Joint two-dimensional observations of ground magnetic and ionospheric electric fields associated with auroral zone currents: Current systems associated with local auroral break-ups

On 15 February, 1977, ground magnetic, ionospheric electric and auroral signatures of a multiple onset substorm were observed simultaneously by the Scandinavian Magnetometer Array (SMA), the Scandinavian Twin Auroral Radar Experiment (STARE) and the Finnish all-sky camera chain. Between 21:00 and 21:30 U.T., i.e. around local magnetic midnight, three consecutive local auroral break-ups were observed over Scandinavia. Each of these break-ups was preceded by a clear fading of the aurora and magnetic fields (while the electric fields remained unaffected), and occurred slightly south of the Harang discontinuity in the region of north-westward-directed electric fields. They were associated with a sudden change in direction of the electric field from north-west to south-west and the appearance of a westward equivalent current in the localized active region (about 1200 × 300 km²). These observations matched the features to be expected during the generation of a Cowling channel by a strong increase of the ionospheric conductivities due to precipitating auroral electrons. Numerical model calculations, based on the observations during the initial brightening and peak development of the second, most conspicuous break-up, show that the field-aligned currents at the northern and southern border of the active region are indeed very weak. However, highly localized and intense upward field-aligned currents at the western edge of the active region and more widespread and less intense downward currents in the eastern half preserve current continuity of the westward Cowling current and complete the substorm current wedge.     

Role of field-aligned currents in generation of high-latitude magnetic disturbances

The distant effects of the field-aligned currents (FAC) observed by TRIAD are computed for conditions of low and moderate activity. The systems of total ionospheric currents (both Hall and Pedersen) generated by corresponding FAC are also examined and the contribution of the distant effects and the ionospheric currents into the total equivalent current system is estimated. The conclusions are as follows. In cases of low magnetic activity the magnetic effects produced by Pedersen currents are mainly cancelled by the FAC distant effect in accord with Fukushima's theorem. In cases of moderate activity when the zone of high ionospheric conductivity and the two-sheet FAC structure are present the FAC distant effect is too small to cancel the effect of Pedersen currents. For these conditions the system of total ionospheric currents shows the best correspondence with the experimental equivalent current system. Effects produced by the IMF azimuthal component are also analysed.     

Equivalent ionospheric current systems representing IMF sector effects on the polar geomagnetic field

Equivalent ionospheric current systems representing IMF sector effects on the geomagnetic field in high latitudes are examined for each of the twelve calendar months by spherical harmonic analyses of geomagnetic hourly data at 13 northern polar stations for seven years. The main feature of obtained equivalent current systems includes circular currents at about 80° invariant latitude mostly in the daytime in summer and reversed circular currents at about 70° invariant latitude mainly at night in winter. Field-aligned current distributions responsible for equivalent currents, as well as vector distributions of electric fields and ionospheric currents, are approximated numerically from current functions of equivalent current systems by taking assumed distributions of the ionospheric conductivity. Two sets of upward and downward field-aligned current pairs in the auroral region, and also a field-aligned current region near the pole show seasonal variations. Also, ionospheric electric-field propagation along geomagnetic field lines from the summer hemisphere to the winter hemisphere with auroral Hall-conductivity effects may provide an explanation for the winter reversal of sector effects.     

On current continuity at the Harang discontinuity

Although the Harang discontinuity has so far been identified in terms of various phenomena (such as ground magnetic fields, ionospheric currents, auroral features, and electric fields), the loci defined by those different phenomena do not always coincide. It is suggested that the Harang discontinuity may not be a line boundary across which the electric field changes its direction simply from poleward to equatorward, but that the field gradually rotates counterclockwise in a narrow region; thus the westward electric field dominates there. In such a case, no field-aligned current is necessarily required to flow from or into the discontinuity region. This view may be contrasted with the conventional view that an intense upward field-aligned current should flow from the Harang discontinuity. A model is presented in which the poleward ionospheric current (the Hall current resulting from the westward electric field) in the Harang discontinuity region connects the eastward electrojet and the westward electrojet.     

Field-aligned and ionospheric currents

Zmuda and Armstrong (1974) showed that the field-aligned currents consist of two pairs; one is located in the morning sector and the other in the evening sector. Our analysis of magnetic records from the TRIAD satellite suggests that in each pair the poleward field-aligned current is more intense than the equatorward current, a typical ratio being 2:1. This difference has a fundamental importance in understanding the coupling between the magnetosphere and the ionosphere. We demonstrate this importance by computing the ionospheric current distribution by solving the continuity equation $\text{▽ .}\text{I}\text{= j}{}_{\mathrm{\parallel }}$ using the “observed” distribution of j_∥ for several models of the ionosphere with a high conductive annular ring (simulating the auroral oval).It is shown that the actual field-aligned and ionospheric current system is neither a simple Birkeland type, Boström type nor Zmuda-Armstrong type, but is a complicated combination of them. The relative importance among them varies considerably, depending on the conductivity distribution, the location of the peak of the field-aligned currents, etc. Further, it is found that the north-south segment of ionospheric current which connects the pair of the field-aligned currents in the morning sector does not close in the same meridian and has a large westward deflection. Thus, it has an appreciable contribution to the westward electrojet. One of the model calculations shows that the entire north-south closure current contributes to the westward electrojet.     

A new method for generating instantaneous ionospheric conductivity models using ground-based magnetic data

We have developed a dynamical model of the ionospheric conductivity distribution using ground magnetic data. The model is based on the Spiro et al. (1982, J. geophys. Res. 87, 8215) average conductivity models, but adjusts their latitudinal distribution to the instantaneous distribution of field-aligned currents calculated from the equivalent current function. It can thus take into account the dependence of the conductivity distribution on fluctuations of solar wind parameters and magnetospheric disturbances. A comparison of electric fields calculated from the equivalent current function and the new conductivity model with those measured by the STARE radars, shows that the present conductivity model gives better results than obtained by using the same current function but earlier conductivity models.     

Reflection of Alfvén waves by non-uniform ionospheres

Magnetospheric Alfvén waves are reflected by the ionosphere. We investigate the effect of horizontally varying ionospheric conductivity on the process of Alfvén wave reflection. Four idealised ionospheric models are considered in detail. We find that the reflection process is strongly dependent on the orientation of the wave electric field vector with respect to the boundary between high and low conductivities, and under certain conditions subsidiary Alfvén waves are generated. The field-aligned currents in the subsidiary Alfvén waves serve to close divergent horizontal currents resulting from the non-uniform ionospheric conductivity. The implications for ground-based pulsation studies are discussed.     

Field-aligned currents and magnetic disturbances in the dayside polar region

Field-aligned currents in the day-time cusp-region are regarded as the superposition of various current sheets under the influence of different solar wind parameters. The principal feature of this pattern is a specific region 3 of field-aligned currents located poleward of region 1 and affected by both the azimuthal and northward components of the interplanetary magnetic field. It is shown that recent measurements carried out on the TRIAD satellite (Saflekos and Potemra, 1979) unambiguously point to the existence of region 3. The data on the transverse magnetic disturbances supplied by S3-2 satellite (Doyle et al., 1981) accord with our model on taking into account the relations between the IMF parameters and the field-aligned current intensity.     

Ionosphere-plasmasheet field-aligned currents and parallel electric fields

Two kinetic models for the auroral topside ionosphere are compared. The collisionless plasma distributed along an auroral magnetic field line behaves like a non-Ohmic conducting medium with highly non-linear characteristic curves relating the parallel current density to the potential difference between the cold ionosphere and the hot plasmasheet region. The (zero-electric current) potential difference, required to balance the current carried by the precipitating plasmasheet particles and the current transported by the outflowing ionospheric particles, depends on the ratio n_ps.e/n_th.e and T_ps.e/T_th.e of the plasmasheet and ionospheric electron densities and temperatures. When in the E-region the magnetic field lines are interconnected by a high conductivity plasma the resulting field-aligned currents driven by the magnetospheric potential distribution are limited by the integrated Pedersen conductivity of the ionospheric layers. These currents are not related to the parallel electric field intensity as they would be in Ohmic materials. The parallel electric field intensity is necessarily determined by the local quasi-neutrality of the plasma.     

Ionospheric currents obtained from the Chatanika radar and ground magnetic perturbations at the Auroral latitude

The relationship between substorm ionospheric currents and the corresponding ground magnetic perturbations is examined, by using the height-integrated ionospheric current density deduced from the Chatanika incoherent scatter radar and the simultaneous magnetic variations along the Alaska meridian chain of stations. Although time variations of the H component near the radar site on the Earth's surface are in good agreement with those of the east-west ionospheric current, there is a substantial disagreement between the current deduced from the D perturbations and the observed north-south current in the evening sector. It is shown that the disagreement can be removed by introducing a new finding by Yasuhara et al. (1975) that the upward field-aligned current on the poleward side of the auroral oval in the evening sector is more intense than its counterpart fieldaligned current and that it contributes greatly to the ground D perturbations.     

Birkeland currents in the Earth's magnetosphere

As a result of his polar expeditions at the beginning of this century, Kristian Birkeland determined that intense ionospheric currents were associated with the aurora. Birkeland suggested that these currents originated far from the Earth and that they flowed ointo and away from the polar atmosphere along the geomagnetic field lines. The existence of such field-aligned or Birkeland currents was disputed because it was not possible to unambiguously identify current systems that are field-aligned (as suggested by Alfvén, 1939, 1940) and those which are completely contained in the ionosphere (as developed by Vestine and Chapman, 1938) with surface magnetic field observations. The presence of Birkeland currents has been absolutely confirmed with satellite-borne particle and magnetic field experiments conducted over the past two decades. These satellite observations have determined the large-scale patterns, flow directions, and intensities of Birkeland currents in the auroral and polar regions, and their relationship to the orientation and magnitude of the interplanetary magnetic field. The Birkeland currents are directly associated with visible and UV auroral forms observed with satellites. The results obtained from a variety of recently launched satellites are discussed here. These include Sweden's first satellite, VIKING, which has provided evidence for resonant Alfvén waves on the same geomagnetic field lines that guide stationary Birkeland currents. These observations demonstrate the important role that these currents play in the coupling of energy between the interplanetary medium and the lower ionosphere and atmosphere.Paper dedicated to Professor Hannes Alfvén on the occasion of his 80th birthday, 30 May 1988.     

Formation of whistler ducts

A theory of whistler duct formation is presented. By means of order of magnitude calculations it is shown that, when the ring current overlaps the outer plasmasphere, irregularities will cause field-aligned currents to flow, which are below the threshold sensitivity of satellite-borne magnetometers. These currents must be continuous with horizontal ionospheric currents, which produce horizontal electric fields. These fields map up to the equatorial plane and are large enough to produce flux tube interchange and hence the formation of whistler ducts in the outer plasmasphere.     

Convection and field-aligned currents, related to polar cap arcs, during strongly northward IMF (11 January 1983)

Electric and magnetic fields and auroral emissions have been measured by the Intercosmos-Bulgaria-1300 satellite on 10–11 January 1983. The measured distributions of the plasma drift velocity show that viscous convection is diminished in the evening sector under IMF B_y < 0 and in the morning sector if IMF B_y > 0. A number of sun-aligned polar cap arcs were observed at the beginning of the period of strongly northward IMF and after a few hours a θ-aurora appeared. The intensity of ionized oxygen emission [O⁺(²P), 7320 Å] increased significantly reaching up to several kilo-Rayleighs in the polar cap arc. A complicated pattern of convection and field-aligned currents existed in the nightside polar cap which differed from the four-cell model of convection and NBZ field-aligned current system. This pattern was observed during 12 h and could be interpreted as six large scale field-aligned current sheets and three convective vortices inside the polar cap. Sun-aligned polar cap arcs may be located in regions both of sunward and anti-sunward convection. Structures of smaller spatial scale correspond to the boundaries of hot plasma regions related to polar cap arcs. Obviously these structures are due to S-shaped distributions of electric potential. Parallel electric fields in these S-structures provide electron acceleration up to 1 keV at the boundaries of polar cap arcs. The pairs of field-aligned currents correspond to those S-structures: a downward current at the external side of the boundary and an upward current at the internal side of it.     

Numerical analysis of equatorial enhancement of geomagnetic sudden commencement

Equatorial behaviour of a polar-originating ionospheric current is examined by solving numerically the continuity equation on a two-dimensional spherical shell with appropriate assumptions for the ionospheric conductivity and the field-aligned source currents. The results show a clear daytime equatorial enhancement of the ionospheric currents in spite of much reduced electric field due to shielding effects of the enhanced Cowling conductivity there. The results are used for interpretation of the preliminary impulse of the geomagnetic sudden commencement.     

Three-dimensional current system in different phases of a substorm

It is assumed that the three-dimensional current system of a substorm passes three successive stages. (1) When a dawn-to-dusk magnetospheric electric field appears, a current system with field-aligned currents at the poleward boundary of the auroral zone arises. An equivalent ionospheric current system calculated, taking into account a day-night asymmetry of ionospheric conductivity, looks like the well-known DP-2 system including an eastward low-latitude current and a greater magnitude of the dusk vortex in comparison with the dawn one. (2) An electric drift of plasma towards the Earth leads to the appearance of a westward partial ring current increasing in time. This current is closed by field-aligned currents at the equatorward boundary of the auroral zone. The calculated equivalent current system is similar to the well-known one of the precursory phase. (3) An increase of the auroral ionospheric conductivity during the expansive phase produces an increase of all currents and a turning of field-aligned currents at the equatorward boundary of the auroral zone relative to those at the poleward one. The calculated equivalent current system is similar to the DP-1 system.     

The interplanetary electric field, cleft currents and plasma convection in the polar caps

This report investigates the suggestion that the pattern of plasma convection in the polar cleft region is directly determined by the interplanetary electric field (IEF). Owing to the geometrical properties of the magnetosphere, the East-West component of the IEF will drive field-aligned currents which connect to the ionosphere at points lying on either side of noon, while currents associated with the North-South component of the IEF will connect the two polar caps as sheet currents centered at noon. The effects of the hypothesized IEF driven cleft current systems on polar cap ionospheric plasma convection are investigated through a series of numerical simulations. The simulations demonstrate that this simple electrodynamic model can account for the narrow “throats” of strong dayside antisunward convection observed during periods of southward interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) as well as the sunward convection observed during periods of strongly northward IMF. Thedawn-dusk shift of polar cap convection which is related to the B_y component of the IMF is also accounted for by the model.     

A model current system for the magnetospheric substorm

We propose a model three-dimensional current system for the magnetospheric substorm, which can account for the new findings of the field-aligned and ionospheric currents obtained during the last few years by using new techniques. They include (1) the ionospheric currents at the auroral latitude deduced from the Chatanika incoherent scatter radar data, (2) the field-aligned currents inferred from the vector magnetic field observations by the TRIAD satellite and (3) the global distribution of auroras with respect to the auroral electrojets appearing in DMSP satellite photographs. The model current system is also tested by a computer model calculation of the ionospheric current pattern. It is shown that the auroral electrojets have a strong asymmetry with respect to the midnight meridian. The westward electrojet flows along the discrete aurora in the evening sector, as well as along the diffuse aurora in the morning sector. The eastward electrojet flows equatorward of the westward electrojet in the evening sector. It has a northward component and joins the westward electrojet by turning westward across the Harang discontinuity. Thus, the latitudinal width of the westward electrojet in the morning sector is much larger than that in the evening sector. The field-aligned currents, consisting of two pairs of upward and inward currents (one is located in the morning sector and the other in the evening sector), are closed neither simply by the east-west ionospheric currents nor by the north-south currents, but by a complicated combination of the north-south and east-west paths in the ionosphere. The magnetospheric extension of the current system is also briefly discussed.     

Field-aligned currents and parallel electric field potential drops at Mars. Scaling from the Earth’ aurora

The observations of electron inverted ‘V’ structures by the MGS and MEX spacecraft, their resemblance to similar events in the auroral regions of the Earth, and the discovery of strong localized magnetic field sources of the crustal origin on Mars, raised hypotheses on the existence of Martian aurora produced by electron acceleration in parallel electric fields. Following the theory of this type of structures on Earth we perform a scaling analysis to the Martian conditions. Similar to the Earth, upward field-aligned currents necessary for the generation of parallel potential drops and peaked electron distributions can arise, for example, on the boundary between ‘closed’ and ‘open’ crustal field lines due to shears of the flow velocity of the magnetosheath or magnetospheric plasmas. A steady-state configuration assumes a closure of these currents in the Martian ionosphere. Due to much smaller magnetic fields as compared to the Earth case, the ionospheric Pedersen conductivity is much higher on Mars and auroral field tubes with parallel potential drops and relatively small cross scales to be adjusted to the scales of the localized crustal patches may appear only if the magnetosphere and ionosphere are decoupled by a zone with a strong E_∥. Another scenario suggests a periodic short-circuit of the magnetospheric electric fields by a coupling with the conducting ionosphere.     

Ground-based observations of an isolated substorm

An isolated substorm occurred in Northern Scandinavia on 1 March, 1977 around magnetic midnight. The ionospheric phenomena associated with this substorm were studied by ground magnetometers, the Scandinavian Twin Auroral Radar Experiment (STARE), riometers and an all-sky camera. The physical properties of the auroral electrojet are determined from the ground magnetic field and the ionospheric electric field data. Mid and low latitude magnetic field data show evidence of field-aligned current flow. It is shown that the enhancement of the electrojet's current density is essentially determined by an increase in the ionospheric conductivity. The current system derived from the data of this study corresponds to a model of Yasuhara et al. (1975a).     

Alfven Wave Reflection model of field-aligned currents at Mercury

An Alfven Wave Reflection (AWR) model is proposed that provides closure for strong field-aligned currents (FACs) driven by the magnetopause reconnection in the magnetospheres of planets having no significant ionospheric and surface electrical conductance. The model is based on properties of the Alfven waves, generated at high altitudes and reflected from the low-conductivity surface of the planet. When magnetospheric convection is very slow, the incident and reflected Alfven waves propagate along approximately the same path. In this case, the net field-aligned currents will be small. However, as the convection speed increases, the reflected wave is displaced relatively to the incident wave so that the incident and reflected waves no longer compensate each other. In this case, the net field-aligned current may be large despite the lack of significant ionospheric and surface conductivity. Our estimate shows that for typical solar wind conditions at Mercury, the magnitude of Region 1-type FACs in Mercury’s magnetosphere may reach hundreds of kilo-Amperes. This AWR model of field-aligned currents may provide a solution to the long-standing problem of the closure of FACs in the Mercury’s magnetosphere.