Accurate local upscaling with variable compact multipoint transmissibility calculations

We propose a new single-phase local upscaling method that uses spatially varying multipoint transmissibility calculations. The method is demonstrated on two-dimensional Cartesian and adaptive Cartesian grids. For each cell face in the coarse upscaled grid, we create a local fine grid region surrounding the face on which we solve two generic local flow problems. The multipoint stencils used to calculate the fluxes across coarse grid cell faces involve the six neighboring pressure values. They are required to honor the two generic flow problems. The remaining degrees of freedom are used to maximize compactness and to ensure that the flux approximation is as close as possible to being two-point. The resulting multipoint flux approximations are spatially varying (a subset of the six neighbors is adaptively chosen) and reduce to two-point expressions in cases without full-tensor anisotropy. Numerical tests show that the method significantly improves upscaling accuracy as compared to commonly used local methods and also compares favorably with a local–global upscaling method.     

Integration of local–global upscaling and grid adaptivity for simulation of subsurface flow in heterogeneous formations

We propose a methodology, called multilevel local–global (MLLG) upscaling, for generating accurate upscaled models of permeabilities or transmissibilities for flow simulation on adapted grids in heterogeneous subsurface formations. The method generates an initial adapted grid based on the given fine-scale reservoir heterogeneity and potential flow paths. It then applies local–global (LG) upscaling for permeability or transmissibility [7], along with adaptivity, in an iterative manner. In each iteration of MLLG, the grid can be adapted where needed to reduce flow solver and upscaling errors. The adaptivity is controlled with a flow-based indicator. The iterative process is continued until consistency between the global solve on the adapted grid and the local solves is obtained. While each application of LG upscaling is also an iterative process, this inner iteration generally takes only one or two iterations to converge. Furthermore, the number of outer iterations is bounded above, and hence, the computational costs of this approach are low. We design a new flow-based weighting of transmissibility values in LG upscaling that significantly improves the accuracy of LG and MLLG over traditional local transmissibility calculations. For highly heterogeneous (e.g., channelized) systems, the integration of grid adaptivity and LG upscaling is shown to consistently provide more accurate coarse-scale models for global flow, relative to reference fine-scale results, than do existing upscaling techniques applied to uniform grids of similar densities. Another attractive property of the integration of upscaling and adaptivity is that process dependency is strongly reduced, that is, the approach computes accurate global flow results also for flows driven by boundary conditions different from the generic boundary conditions used to compute the upscaled parameters. The method is demonstrated on Cartesian cell-based anisotropic refinement (CCAR) grids, but it can be applied to other adaptation strategies for structured grids and extended to unstructured grids.     

Nonlinear two-point flux approximation for modeling full-tensor effects in subsurface flow simulations

Subsurface flow models can exhibit strong full-tensor anisotropy due to either permeability or grid nonorthogonality effects. Upscaling procedures, for example, generate full-tensor effects on the coarse scale even for cases in which the underlying fine-scale permeability is isotropic. A multipoint flux approximation (MPFA) is often needed to accurately simulate flow for such systems. In this paper, we present and apply a different approach, nonlinear two-point flux approximation (NTPFA), for modeling systems with full-tensor effects. In NTPFA, transmissibility (which provides interblock connections) is determined from reference global flux and pressure fields for a specific flow problem. These fields can be generated using either fully resolved or approximate global simulations. The use of fully resolved simulations leads to an NTPFA method that corresponds to global upscaling procedures, while the use of approximate simulations gives a method corresponding to recently developed local–global techniques. For both approaches, NTPFA algorithms applicable to both single-scale full-tensor permeability systems and two-scale systems are described. A unified framework is introduced, which enables single-scale and two-scale problems to be viewed in a consistent manner. Extensive numerical results demonstrate that the global and local–global NTPFA techniques provide accurate flow predictions over wide parameter ranges for both single-scale and two-scale systems, though the global procedure is more accurate overall. The applicability of NTPFA to the simulation of two-phase flow in upscaled models is also demonstrated.     

Upscaling Hydraulic Conductivities in Cross-Bedded Formations

Modern geostatistical techniques allow the generation of high-resolution heterogeneous models of hydraulic conductivity containing millions to billions of cells. Selective upscaling is a numerical approach for the change of scale of fine-scale hydraulic conductivity models into coarser scale models that are suitable for numerical simulations of groundwater flow and mass transport. Selective upscaling uses an elastic gridding technique to selectively determine the geometry of the coarse grid by an iterative procedure. The geometry of the coarse grid is built so that the variances of flow velocities within the coarse blocks are minimum. Selective upscaling is able to handle complex geological formations and flow patterns, and provides full hydraulic conductivity tensor for each block. Selective upscaling is applied to a cross-bedded formation in which the fine-scale hydraulic conductivities are full tensors with principal directions not parallel to the statistical anisotropy of their spatial distribution. Mass transport results from three coarse-scale models constructed by different upscaling techniques are compared to the fine-scale results for different flow conditions. Selective upscaling provides coarse grids in which mass transport simulation is in good agreement with the fine-scale simulations, and consistently superior to simulations on traditional regular (equal-sized) grids or elastic grids built without accounting for flow velocities.     

Ensemble level upscaling for compositional flow simulation

Uncertainty quantification is typically accomplished by simulating multiple geological realizations, which can be very expensive computationally if the flow process is complicated and the models are highly resolved. Upscaling procedures can be applied to reduce computational demands, though it is essential that the resulting coarse-model predictions correspond to reference fine-scale solutions. In this work, we develop an ensemble level upscaling (EnLU) procedure for compositional systems, which enables the efficient generation of multiple coarse models for use in uncertainty quantification. We apply a newly developed global compositional upscaling method to provide coarse-scale parameters and functions for selected realizations. This global upscaling entails transmissibility and relative permeability upscaling, along with the computation of a-factors to capture component fluxes. Additional features include near-well upscaling for all coarse parameters and functions, and iteration on the a-factors, which is shown to improve accuracy. In the EnLU framework, this global upscaling is applied for only a few selected realizations. For 90 % or more of the realizations, upscaled functions are assigned statistically based on quickly computed flow and permeability attributes. A sequential Gaussian co-simulation procedure is incorporated to provide coarse models that honor the spatial correlation structure of the upscaled properties. The resulting EnLU procedure is applied for multiple realizations of two-dimensional models, for both Gaussian and channelized permeability fields. Results demonstrate that EnLU provides P10, P50, and P90 results for phase and component production rates that are in close agreement with reference fine-scale results. Less accuracy is observed in realization-by-realization comparisons, though the models are still much more accurate than those generated using standard coarsening procedures.     

Grid adaptation for the Dirichlet–Neumann representation method and the multiscale mixed finite-element method

A Dirichlet–Neumann representation method was recently proposed for upscaling and simulating flow in reservoirs. The DNR method expresses coarse fluxes as linear functions of multiple pressure values along the boundary and at the center of each coarse block. The number of flux and pressure values at the boundary can be adjusted to improve the accuracy of simulation results and, in particular, to resolve important fine-scale details. Improvement over existing approaches is substantial especially for reservoirs that contain high-permeability streaks or channels. As an alternative, the multiscale mixed finite-element (MsMFE) method was designed to obtain fine-scale fluxes at the cost of solving a coarsened problem, but can also be used as upscaling methods that are flexible with respect to geometry and topology of the coarsened grid. Both methods can be expressed in mixed-hybrid form, with local stiffness matrices obtained as “inner products” of numerically computed basis functions with fine-scale sub-resolution. These basis functions are determined by solving local flow problems with piecewise linear Dirichlet boundary conditions for the DNR method and piecewise constant Neumann conditions for MsMFE. Adding discrete pressure points in the DNR method corresponds to subdividing faces in the coarse grid and hence increasing the number of basis functions in the MsMFE method. The methods show similar accuracy for 2D Cartesian cases, but the MsMFE method is more straightforward to formulate in 3D and implement for general grids.     

Near-well upscaling for three-phase flows

Large-scale flow models constructed using standard coarsening procedures may not accurately resolve detailed near-well effects. Such effects are often important to capture, however, as the interaction of the well with the formation can have a dominant impact on process performance. In this work, a near-well upscaling procedure, which provides three-phase well-block properties, is developed and tested. The overall approach represents an extension of a recently developed oil–gas upscaling procedure and entails the use of local well computations (over a region referred to as the local well model (LWM)) along with a gradient-based optimization procedure to minimize the mismatch between fine and coarse-scale well rates, for oil, gas, and water, over the LWM. The gradients required for the minimization are computed efficiently through solution of adjoint equations. The LWM boundary conditions are determined using an iterative local-global procedure. With this approach, pressures and saturations computed during a global coarse-scale simulation are interpolated onto LWM boundaries and then used as boundary conditions for the fine-scale LWM computations. In addition to extending the overall approach to the three-phase case, this work also introduces new treatments that provide improved accuracy in cases with significant flux from the gas cap into the well block. The near-well multiphase upscaling method is applied to heterogeneous reservoir models, with production from vertical and horizontal wells. Simulation results illustrate that the method is able to accurately capture key near-well effects and to provide predictions for component production rates that are in close agreement with reference fine-scale results. The level of accuracy of the procedure is shown to be significantly higher than that of a standard approach which uses only upscaled single-phase flow parameters.     

Nodal and Mixed Finite Elements for the Numerical Homogenization of 3D Permeability

The aim of upscaling is to determine equivalent homogeneous parameters at a coarse-scale from a spatially oscillating fine-scale parameter distribution. To be able to use a limited number of relatively large grid-blocks in numerical oil reservoir simulators or groundwater models, upscaling of the permeability is frequently applied. The spatial fine-scale permeability distribution is generally obtained from geological and geostatistical models. After upscaling, the coarse-scale permeabilities are incorporated in the relatively large grid-blocks of the numerical model. If the porous rock may be approximated as a periodic medium, upscaling can be performed by the method of homogenization. In this paper the homogenization is performed numerically, which gives rise to an approximation error. The complementarity between two different numerical methods – the conformal-nodal finite element method and the mixed-hybrid finite element method – has been used to quantify this error. These two methods yield respectively upper and lower bounds for the eigenvalues of the coarse-scale permeability tensor. Results of 3D numerical experiments are shown, both for the far field and around wells.     

Statistical assignment of upscaled flow functions for an ensemble of geological models

Upscaled flow functions are often needed to account for the effects of fine-scale permeability heterogeneity in coarse-scale simulation models. We present procedures in which the required coarse-scale flow functions are statistically assigned to an ensemble of upscaled geological models. This can be viewed as an extension and further development of a recently developed ensemble level upscaling (EnLU) approach. The method aims to efficiently generate coarse-scale flow models capable of reproducing the ensemble statistics (e.g., cumulative distribution function) of fine-scale flow predictions for multiple reservoir models. The most expensive part of standard coarsening procedures is typically the generation of upscaled two-phase flow functions (e.g., relative permeabilities). EnLU provides a means for efficiently generating these upscaled functions using stochastic simulation. This involves the use of coarse-block attributes that are both fast to compute and correlate closely with the upscaled two-phase functions. In this paper, improved attributes for use in EnLU, namely the coefficient of variation of the fine-scale single-phase velocity field (computed during computation of upscaled absolute permeability) and the integral range of the fine-scale permeability variogram, are identified. Geostatistical simulation methods, which account for spatial correlations of the statistically generated upscaled functions, are also applied. The overall methodology thus enables the efficient generation of coarse-scale flow models. The procedure is tested on 3D well-driven flow problems with different permeability distributions and variable fluid mobility ratios. EnLU is shown to capture the ensemble statistics of fine-scale flow results (water and oil flow rates as a function of time) with similar accuracy to full flow-based upscaling methods but with computational speedups of more than an order of magnitude.     

Mixed multiscale finite element methods using approximate global information based on partial upscaling

The use of limited global information in multiscale simulations is needed when there is no scale separation. Previous approaches entail fine-scale simulations in the computation of the global information. The computation of the global information is expensive. In this paper, we propose the use of approximate global information based on partial upscaling. A requirement for partial homogenization is to capture long-range (non-local) effects present in the fine-scale solution, while homogenizing some of the smallest scales. The local information at these smallest scales is captured in the computation of basis functions. Thus, the proposed approach allows us to avoid the computations at the scales that can be homogenized. This results in coarser problems for the computation of global fields. We analyze the convergence of the proposed method. Mathematical formalism is introduced, which allows estimating the errors due to small scales that are homogenized. The proposed method is applied to simulate two-phase flows in heterogeneous porous media. Numerical results are presented for various permeability fields, including those generated using two-point correlation functions and channelized permeability fields from the SPE Comparative Project (Christie and Blunt, SPE Reserv Evalu Eng 4:308–317, 2001). We consider simple cases where one can identify the scales that can be homogenized. For more general cases, we suggest the use of upscaling on the coarse grid with the size smaller than the target coarse grid where multiscale basis functions are constructed. This intermediate coarse grid renders a partially upscaled solution that contains essential non-local information. Numerical examples demonstrate that the use of approximate global information provides better accuracy than purely local multiscale methods.     

Mortar Upscaling for Multiphase Flow in Porous Media

In mortar space upscaling methods, a reservoir is decomposed into a series of subdomains (blocks) in which independently constructed numerical grids and possibly different physical models and discretization techniques can be employed in each block. Physically meaningful matching conditions are imposed on block interfaces in a numerically stable and accurate way using mortar finite element spaces. Coarse mortar grids and fine subdomain grids provide two-scale approximations. In the resulting effective solution flow is computed in subdomains on the fine scale while fluxes are matched on the coarse scale. In addition the flexibility to vary adaptively the number of interface degrees of freedom leads to more accurate multiscale approximations. This methodology has been implemented in the Center for Subsurface Modeling's multiphysics multiblock simulator IPARS (Integrated Parallel Accurate reservoir Simulator). Computational experiments demonstrate that this approach is scalable in parallel and it can be applied to non-matching grids across the interface, multinumerics and multiphysics models, and mortar adaptivity. Moreover unlike most upscaling approaches the underlying systems can be treated fully implicitly.     

Numerical Homogenization of Two-Phase Flow in Porous Media

Homogenization has proved its effectiveness as a method of upscaling for linear problems, as they occur in single-phase porous media flow for arbitrary heterogeneous rocks. Here we extend the classical homogenization approach to nonlinear problems by considering incompressible, immiscible two-phase porous media flow. The extensions have been based on the principle of preservation of form, stating that the mathematical form of the fine-scale equations should be preserved as much as possible on the coarse scale. This principle leads to the required extensions, while making the physics underlying homogenization transparent. The method is process-independent in a way that coarse-scale results obtained for a particular reservoir can be used in any simulation, irrespective of the scenario that is simulated. Homogenization is based on steady-state flow equations with periodic boundary conditions for the capillary pressure. The resulting equations are solved numerically by two complementary finite element methods. This makes it possible to assess a posteriori error bounds.     

Efficient multiphysics modelling with adaptive grid refinement using a MPFA method

A sequential solution procedure is used to simulate compositional two-phase flow in porous media. We employ a multiphysics concept that adapts the numerical complexity locally according to the underlying processes to increase efficiency. The framework is supplemented by a local refinement of the simulation grid. To calculate the fluxes on such grids, we employ a combination of the standard two-point flux approximation and a multipoint flux approximation where the grid is refined. This is then used to simulate a large-scale example related to underground CO₂ storage.     

A multi-resolution workflow to generate high-resolution models constrained to dynamic data

Distance-based stochastic techniques have recently emerged in the context of ensemble modeling, in particular for history matching, model selection and uncertainty quantification. Starting with an initial ensemble of realizations, a distance between any two models is defined. This distance is defined such that the objective of the study is incorporated into the geological modeling process, thereby potentially enhancing the efficacy of the overall workflow. If the intent is to create new models that are constrained to dynamic data (history matching), the calculation of the distance requires flow simulation for each model in the initial ensemble. This can be very time consuming, especially for high-resolution models. In this paper, we present a multi-resolution framework for ensemble modeling. A distance-based procedure is employed, with emphasis on the rapid construction of multiple models that have improved dynamic data conditioning. Our intent is to construct new high-resolution models constrained to dynamic data, while performing most of the flow simulations only on upscaled models. An error modeling procedure is introduced into the distance calculations to account for potential errors in the upscaling. Based on a few fine-scale flow simulations, the upscaling error is estimated for each model using a clustering technique. We demonstrate the efficiency of the method on two examples, one where the upscaling error is small, and another where the upscaling error is significant. Results show that the error modeling procedure can accurately capture the error in upscaling, and can thus reproduce the fine-scale flow behavior from coarse-scale simulations with sufficient accuracy (in terms of uncertainty predictions). As a consequence, an ensemble of high-resolution models, which are constrained to dynamic data, can be obtained, but with a minimum of flow simulations at the fine scale.     

Multiscale mixed/mimetic methods on corner-point grids

Multiscale simulation is a promising approach to facilitate direct simulation of large and complex grid models for highly heterogeneous petroleum reservoirs. Unlike traditional simulation, approaches based on upscaling/downscaling, multiscale methods seek to solve the full flow problem by incorporating subscale heterogeneities into local discrete approximation spaces. We consider a multiscale formulation based on a hierarchical grid approach, where basis functions with subgrid resolution are computed numerically to correctly and accurately account for subscale variations from an underlying (fine-scale) geomodel when solving the global flow equations on a coarse grid. By using multiscale basis functions to discretise the global flow equations on a (moderately sized) coarse grid, one can retain the efficiency of an upscaling method and, at the same time, produce detailed and conservative velocity fields on the underlying fine grid. For pressure equations, the multiscale mixed finite-element method (MsMFEM) has been shown to be a particularly versatile approach. In this paper, we extend the method to corner-point grids, which is the industry standard for modelling complex reservoir geology. To implement MsMFEM, one needs a discretisation method for solving local flow problems on the underlying fine grids. In principle, any stable and conservative method can be used. Here, we use a mimetic discretisation, which is a generalisation of mixed finite elements that gives a discrete inner product, allows for polyhedral elements, and can (easily) be extended to curved grid faces. The coarse grid can, in principle, be any partition of the subgrid, where each coarse block is a connected collection of subgrid cells. However, we argue that, when generating coarse grids, one should follow certain simple guidelines to achieve improved accuracy. We discuss partitioning in both index space and physical space and suggest simple processing techniques. The versatility and accuracy of the new multiscale mixed methodology is demonstrated on two corner-point models: a small Y-shaped sector model and a complex model of a layered sedimentary bed. A variety of coarse grids, both violating and obeying the above mentioned guidelines, are employed. The MsMFEM solutions are compared with a reference solution obtained by direct simulation on the subgrid.     

Machine-learning-based modeling of coarse-scale error,with application to uncertainty quantification

The use of upscaled models is attractive in many-query applications that require a large number of simulation runs, such as uncertainty quantification and optimization. Highly coarsened models often display error in output quantities of interest, e.g., phase production and injection rates, so the direct use of these results for quantitative evaluations and decision making may not be appropriate. In this work, we introduce a machine-learning-based post-processing framework for modeling the error in coarse-model results in the context of uncertainty quantification. Coarse-scale models are constructed using an accurate global single-phase transmissibility upscaling procedure. The framework entails the use of high-dimensional regression (random forest in this work) to model error based on a number of error indicators or features. Many of these features are derived from approximations of the subgrid effects neglected in the coarse-scale saturation equation. These features are identified through volume averaging, and they are generated by solving a fine-scale saturation equation with a constant-in-time velocity field. Our approach eliminates the need for the user to hand-design a small number of informative (relevant) features. The training step requires the simulation of some number of fine and coarse models (in this work we perform either 10 or 30 training simulations), followed by construction of a regression model for each well. Classification is also applied for production wells. The methodology then provides a correction at each time step, and for each well, in the phase production and injection rates. Results are presented for two- and three-dimensional oil–water systems. The corrected coarse-scale solutions show significantly better accuracy than the uncorrected solutions, both in terms of realization-by-realization predictions for oil and water production rates, and for statistical quantities important for uncertainty quantification, such as P10, P50, and P90 predictions.     

Successful application of multiscale methods in a real reservoir simulator environment

For the past 10 years or so, a number of so-called multiscale methods have been developed as an alternative approach to upscaling and to accelerate reservoir simulation. The key idea of all these methods is to construct a set of prolongation operators that map between unknowns associated with cells in a fine grid holding the petrophysical properties of the geological reservoir model and unknowns on a coarser grid used for dynamic simulation. The prolongation operators are computed numerically by solving localized flow problems, much in the same way as for flow-based upscaling methods, and can be used to construct a reduced coarse-scale system of flow equations that describe the macro-scale displacement driven by global forces. Unlike effective parameters, the multiscale basis functions have subscale resolution, which ensures that fine-scale heterogeneity is correctly accounted for in a systematic manner. Among all multiscale formulations discussed in the literature, the multiscale restriction-smoothed basis (MsRSB) method has proved to be particularly promising. This method has been implemented in a commercially available simulator and has three main advantages. First, the input grid and its coarse partition can have general polyhedral geometry and unstructured topology. Secondly, MsRSB is accurate and robust when used as an approximate solver and converges relatively fast when used as an iterative fine-scale solver. Finally, the method is formulated on top of a cell-centered, conservative, finite-volume method and is applicable to any flow model for which one can isolate a pressure equation. We discuss numerical challenges posed by contemporary geomodels and report a number of validation cases showing that the MsRSB method is an efficient, robust, and versatile method for simulating complex models of real reservoirs.     

Unstructured, Control-Volume Distributed, Full-Tensor Finite-Volume Schemes with Flow Based Grids

Locally conservative flux-continuous, full-tensor, discretization schemes are presented for general unstructured grids. The schemes are control-volume distributed, where flow variables and rock properties are assigned to the polygonal control-volumes derived from the primal grid. A relationship between these finite volume schemes and the mixed finite element method is established. An extension for unstructured grids is described that leads to a general symmetric positive definite discretization matrix for both quadrilateral and triangular grids. A novel flow based gridding approach for unstructured mesh generation is also proposed for heterogeneous reservoir domains. Results computed with the flux continuous schemes on unstructured flow-based grids demonstrate the advantages of the methods.     

A coarse-scale compositional model

In subsurface flow modeling, compositional simulation is often required to model complex recovery processes, such as gas/CO ₂ injection. However, compositional simulation on fine-scale geological models is still computationally expensive and even prohibitive. Most existing upscaling techniques focus on black-oil models. In this paper, we present a general framework to upscale two-phase multicomponent flow in compositional simulation. Unlike previous studies, our approach explicitly considers the upscaling of flow and thermodynamics. In the flow part, we introduce a new set of upscaled flow functions that account for the effects of compressibility. This is often ignored in the upscaling of black-oil models. In the upscaling of thermodynamics, we show that the oil and gas phases within a coarse block are not at chemical equilibrium. This non-equilibrium behavior is modeled by upscaled thermodynamic functions, which measure the difference between component fugacities among the oil and gas phases. We apply the approach to various gas injection problems with different compositional features, permeability heterogeneity, and coarsening ratios. It is shown that the proposed method accurately reproduces the averaged fine-scale solutions, such as component overall compositions, gas saturation, and density solutions in the compositional flow.