Fine Structure of the Magnetic Chromosphere: Near-Limb Imaging,Data Processing and Analysis of Spicules and Mottles

The origin and the dynamical evolution of spicules and mottles continue to be a highly interesting research subject. Using high-resolution H observations obtained with the Dunn Solar Telescope of the Sacramento Peak Observatory and an image processing technique for the enhancement of near-limb solar images, we study the dynamics of spicules and mottles as well as their relation. Our image-processing technique is based on the correction for the limb darkening and the use of a directionally sensitive operator, the `MadMax'. The temporal evolution of characteristic cases of spicules, dark and bright mottles, indicates an association between them and supports the suggestion that the magnetic field and probably related forces play a fundamental role in their generation and dynamics. We present characteristic cases of fine bright mottles, observable in the H far wings, that appear in close juxtaposition to dark mottles. The phenomenon appears to be common, suggesting that the velocities derived from marginal resolution spectroscopic observations could be underestimated. Typical examples of individual mottles crossing the solar limb further support the association between spicules and mottles. Finally we show images of arch-shaped mottles above the limb and especially on the disk, confirming the existence of chromospheric small loops. Our image-processing method substantially enhances near-limb observations and permits an insight into the studies of the very fine chromospheric structures.     

Solar Spicules: A Review of Recent Models and Targets for Future Observations – (Invited Review)

Since their discovery over 100 years ago, there have been many suggestions for the origin and development of solar spicules. Because the velocities of spicules are comparable to the sound and Alfvén speeds of the low chromosphere, linear theory cannot fully describe them. Consequently, detailed tests of theoretical ideas had to await the development of computing power that only became available during the 1970s. This work reviews theories for spicules and spicule-like features over approximately the past 25 years, with an emphasis on the models based on nonlinear numerical simulations. These models have given us physical insight into wave propagation in the solar atmosphere, and have helped elucidate how such waves, and associated shock waves, may be capable of creating motions and structures on magnetic flux tubes in the lower solar atmosphere. So far, however, it has been difficult to reproduce the most-commonly-quoted parameters for spicules with these models, using what appears to be the most suitable input parameters. A key impediment to developing satisfactory models has been the lack of reliable observational information, which is a consequence of the small angular size and transient lifetime of spicules. I close with a list of key observational questions to be addressed with space-based satellites, such as the currently operating TRACE satellite, and especially the upcoming Solar-B mission. Answers to these questions will help determine which, if any, of the current models correctly explains spicules.     

Solar atmospheric heating

The solar atmosphere is heated by a flux of mechanical waves propagating in one or more of the modes: acoustic, Alfvén and gravitational.The acoustic theory is compared with observational data and found inadequate. First, the theory is based quantitatively on the Böhm-Vitense convection zone model, and large-scale convective motions (supergranulation) and magnetic fields (unipolar regions) show that convection has another form. On the other hand, when granular motions are invoked the energy flux is too small. Second, atmospheric heating is localized in faculae, and enhanced acoustic flux beneath these regions is no longer explicable. Finally, the short periods of 10–30 s invoked recently appear inexplicable. Objections to the gravitational wave heating process are given briefly.Previous objections to Alfvén waves as an energy source followed from the belief that fields were generally uniform and of strength 50 G, now known to be incorrect. Models of Alfvén wave generation are based on (i) granule eddy motions, (ii) overstable oscillations in subsurface flux tubes and sunspot flux ropes, and (iii) supergranule motions, both horizontal and vertical.The first provides waves which propagate along thin flux tubes oscillating as taut wires in a compressible fluid; they may explain mottles, fibrils and other small emission features. The second may explain the enormous dissipation in spot groups, including flares. The third has been invoked earlier to explain spicules, and may have effects in the solar wind.     

Suspended spicules associated with the enhanced bright network in an active region

The progressive rotation from the limb onto the disk of a long-lived cluster of coaligned Hα spicules was observed at high spatial resolution on the fringe of a large complex of activity. Although individual spicules were steadily changing, the organized cluster appeared consistently suspended above the photospheric limb when viewed in the wings of Hα (|Δλ| ≈ 0.9 Å). The phenomenon is the counterpart near an active region of the dark band discovered in the quiet low chromosphere by Loughhead (1969). But in the present circumstances the effect is perceived as a weakening of emission, i.e. as a gap rather than an obscuration. The initial gap between the off-band spicules and the photospheric limb narrowed and closed in about 4 h. A day later, the cluster of spicules could be identified at the same wavelength with a cluster of elongated dark mottles, similarly coaligned; they were adjacent to, but not in contact with, a foreshortened patch of faculae. The persistence of the gap in this cluster, and its occurrence in isolated spicules reported here in quiet regions, imply that the phenomenon is an inherent property of spicules. It is proposed that the gap results from a spicule-generating process initiated above the temperature minimum.     

Acoustic wave ducting along magnetic flux tubes in the sunspot regions

The acoustic waves generated in the solar atmosphere propagate globally as well as upwards. These waves interact with the solar magnetic field structures and are ducted upwards. The velocity of these modified acoustic waves is shown to vary in a modelled solar atmosphere. The solar plasma propagating upwards with these waves are likely to alter the observed features of spicules, granules, and supergranules during changing phases of sunspot regions.     

The dynamic magnetic quiet Sun: physical mechanisms and UV signature

The changes in the Sun occurring at human time-scales can be pinned down to the presence of magnetic fields. These fields determine the structure of the outer solar atmosphere and, therefore, they are responsible for all the energetic part of the solar spectrum, including the UV. Our understanding of the magnetic fields existing at the base of the atmosphere has changed during the last years. The new spectro-polarimeters reveal an ubiquitous magnetic field, present even in the quiet regions. They are widespread and of complex topology, containing far more (unsigned) magnetic flux and magnetic energy that all traditional manifestations of solar activity. These so-called quiet Sun magnetic fields are the subject of the contribution. I summarize their main observational properties, as well as the models put forward to explain them. According to the common wisdom, they may be generated by a turbulent dynamo driven by convective motions. Their true physical role is not understood yet, but it may be consequential both for the Sun (e.g., in determining the structure of the quiet corona), and for other astronomical objects (e.g., if a turbulent dynamo operates in the Sun, the same mechanism provides a very efficient mean of creating surface magnetic fields in all stars with convective envelopes). I discuss the impact of the quiet Sun fields on the transition region and corona, trying to point out the UV signatures of those fields.     

Oscillatory Response of the 3D Solar Atmosphere to the Leakage of Photospheric Motion

The direct propagation of acoustic waves, driven harmonically at the solar photosphere, into the three-dimensional solar atmosphere is examined numerically in the framework of ideal magnetohydrodynamics. It is of particular interest to study the leakage of 5-minute global solar acoustic oscillations into the upper, gravitationally stratified and magnetised atmosphere, where the modelled solar atmosphere possesses realistic temperature and density stratification. This work aims to complement and bring further into the 3D domain our previous efforts (by Erdélyi et al., 2007, Astron. Astrophys. 467, 1299) on the leakage of photospheric motions and running magnetic-field-aligned waves excited by these global oscillations. The constructed model atmosphere, most suitable perhaps for quiet Sun regions, is a VAL IIIC derivative in which a uniform magnetic field is embedded. The response of the atmosphere to a range of periodic velocity drivers is numerically investigated in the hydrodynamic and magnetohydrodynamic approximations. Among others the following results are discussed in detail: i) High-frequency waves are shown to propagate from the lower atmosphere across the transition region, experiencing relatively low reflection, and transmitting most of their energy into the corona; ii) the thin transition region becomes a wave guide for horizontally propagating surface waves for a wide range of driver periods, and particularly at those periods that support chromospheric standing waves; iii) the magnetic field acts as a waveguide for both high- and low-frequency waves originating from the photosphere and propagating through the transition region into the solar corona. Electronic Supplementary Material  The online version of this article () contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Power spectrum analysis of limb and disk spicule using Hinode Ca H-line broadband filter

We present observations of a solar quiet region obtained using the Hinode Solar Optical telescope (SOT) in the Ca II H-line with broadband filter taken on November 2006. We study off-limb and on-disk spicules to find a counterpart of the limb spicule on the disk. This investigation shows a strong correspondence between the limb and near limb spicules (on-disk spicules that historically were called dark or bright mottles, especially when observed in Hα, being a rather cool line) from the dynamical behavior (e.g., periodicity). An excellent time sequence of images obtained near the equatorial region with a cadence of 8 s was selected for analysis. 1D Fourier power spectra made at different positions on the disk and above the limb are shown. We take advantage of the so-called mad-max operator to reduce the effects of overlapping and improve the visibility of these hair-like features. A definite signature with strong power in the 3-min (5.5 mHz) and 5-min (3.5 mHz) oscillations for both places exists. A full range of oscillations was found and the high frequency intensity fluctuation (greater than 10 mHz or less than 100 s) corresponding to the occurrence of the so-called type II spicules and, even more impressively, dominant peaks of Fourier power spectra are seen in a wide range of frequencies and for all places of “on” and “off” disk spicules, in rough agreement with what historical works report regarding disk mottles and limb spicules. Also, some statistically significant behavior, based on the power spectrum computed for different positions, is discussed. The power for all kinds of power spectra is decreasing with increasing distance from the limb, except for photospheric oscillations (5 min or p-mode), which show a dominant peak for on-disk power spectra.     

Radio Detection of a Rapid Disturbance Launched by a Solar Flare

We report the direct observation of motion associated with a solar flare at a speed of 26,000 km s-1. The motion is seen from a radio source at 0.33 GHz, which suddenly starts moving during the flare. At its peak, the radio source covers a quiet region of dimension 500&arcsec;. Emission from any given location is sporadic. The disturbance itself does not seem to radiate, but it excites coronal features that continue to radiate after it passes. The inferred velocity is larger than any previously inferred velocity of a disturbance in the solar atmosphere apart from freely streaming beams of accelerated electrons. The observed motion of the source at a fixed frequency, low polarization, and moderate bandwidth are more consistent with the typical properties of moving type IV radio bursts than with classical coronal shock-associated type II bursts, but any disturbance at such a high velocity must be highly supersonic and should drive a shock. We speculate that the disturbance is associated with the realignment of magnetic fields connecting different portions of an active region.     

Phase mixing of standing Alfvén waves with shear flows in solar spicules

Alfvénic waves are thought to play an important role in coronal heating and solar wind acceleration. Here we investigate the dissipation of such waves due to phase mixing at the presence of shear flow and field in the stratified atmosphere of solar spicules. The initial flow is assumed to be directed along spicule axis and to vary linearly in the x direction and the equilibrium magnetic field is taken 2-dimensional and divergence-free. It is determined that the shear flow and field can fasten the damping of standing Alfvén waves. In spite of propagating Alfvén waves, standing Alfvén waves in Solar spicules dissipate in a few periods. As height increases, the perturbed velocity amplitude does increase in contrast to the behavior of perturbed magnetic field. Moreover, it should be emphasized that the stratification due to gravity, shear flow and field are the facts that should be considered in MHD models in spicules.     

Propagation of magnetically guided acoustic shocks in the solar chromosphere

We study the propagation of a train of acoustic shocks guided by diverging magnetic fields through a static model of the solar chromospheric network and transition region. Our results show that for initial flux densities of the order 10⁶ ergs cm^–2 s^–1 in the lower chromosphere, the local efficiency of acoustic transmission into the corona can be much higher than calculated for a plane parallel atmosphere. Thus acoustic energy will tend to be deposited at higher chromospheric levels in diverging magnetic fields, and magnetic guiding may well influence the temperature profile of the network and plages. But the total flux that can be transmitted into the corona along such diverging fields is severely limited, since the magnetic elements occupy a small fractional area of the photosphere, and the transmission efficiency is a rapidly decreasing function of initial acoustic flux density. We conclude that diverging magnetic fields and a varying ratio of specific heats are not likely to allow high frequency shocks to dissipate high enough in a static atmosphere, to contribute significantly to the coronal energy balance. This result strengthens the view that acoustic waves do not heat the solar corona. However, the conclusion may be sensitive to the influence of observed mass motions, such as spicules.     

Implications of rapid footpoint motions of photospheric flux tubes for coronal heating

Some recent observations at Pic-du-Midi (Mulleret al., 1992a) suggest that the photospheric footpoints of coronal magnetic field lines occasionally move rapidly with typical velocities of the order 3 km s^–1 for about 3 or 4 min. We argue that such occasional rapid footpoint motions could have a profound impact on the heating of the quiet corona. Qualitative estimates indicate that these occasional rapid motions can account for the entire energy flux needed to heat the quiet corona. We therefore carry out a mathematical analysis to study in detail the response of a vertical thin flux tube to photospheric footpoint motions in terms of a superposition of linear kink modes for an isothermal atmosphere. We find the resulting total energy that is asymptotically injected into an isothermal atmosphere (i.e., an atmosphere without any back reflection). By using typical parameter values for fast and slow footpoint motions, we show that, even if the footpoints spend only 2.5% of the time undergoing rapid motions, still these rapid motions could be more efficient in transporting energy to the corona than the slow motions that take place most of the time.     

太阳异极性磁区的相互入侵

我们在文[1]的启发下,计算了磁中性线附近异极性磁区相互入侵(或挤压)引起的等离子体动力学问题。气体初态取用流行的宁静太阳光球色球大气模型,即非等温的密度指数变化的重力分层大气。采用Lagrangian格式数值求解自洽的MHD方程,这可使入侵力学变得直观明显——磁场随流体而运动。我们的新结果是入侵流动在光球低层产生出强的水平磁场(即强的横向场),但光球高层和色球低层的磁结构却变化不大,有力地支持了文[13]提出的光球色球里可能出现磁流体力学间断面的概念。入侵确实在磁中性线附近建立了电流片,但这电流片主要在光球低层,其量级和观测一致。另外还显示垂直下降运动也可能导致异极磁区的入侵。尽管在MHD~1方程里包含了电阻耗散和热传导流,但计算证明它们对入侵力学影响不大,热传导的作用只是使气体温度分布逐渐趋于宁静太阳分布(尽管高度变了)。     

Multiscale Magnetic Underdense Regions on the Solar Surface: Granular and Mesogranular Scales

The Sun is a non-equilibrium, dissipative system subject to an energy flow that originates in its core. Convective overshooting motions create temperature and velocity structures that show a temporal and spatial multiscale evolution. As a result, photospheric structures are generally considered to be a direct manifestation of convective plasma motions. The plasma flows in the photosphere govern the motion of single magnetic elements. These elements are arranged in typical patterns, which are observed as a variety of multiscale magnetic patterns. High-resolution magnetograms of the quiet solar surface revealed the presence of multiscale magnetic underdense regions in the solar photosphere, commonly called voids, which may be considered to be a signature of the underlying convective structure. The analysis of such patterns paves the way for the investigation of all turbulent convective scales, from granular to global. In order to address the question of magnetic structures driven by turbulent convection at granular and mesogranular scales, we used a voids-detection method. The computed distribution of void length scales shows an exponential behavior at scales between 2 and 10 Mm and the absence of features at mesogranular scales. The absence of preferred scales of organization in the 2?–?10 Mm range supports the multiscale nature of flows on the solar surface and the absence of a mesogranular convective scale.     

Direct Propagation of Photospheric Acoustic <Emphasis Type="Italic">p</Emphasis> Modes into Nonmagnetic Solar Atmosphere

Solar p modes are one of the dominant types of coherent signals in Doppler velocity in the solar photosphere, with periods showing a power peak at five minutes. The propagation (or leakage) of these p-mode signals into the higher solar atmosphere is one of the key drivers of oscillatory motions in the higher solar chromosphere and corona. This paper examines numerically the direct propagation of acoustic waves driven harmonically at the photosphere, into the nonmagnetic solar atmosphere. Erdélyi et al. (Astron. Astrophys. 467, 1299, 2007) investigated the acoustic response to a single point-source driver. In the follow-up work here we generalise this previous study to more structured, coherent, photospheric drivers mimicking solar global oscillations. When our atmosphere is driven with a pair of point drivers separated in space, reflection at the transition region causes cavity oscillations in the lower chromosphere, and amplification and cavity resonance of waves at the transition region generate strong surface oscillations. When driven with a widely horizontally coherent velocity signal, cavity modes are caused in the chromosphere, surface waves occur at the transition region, and fine structures are generated extending from a dynamic transition region into the lower corona, even in the absence of a magnetic field.     

Fine structure of the Sun at 1.3 cm wavelength

The two-element interferometer at Hat Creek Observatory was used at 1.3 cm wavelength to study the fine structure of the radio emissive regions on the Sun. Observations of the quiet Sun at 1.3 cm show sudden changes in the fringe amplitude and phase, lasting for typically about 5–8 min. Assuming that these events are identical in nature, a plot of peak amplitude vs the projected baseline at the time of the event suggests emission from a region of angular size of about 10″. The corresponding brightness temperature is 50000 K. It is possible that these events may be related to the appearance and disappearance of groups of spicules or mottles.     

Evolution of the Fine Structure of Magnetic Fields in the Quiet Sun: Observations from Sunrise/IMaX and Extrapolations

Observations with the balloon-borne Sunrise/Imaging Magnetograph eXperiment (IMaX) provide high spatial resolution (roughly 100 km at disk center) measurements of the magnetic field in the photosphere of the quiet Sun. To investigate the magnetic structure of the chromosphere and corona, we extrapolate these photospheric measurements into the upper solar atmosphere and analyze a 22-minute long time series with a cadence of 33 seconds. Using the extrapolated magnetic-field lines as tracer, we investigate temporal evolution of the magnetic connectivity in the quiet Sun’s atmosphere. The majority of magnetic loops are asymmetric in the sense that the photospheric field strength at the loop foot points is very different. We find that the magnetic connectivity of the loops changes rapidly with a typical connection recycling time of about 3±1 minutes in the upper solar atmosphere and 12±4 minutes in the photosphere. This is considerably shorter than previously found. Nonetheless, our estimate of the energy released by the associated magnetic-reconnection processes is not likely to be the sole source for heating the chromosphere and corona in the quiet Sun.     

On the applicability of Goldberg and Unno's method to the determination of microturbulent velocities in an atmosphere with convection

The method of Goldberg and Unno for the determination of microturbulent velocities in a stellar atmosphere is only applicable if there are no macroturbulent or convective motions.If such motions occur, as in the solar photosphere, the derived results are false and may lead to misinterpretations such as an increase of the microturbulent velocity with depth or anisotropic microturbulence.     

Interpreting Helioseismic Structure Inversion Results of Solar Active Regions

Helioseismic techniques such as ring-diagram analysis have often been used to determine the subsurface structural differences between solar active and quiet regions. Results obtained by inverting the frequency differences between the regions are usually interpreted as the sound-speed differences between them. These in turn are used as a measure of temperature and magnetic-field strength differences between the two regions. In this paper we first show that the “sound-speed” difference obtained from inversions is actually a combination of sound-speed difference and a magnetic component. Hence, the inversion result is not directly related to the thermal structure. Next, using solar models that include magnetic fields, we develop a formulation to use the inversion results to infer the differences in the magnetic and thermal structures between active and quiet regions. We then apply our technique to existing structure inversion results for different pairs of active and quiet regions. We find that the effect of magnetic fields is strongest in a shallow region above 0.985R _⊙ and that the strengths of magnetic-field effects at the surface and in the deeper (r<0.98R _⊙) layers are inversely related (i.e., the stronger the surface magnetic field the smaller the magnetic effects in the deeper layers, and vice versa). We also find that the magnetic effects in the deeper layers are the strongest in the quiet regions, consistent with the fact that these are basically regions with weakest magnetic fields at the surface. Because the quiet regions were selected to precede or follow their companion active regions, the results could have implications about the evolution of magnetic fields under active regions.