The structure of the polar ionosphere during exceptionally quiet periods

Knowledge of the structure of the polar ionosphere during exceptionally quiet periods is basic for studying complicated ionospheric behaviors during disturbances. On the basis of data from an airborne ionosonde as well as a meridian chain of ground-basedionosondes, the circumpolar structure of the E,-and F-regions is elucidated. There are two circumpolar zones of E-region ionization with differing characteristics. The first is an auroral E,-layer and/or retarded type sporadic E-band that has previously (Whalen et al., 1971) been found to be identical with the continuous aurora. The second is a zone of non-retarded type spora die E located poleward of the former band. In general, discrete auroras are co-located with the latter. The main trough, a prominent feature of the night sector F-region, is most pronounced in the early morning. The main trough is bounded on the poleward side by a well defined ‘wall’ of F-region ionization. The night sector poleward trough wall is located approximately three degrees of latitude equatorward of the auroral oval. A ‘plateau’ of F-region ionization extends from the poleward trough wall to the auroral oval.     

A snapshot of the polar ionosphere

This paper presents a picture of the north polar F layer and topside ionosphere obtained primarily from three satellites (Alouette 2, ISIS 1, ISIS 2), that passed over the region within a time interval of ca. 50 min on 25 April 1971, a magnetically quiet day. The horizontal distribution of electron densities at the peak of the F layer is found to be similar to synoptic results from the IGY. Energetic particle and ionospheric plasma data are also presented, and the F layer data are discussed in terms of these measurements, and also in terms of electric field and neutral N₂ density measurements made by other satellites on other occasions. The major features observed are as follows: A tongue of F region ionization extends from the dayside across the polar cap, which is accounted for by antisunward drift due to magnetospheric convection. In the F layer and topside ionosphere, the main effect of auroral precipitation appears to be heating and expansion of the topside. A region of low F layer density appears on the morning side of the polar cap, which may be due to convection and possibly also to enhanced N₂ densities.     

Photoionization rates in the night-time E- and F-region ionosphere1

Quantitative estimates of ionization sources that maintain the night-time E- and F-region ionosphere are given. Starlight (stellar continuum radiation in the spectral inverval 911–1026 Å) and resonance scattering of solar Ly-β into the night sector are the most important sources in the E-region and are capable of maintaining observable electron densities of order (1–4) × 10³ cm^?3. Starlight ionization rates have substantial variations (factors of 2–4) with latitude and time of year since the brightest stars in the night sky occur in the southern Milky Way and Orion regions. In the lower F-region the major O⁺ source in the equatorial ionosphere is 910 Å radiation from the O⁺ recombination in the F2-region, whereas in the extratropical ionosphere interplanetary 584 Å radiation only exceeds resonance scattering of solar 584 and 304 Å radiation as the dominant O⁺ source during the month of December.     

The composition,structure, temperature and dynamics of the upper thermosphere in the polar regions during October to December 1981

During the period October to December 1981, the Dynamics Explorer-2 (DE-2) spacecraft successively observed the South polar and the North polar regions, and recorded the temperature, composition and dynamical structure of the upper thermosphere. In October 1981, perigee was about 310 km altitude, in the vicinity of the South Pole, with the satellite orbit in the 09.00–21.00 L.T. plane. During late November and December, the perigee had precessed to the region of the North Pole, with the spacecraft sampling the upper thermosphere in the 06.00 18.00 L.T. plane. DE-2 observed the meridional wind with a Fabry-Perot interferometer (FPI), the zonal wind with the wind and temperature spectrometer (WATS), the neutral temperature with the FPI, and the neutral atmosphere composition and density with the neutral atmosphere composition spectrometer (NACS). A comparison between the South (summer) Pole and the North (winter) Pole data shows considerable seasonal differences in all neutral atmosphere parameters. The region of the summer pole, under similar geomagnetic and solar activity conditions, and at a level of about 300 km, is about 300 K warmer than that of the winter pole, and the density of atomic oxygen is strongly depleted (and nitrogen enhanced) around the summer pole (compared with the winter pole). Only part of the differences in temperature and composition structure can be related to the seasonal variation of solar insolation, however, and both polar regions display structural variations (with latitude and Universal Time) which are unmistakeable characteristics of strong magnetospheric forcing. The magnitude of the neutral atmosphere perturbations in winds, temperature, density and composition within both summer and winter polar regions all increase with increasing levels of geomagnetic activity.The UCL 3-dimensional time dependent global model has been used to simulate the diurnal, seasonal and geomagnetic response of the neutral thermosphere, attempting to follow the major features of the solar and geomagnetic inputs to the thermosphere which were present during the late 1981 period.In the UCL model, geomagnetic forcing is characterized by semi-empirical models of the polar electric field which show a dependence on the Y component of the Interplanetary Magnetic Field, due to Heppner and Maynard (1983), It is possible to obtain an overall agreement, in both summer and winter hemispheres, with the thermospheric wind structure at high latitudes, and to explain the geomagnetic control of the combined thermal and compositional structure both qualitatively and quantitatively. To obtain such agreement, however, it is essential to enhance the polar ionosphere as a consequence of magnetospheric particle precipitation, reflecting both widespread auroral (kilovolt) electrons, and “soft” cusp and polar cap sources. Geomagnetic forcing of the high latitude thermosphere cannot be explained purely by a polar convective electric field, and the thermal as well as ionising properties of these polar and auroral electron sources are crucial components of the total geomagnetic input.     

Atmospheric expansion from Joule heating

An expression for the vertical velocity of the neutral atmosphere in the F-region is derived for Joule heating by the electric field that drives the auroral electrojet. When only vertical expansion is allowed, it is found that the vertical wind must always increase monotonically with altitude. The heating rate is proportional to the F-region ion density, so that appreciable heating, even during high electric fields, requires some production mechanism of ionization such as auroral secondary ionization or solar photoionization, in the lower F-region. Once started at night, when an ionizing source is present in the lower F-region, the expansion of the atmosphere transports ionization upward, thereby increasing the heating rate, and hence the expansion rate, i.e. positive feedback. Electric field strengths and F-region ion densities of 50 mV/m and 2 × 10¹¹e/m³, respectively, will produce vertal neutral wind speeds of several tens of m/sec in the 300–500 km altitude range. During periods of high magnetic activity, i.e. high electric field, Joule heating can produce large increases in the relative N₂ concentration in the upper F-region; computations made with a simple model suggest that tenfold increases can occur at 400 km altitude $\text{1}\text{2?1}\text{hr}$ after the onset of magnetic activity, a result in agreement with satellite observations. When the Joule heating theory is applied to incoherent scatter data taken during one period of high heating, the horizontal electric field in the F-region is found to decrease markedly, possibly approaching zero as the field penetrates a weak, discrete auroral arc; the decrease began 10–20 km from the arc.     

Location and source of ionospheric high latitude troughs

One prominent feature of the high latitude topside ionosphere is the existence of sharp latitudinal depletions in the total ion (electron) concentrations within the auroral/cusp regions. These high latitude troughs, as seen by the Bennett ion mass spectrometer observations on the satellite OGO 6 at altitudes between 400 and 1100km correspond to depletions in the atomic ions which are accompanied by localized enhancements of the minor molecular ion densities. All of the high latitude troughs traversed by OGO 6 (1969–1970) were recorded and the average invariant latitude-magnetic local time (M.L.T.) distribution was determined. The troughs on the average were found at all local times to be in the vicinity of the auroral oval and to move equatorward in response to increasing magnetic activity. The average trough location was compared to the average polar cap boundary as defined by the convection electric field reversal and the electron trapping boundary as well as to the maximum horizontal magnetic disturbance associated with the large scale field aligned currents. The high latitude troughs on the average best followed the maximum magnetic disturbance distribution. It is concluded that the troughs are the result predominantly of enhanced chemical 0⁺ losses in regions with high convection velocities.     

The source of midlatitude metallic ions at F-region altitudes

A survey of metallic ions detected by the Bennett Ion Mass Spectrometers flown on the Atmosphere Explorer satellites, including both circular and eccentric orbital configurations, shows that patches of these ions of meteoric origin are frequently present during magnetically active periods on the bottomside of the F-layer at middle and high latitudes. In particular the F-region metals statistically tend to appear at night in the vicinity of the main ionospheric trough (in a band of invariant latitudes approx. 10 degrees wide) and on the day side of the polar cap. These distributions were previously associated with the expected dynamics of ions in the F-region above 140 km where meridional neutral wind drag and convection electric fields are the dominant ion transport mechanisms. However, the main meteor deposition layer—the presumed source region of the metals—is located below 100 km where these transport mechanisms do not prevail. It is demonstrated that the Pedersen ion drifts driven by intense electric fields such as those associated with sub-auroral ion drifts (SAID) are sufficient to transport the long-lived metallic ions upward from the main meteor layer to altitudes where the drag of equatorial directed neutral winds and electric field convection can support them against the downward pull of gravity and transport them to other locations. The spatial and temporal distribution of the middle and high latitude F-region metals are consistent with the known characteristics of the electric fields and with the expected F-region ion dynamics.     

Diurnal variation of the dayside, ionospheric, mid-latitude trough in the southern hemisphere at 800 km: Model and measurement comparison

Our high latitude ionospheric model predicts the existence of a pronounced “dayside” trough in plasma concentration equatorward of the auroral oval in both the Northern and Southern Hemispheres for solar maximum, winter, and low geomagnetic activity conditions. The trough in the Southern Hemisphere is much deeper than that in the Northern Hemisphere, with the minimum trough density at 800 km being 2 × 10³ cm⁻³ in the Southern Hemisphere and 10⁴ cm⁻³ in the Northern Hemisphere. The dayside trough has a strong longitudinal (diurnal) dependence and appears between 11:00 and 19:00 U.T. in the Southern Hemisphere and between 02:00 and 08:00 U.T. in the Northern Hemisphere. This dayside trough is a result of the auroral oval moving to larger solar zenith angles at those universal times when the magnetic pole is on the antisunward side of the geographic pole. As the auroral ionization source moves to higher geographic latitudes, it leaves a region of declining photoionization on the dayside. For low convection speeds, the ionosphere decays and a dayside trough forms. The trough is deeper in the Southern Hemisphere than in the Northern Hemisphere because of the greater offset between the geomagnetic and geographic poles. Satellite data taken in both the Northern and Southern Hemispheres confirm the gross features of the dayside trough, including its strong longitudinal dependence, its depth, and the asymmetry between the Northern and Southern Hemisphere troughs.     

Diurnal transport effects on the F-region plasma at chatanika under quiet and disturbed conditions

The predictions of a time-dependent, three-dimensional model of the high-latitude ionosphere have been compared with the diurnal variations of plasma convection velocities and electron densities observed at Chatanika on geomagnetically quiet and disturbed days near equinox. The model predictions for the quiet day are in good agreement, both qualitatively and quantitatively, with the measurements. The model predictions for the disturbed day are in qualitative agreement with the measurements, but at certain local times there are significant quantitative differences. Also, the model cannot produce the detailed fine structure in the electron density that was observed on the disturbed day owing to the lack of fine structure in the model convection pattern and auroral precipitation fluxes. For the quiet day, the gross features of plasma convection are consistent with a symmetric two-cell pattern with a cross-polar cap potential of 52 kV. For the disturbed day, on the other hand, the observed plasma convection is consistent with an asymmetric two-cell pattern with enhanced plasma flow in the dusk sector and a cross-polar cap potential of 90 kV. For both the quiet and disturbed days, the lower latitude region of the high-latitude ionosphere was found to be sensitive to the competition between the vertical components of the electrodynamic and wind-induced ion drifts. For both days, horizontal plasma transport was found to be very important. One consequence of transport is that on the dayside the peak density at a given altitude occurs at a later local time as altitude increases. Another consequence of transport is that high electron densities are maintained in regions devoid of ionization sources, particularly on the disturbed day.     

A classification of polar cap auroral arcs

Global auroral imagery obtained by DMSP satellites during the years 1972–1979 over both the northern and southern high latitude polar regions were examined to study the morphology of the discrete arcs known as polar cap arcs. Based upon their morphology, the polar cap arcs can be generally classified into three types viz. (1) the distinctly sun-aligned polar cap arcs—Type 1 arcs, (2) the morning/evening polar cap arcs expanded from the auroral oval—Type 2 arcs and (3) the hook shaped arcs connecting the polar cap arc with the oval arc (including the hitherto unreported oppositely oriented hook shaped arcs)—Type 3 arcs. Concurrent auroral electrojet indices (AE) and interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) data were used to study the occurrence of the polar cap arcs. It was found that Type 1 arcs were observed mostly during low geomagnetic activity conditions, bright Type 2 arcs during the recovery phase of the substorms and Type 3 arcs do not occur during the recovery phase of the substorm. Over both hemispheres, the polar cap arcs were observed mostly during northward IMF. Furthermore, Type 1 arcs were obeserved over the northern polar cap during mostly negative B_x periods and over the southern polar cap during mostly positive B_x periods. The latter observation suggests that these types of arcs may be non-conjugate.     

Interpretation of single-site scintillation measurements to estimate F-region drift velocities

A method of estimating ionospheric drift velocities using single-site scintillation measurements is applied to determine a correlation coefficient of 0.55 between magnetic activity and F-region drift velocity near the auroral ionosphere. This method is based on the relationship between the drift velocity and the scintillation spectral breakpoint.     

Short-wavelength drift dissipative instability in the presence of field-aligned currents

Sharp density gradients coupled with field-aligned currents can give rise to short wavelength (?15 m) drift waves due to collisional effects in the F-region of the auroral ionosphere. In this wavelength range, ion-ion collisions at altitudes of 300–450 km render the ions unmagnetized and a field-aligned current can drive a drift wave, propagating almost transverse to the magnetic field, unstable due to the resistance in electron parallel motion arising from electron collisions.     

Theoretical ion densities in the lower ionosphere

We have solved the coupled momentum and continuity equations for NO⁺, O₂⁺, and O⁺ions in the E- and F-regions of the ionosphere. This theoretical model has enabled us to examine the relative importance of various processes that affect molecular ion densities. We find that transport processes are not important during the day; the molecular ions are in chemical equilibrium at all altitudes. At night, however, both diffusion and vertical drifts induced by winds or electric fields are important in determining molecular ion densities below about 200 km. Molecular ion densities are insensitive to the O⁺ density distribution and so are little affected by decay of the nocturnal F-region or by processes, such as a protonospheric flux, that retard this decay. The O⁺ density profile, on the other hand, is insensitive to molecular ion densities, although the O⁺ diffusion equation is formally coupled to molecular ion densities by the polarization electrostatic field. Nitric oxide plays an important role in determining the NO⁺ to O₂⁺ ratio in the E-region, particularly at night. Nocturnal sources of ionization are required to maintain the E-region through the night. Vertical velocities induced by expansion and contraction of the neutral atmosphere are too small to affect ion densities at any altitude.     

The calculated and observed diurnal variation of the ionosphere over Millstone Hill on 23–24 March 1970

A numerical model of current F-region theory is use to calculate the diurnal variation of the mid-latitude ionospheric F-region over Millstone Hill on 23–24 March 1970, during quiet geomagnetic conditions. From the solar EUV flux, the model calculates at each altitude and time step primary photoelectron spectra and ionization rates of various ion species. The photoelectron transport equation is solved for the secondary ionization rates, photoelectron spectra, and various airglow excitation rates. Five ion continuity equations that include the effects of transport by diffusion, magnetospheric-ionospheric plasma transport, electric fields, and neutral winds are solved for the ion composition and electron density. The electron and ion temperatures are also calculated using the heating rates determined from chemical reactions, photoelectron collisions, and magnetospheric-ionospheric energy transport. The calculations are performed for a diurnal cycle considering a stationary field tube co-rotating with the Earth; only the vertical plasma drift caused by electric fields perpendicular to the geomagnetic field line is allowed but not the horizontal drift. The boundary conditions used in the model are determined from the incoherent scatter radar measurements of T_e, T_i and O⁺ flux at 800km over Millstone Hill (Evans, 1971a). The component of the neutral thermospheric winds along the geomagnetic field has an important influence on the overall ionospheric structure. It is determined from a separate dynamic model of the neutral thermosphere, using incoherent scatter radar measurements.The calculated diurnal variation of the ionospheric structure agrees well with the values measured by the incoherent scatter radar when certain restrictions are placed on the solar EUV flux and model neutral atmospheric compositions. Namely, the solar EUV fluxes of Hinteregger (1970) are doubled and an atomic oxygen concentration of at least $\text{10}{}^{11}\text{cm}{}^3$ at 120 km is required for the neutral model atmosphere. Calculations also show that the topside thermal structure of the ionosphere is primarily maintained by a flow of heat from the magnetosphere and the night-time F2-region is maintained in part by neutral winds, diffusion, electric fields, and plasma flow from the magnetosphere. The problem of maintaining the calculated night-time ionosphere at the observed values is also discussed.     

Effects of interplanetary magnetic field and magnetospheric substorm variations on the dayside aurora

Photometric observations of dayside auroras are compared with simultaneous measurements of geomagnetic disturbances from meridian chains of stations on the dayside and on the nightside to document the dynamics of dayside auroras in relation to local and global disturbances. These observations are related to measurements of the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) from the satellites ISEE-1 and 3. It is shown that the dayside auroral zone shifts equatorward and poleward with the growth and decay of the circum-oval/polar cap geomagnetic disturbance and with negative and positive changes in the north-south component of the interplanetary magnetic field (B_z). The geomagnetic disturbance associated with the auroral shift is identified as the DP2 mode. In the post-noon sector the horizontal disturbance vector of the geomagnetic field changes from southward to northward with decreasing latitude, thereby changing sign near the center of the oval precipitation region. Discrete auroral forms are observed close to or equatorward of the ΔH = 0 line which separates positive and negative H-component deflections. This reversal moves in latitude with the aurora and it probably reflects a transition of the electric field direction at the polar cap boundary. Thus, the discrete auroral forms observed on the dayside are in the region of sunward-convecting field lines. A model is proposed to explain the equatorward and poleward movement of the dayside oval in terms of a dayside current system which is intensified by a southward movement of the IMF vector. According to this model, the Pedersen component of the ionospheric current is connected with the magnetopause boundary layer via field-aligned current (FAC) sheets. Enhanced current intensity, corresponding to southward auroral shift, is consistent with increased energy extraction from the solar wind. In this way the observed association of DP2 current system variations and auroral oval expansion/contraction is explained as an effect of a global, ‘direct’ response of the electromagnetic state of the magnetosphere due to the influence of the solar wind magnetic field. Estimates of electric field, current, and the rate of Joule heat dissipation in the polar cap ionosphere are obtained from the model.     

Antarctic substorm events observed by sounding rockets,ionization of the D- and E-regions by auroral electrons

The ionization structure of the auroral arc was measured on a sounding rocket which penetrated into a bright auroral arc. The E-region electron density becomes large (2 ～ 5 × 10⁵ el/cm³ only in the moving auroral arc, whose N₂⁺ 4278 Å brightness is 1 ～ 2·5 kR. The electron density in the D-region beneath the lower boundary of the arc (75 ～ 98 km in altitude) is also considerably enhanced to 2 ～ 5 × 10⁴ el/cm³.The observed E-region electron density can be interpreted theoretically as due to the direct ionization by precipitating electrons, whose energy spectrum is approximately represented by an exponential type having the characteristic energy of 2 keV. The correlation between the electron density and the N₂⁺ 4278 Å brightness can be reasonably explained by considering the simultaneous effects on the ionization and the optical excitation caused by the primary electrons having a flux of 9 × 10⁹ el/cm²/sec per 1 kR of the 4278 Å emission.Further analyses using the electron density data from four other sounding rockets have shown that the D-region ionization has good correlations to the cosmic noise absorption (CNA) and the magnetic substorm activities observed simultaneously at the ground station, whereas it has poor correlation to the same quantity of the E-region measured in the same experiment. It is found that the observed D-region ionization is much larger than that predicted by the theory which takes into account the Bremsstrahlung X-ray ionization along with the direct impact ionization when it is applied to the precipitating electron flux spectrum consistent to the E-region ionization and optical excitation.After all the present experimental results suggest a dual nature of the electron precipitation spectrum in the substorm, i.e. the softer part which is localized in the auroral arc and the harder part which is spatially wide-spread over the substorm area.     

The consequences of high latitude particle precipitation on global thermospheric dynamics

A previous comparison of experimental measurements of thermospheric winds with simulations using a global self-consistent three-dimensional time-dependent model confirmed a necessity for a high latitude source of energy and momentum acting in addition to solar u.v. and e.u.v. heating. During quiet geomagnetic conditions, the convective electric field over the polar cap and auroral oval seemed able to provide adequate momentum input to explain the thermospheric wind distribution observed in these locations. However, it seems unable to provide adequate heating, by the Joule mechanism, to complete the energy budget of the thermosphere and, more importantly, unable to provide the high latitude input required to explain mean meridional winds at mid-latitudes. In this paper we examine the effects of low energy particle precipitation on thermospheric dynamics and energy budget. Modest fluxes over the polar cap and auroral oval, of the order of 0.4 erg cm ⁻²/s, are consistent with satellite observations of the particles themselves and with photometer observations of the OI and OII airglow emissions. Such particle fluxes, originating in the dayside magnetosheath cusp region and in the nightside central plasma sheet, heat the thermosphere and modify mean meridional winds at mid-latitudes without enhancing the OI 557.7 line, or the ionization of the lower thermosphere (and thus enhancing the auroral electrojets), neither of which would be consistent with observations during quiet geomagnetic conditions.     

Observed connections between apparent polar cap features and the instantaneous diffuse auroral oval

Images of the instantaneous nightside auroral distribution reveal that at times the orientation of auroral oval arcs changes to become characteristic of polar cap arcs. These connecting arcs all terminate in the diffuse aurora in the midnight sector, and their separation from the equatorward boundary of the diffuse aurora generally increases away from the midnight termination. The occurrence of these features requires a northward interplanetary magnetic field (positive B_z) as well as low magnetic activity. The existence of connecting arcs and the observation that they are at times the poleward boundary of weak diffuse emission indicate that the poleward boundary of auroral emissions can be significantly modified during non-substorm periods. Such a distortion implies that there can be a modification of the standard convection pattern in the magnetosphere during periods of positive B_z to produce expanded regions of sunward convection in the high latitude ionosphere.     

The transient response of the topside ionosphere to precipitation

A numerical time-dependent model of the topside and F-layer ionosphere is used to describe how the density of O⁺ ions and the plasma temperatures change as a result of transient electron precipitation with a soft energy spectrum (ca. 100 eV per electron). The response time for electron gas heating is about 2 min; for changes in topside scale height it is from 5 to 15 min, depending on altitude; and for changes in F-layer peak density, it is more than an hour. The low-density topside ion gas is thermally isolated on a short time scale; consequently the ion temperature responds almost adiabatically to volume changes. A transient precipitation event (of, say, 10 min duration) initiates a disturbance that propagates upward at approximately the sonic upeed in the plasma (ca. 2km/s), growing in amplitude with height. Such an event has little effect on the density at the peak of the F layer. An element of ionosphere that drifts horizontally in an antisunward direction through the magnetospheric cleft and into the polar cap recieves some ionization from the cleft, but not enough to be decisive in its survival. The collapse of the topside when heating is removed increases temporarily the density of the F layer.