Three-dimensional current system in different phases of a substorm

It is assumed that the three-dimensional current system of a substorm passes three successive stages. (1) When a dawn-to-dusk magnetospheric electric field appears, a current system with field-aligned currents at the poleward boundary of the auroral zone arises. An equivalent ionospheric current system calculated, taking into account a day-night asymmetry of ionospheric conductivity, looks like the well-known DP-2 system including an eastward low-latitude current and a greater magnitude of the dusk vortex in comparison with the dawn one. (2) An electric drift of plasma towards the Earth leads to the appearance of a westward partial ring current increasing in time. This current is closed by field-aligned currents at the equatorward boundary of the auroral zone. The calculated equivalent current system is similar to the well-known one of the precursory phase. (3) An increase of the auroral ionospheric conductivity during the expansive phase produces an increase of all currents and a turning of field-aligned currents at the equatorward boundary of the auroral zone relative to those at the poleward one. The calculated equivalent current system is similar to the DP-1 system.     

The sources of the polar cap and low latitude bay-like disturbances during substorms

Examination of the polar cap and low-latitude bays during substorms shows that there are two types of disturbances, DP₁₁ and DP₁₂, which are different not only in their morphological features, but in their origin as well. The DP₁₂ disturbances are associated with pure ionospheric currents, whereas the DP₁₁ are though to be generated by the Birkeland type current system. This conclusion is based on examination of the following characteristics: (1) the seasonal changes of the DP₁₁ and DP₁₂ disturbances in the polar cap, (2) the seasonal variations of the low-latitude bay intensity at the conjugate points in the cases of the DP₁₁ and DP₁₂ disturbances, (3) the distribution of the intensity of the DP₁₁ and DP₁₂ disturbances in both northern and southern hemispheres along the midnight meridian.     

High latitude equivalent current systems during extremely quiet times

The magnetic perturbation patterns in the polar cap and auroral zone regions are obtained for extremely quiet days using two different techniques. It is shown that the form of the equivalent current flow pattern is extremely sensitive to the level of quietness, and that even so-called quiet days are at times disturbed by substorm activity. Certain characteristic equivalent flow not typically observed during substorms is noted in the polar cap, and this flow appears to be associated with effects associated with polar cap perturbations discussed by Svalgaard (1973). As well a region of equatorward flow appears at high latitudes near the dawn meridian, which appears to be Hall current driven by an eastward electric field. The dayside sub-auroral zone is dominated by the S_q-current system, while the nightside shows no significant current flow in the absence of substorm activity.     

Event study on pre-substorm phases and their relation to the energy coupling between solar wind and magnetosphere

On 11 November 1976, after a magnetically quiet period with the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) directed northward, a sudden southward turning of the IMF immediately led to a world-wide intensification of convection which was observed to start almost simultaneously at stations within the auroral zone and polar cap. The two-dimensional equivalent current system over the northern hemisphere had a typical two-cell convection pattern with a maximum disturbance of ΔH = ?300 nT observed on the morningside in the westward electrojet region. This enhancement of activity ended after 35 min in a localized substorm onset in the midnight sector over Scandinavia.The recordings made in this area indicate large fluctuations of various ionospheric parameters starting several minutes before the substorm onset. Two subsequent stages can be resolved: (1) high-energy particle precipitation recorded by balloon X-ray detectors and maximum ionospheric current density increase, while the electrojet halfwidth shrinks and the total electrojet current becomes weaker; (2) the maximum ionospheric current density stays constant and the high-energy particle precipitation decreases, while the auroral brightness increases and the total electrojet current and its half-width show a growing trend prior to the final breakup. A suggestion is made that the time interval of these two stages should be called “trigger phase”. A short discussion explains the trigger phase observations in a magnetospheric scale. The energy coupling between solar wind and magnetosphere during the pre-substorm phases is discussed by utilizing the energy coupling function ? defined by Perreault and Akasofu (Geophys. J. R. Astr. Soc.54, 547, 1978). The ? values appear to be on substorm level during the period of enhanced convection. A good correlation between ? and the growth of the Joule heating rate (estimated from the AE data) is found in the beginning, but during the last 20 min before substorm triggering ? is high while the Joule heating rate decreases. The behaviour of ? during the two stages of the trigger phase suggests that the start of the trigger phase is purely internally controlled while the length of the trigger phase and the final substorm onset may be influenced by the variation in ?.     

Electron counts in the neutral sheet and magnetic variations at a geomagnetic longitude associated ground station

A comparison of the variations in the count of electrons E > 36 keV on the satellite Vela 4A, and in the Macquarie Island magnetometer H trace, shows for a time lag of 22-8 min a correlation, r = 0.95, over a 90 min period of the recovery phase of a magnetospheric substorm on 17 August 1968. All-sky camera data suggest that during the correlation period the auroral electrojet showed very little latitudinal movement. Each peak in electron count relates to a current surge in the electrojet as shown by a deepening of the negative bay at Macquarie Island.Using the Fairfield (1968) model of the location of auroral shells in the solar magnetic equatorial plane, and the known location of the satellite, an estimate of the velocity of tail to Earth plasma convection in the plasma sheet of about 0·33 R_e/min is obtained for the recovery phase.The relationship is discussed between plasma sheet thinning and subsequent broadening, and the extension of the magnetic field lines into the tail region and their subsequent return. This discussion makes use of the estimated time lags between electron count at the satellite and the time of arrival of auroral particles at the antisolar meridian.From a somewhat speculative explanation, but one largely supported from the literature, of the magnetospheric processes involved in this auroral substorm, a plasma velocity estimate of 0·42 R_e/min for the initial phase of the substorm is obtained. These velocities are of the same order as the 0·5 R_e/min obtained by Lezniak and Winkler (1970) at 6·6 R_e.     

A global view at the polar region on 18 December 1971

The ISIS-2 scanning auroral photometer surveyed the polar region during three successive passes on 18 December 1971, at times when Kp values were still high due to an intense magnetic storm which began on 16 December. Two very bright (IBC III) auroral substorm patterns were seen to correspond to rather weak magnetic substorms (about 300 γ in magnitude). A large spiral auroral pattern, with intensity of the order of 100 kR and a size of about 1300 km, was present in the polar cap; it gradually decreased in size and intensity during the interval 0200–0600 UT. A region of enhanced 3914 emission was present in the noon sector of the auroral oval between 0200 and 0400. The presence of the diffuse auroral belt is also evident at all local times during this period, extending down to about 61° corrected geomagnetic latitude in the midnight sector.     

A classification of polar cap auroral arcs

Global auroral imagery obtained by DMSP satellites during the years 1972–1979 over both the northern and southern high latitude polar regions were examined to study the morphology of the discrete arcs known as polar cap arcs. Based upon their morphology, the polar cap arcs can be generally classified into three types viz. (1) the distinctly sun-aligned polar cap arcs—Type 1 arcs, (2) the morning/evening polar cap arcs expanded from the auroral oval—Type 2 arcs and (3) the hook shaped arcs connecting the polar cap arc with the oval arc (including the hitherto unreported oppositely oriented hook shaped arcs)—Type 3 arcs. Concurrent auroral electrojet indices (AE) and interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) data were used to study the occurrence of the polar cap arcs. It was found that Type 1 arcs were observed mostly during low geomagnetic activity conditions, bright Type 2 arcs during the recovery phase of the substorms and Type 3 arcs do not occur during the recovery phase of the substorm. Over both hemispheres, the polar cap arcs were observed mostly during northward IMF. Furthermore, Type 1 arcs were obeserved over the northern polar cap during mostly negative B_x periods and over the southern polar cap during mostly positive B_x periods. The latter observation suggests that these types of arcs may be non-conjugate.     

Precipitation of auroral particles in the central polar cap during a sudden commencement magnetic storm

All-sky camera observations from two stations in the inner (northern) polar cap and an auroral zone station are combined with photometer records from the polar cap station Nord in a study of the brilliant auroral display following the ssc of the storm of 7 November 1970. This display is the large, poleward expanding bulge of a substorm triggered by the ssc. It is composed of brilliant discrete forms embedded in low-intensity diffuse electron and proton aurora. The poleward edge of the diffuse electron aurora is 5° north of the discrete auroras and 3° north of the proton aurora. The intensity of the discrete aurora varies as the strength of the auroral electrojet as shown by magnetograms from auroral zone stations. Succeeding the retreating display a subvisible low-energy electron precipitation, which may be identified as the polar squall (Winningham and Heikkila, 1974) is observed over the polar cap during the main phase of the storm.In the early morning sector already existing diffuse auroras broaden towards the equator from the time of the ssc and at least during the following half hour.Ssc-triggered displays have been found (Feldstein, 1959) to withdraw from the inner polar cap as the initial (positive H) phase of the storm ends. A comparison of the records from seven low-latitude stations shows that during this particular storm the positive phase appears to be composed by two overlapping disturbances, i.e. the proper initial phase, which is generally thought to be due to compression of the inner magnetosphere and a series of positive bays accompanying the negative bays in auroral latitudes. These positive bays are observable over a great range of longitudes with a maximum of amplitude near midnight. As judged from the dayside magnetograms the initial (compression) phase ends at an early stage of the substorm. The observed coincidence between the withdrawal of the display and the cessation of the positive H phase of the storm is a consequence of the fact that the second component—the positive bays—and the auroral display over the polar cap are both signatures of the substorm activity.     

Effects of interplanetary magnetic field and magnetospheric substorm variations on the dayside aurora

Photometric observations of dayside auroras are compared with simultaneous measurements of geomagnetic disturbances from meridian chains of stations on the dayside and on the nightside to document the dynamics of dayside auroras in relation to local and global disturbances. These observations are related to measurements of the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) from the satellites ISEE-1 and 3. It is shown that the dayside auroral zone shifts equatorward and poleward with the growth and decay of the circum-oval/polar cap geomagnetic disturbance and with negative and positive changes in the north-south component of the interplanetary magnetic field (B_z). The geomagnetic disturbance associated with the auroral shift is identified as the DP2 mode. In the post-noon sector the horizontal disturbance vector of the geomagnetic field changes from southward to northward with decreasing latitude, thereby changing sign near the center of the oval precipitation region. Discrete auroral forms are observed close to or equatorward of the ΔH = 0 line which separates positive and negative H-component deflections. This reversal moves in latitude with the aurora and it probably reflects a transition of the electric field direction at the polar cap boundary. Thus, the discrete auroral forms observed on the dayside are in the region of sunward-convecting field lines. A model is proposed to explain the equatorward and poleward movement of the dayside oval in terms of a dayside current system which is intensified by a southward movement of the IMF vector. According to this model, the Pedersen component of the ionospheric current is connected with the magnetopause boundary layer via field-aligned current (FAC) sheets. Enhanced current intensity, corresponding to southward auroral shift, is consistent with increased energy extraction from the solar wind. In this way the observed association of DP2 current system variations and auroral oval expansion/contraction is explained as an effect of a global, ‘direct’ response of the electromagnetic state of the magnetosphere due to the influence of the solar wind magnetic field. Estimates of electric field, current, and the rate of Joule heat dissipation in the polar cap ionosphere are obtained from the model.     

DP2 current system in the ionosphere and magnetosphere

Some years ago Nishida (1966) identified an equivalent current system which appeared to reflect a coherent magnetic field fluctuation observed at the equator and at high latitudes. This equivalent current system was subsequently labelled DP2, and since its existence was proposed it has been a topic of some controversy. In this paper we utilize the fact that DP2 intensity is regulated by the B_z component of the interplanetary magnetic field to decouple the DP2 variation from the very similar S_q perturbation pattern. We demonstrate how DP2 can arise as a manifestation of the overall three-dimensional magnetospheric-ionospheric current system which couples the magnetosphere to the high latitude ionosphere, and suggest how ionospheric conductivity is a major factor in regulating the strength of DP2 disturbances.     

On the nature of polar cap magnetic activity during undisturbed periods

The correlation between the polar cap geomagnetic variations (H-traces) and the changes of the azimuthal (Y_SE) and vertical (Z_SE) components of the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) during undisturbed periods is examined. It is shown that peak-to-peak correlation between Y_SE and geomagnetic horizontal component variations may be generally observed in the daytime cusp region, independently of the magnitude and polarity of the Z_SE. The existence of the DP₃ disturbances associated with the northward component Z_SE > 0 is confirmed. It is shown that the disturbances due to the vertical component of the IMF dominate in the region near the pole. In so far as the southward component of the IMF generates both polar cap disturbances and geomagnetic substorms, the disturbances in the region near the pole, associated with Z_SE < 0, may be regarded as a precursor of a substorm. On this basis a new index of the polar cap magnetic activity PC_L, characterizing the changeability of the magnetic field is proposed. It is shown that the increase of the PC_L index is followed in 1–2 hr by a substorm in 70% of events considered.     

Ground-based observations of an isolated substorm

An isolated substorm occurred in Northern Scandinavia on 1 March, 1977 around magnetic midnight. The ionospheric phenomena associated with this substorm were studied by ground magnetometers, the Scandinavian Twin Auroral Radar Experiment (STARE), riometers and an all-sky camera. The physical properties of the auroral electrojet are determined from the ground magnetic field and the ionospheric electric field data. Mid and low latitude magnetic field data show evidence of field-aligned current flow. It is shown that the enhancement of the electrojet's current density is essentially determined by an increase in the ionospheric conductivity. The current system derived from the data of this study corresponds to a model of Yasuhara et al. (1975a).     

Time-sequence of polar magnetic substorms

The time-sequence of polar magnetic substorms is discussed to clarify some controversies on the magnetospheric substorm model including the growth phase. The main purpose of the analyses is to examine magnetic variations in the polar cap and in low latitudes. The onset of the expansion phase is confirmed to be reasonably defined by a vector change of polar-cap magnetic disturbance, a sharp intensification of the auroral electrojet disturbance and the beginning of positive ΔH disturbance in midlatitudes near midnight. It is shown that the growth phase signatures so far proposed are consistent when the onset of the expansion phase is identified from the above mentioned features.     

The roles of the north-south component of the interplanetary magnetic field on large-scale auroral dynamics observed by the DMSP satellite

An extensive study of DMSP photographs and the simultaneous interplanetary magnetic field data suggests that the quantity defined by

$\text{S=∫}{}^{\mathrm{\tau }}{}_0\text{(Ф}{}_{\mathrm{D}}\text{? Ф}{}_{\mathrm{N}}\text{)dt}$

has a fundamental importance in substorm processes, where Φ_D and Φ_N denote the production rate of merged (or open) field lines along the dayside X-line and of reconnected (or closed) field lines along the nightside X-line, respectively; t = 0 is measured from the time when the B_z component begins to decrease after a prolonged period of a large positive B_z value. It is shown, first of all, that substorms occur so long as S > 0, regardless of the sign of the B_z component and its changes (namely, the southward and northward turnings) and of its time derivative as well. Secondly, the intensity of substorms is proportional to S². By introducing the quantity S, the recent confusion of the problem of the roles of the north-south component of the interplanetary magnetic field on substorm processes can be removed.Since S is equal to the amount of the open magnetic fluxes at a time reckoned from t = 0, it is proportional to (A₁ ? A₀), where A₀ denotes the minimum polar cap area (namely, the area bounded by the minimum auroral oval) and A₁ the polar cap area at an arbitrary time t. Therefore, substorms can occur whenever the auroral oval is larger than its minimum size. Further, an intense substorm tends to occur along a large oval.The quantity S can also be considered as an excess flux, and thus the substorm can be considered as a process by which the magnetosphere tends to remove sporadically the excess energy associated with S.     

Polar cap magnetic activity as a signature of substorm development

On the basis of the 5.46 min IMF data and the 3-min data on magnetic field at polar cap station Alert, various characteristics of the interplanetary magnetic field and polar cap magnetic activity are examined for the purpose of separating the substorm precursors. It is shown that the most suitable characteristics toward this aim are the following: 1.σ(B_Z)-index, defined as the 15-min sum of values of the southward (B_ZS) components of the IMF with an account of the negative gradient of the IMF vertical (B_Z) component; and 2.PC(B_Z)-index, defined as the 15-min sum of values of the polar cap magnetic disturbances, concerned with southward component B_ZS, with an account of variability of these disturbances. Every intense peak in the substorm activity is preceded by a corresponding increase in σ(B_Z) and PC(B_Z) indices. Thus, the conclusion is made that moderate and large substorms have a growth phase and as a result such substorms may be forecasted using the above indices.     

The day-sector polar F-layer during a magnetospheric substorm

Ionogram and all-sky camera data have been recorded on the Air Force Cambridge Research Laboratories' Flying Ionospheric Laboratory in the day sector of the auroral oval under conditions of darkness. The airborne measurements show that the polar F-layer irregularity zone, which is characterized on ionograms by a generally non-retarded and spread F type echo, exhibits meridional motions similar to the day-sector auroras. The polar F-layer irregularity zone and the day-sector auroras move equatorward and then move poleward in harmony with the development and decay of a magnetospheric substorm. We suggest that the polar cusp also moves in essentially the same fashion.     

A possible current system associated with the Sqp variation

It is suggested that the quiet day daily magnetic variation in the polar cap region, S_q^p, results partly from the short-circuit effect of the magnetotail current by the polar ionosphere. This implies that there is an inward field-aligned current from the dawnside magnetopause to the forenoon sector of the auroral oval (positively charged) and an outward field-aligned current to the duskside magnetopause from the afternoon sector of the oval (negatively charged), together with the ionospheric (Pedersen and Hall) currents. The distribution of the magnetic field vectors of both combined current systems agrees with the observed S_q^pvector distribution. The space charges provide an electric field distribution which is similar to that which has been observed by polar orbiting satellites.     

Precipitation of > 115 kev protons in the evening and forenoon sectors in relation to the magnetic activity

Data from a low altitude polar orbiting satellite, on auroral protons >115 keV in the evening and forenoon sectors, are presented.In the forenoon sector there is a weak but fairly steady precipitation at Λ ≈ 75° during quiet conditions. This precipitation is situated at higher invariant latitudes at local noon than at local dawn and can probably be ascribed to the high energy tail of the polar cleft protons. During moderately disturbed conditions, especially during the recovery phase of geomagnetic storms, there are some seemingly more “impulsive” precipitation events at Λ ≈ 65°. During very disturbed conditions these two precipitation zones in the forenoon sector seem to merge.In the evening sector a rather sharp equatorward boundary of the main precipitation, at Λ ≈ 69° during quiet conditions, varies fairly smoothly from pass to pass. South of this boundary, at invariant latitudes around 62°, there is a steady weak drizzle from the radiation belt. Due to a longitudinal effect this drizzle, as recorded by the satellite, shows a diurnal variation.The equatorward boundaries of the main precipitation at both local times move equatorward with increasing ring current strength. When D_st gets less than about — 100nT, the poleward boundaries are found to move equatorward too. From an attempt to reveal some of the substorm-dependent changes of the precipitation it is found that an equatorward shift of the precipitation areas takes place during, or just prior to, the substorm expansive phase, accompanied by a large intensity increase in the evening sector, whereas the recovery phase is linked with a poleward expansion of the precipitation at both local times.     

Ionosphere-plasmasheet field-aligned currents and parallel electric fields

Two kinetic models for the auroral topside ionosphere are compared. The collisionless plasma distributed along an auroral magnetic field line behaves like a non-Ohmic conducting medium with highly non-linear characteristic curves relating the parallel current density to the potential difference between the cold ionosphere and the hot plasmasheet region. The (zero-electric current) potential difference, required to balance the current carried by the precipitating plasmasheet particles and the current transported by the outflowing ionospheric particles, depends on the ratio n_ps.e/n_th.e and T_ps.e/T_th.e of the plasmasheet and ionospheric electron densities and temperatures. When in the E-region the magnetic field lines are interconnected by a high conductivity plasma the resulting field-aligned currents driven by the magnetospheric potential distribution are limited by the integrated Pedersen conductivity of the ionospheric layers. These currents are not related to the parallel electric field intensity as they would be in Ohmic materials. The parallel electric field intensity is necessarily determined by the local quasi-neutrality of the plasma.