Sunspot and Auroral Activity During Maunder Minimum

The extremely low sunspot activity during the period of the Maunder minimum 1645–1715 was confirmed by group sunspot numbers, a new sunspot index constructed by Hoyt and Schatten (1998a,b). Neither sunspots nor auroral data time behavior indicate the presence of 11-year solar cycles as stated by Eddy (1976). The evidence for solar cycles was found in the butterfly diagram, constructed from observations made at Observatoire de Paris. After Clivier, Boriakoff, and Bounar (1998) the solar cycles were reflected also in geomagnetic activity. Results are supported by the variation of cosmogenic isotopes ¹⁰Be and ¹⁴C. The majority of the observed 14 naked-eye sunspots occurred on days when telescopic observations were not available. A part of them appeared in the years when no spot was allegedly observed. Two-ribbon flares appear in plages with only very small or no sunspots. Some of these flares are geoactive. Most aurorae (90%), which were observed during the Maunder minimum, appeared in years when no spot was observed. Auroral events as a consequence of proton flares indicate that regions with enhanced magnetic field can occur on the Sun when these regions do not produce any sunspots.     

Long-Term Modulation of Galactic Cosmic Rays in the Heliosphere by Curvature of the Interplanetary Magnetic Field

Long-term changes of the GCR intensity in the heliosphere were analysed making use of records of cosmogenic isotopes abundances (¹⁰Be and ¹⁴C) in natural archives and neutron monitor data. These data contain information about short-term, 11-year, 22-year, centennial and two-centennial cycles of solar activity. A mechanism to explain the long-term modulation of GCR due to changes in the curvature of the interplanetary magnetic field, resulting from changes in solar activity, is suggested.     

Nitrate in Polar Ice: A New Tracer of Solar Variability

Knowledge of the long-term variability of solar activity is of both astrophysical and geoscientific interest. Reconstructions of solar activity over multiple millennia are traditionally based on cosmogenic isotopes ¹⁴C or ¹⁰Be measured in natural terrestrial archives, but the two isotopes exhibit significant differences on millennial time scales, so that our knowledge of solar activity at this time scale remains somewhat uncertain. Here we present a new potential proxy of solar activity on the centennial-millennial time scale, based on a chemical tracer, viz. nitrate content in an ice core drilled at Talos Dome (Antarctica). We argue that this location is optimal for preserving the solar signal in the nitrate content during the Holocene. By using the firn core from the same location we show that the 11-year and Gleissberg cycles are present with the variability of 10??C?25?% in nitrate content in the pre-industrial epoch. This is consistent with the results of independent efforts of modeling HNO₃ and NO _y in Antarctic near surface air. However, meteorological noise on the interannual scale makes it impossible to resolve individual solar cycles. Based on different processes of formation and transport compared to cosmogenic isotopes, it provides new, independent insight into long-term solar activity and helps resolve the uncertainties related to cosmogenic isotopes as diagnostics of solar activity.     

Cosmogenic Isotope Variability During the Maunder Minimum: Normal 11-year Cycles Are Expected

The amplitude of the 11-year cycle measured in the cosmogenic isotope ¹⁰Be during the Maunder Minimum is comparable to that during the recent epoch of high solar activity. Because of the virtual absence of the cyclic variability of sunspot activity during the Maunder Minimum this seemingly contradicts an intuitive expectation that lower activity would result in smaller solar-cycle variations in cosmogenic radio-isotope data, or in none, leading to confusing and misleading conclusions. It is shown here that large 11-year solar cycles in cosmogenic data observed during periods of suppressed sunspot activity do not necessarily imply strong heliospheric fields. Normal-amplitude cycles in the cosmogenic radio-isotopes observed during the Maunder Minimum are consistent with theoretical expectations because of the nonlinear relation between solar activity and isotope production. Thus, cosmogenic-isotope data provide a good tool to study solar-cycle variability even during grand minima of solar activity.     

Fluence Ordering of Solar Energetic Proton Events Using Cosmogenic Radionuclide Data

While data on the cosmogenic isotopes ¹⁴C and ¹⁰Be made it possible to evaluate extreme solar proton events (SPEs) in the past, their relation to standard parameters quantifying the SPE strengths, viz. the integrated fluence of protons with energy above 30 MeV, F ₃₀, is ambiguous and strongly depends on the assumed shape of the energy spectrum. Here we propose a new index, the integral fluence of an SPE above 200 MeV, F ₂₀₀, which is related to the production of the cosmogenic isotopes ¹⁴C and ¹⁰Be in the Earth atmosphere, independently of the assumptions on the energy spectrum of the event. The F ₂₀₀ fluence is reconstructed from past cosmogenic isotope data, which provides an assessment of the occurrence probability density function for extreme SPEs. In particular, we evaluate that extreme SPEs with F ₂₀₀>10¹⁰ cm^?2 occur no more frequently than once per 10?–?15 kyr.     

“Isotopic footprints” of gamma-ray and proton events and anomalous signal in radiocarbon in 775 AD

The production of the cosmogenic radionuclides ¹⁴C, ¹⁰Be, and ³⁶Cl in the Earth’s atmosphere under the action of powerful impulsive proton and gamma-ray events (superpowerful solar flares and Galactic gamma-ray bursts) is considered. The possible “isotopic footprint” in natural archives (the concentrations of these isotopes in dated polar ice cores and annual tree rings) has been calculated by taking into account geophysical processes. The results obtained have been applied to analyzing the anomalous increase in the concentration of radiocarbon measured in tree rings dated 774–775 AD. Arguments for the fact that the most likely cause of this increase is the high-energy emission from a Galactic gamma-ray burst are adduced.     

Statistical Properties of Extreme Solar Activity Intervals

A study of long-term solar variability reflected in indirect indices of past solar activity leads to stimulating results. We compare the statistics of intervals of very low and very high solar activity derived from two cosmogenic radionuclide records and look for consistency in their timing and physical interpretation. According to the applied criteria, the numbers of minima and of maxima are 61 and 68, respectively, from the ¹⁰Be record, and 42 and 46 from the ¹⁴C record. The difference between the enhanced and depressed states of solar activity becomes apparent in the difference in their statistical distributions. We find no correlation between the level or type (minimum or maximum) of an extremum and the level or type of the predecessor. The hypothesis of solar activity as a periodic process on the millennial time scale is not supported by the existing proxies. A new homogeneous series of ¹⁰Be measurements in polar ice covering the Holocene would be of great value for eliminating the existing discrepancy in the available solar activity reconstructions.     

An Active Sun Throughout the Maunder Minimum

Measurements of ¹⁰Be concentration in the Dye 3 ice core show that magnetic cycles persisted throughout the Maunder Minimum, although the Sun's overall activity was drastically reduced and sunspots virtually disappeared. Thus the dates of maxima and minima can now be reliably estimated. Similar behaviour is shown by a nonlinear dynamo model, which predicts that, after a grand minimum, the Sun's toroidal field may switch from being antisymmetric to being symmetric about the equator. The presence of cyclic activity during the Maunder Minimum limits estimates of the solar contribution to climatic change.     

Solar Activity in the Past: From Different Proxies to Combined Reconstruction

Using proxy series that includes ancient observations of sunspots and auroras, concentrations of cosmogenic isotopes ¹⁴C and ¹⁰Be, we reconstruct sunspot activity level since 850 AD to the present. As a main reference index of solar activity we use the Wolf sunspot numbers, which, as we demonstrate, reflect true levels of the activity in the 18th and 19th centuries better than the Group sunspot numbers. We construct a set of linear and nonlinear inductive models, which are in a good agreement with each other and reproduce the known global solar activity extrema. According to our results, amplitudes of the global maxima are in intermediate positions in respect to estimations of other authors. It follows from our reconstructions that the global maximum of the 20th century is not much higher, if at all, than others.     

Long-Term Solar Cycle Evolution: Review of Recent Developments

The sunspot number series forms the longest directly observed index of solar activity and allows one to trace its variations on the time scale of about 400 years since 1610. This time interval covers a wide range from seemingly vanishing sunspots during the Maunder minimum in 1645–1700 to the very high activity during the last 50 years. Although the sunspot number series has been studied for more than a century, new interesting features have been found even recently. This paper gives a review of the recent achievements and findings in long-term evolution of solar activity cycles such as determinism and chaos in sunspot cyclicity, cycles during the Maunder minimum, a general behaviour of sunspot activity during a great minimum, the phase catastrophe and the lost cycle in the beginning of the Dalton minimum in 1790s and persistent 22-year cyclicity in sunspot activity. These findings shed new light on the underlying physical processes responsible for sunspot activity and allow a better understanding of such empirical rules as the Gnevyshev–Ohl rule and the Waldmeier relations.     

Redefining the limit dates for the Maunder Minimum

The Maunder Minimum corresponds to a prolonged minimum of solar activity a phenomenon that is of particular interest to many branches of natural and social sciences commonly considered to extend from 1645 until 1715. However, our knowledge of past solar activity has improved significantly in recent years and, thus, more precise dates for the onset and termination of this particularly episode of our Sun can be established. Based on the simultaneous analysis of distinct proxies we propose a redefinition of the Maunder Minimum period with the core “Deep Maunder Minimum” spanning from 1645 to 1700 (that corresponds to the Grand Minimum state) and a wider “Extended Maunder Minimum” for the longer period 1618–1723 that includes the transition periods.     

The L3–6 chondritic regolith breccia Northwest Africa (NWA) 869: (II) Noble gases and cosmogenic radionuclides

Abstract– We measured cosmogenic radionuclides and noble gases in the L3–6 chondrite breccia Northwest Africa (NWA) 869, one of the largest meteorite finds from the Sahara. Concentrations of ¹⁰Be, ²⁶Al, and ³⁶Cl in stone and metal fractions of six fragments of NWA 869 indicate a preatmospheric radius of 2.0–2.5 m. The ¹⁴C and ¹⁰Be concentrations in three fragments yield a terrestrial age of 4.4 ± 0.7 kyr, whereas two fragments show evidence for a recent change in shielding, most likely due to a recent impact on the NWA meteoroid, approximately 10⁵ yr ago, that excavated material up to approximately 80 cm deep and exposed previously shielded material to higher cosmic‐ray fluxes. This scenario is supported by the low cosmogenic ³He/²¹Ne ratios in these two samples, indicating recent loss of cosmogenic ³He. Most NWA samples, except for clasts of petrologic type 4–6, contain significant amounts of solar Ne and Ar, but are virtually free of solar helium, judging from the trapped ⁴He/²⁰Ne ratio of approximately 7. Trapped planetary‐type Kr and Xe are most clearly present in the bulk and matrix samples, where abundances of ¹²⁹Xe from decay of now extinct ¹²⁹I are highest. Cosmogenic ²¹Ne varies between 0.55 and 1.92 × 10^?8 cm³ STP g^?1, with no apparent relationship between cosmogenic and solar Ne contents. Low cosmogenic (²²Ne/²¹Ne)_c ratios in solar gas free specimens are consistent with irradiation in a large body. Combined ¹⁰Be and ²¹Ne concentrations indicate that NWA 869 had a 4π cosmic‐ray exposure (CRE) age of 5 ± 1 Myr, whereas elevated ²¹Ne concentrations in several clasts and bulk samples indicate a previous CRE of 10–30 Myr on the parent body, most probably as individual components in a regolith. Unlike many other large chondrites, NWA 869 does not show clear evidence of CRE as a large boulder near the surface of its parent body. Radiogenic ⁴He concentrations in most NWA 869 samples indicate a major outgassing event approximately 2.8 Gyr ago that may have also resulted in loss of solar helium.     

Exposure History of H5 Chondrite Gujargaon

Abstract— Cosmic ray produced tracks, He and Ne isotopes and radionuclides have been studied in the recently fallen H5 chondrite Gujargaon. The results indicate an exposure age of about 7 Ma. The high track production rates of 0.25 to 0.69 × 10⁶ cm^?2 Ma^?1 suggest that the Gujargaon meteoroid had a small size (Re = 9–10 cm) in space and suffered 1–3 cm ablation in the atmosphere. The conclusion about the meteoroid size is supported by the low activity of neutron capture isotope ⁶⁰Co and high spallogenic ²²Ne/²¹Ne ratio of about 1.25. The data on long lived isotopes ¹⁰Be, ⁵³Mn and ²⁶Al are used to derive production rates of these isotopes in a rock having a radius of 9 cm and the activity levels of the short lived isotopes ²²Na and ⁵⁴Mn are used to estimate the effect of modulation of galactic cosmic rays at the time of solar maximum of 1982.     

Fall,classification and cosmogenic records of the Sabrum (LL6) chondrite

Abstract— The petrographic and chemical characteristics of a fresh Indian meteorite fall at Sabrum are described. Its mean mineral composition is defined by olivine (Fa_31.4), orthopyroxene (Fs_25.1,Wo_2.0), clinopyroxene (Wo₄₅En_45.6Fs_9.4) and plagioclase (An_10.6Ab_83.6Or_5.8). The meteorite shows moderate shock features, which indicate that it belongs to the S4 category. Based on mineralogical and chemical criteria the meteorite is classified as an LL6 brecciated veined chondrite. Several cosmogenic radioisotopes (⁴⁶Sc, ⁷Be, ⁵⁴Mn, ²²Na and ²⁶Al), noble gas (He, Ne, Ar, Kr and Xe), nitrogen isotopes, and particle tracks density have been measured. Concentrations of cosmogenic ²¹Ne and ³⁸Ar indicate that its cosmic‐ray exposure age is 24.8 Ma. Small amounts of trapped Kr and Xe, consistent with petrologic class 5/6, are present. The track density in olivines is found to be (1.3 ± 0.3) × 10⁶/cm². Activities of most of the short‐lived isotopes are lower than those expected from solar cycle variation. ²²Na/²⁶Al (1.12 ± 0.02) is found to be significantly anomalous, being ?25% lower than expected from the Climax neutron monitor data. These results indicate that the cosmic‐ray flux during the terminal segment of the meteoroid orbit was low. The activities of ²⁶Al and ⁶⁰Co and the track density indicate small meteoroid size with a radius ?15 cm.     

The irradiation history of the Ghubara (L5) regolith breccia

Abstract— We measured cosmic‐ray products—noble gases, radionuclides, thermoluminescence, and nuclear tracks—and trace element contents and mineralogy of samples of three orthogonal and mutually intersecting cores (41–46 cm long) of a 101.6 kg Ghubara individual (1958,805) at The Natural History Museum, London. The xenoliths, like the host, have high concentrations of trapped solar gases and are heavily shocked. While contents of noble gases and degree of shock‐loading in this individual and three others differ somewhat, the data indicate that Ghubara is a two‐generation regolith breccia. Contents of cosmogenic ²⁶Al and ¹⁰Be and low track densities indicate that the Ghubara individuals were located more than 15 cm below the surface of an 85 cm meteoroid. Because of its large size, Ghubara's cosmic‐ray exposure age is poorly defined to be 15–20 Ma from cosmogenic nuclides. Ghubara's terrestrial age, based on ¹⁴C data, is 2–3 ka. Not only is Ghubara the first known case of a two‐generation regolith breccia on the macroscale, it also has a complicated thermal and irradiation history.     

Cosmogenic nuclides in core samples of the Chico L6 chondrite: Evidence for irradiation under high shielding

Abstract— Core samples were obtained from various locations of the ～ 105-kg Chico, NM, L6 chondrite in order to study the effects of large shielding on the production rates of cosmic-ray-produced nuclides. Relations between measured abundances of cosmogenic nuclides (¹⁰Be, ²⁶Al, and stable isotopes of He, Ne, and Ar) and the cosmogenic ²²Ne/²¹Ne ratio were determined and compared with recent model predictions of production rates. The measured ²²Ne/²¹Ne ratios (1.06-1.08) and significant variations observed in concentrations of cosmogenic ²¹Ne and ³He suggest an ～40-cm shielding gradient across Chico and irradiation within a large object (> 100-cm radius). Noble gas data indicate that Chico experienced greater shielding than chondrites Knyahinya or Keyes and similar to Jilin. Values of ¹⁰Be (average = 20.7 dpm/kg) and ²⁶Al (average = 71.1 dpm/kg) are nearly constant, however, and show no correlation with either ²²Ne/²¹Ne or ²¹Ne. Activities of ¹⁰Be and ²⁶Al suggest irradiation in a smaller object (～40–80 cm radius). The ²⁶Al activity and the ²⁶Al/¹⁰Be ratio (average value = 3.42) are both significantly larger than values for most other chondrites. These results could indicate a two-stage irradiation with t₁ ～ 104 Ma and t₂ ～ 4 Ma and a second-stage body the size of Knyahinya. The single stage, ¹⁰Be/²¹Ne exposure age for Chico is 65 Ma. The ²²Ne/²¹Ne ratio apparently becomes insensitive to shielding for objects the size of Chico. No substantial evidence exists for chondrites with ²²Ne/²¹Ne ratios significantly less than ～ 1.055.     

Occurrence Probability of Large Solar Energetic Particle Events: Assessment from Data on Cosmogenic Radionuclides in Lunar Rocks

We revisited assessments of the occurrence probability distribution of large events in solar energetic particles (SEP), based on measurements of cosmogenic radionuclides in lunar rocks. We present a combined cumulative occurrence probability distribution of SEP events based on three timescales: directly measured SEP fluences for the past 60 years; estimates based on the terrestrial cosmogenic radionuclides ¹⁰Be and ¹⁴C for the multi-millennial (Holocene) timescale; and cosmogenic radionuclides measured in lunar rocks on a timescale of up to 1 Myr. These three timescales yield a consistent distribution. The data suggest a strong roll-over of the occurrence probability, so that SEP events with a proton fluence with energy >?30 MeV greater than 10¹¹ (protons cm^?2?yr^?1) are not expected on a Myr timescale.     

Did the Sun’s Prairie Ever Stop Burning?

The presence of the red flash at total solar eclipses requires the existence of an extended chromosphere and therefore of a photospheric magnetic network that gives rise to spicules. We draw attention to the earliest historical reports of a red flash at the 1706 and 1715 eclipses, which therefore imply a substantial, widespread photospheric field during at least the last decade of the Maunder Minimum. Our finding is consistent with reports of a persistent photospheric field throughout the Maunder Minimum from analyses of ¹⁰Be radioisotope evidence. We note, however, that the last decade may not be representative of conditions throughout the roughly 1645 – 1715 extent of that prolonged activity minimum.     

Energetic proton irradiation history of the howardite parent body regolith and implications for ancient solar activity

Abstract— Previous studies have shown that the Kapoeta howardite, as well as several other meteorites, contains excess concentrations of cosmogenic Ne in the darkened, solar-irradiated phase compared to the light, non-irradiated phase. The two explanations offered for the nuclear production of these Ne excesses in the parent body regolith are either from galactic cosmic-ray proton (GCR) irradiation or from a greatly enhanced flux of energetic solar “cosmic-ray” protons (SCR), as compared to the recent solar flux. Combining new isotopic data we obtained on acid-etched, separated feldspar from Kapoeta light and dark phases with literature data, we show that the cosmogenic ²¹Ne/²²Ne ratio of light phase feldspar (0.80) is consistent with only GCR irradiation in space for ～3 Ma. However, the ²¹Ne/²²Ne ratio (0.68) derived for irradiation of dark phase feldspar in the Kapoeta regolith indicates that cosmogenic Ne was produced in roughly equal proportions from galactic and solar protons. Considering a simple model of an immature Kapoeta parent body regolith, the duration of this early galactic exposure was only ～3–6 Ma, which would be an upper limit to the solar exposure time of individual grains. Concentrations of cosmogenic ²¹Ne in pyroxene separates and of cosmogenic ¹²⁶Xe in both feldspar and pyroxene are consistent with this interpretation. The near-surface irradiation time of individual grains in the Kapoeta regolith probably varied considerably due to regolith mixing to an average GCR irradiation depth of ～10 cm. Because of the very different depth scales for production of solar ～Fe tracks, SCR Ne, and GCR Ne, the actual regolith exposure times for average grains probably differed correspondingly. However, both the SCR ²¹Ne and solar track ages appear to be longer because of enhanced production by early solar activity. The SCR/GCR production ratio of ²¹Ne inferred from the Kapoeta data is larger by a at least a factor of 10 and possibly as much as a factor of ～50 compared to recent solar particle fluxes. Thus, this study indicates that our early Sun was much more active and emitted a substantially higher flux of energetic (>10 MeV/nucleon) protons.