Annite stability revised. 1. Hydrogen-sensor data for the reaction annite = sanidine + magnetite + H2

In P - T - logfO₂ space, the stability of annite (ideally KFe ₃ ²⁺ (OH)₂AlSi₃O₁₀) at high fO₂ (low fH₂) is limited by the reaction: annite = sanidine + magnetite + H₂. Using the hydrogen-sensor technique, the equilibrium fH₂ of this reaction was measured between 500 and 800° C at 2.8 kbar in 50° C intervals. Microbrobe analyses of the reacted annite+sanidine+magnetite mixtures show that tetrahedral positions of annite have a lower Si/Al ratio than the ideal value of 3/1. Silicon decreases from 2.9 per formula unit at low temperatures to 2.76 at high temperatures. As determined by Mössbauer spectroscopy in three experimental runs, the Fe³⁺ content of annite in the equilibrium assemblage is 11%±3. A least squares fit to the hydrogensensor data gives H _R ⁰ = 50.269 ± 3.987 kJ and S _R ⁰ = 83.01 ± 4.35 J/K for equilibrium (1). The hydrogene-sensor data are consistent with temperature half brackets determined in the classical way along the nickel-nickel oxide (NNO) and quartz-fayalite-magnetite (QFM) buffers with a mixture of annite+sanidine+magnetite for control. Compared to published oxygen buffer reversals, agreement is only found at high temperature and possible reasons for that discrepancy are discussed. The resulting slope of equilibrium (1) in logfO₂ – T dimensions is considerably steeper than previously determined and between 400 and 800°C only intersects with the QFM buffer curve. Based on the hydrogen-sensor data and on the thermodynamic dataset of Berman (1988, and TWEEQ data base) for sanidine, magnetite and H₂, the deduced standard-state properties of annite are: H _f ⁰ =-5127.376±5.279 kJ and S ⁰=422.84±5.29 J/(mol K). From the recently published unit cell refinements of annites and their Fe³⁺ contents, determined by Mössbauer spectroscopy (Redhammer et al. 1993), the molar volume of pure annite was constrained as 15.568±0.030 J/bar. A revised stability field for annite is presented, calculated between 400 and 800°C.     

The stability of annite+quartz: reversed experimental data for the reaction 2 annite+3 quartz=2 sanidine+3 fayalite +2 H2O

Reversals for the reaction 2 annite+3 quartz=2 sanidine+3 fayalite+2 H₂O have been experimentally determined in cold-seal pressure vessels at pressures of 2, 3, 4 and 5?kbar, limiting annite +quartz stability towards higher temperatures. The equilibrium passes through the temperature intervals 500–540°?C (2?kbar), 550–570°?C (3?kbar), 570–590°?C (4?kbar) and 590–610°?C (5?kbar). Starting materials for most experiments were mixtures of synthetic annite +fayalite+sanidine+quartz and in some runs annite+quartz alone. Microprobe analyses of the reacted mixtures showed that the annites deviate slightly from their ideal Si/Al ratio (Si per formula unit ranges between 2.85 and 2.92, Al^VI between 0.06 and 0.15). As determined by Mössbauer spectroscopy, the Fe³⁺ content of annite in the assemblage annite+fayalite +sanidine+quartz is around 5–7%. The experimental data were used to extract the thermodynamic standard state enthalpy and entropy of annite as follows: H ⁰ _f,?Ann =?5125.896±8.319 [kJ/mol] and S ⁰ _Ann=432.62±8.89 [J/mol/K] (consistent with the Holland and Powell 1990 data set), and H ⁰ _f,Ann =?5130.971±7.939 [kJ/mol] and S ⁰ _Ann=424.02±8.39 [J/mol/K] (consistent with the TWEEQ data base, Berman 1991). The preceeding values are close to the standard state properties derived from hydrogen sensor data of the redox reaction annite=sanidine+magnetite+H ₂ (Dachs 1994). The experimental half-reversal of Eugster and Wones (1962) on the annite +quartz breakdown reaction could not be reproduced experimentally (formation of annite from sanidine+fayalite+quartz at 540°?C/1.035?kbar/magnetite-iron buffer) and probable reasons for this discrepancy remain unclear. The extracted thermodynamic standard state properties of annite were used to calculate annite and annite+quartz stabilities for pressures between 2 and 5?kbar.     

The mechanism of the reaction 1 tremolite+3 calcite+2 quartz =5 diopside+3 CO2+1 H2O: results of powder experiments

The mechanism of the reaction 1 tremolite +3 calcite+2 quartz=5 diopside+3 CO₂+1 H₂O was investigated at 2 and 5 kb, , using powder experiments lasting from 14 to 170 days. Because experiments were at high ratios of fluid to solids, the study identified the mechanism under surface-control conditions and thus establishes which reactant surface determines the kinetics. To achieve a diopside nucleation rate high enough to gain detectable reaction in the time of experimentation, the equilibrium boundary had to be overstepped by 30°–60° C at 5 kb. Experiments in which diopside successfully nucleated show that the reaction proceeds by a dissolution-crystallization mechanism. Experimentally-produced textures are presented in a series of SEM images and demonstrate that diopside nucleates and grows topotactically exclusively on tremolite. The mechanism of the forward reaction is modeled by a simplified scheme consisting of three processes, each comprising formation, transport and incorporation of 1) the Ca-, 2) the Mg-, and 3) the Si-bearing species in the fluid in response to dissolution of the reactants and crystallization of diopside. Using the dependence of the overall-reaction rate on the surface area of the reactants, it was experimentally determined that process 2) (dissolution of tremolite, transport of the Mg-bearing species in the fluid and crystallization of diopside) will be rate-limiting in most cases where metamorphism occurs in an internally controlled system. Due to the experimental design chosen, the dissolution of tremolite at the beginning of process 2) is rate-limiting in the experiments. The magnitude of the probable temperature-overstep necessary to achieve a significant nucleation rate during metamorphism is discussed on the basis of the experimental evidence and a simple nucleation rate model.     

Experimental determination of the reaction paragonite=jadeite+kyanite+H2O,and internally consistent thermodynamic data for part of the system Na2O−Al2O3−SiO2−H2O,with applications to eclogites and blueschists

Hydrothermal reversal experiments have been performed on the upper pressure stability of paragonite in the temperature range 550–740 ° C. The reaction $$\begin{gathered} {\text{NaAl}}_{\text{3}} {\text{Si}}_{\text{3}} {\text{O}}_{{\text{1 0}}} ({\text{OH)}}_{\text{2}} \hfill \\ {\text{ paragonite}} \hfill \\ {\text{ = NaAlSi}}_{\text{2}} {\text{O}}_{\text{6}} + {\text{Al}}_{\text{2}} {\text{SiO}}_{\text{5}} + {\text{H}}_{\text{2}} {\text{O}} \hfill \\ {\text{ jadeite kyanite vapour}} \hfill \\ \end{gathered}$$ has been bracketed at 550 ° C, 600 ° C, 650 ° C, and 700 ° C, at pressures 24–26 kb, 24–25.5 kb, 24–25 kb, and 23–24.5 kb respectively. The reaction has a shallow negative slope (? 10 bar °C^?1) and is of geobarometric significance to the stability of the eclogite assemblage, omphacite+kyanite. The experimental brackets are thermodynamically consistent with the lower pressure reversals of Chatterjee (1970, 1972), and a set of thermodynamic data is presented which satisfies all the reversal brackets for six reactions in the system Na₂O-Al₂O₃-SiO₂-H₂O. The Modified Redlich Kwong equation for H₂O (Holloway, 1977) predicts fugacities which are too high to satisfy the reversals of this study. The P-T stabilities of important eclogite and blueschist assemblages involving omphacite, kyanite, lawsonite, Jadeite, albite, chloritoid, and almandine with paragonite have been calculated using thermodynamic data derived from this study.     

Experimental determination of the reaction dolomite + 2 coesite = diopside + 2 CO2 to 6 GPa

 The carbonation reaction CaMg(CO₃)₂ (dolomite)+2SiO₂ (coesite)=CaMgSi₂O₆ (diopside)+2 CO₂ (vapor) has been determined experimentally between 3.5 and 6 GPa in a multiple-anvil, solid-media apparatus. This reaction, a candidate for carbonation of eclogites (garnet+clinopyroxene) in the Earth’s mantle, lies at higher pressure for a given temperature than do the carbonation reactions for peridotites (olivine+orthopyroxene±clinopyroxene). A depth interval may exist within the Earth’s mantle under either ‘normal’ or ‘subduction’ thermal regimes where carbonated peridotite could coexist with carbonate-free, CO₂-bearing eclogite. Received: 25 May 1994/Accepted: 13 June 1995     

The reaction garnet+clinopyroxene+quartz =2 orthopyroxene+anorthite: A potential geobarometer for granulites

A mineralogic geobarometer based on the reaction garnet+clinopyroxene+quartz=2 orthopyroxene+anorthite is proposed. The geobarometric formulations for the Fe- and Mg- end member equilibria are $$\begin{gathered} P_{({\text{Fe}})} {\text{ }}({\text{bars}}){\text{ = 32}}{\text{.097 }}T{\text{ }} - {\text{ 26385 }} - {\text{ 22}}{\text{.79 (}}T - 848 - T1{\text{n(}}T/848{\text{))}} \hfill \\ {\text{ }} - (3.655 + 0.0138T){\text{ }}\left( {\frac{{{\text{(}}T - 848{\text{)}}^{\text{2}} }}{T}} \right) \hfill \\ {\text{ }} - {\text{(3}}{\text{.123) }}T1{\text{n }}\frac{{(a_{a{\text{n}}}^{{\text{Plag}}} )(a_{{\text{fs}}}^{{\text{P}}\ddot u{\text{x}}} )^2 }}{{(a_{{\text{alm}}}^{{\text{Gt}}} )(a_{{\text{hed}}}^{{\text{Opx}}} )}} \hfill \\ P_{({\text{Mg}})} {\text{ (bars) = 9}}{\text{.270 }}T + 4006 - 0.9305{\text{ }}(T - 848 - T1{\text{n (}}T/848{\text{)}}) \hfill \\ {\text{ }} - (1.1963{\text{ }} - {\text{ }}6.0128{\text{ x 10}}^{ - {\text{3}}} T)\left( {\frac{{(T - 848)^2 }}{T}} \right) \hfill \\ {\text{ }} - 3.489{\text{ }}T1{\text{n }}\frac{{(a_{an}^{{\text{Plag}}} ){\text{ }}(a_{{\text{ens}}}^{{\text{Opx}}} )}}{{{\text{(}}a_{{\text{pyr}}}^{{\text{Gt}}} {\text{) (}}a_{{\text{diop}}}^{{\text{Cpx}}} {\text{)}}}}. \hfill \\ \end{gathered}$$ The end member thermodynamic data have been taken from the data base of Helgeson et al. (1978) and Saxena and Erikson (1983). The activities of pyroxene components and anorthite in plagioclase have been modelled after Wood and Banno (1973) and Newton (1983) respectively. The activities of pyrope and almandine are calculated from the binary interaction parameters for garnet solid solutions proposed by Saxena and Erikson (1983). Pressures computed from these equations for fifty sets of published mineral data from several granulite areas are comparable with those obtained from dependable geobarometers. The pressure values determined from the Fe-end member equilibrium appear to be more reasonable than those from the Mg-end member reaction. It is likely that the difference in pressures computed from the Fe- and Mg-end members, ΔP ^*, have been caused by non-ideal mixing in the phases, especially in garnets.     

Mechanism and kinetics of the reaction: 1 dolomite + 2 quartz = 1 diopside + 2 CO2: a comparison of rock-sample and of powder experiments

Two experiments using cylindrical samples of a dolomite-quartz rock were carried out in a conventional hydrothermal apparatus for the forward reaction: 1 dolomite + 2 quartz = 1 diopside + 2 CO₂, in order to compare the mechanism and the kinetics with results from experiments using mineral powders of dolomite and quartz at the same P-T-X conditions. Experimental conditions were as follows: total pressure 500 MPa; temperature 680° C (overstepping 65° C); CO₂ content of the fluid phase, consisting of carbon dioxide and water, was nearly 90 mol%; the fluid/rock ratio was 1:37, and the H₂O/rock ratio was about 1:740; run duration was 92 days. Scanning electron microscope (SEM) examination of a polished axial section of the rock cylinders after the run, using back-scattered electrons (BSE), shows that the reaction produced corona textures. The diopside crystals nucleate and grow exclusively on dolomite surfaces adjacent to quartz grains, i.e. in regions where there is intimate contact between the reactants. The dolomite matrix, in contrast, is diopside free. A concept of microsystems is used to compare directly the rock cylinder results with those from runs done with mineral powders. The microsystems, which consist of quartz, dolomite and diopside, are connected by the intergranular space which is filled by the fluid phase. The SEM analysis of the rock cylinders indicates a dissolution-crystallization mechanism operating in the microsystems; this is consistent with the results of experiments using dolomite quartz powders (Lüttge et al. 1989). It can be demonstrated that reaction kinetics in mineral powder runs are interface controlled as long as the newly formed diopside crystals do not cover the dolomite surfaces completely (Lüttge and Metz 1991 c). This result is applicable to each microsystem of the rock cylinder, since the reaction mechanism and the resulting textures are the same in both kinds of experiments. The reaction is much slower outside the microsystems, i.e. in the dolomite matrix but in the close vicinity of the quartz grains. At these places, the reaction is controlled by the transport of Si-species in the CO₂-rich fluid phase filling the intergranular space. The reaction is absent in quartz-free regions of the dolomite matrix. Calculations and measurements of the extent of reaction progress in both kinds of experiments give results of the same order of magnitude: the conversion, and therefore the reaction rate, differs by less than a factor of two. The conclusion is that there are no differences, in principle, concerning mechanisms, rate controls, rates, and resulting textures between rock cylinder experiments, and mineral powder experiments.     

Experimental investigation of the metamorphism of siliceous dolomites III. Equilibrium data for the reaction: 1 Tremolite + 11 dolomite ⇌ 8 forsterite + 13 calcite + 9 CO2 +1H2O for the total pressures of 3,000 and 5,000 bars

The temperature-X _{CO 2}-equilibrium data for the reaction 1 tremolite + 11 dolomite 8 forsterite + 13 calcite + 9 CO₂ +1H₂O have been determined at total pressures (P _{CO 2} + P _H2_O) of 3,000 and 5,000 bars. The results are shown in Figure 2 along with the data for the total pressure of 1,000 bars (Metz, 1967).The MgCO₃ contents of the magnesian-calcites formed during the experiments agree very well with the calcite-dolomite-solvus which can be recalculated from Equation (1) and the activity coefficients for MgCO₃ in magnesiancalcite as given by Gordon and Greenwood (1970).If the T-X _{CO 2}-equilibrium data are calculated from the equilibrium constant as given by Skippen (1974), assuming ideal mixing of CO₂ and H₂O, good agreement is achieved for the total pressure of 1,000 bars (see Figs. 4 and 5). At a total pressure of 3,000 bars, however, the calculated equilibrium temperatures are about 40 ° C below the experimentally determined values (see Fig. 6). This difference increases up to 70 ° C for a total pressure of 5,000 bars (see Fig. 7).From the experimentally determined equilibrium conditions of the assemblage: tremolite + dolomite + forsterite + magnesian calcite (see Fig. 8) the pressure of metamorphism can be estimated if the temperature is determined by the MgCO₃-content of the magnesian-calcite from the calcite-dolomite solvus. However, when using the data of Figure 8, attention has to be drawn to the limiting condition of X _{CO 2}0.2.Simplified reaction equation not considering solid solution in the carbonates     

Phase relations to 3 kbar in the systems edenite + H2O and edenite + excess quartz + H2O

Amphiboles approached edenite (NaCa₂Mg₅Si₇AlO₂₂(OH)₂), richterite (Na₂CaMg₅Si₈O₂₂(OH)₂), tremolite (□Ca₂Mg₅Si₈O₂₂(OH)₂) solid solutions were studied by conventional hydrothermal techniques employing the bulk compositions edenite, and edenite + additional quartz, all with excess H₂O. For the stoichiometric edenite bulk composition + excess H₂O, the equilibrium phase assemblage is diopside + Na-phlogopite + forsterite + fluid at, and just above the amphibole high-temperature limit at 850 ± 5°C, 500 bar, and 880 ± 5°C, 1000 bar. The breakdown temperature of sodic phlogopite is 855 ± 3°C at 500 bar, and 890 ± 5°C at 700 bar, producing nepheline + plagioclase (or melt), additional forsterite and fluid. Diopside and Na-phlogopite solid solution coexist over a broad P_fluid-T region, even within the amphibole field, where they are associated with an edenite-richterite (-tremolite) solid solution of approximate composition Ed₃₅Rc₅₀Tr₁₅.In the system edenite + 4 quartz + excess H₂O, nearly pure tremolite and albite coexist stably between 670° and 830°C at 1000 bar and give way to the possibly metastable assemblage diopside + talc + albite below 670°C. In the presence of albite, tremolite reacts to produce diopside + quartz + enstatite + fluid above 830°C at 1000 bar. For the investigated silica-rich bulk composition, amphibole P_fluid-T stability is divided by the albite melting curve into a tremolite + albite field, and a tremolite + aqueous melt field. Substantial equilibrium solid solution of tremolite towards edenite or richterite was not observed for silica-excess bulk compositions. Metastable edenite-rich amphiboles initially synthesized change to tremolite with increasing run length in the presence of free SiO₂.Edenitic amphibole is stable only over a very limited temperature range in silica-undersaturated environments, thus accounting for its rarity in nature. Na-phlogopite solid solutions are also disfavored by high a_SiO2; even for nepheline-normative lithologies, a hypothesized rapid low-temperature conversion to vermiculite or smectite could partly explain the scarcity of sodic phlogopite in rocks.     

Experimental investigation of the mechanism of the reaction: 1 tremolite+11 dolomite ⇌ 8 forsterite+13 calcite+9 CO2+1H2O

Stoichiometric mixtures of tremolite and dolomite were heated to 50° C above equilibrium temperatures to form forsterite and calcite. The pressure of the CO₂-H₂O fluid was 5 Kb and \(X_{{\text{CO}}_{\text{2}} }\) varied from 0.1 to 0.6. The extent of the conversion was determined by the amount of CO₂ produced. The resulting mixtures of unreacted tremolite and dolomite and of newly-formed forsterite and calcite were examined with a scanning electron microscope. All tremolite and dolomite grains showed obvious signs of dissolution. At fluid compositions with \(X_{{\text{CO}}_{\text{2}} }\) less than about 0.4, the forsterite and calcite crystals are randomly distributed throughout the charges, indicating that surfaces of the reactants are not a controlling factor with respect to the sites of nucleation of the products. A change is observed when \(X_{{\text{CO}}_{\text{2}} }\) is greater than about 0.4; the forsterite and calcite crystals now nucleate and grow at the surface of the dolomite grains, thus indicating a change in mechanism at medium CO₂ concentrations. As the reaction progresses, the dolomite grains become more and more surrounded by forsterite and calcite, finally forming armoured relics of dolomite. Under experimental conditions this characteristic texture can only be formed if the CO₂-concentration is greater than about 40 mole %. These findings make it possible to estimate the CO₂-concentration from the texture of the dolomite+tremolite+forsterite+calcite assemblage. The results suggest a dissolution-precipitation mechanism for the reaction investigated. In a simplified form it consists of the following 4 steps:

1. Dissolution of the reactants tremolite and dolomite.
2. Diffusion of the dissolved constituents in the fluid.
3. Heterogeneous nucleation of the product minerals.
4. Growth of forsterite and calcite from the fluid.

Two possible explanations are discussed for the development of the amoured texture at \(X_{{\text{CO}}_{\text{2}} }\) above 0.4. The first is based upon the assumption that dolomite has a lower rate of dissolution than tremolite at high \(X_{{\text{CO}}_{\text{2}} }\) values resulting in preferential calcite and forsterite nucleation and growth on the dolomite surface. An alternative explanation is the formation of a raised CO₂ concentration around the dolomite grains at high \(X_{{\text{CO}}_{\text{2}} }\) values, leading to product precipitation on the dolomite crystals.     

The reaction MgCr2O4 + SiO2 = Cr2O3 + MgSiO3 and the free energy of formation of magnesiochromite (MgCr2O4)

Low-temperature heat capacity measurements for MgCr₂O₄ have only been performed down to 52 K, and the commonly quoted third-law entropy at 298 K (106 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹) was obtained by empirical extrapolation of these measurements to 0 K without considering the magnetic or electronic ordering contributions to the entropy. Subsequent magnetic measurements at low temperature reveal that the Néel temperature, at which magnetic ordering of the Cr³⁺ ions in MgCr₂O₄ occurs, is at ∼15 K. Hence a substantial contribution to the entropy of MgCr₂O₄ has been missed. We have determined the position of the near-univariant reaction MgCr₂O₄+SiO₂=MgSiO₃+Cr₂O₃. The reaction, which has a small positive slope in P-T space, has been bracketed at 100 K intervals between 1273 and 1773 K by reversal experiments. The reaction is extremely sluggish, and lengthy run times with a flux (H₂O, BaO-B₂O₃ or K₂O-B₂O₃) are needed to produce tight reversal brackets. The results, combined with assessed thermodynamic data for Cr₂O₃, MgSiO₃ and SiO₂, give the entropy and enthalpy of formation of MgCr₂O₄ spinel. As expected, our experimental results are not in good agreement with the presently available thermodynamic data. We obtain Δ _f H ^∘ ₂₉₈=−1759.2±1.5 kJ mol⁻¹ and S ^∘ ₂₉₈=122.1±1.0 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ for MgCr₂O₄. This entropy is some 16 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ more than the calorimetrically determined value, and implies a value for the magnetic entropy of MgCr₂O₄ consistent with an effective spin quantum number (S') for Cr³⁺ of 1/2 rather than the theoretical 3/2, indicating, as in other spinels, spin quenching. Received: 9 May 1997 / Accepted: 28 July 1997     

Melting and subsolidus reactions in the system K2O-CaO-Al2O3-SiO2-H2O: corrections and additional experimental data

Melting relationships in the system K₂O-CaO-Al₂O₃-SiO₂-H₂O have been reinvestigated using Schreinemakers analysis and hydrothermal experiments. The reaction sanidine+muscovite+zoisite+quartz+vapor =melt has been bracketed at 10, 15, and 20 kbars and 670–680, 680–690, and 690–700° C, respectively and it marks the lowest solidus temperatures in the system investigated.Below 10 kbars, experimental data on the beginning of melting in zoisite- or muscovite-bearing anorthite+sanidine assemblages have been obtained, which are not showing any differences and therefore point to melt compositions close to the feldspar-quartz join.     

The experimental investigation of the reactions MnCO3+SiO2=MnSiO37#x002B;CO2 and MnSiO3+MnCO3=Mn2SiO4+CO2 in CO2/H2O gasmixtures at a total pressure of 500 bars

The equilibrium constants for the reaction (2) Rhodochrosite + Quartz=Pyroxmangite+CO₂ obtained are:logK(₂)(bars)= $$\begin{gathered}{\text{log}}f_{co_2 } = - \frac{{(9862 \pm 102)}}{T} \hfill \\+ (15.887 \pm 0.220) + (0.1037 \pm 0.0020)\frac{{P - 1}}{T} \hfill \\\end{gathered} $$ and for the reaction (3) Rhodochrosite+Pyroxmangite=Tephroite+CO₂: logK(₃)(bars)= $$\begin{gathered}{\text{log}}f_{co_2 } = - \frac{{(6782 \pm 205)}}{T} \hfill \\+ (11.296 \pm 0.304) + (0.0835 \pm 0.0030)\frac{{P - 1}}{T} \hfill \\\end{gathered} $$ The present data lie within reasonable limits of error of the values calculated from previous experimental results at P _tot = 2000 bars.     

Subsolidus and Partial Melting Reactions in the Quartz-excess CaO+MgO+Al2O3+SiO2+H2O System under Water-excess and Water-deficient Conditions to 10 kb: Some Implications for the Origin of Peraluminous Melts from Mafic Rocks

Experimental results up to 10 kb pressure are presented on thestability of amphibole in the quartz-excess CaO+MgO+Al₂O₃ (CMASH)system under H₂O)-excess and H₂O deficient conditions. Amphiboleis stable above the solidus under H₂O-excess conditions whereasunder H₂O-deficient conditions dehydration melting of amphibole-bearingassemblages defines the solidus. The successive appearance ofamphibole, talc, and zoisite with increasing pressure considerablymodifies the plagioclase-pyroxene-garnet-kyanite reactions documentedexperimentally in the CaO+MgO+Al₂O₃+SiO₂ system for gabbro-granulite-eclogitetransitions. Although both clino pyroxene and cordierite (withanorthite+orthopyroxene+quartz) may melt eutectically at oneatmosphere to form diopside-normative and corundum-normativemelts respectively, at higher pressures under H₂O-excess conditionsthe peritectic melting of mafic rock compositions produces corundum-normativeliquids together with either clinopyroxene or amphibole. Dehydrationmelting produces melts which are not corundum-normative. Thesedata are used to discuss the origins and evolution of contrastingbasalt-andesite-dacite-rhyolite volcanic suites and graniticplutons, many of whose silicic variants are corundum-normativein character, such as the Toba luff ignimbrites, Indonesia (Beddoc-Stephenset al., 1983) and I-type granite minimum melts (White &Chappell, 1977). In contrast, it is proposed that for the Cascadesbasalt-andesite-dacite-rhyolite suite the ortho pyroxene-plagioclase-quartzthermal divide was maintained up to rhyolite compositions, therebyprohibiting the derivation of corundum-normative rocks fromdiopside-normative parent magmas. The deduced reaction relations between pyroxenes, amphibole,plagioclase, quartz, and liquid are used to explain the absenceor extreme scarcity of hydrous phases in some hydrous magmas.These phase relations can also explain the development of laterplagioclase overgrowths on resorbed plagioclase cores in graniticintrusives, and the general absence of resorption and overgrowthsin chemically equivalent extrusive rocks. A theoretical analysis of the partial melting of forsterite-bearingassemblages in the CaO+MgO+Al₂O₃+SiO₂+H₂O system shows thatunder H₂O-excess conditions partial melting may generate corundum-normative(but low SiO₂) melts from a peridotite source at shallow depths.     

Metamorphic reactions between fluid inclusions and mineral hosts. I. Progress of the reaction calcite+quartz=wollastonite+CO2 in natural wollastonite-hosted fluid inclusions

 At the Bufa del Diente contact-metamorphic aureole, brine infiltration through metachert layers embedded in limestones produced thick wollastonite rims, according to Cc+Qz=Wo+CO₂. Fluid inclusions trapped in recrystallized quartz hosts include: (1) high salinity four phase inclusions [Th(V-L)=460–573° C; Td(salts)=350–400° C; (Na+K)_Cleq=64–73 wt%; X _{CO 2}≤0.02]; (2) low density vapour-rich CO₂-bearing inclusions [Th(L-V)≈500±100° C; X _{CO 2}=0.22–0.44; X _NaCl≤0.01], corresponding to densities of 0.27± 0.05 gcm⁻³. Petrographical observations, phase compositions and densities show that the two fluids were simultaneously trapped in the solvus of the H₂O-CO₂-salts system at 500–600° C and 700±200 bars. The low density fluid was generated during brine infiltration at the solvus via the wollastonite producing reaction. Identical fluid types were also trapped as inclusion populations in wollastonite hosts 3 cm adjacent to quartz crystals. At room temperature, both fluid types additionally contain one quartz and one calcite crystal, generated by the back-reaction Wo+CO₂=Cc+Qz of the host with the CO₂-proportion of the fluid during retrogression. All of the CO₂ was removed from the fluid. On heating in the microstage, the reaction progress of the prograde reaction was estimated via volume loss of the calcites. In vapour-rich fluids, 50% progress is reached at 490–530° C; 80% at 520–560° C; and 100% at 540–590° C, the latter representing the trapping temperatures of the original fluid at the two fluid solvus. The progress is volume controlled. With knowledge of compositions and densities from unmodified inclusions in quartz and using the equation of state of Duan et al. (1995) for H₂O-CO₂-NaCl, along with f _{CO 2}-values extracted from it, the reaction progress curve was recalculated in the P-T-X-space. The calculated progress curve passes through the two fluid solvus up to 380° C/210 bars, continues in the one fluid field and meets the solvus again at trapping conditions. The P-T slope is steep, most of the reaction occurs above 450° C and there is high correspondence between calculated and measured reaction progress. We emphasize that with the exception of quartz, back-reactions between inclusion fluids and mineral hosts is a common process. For almost any prograde metamorphic mineral that was formed by a devolatilization reaction and that trapped the equilibrium fluid or any peak metamorphic fluid as an inclusion, a fluid-host back-reaction exists which must occur somewhere along the retrograde path. Such retrograde reactions may cause drastic changes in density and composition of the fluid. In most cases, however, evidence of the evolving mineral assemblages is not given for they might form submicroscopical layers at the inclusion walls. Received: 15 March 1995 / Accepted: 1 June 1995     

The stability of UO2OH+ and UO2[HPO4]22− complexes at 25°C (reply to a comment by V. S. Tripathi)

Tripathi argues that we could not determine the stability constant (β₂) of UO₂[HPO₄]₂^2? in our solutions because they were supersaturated with respect to solid uranyl triphosphate. This is irrelevant because no phosphate solids were present in solution during our experiments. He further argues that the conditions of our experiments were not ideal for us to determine the potentially most accurate value of β₂. This is also irrelevant. The point is that our published value of log β₂ = 18.3 ± 0.2 is given with an uncertainty which clearly acknowledges the inaccuracy of its determination based on our experimental and computational approach.     

The pressure and temperature stability limits of lawsonite: implications for H2O recycling in subduction zones

The stability relations of lawsonite, CaAl₂Si₂O₇(OH)₂H₂O, have been investigated at pressures of 6 to 14 GPa and temperatures of 740 to 1150°C in a multi-anvil apparatus. Experiments used the bulk composition lawsonite+H₂O to determine the maximum stability of lawsonite. Lawsonite is stable on its own bulk composition to a pressure of 13.5 GPa at 800°C, and between 6.5 and 12 GPa at 1000°C. Its composition does not change with pressure or temperature. All lawsonite reactions have grossular, vapour and two other phases in the system Al₂O₃-SiO₂-H₂O (ASH) on their high-temperature side. A Schreinemakers analysis of the ASH phases was used to relate the reactions to each other. At the lowest pressures studied lawsonite breaks down to grossular+kyanite+coesite+vapour in a reaction passing through 980°C at 6 GPa and 1070°C at 9 GPa. Above 9 GPa the reactions coesite=stishovite and kyanite+vapour=topaz-OH are crossed. The maximum thermal stability of lawsonite is at 1080°C, at 9.4 GPa. At higher pressures the lawsonite breakdown reactions have negative slopes. The reaction lawsonite=grossular+topaz-OH+stishovite+vapour passes through 1070°C at 10 GPa and 1010°C at 12 GPa. At 14 GPa, 740–840°C, lawsonite is unstable relative to the assemblage grossular+diaspore+vapour+a hydrous phase with an Al:Si ratio of 1:1. Oxide totals in electron microprobe analyses suggest that the composition of this phase is AlSiO₃(OH). Two experiments on the bulk composition lawsonite+pyrope [Mg₃Al₂Si₃O₁₂] show that at 10 GPa the reaction lawsonite=Gr-Py_ss+topaz-OH+stishovite+vapour is displaced down temperature from the end-member reaction by 200°C for a garnet composition of Gr₂₀Py₈₀. Calculations suggest similar temperature displacements for reaction between lawsonite and Gr-Py-Alm garnets of compositions likely to occur in high-pressure eclogites. Temperatures in subduction zones remain relatively low to considerable depth, and therefore slab P-T paths can be within the stability field of lawsonite from the conditions of its crystallisation in blueschists and eclogites, up to pressures of at least 10 GPa. Lawsonite contains 11.5 wt% H₂O, which when released may trigger partial melting of the slab or mantle, or be incorporated in hydrous phases such as the aluminosilicates synthesised here. These phases may then transport H₂O to an even greater depth in the mantle.