both models. Deviations are found for the electromagnetic component, where both models predict a steeper lateral shape than observed in the data. For both models the observed lateral shapes of the electron component indicate a transition from a light to a more heavy composition of the cosmic ray spectrum above the knee.     

Monte Carlo simulations of radio pulses in atmospheric showers using ZHAireS

We present predictions for the radio pulses emitted by extensive air showers using ZHAireS, an AIRES-based Monte Carlo code that takes into account the full complexity of ultra-high energy cosmic-ray induced shower development in the atmosphere, and allows the calculation of the electric field in both the time and frequency domains. We do not presuppose any emission mechanism and our results are compatible with a superposition of geomagnetic and charge excess radio emission effects. We investigate the polarization of the electric field as well as the effects of the refractive index n and shower geometry on the radio pulses. We show that geometry, coupled to the relativistic effects that appear when using a realistic refractive index n > 1, play a prominent role on the radio emission of air showers.     

The air shower maximum probed by Cherenkov effects from radio emission

Radio detection of cosmic-ray-induced air showers has come to a flight the last decade. Along with the experimental efforts, several theoretical models were developed. The main radio-emission mechanisms are established to be the geomagnetic emission due to deflection of electrons and positrons in Earth’s magnetic field and the charge-excess emission due to a net electron excess in the air shower front. It was only recently shown that Cherenkov effects play an important role in the radio emission from air showers. In this article we show the importance of these effects to extract quantitatively the position of the shower maximum from the radio signal, which is a sensitive measure for the mass of the initial cosmic ray. We also show that the relative magnitude of the charge-excess and geomagnetic emission changes considerably at small observer distances where Cherenkov effects apply.     

Evidence for the charge-excess contribution in air shower radio emission observed by the CODALEMA experiment

CODALEMA is one of the pioneer experiments dedicated to the radio detection of ultra high energy cosmic rays (UHECR), located at the radio observatory of Nançay (France). The CODALEMA experiment uses both a particle detector array and a radio antenna array. Data from both detection systems have been used to determine the ground coordinates of the core of extensive air showers (EAS). We discuss the observed systematic shift of the core positions determined with these two detection techniques. We show that this shift is due to the charge-excess contribution to the total radio emission of air showers, using the simulation code SELFAS. The dependences of the radio core shift to the primary cosmic ray characteristics are studied in details. The observation of this systematic shift can be considered as an experimental signature of the charge excess contribution.     

A parameterization for the radio emission of air showers as predicted by CoREAS simulations and applied to LOFAR measurements

Measuring radio emission from air showers provides excellent opportunities to directly measure all air shower properties, including the shower development. To exploit this in large-scale experiments, a simple and analytic parameterization of the distribution of the radio signal at ground level is needed. Data taken with the Low-Frequency Array (LOFAR) show a complex two-dimensional pattern of pulse powers, which is sensitive to the shower geometry. Earlier parameterizations of the lateral signal distribution have proven insufficient to describe these data. In this article, we present a parameterization derived from air-shower simulations. We are able to fit the two-dimensional distribution with a double Gaussian, requiring five fit parameters. All parameters show strong correlations with air shower properties, such as the energy of the shower, the arrival direction, and the shower maximum. We successfully apply the parameterization to data taken with LOFAR and discuss implications for air shower experiments.     

Can intergalactic suprathermal grains produce extensive air showers?

The events following the impact of intergalactic suprathermal grains with atmosphere are examined, and some similarity is found between the expected air shower and observations of largest cosmic ray showers. It is concluded that the largest air showers are, in any case, initiated by primaries of intergalactic origin. Whether the primaries are suprathermal dust grains or single nuclei is inconclusive.     

Coherent synchrotron emission from cosmic ray air showers

Coherent synchrotron emission by particles moving along semi-infinite tracks is discussed, with a specific application to radio emission from air showers induced by high-energy cosmic rays. It is shown that in general, radiation from a particle moving along a semi-infinite orbit consists of usual synchrotron emission and modified impulsive bremsstrahlung. The latter component is due to the instantaneous onset of the curved trajectory of the emitting particle at its creation. Inclusion of the bremsstrahlung leads to broadening of the radiation pattern and a slower decay of the spectrum at the cut-off frequency than the conventional synchrotron emission. Possible implications of these features for air shower radio emission are discussed.     

Gamma-Hadron Separation using Čerenkov Photon Density Fluctuations

In the atmospheric Čerenkov technique γ-rays are detected against the abundant background produced by hadronic showers. In order to improve the signal to noise ratio of theexperiment, it is necessary to reject a significant fraction of hadronic showers. Traditional background rejection methods based on image shape parameters have been extensively used for the data from imaging telescopes. However, non-imaging Čerenkov telescopes have to develop very different means of statistically identifying and removing cosmic ray events. Some of the parameters, which could be potentially important for non-imaging arrays, are the temporal and spectral differences, the lateral distributions and density fluctuations of Čerenkov photons generated by γ-ray and hadron primaries. Here we study the differences in fluctuations of Čerenkov photon density in the light pool at the observation level from showers initiated by photons and those initiated by protons or heavier nuclei. The database of simulated events for the PACT array has been used to evaluate the efficiency of the new technique. Various types of density fluctuations like the short range and medium range fluctuations as well as flatness parameter are studied. The estimated quality factors reflect the efficiencies with which the hadrons can be rejected from the data. Since some of these parameters are independent, the cuts may be applied in tandem and we demonstrate that the proton rejection efficiency of ∼90% can be achieved. Use of density fluctuations is particularly suited for wavefront sampling observations and it seems to be a good technique to improve the signal to noise ratio. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Numerical simulation of radio signal from extended air showers

The burst of radio emission by an extensive air shower provides a promising alternative for detecting ultra-high energy cosmic rays. We have developed an independent numerical program to simulate these radio signals. Our code is based on a microscopic treatment, with both the geosynchrotron radiation and charge included.Here we give the first presentation of our basic program and its results. When the time-domain signals for different polarizations are computed, we find that the pulses take on a bipolar pattern and the spectrum is suppressed towards the lower frequencies. We investigate how showers at different heights in the atmosphere contribute to the total signal, and examine the signal strength and distribution at sites with different elevations. We also study the signal from showers with different inclination angles and azimuth directions. In all these cases we find the charge excess effect is important.     

Coherent Cherenkov radio pulses from hadronic showers up to EeV energies

The Cherenkov radio pulse emitted by hadronic showers of energies in the EeV range in ice is calculated for the first time using full three dimensional simulations of both shower development and the coherent radio pulse emitted as the excess charge develops in the shower. A Monte Carlo, ZHAireS, has been developed for this purpose combining the high energy hadronic interaction capabilities of AIRES, and the dense media propagation capabilities of TIERRAS, with the precise low energy tracking and specific algorithms developed to calculate the radio emission in ZHS. A thinning technique is implemented to allow the simulation of radio pulses induced by showers up to 10 EeV in ice. The code is validated comparing the results for electromagnetic and hadronic showers to those obtained with GEANT4 and ZHS codes. The contribution to the pulse of other shower particles in addition to electrons and positrons, mainly protons, pions and muons, is found to be below 3% for 10 PeV and above proton induced showers. The characteristics of hadronic showers and the corresponding Cherenkov frequency spectra are compared with those from purely electromagnetic showers. The dependence of the spectra on shower energy and high-energy hadronic model is addressed and parameterizations for the radio emission in hadronic showers in ice are given for practical applications.     

Multi‐Messenger Cosmic Particles

A54 Cosmic Ray Acceleration in Galactic Wind Shocks A71 Detection of Ultra‐High Energy Cosmic Rays and Neutrinos with LOFAR A80 Status of the gravitational‐wave detector GEO600 A87 Recent Results and Future of the MAGIC gamma‐ray telescope A92 Cosmic ray detection with the radio technique A93 Cosmic Ray Physics with IceCube A94 The resonance‐like gamma‐ray absorption processes for use in astrophysics A97 Geometry reconstruction of air shower fluorescence detectors revisited A102 Supermassive Binary Black Holes & Radio Jets A108 Muonic Component of Air Showers Measured by KASCADE‐Grande A110 Towards new frontiers: observation of photons with energies above 10¹⁸ eV A112 The IceCube Neutrino Telescope A114 The ground‐based gamma‐ray observatory CTA A116 IceCube: Recent Results and Prospects A117 Particle Physics with AMANDA and IceCube A118 Altitude dependence of fluorescence light emission by extensive air showers A120 Neutrino‐induced cascades in AMANDA & IceCube A122 Enhancement Telescopes for the Pierre Auger Southern Observatory in Argentina A123 Proton spectra from relativistic shock environments in AGN and GRBs A124 The Baikal Neutrino Telescope – Physics Results A127 Searches for point‐like sources of cosmic neutrinos with IceCube A128 The MAGIC/IceCube Target of Opportunity Programtest run A131 Supernova detection with IceCube: from low to high energy neutrinos A132 Measurement of the UHECR energy spectrum from hybrid data of the Pierre Auger Observatory A133 Extension of IceCube at Lower Energy: the Use of AMANDA as Nested Array and the Future Prospectives A135 Searching for neutrinos with the Pierre Auger Observatory A138 Search for Transient Emission of Neutrinos in IceCube A140 Acoustic Neutrino Detection in Antarctic Ice A159 AMANDA limits on the diffuse muon‐neutrino flux: physics implications A164 Investigation of the Radio Emission of Cosmic Ray Air Showers with LOPES A168 The Northern Site of the Pierre Auger Observatory A170 Shower reconstruction and size spectra with KASCADE‐Grande data A171 Neutrinos from Gamma Ray Bursts: predictions and limits from AMANDA‐II data A172 Simulation study of shower profiles from ultra‐high energy cosmic rays A174 Upper limit to the photon fraction in cosmic rays above 10¹⁹ eV from the Pierre Auger Observatory A176 Astrophysics at MeV energies A180 Study of the Cosmic Ray Composition above 0.4 EeV using the Longitudinal Profiles of Showers observed at the Pierre Auger Observatory A185 Backgrounds for UHE horizontal neutrino showers A186 The Front‐End Cards of the Pierre Auger Surface Detectors: Test Results and Performance in the Field A187 Monte Carlo Studies for MAGIC‐II A194 Measuring the proton‐air cross section from logitudinal air shower profiles A195 The UHECR energy spectrummeasured at the Pierre Auger Observatory A203 Highlights of Observations of Galactic Sources with the MAGIC telescope A207 Adesign study for a 12.5 m ∅︁ Imaging Air Cherenkov Telescope for ground‐based γ ‐ray astronomy A210 The Future of Long‐Wavelengths Radio‐Astronomy in Germany: LOFAR and GLOW A211 Online Monitoring of the Pierre Auger Observatory A216 OPTIMA‐Burst – Catching GRB Afterglows (and other Transients) with High Time Resolution A227 JEM‐EUSO mission A232 Rapid Variations in AGN: Clues on Particle Accelerators A235 Systematic search forVHEgamma‐ray emission from X‐ray bright high‐frequency peaked BL Lac objects A237 Prospects for GeV Astronomy in the Era of GLAST A241 Improvements of the energy reconstruction for the MAGIC telescope by means of analysis and Monte Carlo techniques A265 Discovery of VHE γ ‐rays from BL Lacertae with the MAGIC telescope A266 Results of two observation cycles of LS I+61°303 with the MAGIC telescope A267 Wide Range Multifrequency Observations of Northern TeV Blazars A269 Diffusive and convective cosmic ray transport in elliptical galaxies     

Radio pulses from ultra-high energy atmospheric showers as the superposition of Askaryan and geomagnetic mechanisms

Radio emission in atmospheric showers is currently interpreted in terms of radiation due to the deviation of the charged particles in the magnetic field of the Earth and to the charge excess (Askaryan effect). Each of these mechanisms has a distinctive polarization. The complex signal patterns can be qualitatively explained as the interference (superposition) of the fields induced by each mechanism. In this work we explicitly and quantitatively test a simple phenomenological model based on this idea. The model is constructed by isolating each of the two components at the simulation level and by making use of approximate symmetries for each of the contributions separately. The results of the model are then checked against full ZHAireS Monte Carlo simulations of the electric field calculated from first principles. We show that the simple model describes radio emission at a few percent level in a wide range of shower-observer geometries and on a shower-by-shower basis. As a consequence, this approach provides a simple method to reduce the computing time needed to accurately predict the electric field of radio pulses emitted from air showers, with many practical applications in experimental situations of interest.     

Measurement of the cosmic-ray energy spectrum above 1016 eV with the LOFAR Radboud Air Shower Array

The energy reconstruction of extensive air showers measured with the LOFAR Radboud Air Shower Array (LORA) is presented in detail. LORA is a particle detector array located in the center of the LOFAR radio telescope in the Netherlands. The aim of this work is to provide an accurate and independent energy measurement for the air showers measured through their radio signal with the LOFAR antennas. The energy reconstruction is performed using a parameterized relation between the measured shower size and the cosmic-ray energy obtained from air shower simulations. In order to illustrate the capabilities of LORA, the all-particle cosmic-ray energy spectrum has been reconstructed, assuming that cosmic rays are composed only of protons or iron nuclei in the energy range between ∼2 × 10¹⁶ and 2 × 10¹⁸ eV. The results are compatible with literature values and a changing mass composition in the transition region from a Galactic to an extragalactic origin of cosmic rays.