Can lightning produce significant levels of mass‐independent oxygen isotopic fractionation in nebular dust?

Based on recent evidence that oxide grains condensed from a plasma will contain oxygen that is mass‐independently fractionated compared to the initial composition of the vapor, we present a first attempt to evaluate the potential magnitude of this effect on dust in the primitive solar nebula. This assessment relies on previous studies of nebular lightning to provide reasonable ranges of physical parameters to form a very simple model to evaluate the plausibility that lightning could affect a significant fraction of nebular dust and that such effects could cause a significant change in the oxygen isotopic composition of solids in the solar nebula over time. If only a small fraction of the accretion energy is dissipated as lightning over the volume of the inner solar nebula, then a large fraction of nebular dust will be exposed to lightning. If the temperature of such bolts is a few percent of the temperatures measured in terrestrial discharges, then dust will vaporize and recondense in an ionized environment. Finally, if only a small average decrease is assumed in the ¹⁶O content of freshly condensed dust, then over the last 5 Myr of nebular accretion the average Δ¹⁷O of the dust could increase by more than 30 per mil. We conclude that it is possible that the measured “slope 1” oxygen isotope line measured in meteorites and their components represents a time‐evolution sequence of nebular dust over the last several million years of nebular evolution where ¹⁶O‐rich materials formed first, then escaped further processing as the average isotopic composition of the dust gradually became increasingly depleted in ¹⁶O.     

Oxygen isotopic compositions and origins of calcium‐aluminum‐rich inclusions and chondrules

Abstract— Primary minerals in calcium‐aluminum‐rich inclusions (CAIs), Al‐rich and ferromagnesian chondrules in each chondrite group have δ¹⁸O values that typically range from ?50 to +5%0. Neglecting effects due to minor mass fractionations, the oxygen isotopic data for each chondrite group and for micrometeorites define lines on the three‐isotope plot with slopes of 1.01 ± 0.06 and intercepts of ?2 ± 1. This suggests that the same kind of nebular process produced the ¹⁶O variations among chondrules and CAIs in all groups. Chemical and isotopic properties of some CAIs and chondrules strongly suggest that they formed from solar nebula condensates. This is incompatible with the existing two‐component model for oxygen isotopes in which chondrules and CAIs were derived from heated and melted ¹⁶O‐rich presolar dust that exchanged oxygen with ¹⁶O‐poor nebular gas. Some FUN CAIs (inclusions with isotope anomalies due to fractionation and unknown nuclear effects) have chemical and isotopic compositions indicating they are evaporative residues of presolar material, which is incompatible with ¹⁶O fractionation during mass‐independent gas phase reactions in the solar nebula. There is only one plausible reason why solar nebula condensates and evaporative residues of presolar materials are both enriched in ¹⁶O. Condensation must have occurred in a nebular region where the oxygen was largely derived from evaporated ¹⁶O‐rich dust. A simple model suggests that dust was enriched (or gas was depleted) relative to cosmic proportions by factors of ～10 to >50 prior to condensation for most CAIs and factors of 1–5 for chondrule precursor material. We infer that dust‐gas fractionation prior to evaporation and condensation was more important in establishing the oxygen isotopic composition of CAIs and chondrules than any subsequent exchange with nebular gases. Dust‐gas fractionation may have occurred near the inner edge of the disk where nebular gases accreted into the protosun and Shu and colleagues suggest that CAIs formed.     

Oxygen isotopic and chemical zoning of melilite crystals in a type A Ca‐Al‐rich inclusion of Efremovka CV3 chondrite

Abstract– Different oxygen isotopic reservoirs have been recognized in the early solar system. Fluffy type A Ca‐Al‐rich inclusions (CAIs) are believed to be direct condensates from a solar nebular gas, and therefore, have acquired oxygen from the solar nebula. Oxygen isotopic and chemical compositions of melilite crystals in a type A CAI from Efremovka CV3 chondrite were measured to reveal the temporal variation in oxygen isotopic composition of surrounding nebular gas during CAI formation. The CAI is constructed of two domains, each of which has a core‐mantle structure. Reversely zoned melilite crystals were observed in both domains. Melilite crystals in one domain have a homogeneous ¹⁶O‐poor composition on the carbonaceous chondrite anhydrous mineral (CCAM) line of δ¹⁸O = 5–10‰, which suggests that the domain was formed in a ¹⁶O‐poor oxygen isotope reservoir of the solar nebula. In contrast, melilite crystals in the other domain have continuous variations in oxygen isotopic composition from ¹⁶O‐rich (δ¹⁸O = ?40‰) to ¹⁶O‐poor (δ¹⁸O = 0‰) along the CCAM line. The oxygen isotopic composition tends to be more ¹⁶O‐rich toward the domain rim, which suggests that the domain was formed in a variable oxygen isotope reservoir of the solar nebula. Each domain of the type A CAI has grown in distinct oxygen isotope reservoir of the solar nebula. After the domain formation, domains were accumulated together in the solar nebula to form a type A CAI.     

The CR chondrite clan: Implications for early solar system processes

Abstract— In this paper, we review the mineralogy and chemistry of calcium‐aluminum‐rich inclusions (CAIs), chondrules, FeNi‐metal, and fine‐grained materials of the CR chondrite clan, including CR, CH, and the metal‐rich CB chondrites Queen Alexandra Range 94411, Hammadah al Hamra 237, Bencubbin, Gujba, and Weatherford. The members of the CR chondrite clan are among the most pristine early solar system materials, which largely escaped thermal processing in an asteroidal setting (Bencubbin, Weatherford, and Gujba may be exceptions) and provide important constraints on the solar nebula models. These constraints include (1) multiplicity of CAI formation; (2) formation of CAIs and chondrules in spatially separated nebular regions; (3) formation of CAIs in gaseous reservoir(s) having ¹⁶O‐rich isotopic compositions; chondrules appear to have formed in the presence of ¹⁶O‐poor nebular gas; (4) isolation of CAIs and chondrules from nebular gas at various ambient temperatures; (5) heterogeneous distribution of ²⁶Al in the solar nebula; and (6) absence of matrix material in the regions of CAI and chondrule formation.     

Oxygen isotopic composition of the solar nebula gas inferred from high‐precision isotope imaging of melilite crystals in an Allende CAI

Abstract– High‐precision isotope imaging analyses of reversely zoned melilite crystals in the gehlenitic mantle of Type A CAI ON01 of the Allende carbonaceous chondrite reveal that there are four types of oxygen isotopic distributions within melilite single crystals: (1) uniform depletion of ¹⁶O (δ¹⁸O ≈ ?10‰), (2) uniform enrichment of ¹⁶O (δ¹⁸O ≈ ?40‰), (3) variations in isotopic composition from ¹⁶O‐poor core to ¹⁶O‐rich rim (δ¹⁸O ≈ ?10‰ to ?30‰, ?20‰ to ?45‰, and ?10‰ to ?35‰) with decreasing åkermanite content, and (4) ¹⁶O‐poor composition (δ¹⁸O ≥ ?10‰) along the crystal rim. Hibonite, spinel, and perovskite grains are ¹⁶O‐rich (δ¹⁸O ≈ ?45‰), and adjoin ¹⁶O‐poor melilites. Gas‐solid or gas‐melt isotope exchange in the nebula is inconsistent with both the distinct oxygen isotopic compositions among the minerals and the reverse zoning of melilite. Fluid‐rock interaction on the parent body resulted in ¹⁶O‐poor compositions of limited areas near holes, cracks, or secondary phases, such as anorthite or grossular. We conclude that reversely zoned melilites mostly preserve the primary oxygen isotopic composition of either ¹⁶O‐enriched or ¹⁶O‐depleted gas from which they were condensed. The correlation between oxygen isotopic composition and åkermanite content may indicate that oxygen isotopes of the solar nebula gas changed from ¹⁶O‐poor to ¹⁶O‐rich during melilite crystal growth. We suggest that the radial excursions of the inner edge of the protoplanetary disk gas simultaneously resulted in both the reverse zoning and oxygen isotopic variation of melilite, due to mixing of ¹⁶O‐poor disk gas and ¹⁶O‐rich coronal gas. Gas condensates aggregated to form the gehlenite mantle of the Type A CAI ON01.     

Oxygen isotopic zoning of reversely zoned melilite crystals in a fluffy type A Ca‐Al‐rich inclusions from the Vigarano meteorite

Abstract– The oxygen isotopic microdistributions within melilite measured using in situ secondary ion mass spectrometry correspond to the chemical zoning profiles in single melilite crystals of a fluffy type A Ca‐Al‐rich inclusions (CAIs) of reduced CV3 Vigarano meteorite. The melilite crystals show chemical reverse zoning within an individual single crystal from the åkermanite‐rich core to the åkermanite‐poor rim. The composition changes continuously with the crystal growth. The zoning structures suggest that the melilite grew in a hot nebular gas by condensation with decreasing pressure. The oxygen isotopic composition of melilite also changes continuously from ¹⁶O‐poor to ¹⁶O‐rich with the crystal growth. These observations suggest that the melilite condensation proceeded with change consistent with an astrophysical setting around the inner edge of a protoplanetary disk where both ¹⁶O‐rich solar coronal gas and ¹⁶O‐poor dense protoplanetary disk gas could coexist. Fluffy type A CAIs could have been formed around the inner edge of the protoplanetary disk surrounding the early sun.     

Oxygen isotopes in chondrule olivine and isolated olivine grains from the CO3 chondrite Allan Hills A77307

Abstract— We have measured O‐isotopic ratios in a variety of olivine grains in the CO3 chondrite Allan Hills (ALH) A77307 using secondary ion mass spectrometry in order to study the chondrule formation process and the origin of isolated olivine grains in unequilibrated chondrites. Oxygen‐isotopic ratios of olivines in this chondrite are variable from δ¹⁷O = ?15.5 to +4.5% and δ¹⁸O = ?11.5 to +3.9%, with Δ¹⁷O varying from ?10.4 to +3.5%. Forsteritic olivines, Fa_<1, are enriched in ¹⁶O relative to the bulk chondrite, whereas more FeO‐rich olivines are more depleted in ¹⁶O. Most ratios lie close to the carbonaceous chondrite anhydrous minerals (CCAM) line with negative values of Δ¹⁷O, although one grain of composition Fa₄ has a mean Δ¹⁷O of +1.6%. Marked O‐isotopic heterogeneity within one FeO‐rich chondrule is the result of incorporation of relic, ¹⁶O‐rich, Mg‐rich grains into a more ¹⁶O‐depleted host. Isolated olivine grains, including isolated forsterites, have similar O‐isotopic ratios to olivine in chondrules of corresponding chemical composition. This is consistent with derivation of isolated olivine from chondrules, as well as the possibility that isolated grains are chondrule precursors. The high ¹⁶O in forsteritic olivine is similar to that observed in forsterite in CV and CI chondrites and the ordinary chondrite Julesburg and suggests nebula‐wide processes for the origin of forsterite that appears to be a primitive nebular component.     

Nebular shock waves generated by planetesimals passing through Jovian resonances: Possible sites for chondrule formation

Abstract— The primordial asteroid belt contained at least several hundred and possibly as many as 10,000 bodies with diameters of 1000 km or larger. Following the formation of Jupiter, nebular gas drag combined with passage of such bodies through Jovian resonances produced high eccentricities (e = 0.3‐0.5), low inclinations (i < 0.5°), and, therefore, high velocities (3–10 km/s) for “resonant” bodies relative to both nebular gas and non‐resonant planetesimals. These high velocities would have produced shock waves in the nebular gas through two mechanisms. First, bow shocks would be produced by supersonic motion of resonant bodies relative to the nebula. Second, high‐velocity collisions of resonant bodies with non‐resonant bodies would have generated impact vapor plume shocks near the collision sites. Both types of shocks would be sufficient to melt chondrule precursors in the nebula, and both are consistent with isotopic evidence for a time delay of ?1‐1.5 Myr between the formation of CAIs and most chondrules. Here, initial simulations are first reported of impact shock wave generation in the nebula and of the local nebular volumes that would be processed by these shocks as a function of impactor size and relative velocity. Second, the approximate maximum chondrule mass production is estimated for both bow shocks and impact‐generated shocks assuming a simplified planetesimal population and a rate of inward migration into resonances consistent with previous simulations. Based on these initial first‐order calculations, impact‐generated shocks can explain only a small fraction of the minimum likely mass of chondrules in the primordial asteroid belt (?10²⁴‐10²⁵g). However, bow shocks are potentially a more efficient source of chondrule production and can explain up to 10–100 times the estimated minimum chondrule mass.     

Nebular thermal evolution and the properties of primitive planetary materials

Abstract— Models of the solar nebula are constructed to investigate the hypothesis that surviving planetary objects began to form as the nebula cooled from an early, hot epoch. The imprint of such an epoch might be retained in the spatial distribution of planetary material, the systematic deviations of its elemental composition from that of the Sun, chemical indicators of primordial oxidation state, and variations in oxygen and other isotopic compositions. Our method of investigation is to calculate the time‐dependent, two‐dimensional temperature distributions within model nebulas of prescribed dynamical evolution, and to deduce the consequences of the calculated thermal histories for coagulated solid material. The models are defined by parameters which characterize nebular initial states (mass and angular momentum), mass accretion histories, and coagulation rates and efficiencies. It is demonstrated that coagulation during the cooling of the nebula from a hot state is expected to produce systematic heterogeneities which affect the chemical and isotopic compositions of planetary material. The radial thermal gradient at the midplane results in delayed coagulation of the more volatile elements. Vertical thermal gradients isolate the most refractory material and concentrate evaporated heavy elements in the gas phase. It is concluded that these effects could be responsible for the distribution of terrestrial planetary masses, the systematic depletion patterns of the moderately volatile elements in chondritic meteorites and the Earth, the range of oxygen isotopic compositions exhibited by calcium‐aluminum‐rich inclusions (CAIs) and other refractory inclusions, and some geochemical evidence for a moderately enhanced oxidation state. However, nebular fractionations on a global scale are unlikely to account for the more oxidizing conditions inferred for some CAIs and chondritic silicates, which require dust enhancements greater than a few hundred. This conclusion, along with the well‐established evidence from studies of chondrules and CAIs for thermal excursions of short duration, make it likely that local environments, unrelated to nebular thermal evolution, were also important.     

Effects of dust enrichment on oxygen fugacity of cosmic gases

The degree to which dust enrichment enhances the oxygen fugacity (fO₂) of a system otherwise solar in composition depends on the dust composition. Equilibrium calculations were performed at 10^?3 bar in systems enriched by a factor of 10⁴ in two fundamentally different types of dust to investigate the iron oxidation state in both cases. One type of dust, called SC for solar condensate, stopped equilibrating with solar gas at too high a temperature for FeO or condensed water to be stabilized in any form, and thus has the composition expected of a nebular condensate. The other has CI chondrite composition, appropriate for a parent body that accreted from SC dust and low‐temperature ice. Upon total vaporization at 2300 K, both systems have high fO₂, >IW. In the SC dust‐enriched system, FeO of the bulk silicate reaches ~10 wt% at 1970 K but decreases to <1 wt% below 1500 K. The FeO undergoes reduction because consumption of gaseous oxygen by silicate recondensation causes a precipitous drop in fO₂. Thus, enrichment in dust having the composition of likely nebular condensates cannot yield a sufficiently oxidizing environment to account for the FeO contents of chondrules. The fO₂ of the system enriched in water‐rich, CI dust, however, remains high throughout condensation, as gaseous water remains uncondensed until very low temperatures. This allows silicate condensates to achieve and maintain FeO contents of 27–35 wt%. Water‐rich parent bodies are thus excellent candidate sources of chondrule precursors. Impacts on such bodies may have created the combination of high dust enrichment, total pressure, and fO₂ necessary for chondrule formation.     

Calcium‐aluminum‐rich inclusions and amoeboid olivine aggregates from the CR carbonaceous chondrites

Abstract— Calcium‐aluminum‐rich refractory inclusions (CAIs) in CR chondrites are rare (<1 vol%), fairly small (<500 μm) and irregularly‐shaped, and most of them are fragmented. Based on the mineralogy and petrography, they can be divided into grossite ± hibonite‐rich, melilite‐rich, and pyroxene‐anorthite‐rich CAIs. Other types of refractory objects include fine‐grained spinel‐melilite‐pyroxene aggregates and amoeboid olivine aggregates (AOAs). Some of the pyroxene‐anorthite‐rich CAIs have igneous textures, and most melilite‐rich CAIs share similarities to both the fluffy and compact type A CAIs found in CV chondrites. One major difference between these CAIs and those in CV, CM, and CO chondrites is that secondary mineral phases are rare. In situ ion microprobe analyses of oxygen‐isotopic compositions of 27 CAIs and AOAs from seven CR chondrites demonstrate that most of the CAIs are ¹⁶O‐rich (δ¹⁷O of hibonite, melilite, spinel, pyroxene, and anorthite < ?22‰) and isotopically homogeneous within 3–4‰. Likewise, forsterite, spinel, anorthite, and pyroxene in AOAs have nearly identical, ¹⁶O‐rich compositions (?24‰ < δ¹⁷O < ?20‰). In contrast, objects which show petrographic evidence for extensive melting are not as ¹⁶O‐rich (δ¹⁷O less than ?18‰). Secondary alteration minerals replacing ¹⁶O‐rich melilite in melilite‐rich CAIs plot along the terrestrial fractionation line. Most CR CAIs and AOAs are mineralogically pristine objects that largely escaped thermal metamorphism and secondary alteration processes, which is reflected in their relatively homogeneous ¹⁶O‐rich compositions. It is likely that these objects (or their precursors) condensed in an ¹⁶O‐rich gaseous reservoir in the solar nebula. In contrast, several igneous CAIs are not very enriched in ¹⁶O, probably as a result of their having melted in the presence of a relatively ¹⁶O‐poor nebular gas. If the precursors of these CAIs were as ¹⁶O‐rich as other CR CAIs, this implies either temporal excursions in the isotopic composition of the gas in the CAI‐forming regions and/or radial transport of some CAI precursors into an ¹⁶O‐poor gas. The absence of oxygen isotope heterogeneity in the primary minerals of melilite‐rich CAIs containing alteration products suggests that mineralogical alteration in CR chondrites did not affect oxygen‐isotopic compositions of their CAIs.     

Fine‐grained,spinel‐rich inclusions from the reduced CV chondrite Efremovka: II. Oxygen isotopic compositions

Abstract— Oxygen isotopes have been measured by ion microprobe in individual minerals (spinel, Al‐Ti‐diopside, melilite, and anorthite) within four relatively unaltered, fine‐grained, spinel‐rich Ca‐Al‐rich inclusions (CAIs) from the reduced CV chondrite Efremovka. Spinel is uniformly ¹⁶O‐rich (Δ¹⁷O ≤ ?20‰) in all four CAIs; Al‐Ti‐diopside is similarly ¹⁶O‐rich in all but one CAI, where it has smaller ¹⁶O excesses (‐15‰ ≤ Δ¹⁷O ≤ ?10‰). Anorthite and melilite vary widely in composition from ¹⁶O‐rich to ¹⁶O‐poor (‐22‰ ≤ Δ¹⁷O ≤ ?5‰). Two of the CAIs are known to have group II volatility‐fractionated rare‐earth‐element patterns, which is typical of this variety of CAI and which suggests formation by condensation. The association of such trace element patterns with ¹⁶O‐enrichment in these CAIs suggests that they formed by gas‐solid condensation from an ¹⁶O‐rich gas. They subsequently experienced thermal processing in an ¹⁶O‐poor reservoir, resulting in partial oxygen isotope exchange. Within each inclusion, oxygen isotope variations from mineral to mineral are consistent with solid‐state oxygen self‐diffusion at the grain‐to‐grain scale, but such a model is not consistent with isotopic variations at a larger scale in two of the CAIs. The spatial association of ¹⁶O depletions with both elevated Fe contents in spinel and the presence of nepheline suggests that late‐stage iron‐alkali metasomatism played some role in modifying the isotopic patterns in some CAIs. One of the CAIs is a compound object consisting of a coarse‐grained, melilite‐rich (type A) lithology joined to a fine‐grained, spinel‐rich one. Melilite and anorthite in the fine‐grained portion are mainly ¹⁶O‐rich, whereas melilite in the type A portion ranges from ¹⁶O‐rich to ¹⁶O‐poor, suggesting that oxygen isotope exchange predated the joining together of the two parts and that both ¹⁶O‐rich and ¹⁶O‐poor gaseous reservoirs existed simultaneously in the early solar nebula.     

A new model for the origin of Type‐B and Fluffy Type‐A CAIs: Analogies to remelted compound chondrules

Abstract– In the scenario developed here, most types of calcium‐aluminum‐rich inclusions (CAIs) formed near the Sun where they developed Wark‐Lovering rims before being transported by aerodynamic forces throughout the nebula. The amount of ambient dust in the nebula varied with heliocentric distance, peaking in the CV–CK formation location. Literature data show that accretionary rims (which occur outside the Wark‐Lovering rims) around CAIs contain substantial ¹⁶O‐rich forsterite, suggesting that, at this time, the ambient dust in the nebula consisted largely of ¹⁶O‐rich forsterite. Individual sub‐millimeter‐size Compact Type‐A CAIs (each surrounded by a Wark‐Lovering rim) collided in the CV–CK region and stuck together (in a manner similar to that of sibling compound chondrules); the CTAs were mixed with small amounts of ¹⁶O‐rich mafic dust and formed centimeter‐size compound objects (large Fluffy Type‐A CAIs) after experiencing minor melting. In contrast to other types of CAIs, centimeter‐size Type‐B CAIs formed directly in the CV–CK region after gehlenite‐rich Compact Type‐A CAIs collided and stuck together, incorporated significant amounts of ¹⁶O‐rich forsteritic dust (on the order of 10–15%) and probably some anorthite, and experienced extensive melting and partial evaporation. (Enveloping compound chondrules formed in an analogous manner.) In those cases where appreciably higher amounts of ¹⁶O‐rich forsterite (on the order of 25%) (and perhaps minor anorthite and pyroxene) were incorporated into compound Type‐A objects prior to melting, centimeter‐size forsterite‐bearing Type‐B CAIs (B3 inclusions) were produced. Type‐B1 inclusions formed from B2 inclusions that collided with and stuck to melilite‐rich Compact Type‐A CAIs and experienced high‐temperature processing.     

Spatial heterogeneity of 26Al/27Al and stable oxygen isotopes in the solar nebula

Abstract— The degree of isotopic spatial heterogeneity in the solar nebula has long been a puzzle, with different isotopic systems implying either large‐scale initial spatial homogeneity (e.g., ²⁶Al chronometry) or a significant amount of preserved heterogeneity (e.g., ratios of the three stable oxygen isotopes, ¹⁶O, ¹⁷O, and ¹⁸O). We show here that in a marginally gravitationally unstable (MGU) solar nebula, the efficiency of large‐scale mixing and transport is sufficient to spatially homogenize an initially highly spatially heterogeneous nebula to dispersions of ?10% about the mean value of ²⁶Al/²⁷Al on time scales of thousands of years. A similar dispersion would be expected for ¹⁷O/¹⁶O and ¹⁸O/¹⁶O ratios produced by ultraviolet photolysis of self‐shielded molecular CO gas at the surface of the outer solar nebula. In addition to preserving a chronological interpretation of initial ²⁶Al/²⁷Al ratios and the self‐shielding explanation for the oxygen isotope ratios, these solar nebula models offer a self‐consistent environment for achieving large‐scale mixing and transport of thermally annealed dust grains, shock‐wave processing of chondrules and refractory inclusions, and giant planet formation.     

Calcium‐aluminum‐rich inclusions in enstatite chondrites (II): Oxygen isotopes

Abstract— In situ io n microprobe analyses of spinel in refractory calcium‐aluminium‐rich inclusions (CAIs) from type 3 EH chondrites yield ¹⁶O‐rich compositions (δ ¹⁸O and δ ¹⁷O about‐40‰). Spinel and feldspar in a CAI from an EL3 chondrite have significantly heavier isotopic compositions (δ ¹⁸O and δ ¹⁷O about ?5‰). A regression through the data results in a line with slope 1.0 on a three‐isotope plot, similar to isotopic results from unaltered minerals in CAIs from carbonaceous chondrites. The existence of CAIs with ¹⁶O‐rich and ¹⁶O‐poor compositions in carbonaceous as well as enstatite chondrites indicates that CAIs formed in at least two temporally or spatially distinct oxygen reservoirs. General similarities in oxygen isotopic compositions of CAIs from enstatite, carbonaceous, and ordinary chondrites indicate a common nebular mechanism or locale for the production of most CAIs.     

The origin of chondrules and chondrites: Debris from low‐velocity impacts between molten planetesimals?

Abstract– We investigate the hypothesis that many chondrules are frozen droplets of spray from impact plumes launched when thin‐shelled, largely molten planetesimals collided at low speed during accretion. This scenario, here dubbed “splashing,” stems from evidence that such planetesimals, intensely heated by ²⁶Al, were abundant in the protoplanetary disk when chondrules were being formed approximately 2 Myr after calcium‐aluminum‐rich inclusions (CAIs), and that chondrites, far from sampling the earliest planetesimals, are made from material that accreted later, when ²⁶Al could no longer induce melting. We show how “splashing” is reconcilable with many features of chondrules, including their ages, chemistry, peak temperatures, abundances, sizes, cooling rates, indented shapes, “relict” grains, igneous rims, and metal blebs, and is also reconcilable with features that challenge the conventional view that chondrules are flash‐melted dust‐clumps, particularly the high concentrations of Na and FeO in chondrules, but also including chondrule diversity, large phenocrysts, macrochondrules, scarcity of dust‐clumps, and heating. We speculate that type I (FeO‐poor) chondrules come from planetesimals that accreted early in the reduced, partially condensed, hot inner nebula, and that type II (FeO‐rich) chondrules come from planetesimals that accreted in a later, or more distal, cool nebular setting where incorporation of water‐ice with high Δ¹⁷O aided oxidation during heating. We propose that multiple collisions and repeated re‐accretion of chondrules and other debris within restricted annular zones gave each chondrite group its distinctive properties, and led to so‐called “complementarity” and metal depletion in chondrites. We suggest that differentiated meteorites are numerically rare compared with chondrites because their initially plentiful molten parent bodies were mostly destroyed during chondrule formation.     

Photodissociation of CO isotopologues: Models of laboratory experiments and implications for the solar nebula

CO photodissociation in the solar nebula and/or parent cloud has been proposed to be the mechanism responsible for forming the ¹⁶O‐poor reservoir of the calcium‐aluminum‐rich inclusion (CAI) mixing line. However, laboratory experiments on CO photolysis found a wavelength dependence in the oxygen isotope ratios of the product O atoms, which was interpreted as proof that CO photolysis was not a viable mechanism. Here, I report photochemical simulations of these experiments using line‐by‐line CO spectra to identify the origin of the wavelength dependence. At long wavelengths (>105 nm), the line‐by‐line spectra for isotopic CO can explain the experimental data with a combination of C¹⁶O self‐shielding and reduced dissociation probabilities for C¹⁸O. At short wavelengths, the greater number of diffuse bands increases the importance of mass‐dependent fractionation, lowering the slope to below unity. The line‐by‐line isotopic spectra are then applied to CO photodissociation in a model solar nebula. Three FUV sources are considered (1) HD 303308, an O4 star in Carina; (2) HD 36981, a B5 star in Orion; and (3) TW Hydrae, a T Tauri star of 10 Myr age. Using reduced dissociation probabilities for C¹⁸O based on the photolysis experiments yields nebular water slopes approximately 0.95–1.0 for HD 303308 and TW Hya, and approximately 0.8–1.5 for HD 36981. For the central protostar case (TW Hya) with a simplified treatment of the 2‐D radiative transfer, slopes approximately 0.95–1.0 are obtained, independent of the C¹⁸O dissociation probability. Greatly improved measurements of the C¹⁷O and C¹⁸O cross sections and dissociation probabilities are in progress.     

A refractory inclusion returned by Stardust from comet 81P/Wild 2

Abstract— Among the samples returned from comet 81P/Wild 2 by the Stardust spacecraft is a suite of particles from one impact track (Track 25) that are Ca‐, Al‐rich and FeO‐free. We studied three particles from this track that range in size from 5.3 × 3.2 μ to 15 × 10 μ. Scanning and transmission electron microscopy show that they consist of very fine‐grained (typically from ?0.5 to ?2 μ) Al‐rich, Ti‐bearing and Ti‐free clinopyroxene, Mg‐Al spinel and anorthite, with trace amounts of fine perovskite, FeNi metal and osbornite (TiN) grains. In addition to these phases, the terminal particle, named “Inti”, also contains melilite. All of these phases, with the exception of osbornite, are common in refractory inclusions and are predicted to condense at high temperature from a gas of solar composition. Osbornite, though very rare, has also been found in meteoritic refractory inclusions, and could have formed in a region of the nebula where carbon became enriched relative to oxygen compared to solar composition. Compositions of Ti‐pyroxene in Inti are similar, but not identical, to those of fassaite from Allende inclusions. Electron energy loss spectroscopy shows that Ti‐rich pyroxene in Inti has Ti³⁺/Ti⁴⁺within the range of typical meteoritic fassaite, consistent with formation under reducing conditions comparable to those of a system of solar composition. Inti is ¹⁶O‐rich, with δ₁₈O?δ¹⁷O?‐40%0, like unaltered phases in refractory inclusions and refractory IDPs. With grain sizes, mineralogy, mineral chemistry, and an oxygen isotopic composition like those of refractory inclusions, we conclude that Inti is a refractory inclusion that formed in the inner solar nebula. Identification of a particle that formed in the inner solar system among the comet samples demonstrates that there was transport of materials from the inner to the outer nebula, probably either in a bipolar outflow or by turbulence.     

Overview of the rocky component of Wild 2 comet samples: Insight into the early solar system,relationship with meteoritic materials and the differences between comets and asteroids

Abstract– The solid 2–10 μm samples of comet Wild 2 provide a limited but direct view of the solar nebula solids that accreted to form Jupiter family comets. The samples collected by the Stardust mission are dominated by high‐temperature materials that are closely analogous to meteoritic components. These materials include chondrule and CAI‐like fragments. Five presolar grains have been discovered, but it is clear that isotopically anomalous presolar grains are only a minor fraction of the comet. Although uncertain, the presolar grain content is perhaps higher than found in chondrites and most interplanetary dust particles. It appears that the majority of the analyzed Wild 2 solids were produced in high‐temperature “rock forming” environments, and they were then transported past the orbit of Neptune, where they accreted along with ice and organic components to form comet Wild 2. We hypothesize that Wild 2 rocky components are a sample of a ubiquitously distributed flow of nebular solids that was accreted by all bodies including planets and meteorite parent bodies. A primary difference between asteroids and the rocky content of comets is that comets are dominated by this widely distributed component. Asteroids contain this component, but are dominated by locally made materials that give chondrite groups their distinctive properties. Because of the large radial mixing in this scenario, it seems likely that most comets contain a similar mix of rocky materials. If this hypothesis is correct, then properties such as oxygen isotopes and minor element abundances in olivine, should have a wider dispersion than in any chondrite group, and this may be a characteristic property of primitive outer solar system bodies made from widely transported components.     

Galactic chemical evolution and the oxygen isotopic composition of the solar system

Abstract– We review current observational and theoretical constraints on the galactic chemical evolution (GCE) of oxygen isotopes to explore whether GCE plays a role in explaining the lower ¹⁷O/¹⁸O ratio of the Sun, relative to the present‐day interstellar medium, or the existence of distinct ¹⁶O‐rich and ¹⁶O‐poor reservoirs in the solar system. Although the production of both ¹⁷O and ¹⁸O are related to the metallicity of progenitor stars, ¹⁷O is most likely produced in stars that evolve on longer timescales than those that produce ¹⁸O. Therefore, the ¹⁷O/¹⁸O ratio need not have remained constant over time, contrary to preconceptions and the simplest models of GCE. An apparent linear, slope‐one correlation between δ¹⁷O and δ¹⁸O in the ISM need not necessarily reflect an O isotopic gradient, and any slope‐one galactocentric gradient need not correspond to evolution in time. Instead, increasing ¹⁷O/¹⁸O is consistent both with observational data from molecular clouds and with modeling of the compositions of presolar grains. Models in which the rate of star formation has decelerated over the past few Gyr or in which an enhanced period of star formation occurred shortly before solar birth (“starburst”) can explain the solar‐ISM O‐isotopic difference without requiring a local input of supernova ejecta into the protosolar cloud. “Cosmic chemical memory” models in which interstellar dust is on average older than interstellar gas predict that primordial solar system solids should be ¹⁶O‐rich, relative to the Sun, in conflict with observations. However, scenarios can be constructed in which the ¹⁶O‐rich contribution of very massive stars could lead to ¹⁶O‐poor solids and a ¹⁶O‐rich bulk Sun, if the solar system formed shortly after a starburst, independent of the popular scenario of photochemical self‐shielding of CO.