Solubility of aragonite in seawater—II. Effect of pressure on the onset and maintenance of dissolution

The apparent solubility product (K'_sp) of aragonite in a variety of seawater compositions has been determined at pressures from 0 to 1019 atm and a nomogram developed to allow the determination of the K'_sp when the apparent ion product (AIP) at one atmosphere and the collection depth of a water sample are known.This nomogram provides a basis from which the onset of aragonite dissolution can be determined for conditions representative of aragonite sedimentation through the changing water masses of the open ocean.     

The chemistry of orthophosphate uptake from seawater on to calcite and aragonite

The chemistry of orthophosphate uptake from synthetic seawater onto the surfaces of synthetic calcite, aragonite and low-magnesium biogenic calcite has been studied, in order to elucidate the kinetics of the process (generally believed to be the major control of dissolved reactive phosphate in carbonate-rich marine sediments). Our results differ from those obtained by others, who have studied orthophosphate uptake in low ionic strength solutions and at much higher supersaturations relative to apatite.In both ‘free drift’ and chemostat experiments, Mg and F have only a minor effect on the reaction rate. Even at constant solution composition the rate of orthophosphate uptake was found to decrease by 10⁶ over a two week period. The data from the ‘free drift’ experiments can be fitted to the Elovich equation. This indicates that the kinetics observed for this reaction can be explained by an exponential decrease in available surface reaction sites and/or a linear increase in the activation energy associated with chemisorption as the reaction proceeds.     

The effect of oxalate on the dissolution rates of oligoclase and tremolite

The effect of oxalate, a strong chelator for Al and other cations, on the dissolution rates of oligoclase feldspar and tremolite amphibole was investigated in a flow-through reactor at 22°C. Oxalate at concentrations of 0.5 and 1 mM has essentially no effect on the dissolution rate of tremolite, nor on the steady-state rate of release of Si from oligoclase. The fact that oxalate has no effect on dissolution rate suggests that detachment of Si rather than Al or Mg is the rate-limiting step. At pH 4 and 9, oxalate has no effect on the steady-state rate of release of Al, and dissolution is congruent. At pH 5 and 7, oligoclase dissolution is congruent in the presence of oxalate, but in the absence of oxalate Al is preferentially retained in the solid relative to Si.Large transient “spikes” of Al or Si are observed when oxalate is added to or removed from the system. The cause of the spikes is unknown; we suggest adsorption on feldspar surfaces away from sites of active dissolution as a possibility. Solutions in the reactors are undersaturated with respect to both gibbsite and kaolinite, so neither the spikes nor the incongruent dissolution can be explained by formation of a secondary precipitate.The rate of dissolution of tremolite is independent of pH over the pH range 2–5, and decreases at higher pH. The rate of dissolution of oligoclase in our experiments was independent of pH over the pH range 4–9. Since the dissolution rate of these minerals is independent of pH and organic ligand concentration, the effect of acid deposition from the atmosphere on the rate of supply of cations from weathering of granitic rocks should be minor.     

Calcite and aragonite precipitation from seawater solutions of various salinities: Precipitation rates and overgrowth compositions

The reaction rate and composition of calcite and aragonite overgrowths precipitated from seawater solutions of various salinities (i.e. S=5, 15, 25, 35, 44) were determined at 25°C and 10^−2.5-atm. CO₂ partial pressure using a constant disequilibrium seeded technique. The rate data were fitted to an empirical rate law of the form:

logR=n(ω_{c(or a)}-1)+logk

where n is the empirical reaction order; and k is the rate constant. Calcite precipitation rates in seawater solutions do not vary appreciably as a result of salinity variations over the range investigated, while those for aragonite show an increase in going from the higher (i.e. S=35, 44) to the lower (i.e. S=5, 15, 25) salinity range. This study also confirms previously published findings that above a given saturation state (i.e. Ω_c>/2.6) aragonite precipitates more rapidly than calcite at 25°C.

The incorporation of Sr²⁺ in aragonite and Mg²⁺ in calcite overgrowths are independent of the precipitation rate. The partition coefficient of Sr²⁺ in aragonite is approximately equal to unity and is unaffected by salinity variations between 5 and 44. However, the Mg²⁺ partition coefficient in calcite, increases with decreasing salinity of the parent seawater solutions, possibly as a result of variations in the sulfate content of the solutions and solids.

The experimental results were discussed in the context of a number of geological environments.     

The solubility of calcite and aragonite in seawater of 35%. salinity at 25°C and atmospheric pressure

The solubilities of synthetic, natural and biogenic aragonite and calcite, in natural seawater of 35%. salinity at 25°C and 1 atm pressure, were measured using a closed system technique. Equilibration times ranged up to several months. The apparent solubility constant determined for calcite of 4.39(±0.20) × 10^?7 mol² kg^?2 is in good agreement with other recent solubility measurements and is constant after 5 days equilibration. When we measured aragonite solubility we observed that it decreased with increasing time of equilibration. The value of 6.65(±0.12) × 10^?7 mol² kg^?2, determined for equilibration times in excess of 2 months, is significantly less than that found in other recent measurements, which employed equilibration times of only a few hours to days. No statistically significant difference was found among the synthetic, natural and biogenic material. Solid to solution ratio, contamination of aragonite with up to 10 wt% calcite and recycling of the aragonite made no statistically significant difference in solubility when long equilibration times were used.Measured apparent solubility constants of aragonite and calcite are respectively 22( ± 3)% and 20( ± 2)% less than apparent solubility constants calculated from thermodynamic equilibrium constants and seawater total activity coefficients. These large differences in measured and calculated apparent solubility constants may be the result of the formation of surface layers of lower solubility than the bulk solid.     

The effect of pressure on the solubility of minerals in water and seawater

The effect of presure on the solubility of minerals in water and seawater can be estimated from In

$\text{(}\text{K}{}^{\mathrm{P}}{}_{\mathrm{sp}}\text{K}{}^0{}_{\mathrm{sp}}\text{) +}\text{(?ΔVP + 0.5ΔKP}{}^2\text{)}\text{RT}$

where the volume (ΔV) and compressibility (ΔK) changes at atmospheric pressure (P = 0) are given by

$\text{ΔV =}\text{V}\text{?}\text{(M}{}^{\mathrm{+}}\text{, X}{}^{\mathrm{?}}\text{) ?}\text{V}\text{?}\text{[MX(s)]ΔK =}\text{K}\text{?}\text{(M}{}^{\mathrm{+}}\text{, X}{}^{\mathrm{?}}\text{) ?}\text{K}\text{?}\text{[MX(s)]}$

Values of the partial molal volume ($\text{V}\text{?}$) and compressibilty ($\text{K}\text{?}$) in water and seawater have been tabulated for some ions from 0 to 50°C. The compressibility change is quite large (~10 × 10^?3 cm³ bar^?1 mol^?1) for the solubility of most minerals. This large compressibility change accounts for the large differences observed between values of ΔV obtained from linear plots of In K_sp versus P and molal volume data (Macdonald and North, 1974; North, 1974). Calculated values of $\text{K}{}^{\mathrm{P}}{}_{\mathrm{sp}}\text{K}{}^{\mathrm{o}}{}_{\mathrm{sp}}$ for the solubility of CaCO₃, SrSO₄ and CaF₂ in water were found to be in good agreement with direct measurements (Macdonald and North, 1974). Similar calculations for the solubility of minerals in seawater are also in good agreement with direct measurements (Ingle, 1975) providing that the surface of the solid phase is not appreciably altered.     

Americium interaction with calcite and aragonite surfaces in seawater

Observations of the distribution of ²⁴¹Am in the marine environment indicate that Am has a high affinity for solid surfaces. The adsorption of Am onto calcite and aragonite surfaces from seawater and related solutions has been studied, in order to establish the interaction of Am with a major component of many marine sediments. Results indicate that Am is rapidly and strongly adsorbed. This occurs even when both dissolved Am concentrations and solid to solution ratios are low. The minimum value for $\text{K}{}_{\mathrm{D}}$ determined is 2 × 10⁵. Measurements of reaction kinetics established that Am is adsorbed from seawater at 40 times the rate per unit surface area on synthetic aragonite that it is on synthetic calcite. Approximately 15% of the difference is attributable to epitaxial influences, with the remainder being due to enhanced site competition by Mg on calcite relative to aragonite. The adsorption rate is first order with respect to Am concentration, but follows approximately the square root of the solid surface area to solution volume ratio.Adsorption rate of Am on biogenic aragonite and Mg-calcites are, within a given particle size range, close to equal. It is not possible to normalize these adsorption rates to surface area due to the differing microporous structure of biogenic carbonates. The Am adsorption rates on a shallow water calcium carbonate-rich sediment gave results which were predicted from, its mineralogie mixture of components.     

The dissolution kinetics of biogenic calcium carbonates in seawater

Dissolution rate as a function of degree of undersaturation was measured on shells of individual species of coccoliths and foraminifera, various size fractions of sediment from the Ontong-Java Plateau and the Rio Grande Rise, a collection of large pteropods, and on synthetic calcite and aragonite powder.Results of the study indicate that all biogenic and synthetic calcium carbonate follows the rate law $\text{R\% = k\%(1 ? Ω)}{}^{\mathrm{n}}$ where $\text{Ω  [Ca}{}^{\mathrm{2+}}\text{][CO}{}_3{}^{\mathrm{2?}}\text{]/K'}{}_{\mathrm{sp}}$ and K'_sp is the apparent solubility product of calcite or aragonitic seawater. In the case of all calcite samples, n_c = 4.5, while for aragonitic samples n_a = 4.2. The ‘rate constant’, k%, varies widely between samples and in many cases is inversely correlated with grain size. However, the individual species of coccoliths, E. huxleyi and C. neohelis, which were cultured in the laboratory appear not to follow this rule, with dissolution rates an order to magnitude lower than expected.     

The effect of crystallinity on dissolution rates and CO2 consumption capacity of silicates

Comparison of measured far-from-equilibrium dissolution rates of natural glasses and silicate minerals at 25 °C and pH 4 reveals the systematic effects of crystallinity and elemental composition on these rates. Rates for both minerals and glasses decrease with increasing Si:O ratio, but glass dissolution rates are faster than corresponding mineral rates. The difference between glass and mineral dissolution rates increases with increasing Si:O ratio; ultra-mafic glasses (Si:O ? 0.28) dissolve at similar rates as correspondingly compositioned minerals, but Si-rich glasses such as rhyolite (Si:O ∼ 0.40) dissolve ?1.6 orders of magnitude faster than corresponding minerals. This behaviour is interpreted to stem from the effect of Si-O polymerisation on silicate dissolution rates. The rate controlling step of dissolution for silicate minerals and glasses for which Si:O > 0.28 is the breaking of Si-O bonds. Owing to rapid quenching, natural glasses will exhibit less polymerisation and less ordering of Si-O bonds than minerals, making them less resistant to dissolution. Dissolution rates summarized in this study are used to determine the Ca release rates of natural rocks at far-from-equilibrium conditions, which in turn are used to estimate their CO₂ consumption capacity. Results indicate that Ca release rates for glasses are faster than those of corresponding rocks. This difference is, however, significantly less than the corresponding difference between glass and mineral bulk dissolution rates. This is due to the presence of Ca in relatively reactive minerals. In both cases, Ca release rates increase by ∼two orders of magnitude from high to low Si:O ratios (e.g., from granite to gabbro or from rhyolitic to basaltic glass), illustrating the important role of Si-poor silicates in the long-term global CO₂ cycle.     

Modeling the dissolution behavior of standard clays in seawater

The present investigation tests a model to explain the behavior of dissolved Si during early diagenesis in sediments. The model assumes that low-Fe clays and other minerals can be treated simply as Al hydroxides, having attached silica. When the minerals are placed in seawater solutions, Si is released, causing exposure of fresh Al-octahedra. which are reactive toward Si and other elements in solution. Standard clays (kaolinite, montmorillonite) and solid silicic acid were suspended in seawater solutions in various combinations and dissolved Al, Si, Ca, pH and alkalinity were determined as a function of time. The theoretical model correctly predicts the behavior of Si in mixtures of the different minerals, based upon the dissolution behavior of the minerals in suspension alone. Further, the decrease in the alkalinity of kaolinitecontaining seawater solutions, where carbonate dissolution, organic matter decomposition and reduced sulfur oxidation are apparently unimportant, can be predicted from a simple extrapolation of the silica model results. The alkalinity changes observed in this study, as well as the pH changes observed in standard clay suspensions by other researchers, can be explained simply by equilibration of the charge on exposed Al-octahedra with the pH of the surrounding waters. The results of this study indicate that theoretical models of Si diagenesis in sediments should have general usefulness for predicting the effects of clay dissolution on sediment properties.     

The solubility of aragonite in seawater—I. Effect of pH and water chemistry at one atmosphere

The effect of water chemistry on the solubility of aragonite in seawater has been defined experimentally as a series of apparent solubility products measured with respect to pH at one atmosphere.The dominant control of the apparent solubility product of aragonite is the carbonate ion concentration, and this is primarily a function of pH. In the light of this fact, we have reconciled our data with 81 other reported values of aragonite solubility by simply examining the water chemistry of the waters in which they were determined.     

The dissolution kinetics of shallow marine carbonates in seawater: A laboratory study

The dissolution kinetics of shallow water marine carbonates (low-Mg calcite, aragonite and Mg-calcites) were investigated in seawater (S = 35) at 25°C and a P_CO2 of 10^?2.5 atm. using the pH-stat method. Carbonate dissoluton rates (μmoles g^?1 hr^?1) fit the empirical kinetic expression, R = k(1 - Ω)ⁿ, where R = dissolution rate, k = rate constant, Ω = saturation state, and n = order of reaction. Reaction orders were near 2.9 for low-Mg calcites, 2.5 for aragonites and 3.4 for Mg-calcites.The rate constant, k, expressed as μmoles g^?1 hr^?1, varied by nearly a factor of ten for the different samples, reflecting differences in amount of reactive surface area. Reactive surface area of the biogenic phases ranged from 0.3% to 66% of the total surface area determined by the BET gas adsorption method. The discrepancy between reactive and total surface area was greatest for samples with high BET surface areas (> 1 m² g^?1) and delicate microstructures.Relative dissolution rates of the various biogenic carbonates as a function of seawater calcium carbonate ion molal product (IMP) were related to both mineral stability and grain microstructure. In seawater undersaturated with respect to aragonite, finely crystalline aragonites dissolved more rapidly than thermodynamically less stable high Mg-calcites (15–18 mole% MgCO₃) with lower reactive surface areas. Therefore, under certain conditions, differences in grain microstructural complexity can override thermodynamic constraints and lead to selective dissolution of a thermodynamically more stable mineral phase.     

Deep-sea coral aragonite as a recorder for the neodymium isotopic composition of seawater

Deep-sea corals have been shown to be useful archives of rapid changes in ocean chemistry during the last glacial cycle. Their aragonitic skeleton can be absolutely dated by U-Th data, freeing radiocarbon to be used as a water-mass proxy. For certain species of deep-sea corals, the growth rate allows time resolution that is comparable to ice cores. An additional proxy is needed to exploit this opportunity and turn radiocarbon data into rates of ocean overturning in the past.Neodymium isotopes in seawater can serve as a quasi-conservative water-mass tracer and initial results indicate that deep-sea corals may be reliable archives of seawater Nd isotopes. Here we present a systematic study exploring Nd isotopes as a water-mass proxy in deep-sea coral aragonite. We investigated five different genera of modern deep-sea corals (Caryophyllia, Desmophyllum, Enallopsamia, Flabellum, Lophelia), from global locations covering a large potential range of Nd isotopic compositions. Comparison with ambient seawater measurements yields excellent agreement and suggests that deep-sea corals are reliable archives for seawater Nd isotopes.A parallel study of Nd concentrations in these corals yields distribution coefficients for Nd between seawater and coral aragonite of 1-10, omitting one particular genus (Enallopsamia). The corals and seawater did however not come from exactly the same location, and further investigations are needed to reach robust conclusions on the incorporation of Nd into deep-sea coral aragonite.Lastly, we studied the viability of extracting the Nd isotope signal from fossil deep-sea corals by carrying out stepwise cleaning experiments. Our results show that physical removal of the ferromanganese coating and chemical pre-cleaning have the highest impact on Nd concentrations, but that oxidative/reductive cleaning is also needed to acquire a seawater Nd isotope signal.     

The effect of fluoride on the dissolution rates of natural glasses at pH 4 and 25°C

Far-from-equilibrium, steady-state dissolution rates at pH 4 of a suite of natural glasses, ranging from basaltic to rhyolitic in composition, have been determined as a function of aqueous fluoride concentrations up to 1.8 × 10⁻⁴ mol/kg in mixed-flow reactors. Dissolution rates of each of these glasses increase monotonically with increasing aqueous fluoride concentration. Measured dissolution rates are found to be consistent with both the Furrer and Stumm (1986) surface coordination model and the Oelkers (2001) multi-oxide dissolution model. Application of the latter model yields the following equation that can describe all measured rates as a function of both glass and aqueous solution composition:

     

Compositional and morphological features of aragonite precipitated experimentally from seawater and biogenically by corals

The morphology and composition of abiogenic (synthetic) aragonites precipitated experimentally from seawater and the aragonite accreted by scleractinian corals were characterized at the micron and nano scale. The synthetic aragonites precipitated from supersaturated seawater solutions as spherulites, typically 20-100 μm in diameter, with aggregates of sub-micron granular materials occupying their centers and elongate (fibrous) needles radiating out to the edge. Using Sr isotope spikes, the formation of the central granular material was shown to be associated with high fluid pH and saturation state whereas needle growth occurred at lower pH and saturation state. The granular aggregates have significantly higher Mg/Ca and Ba/Ca ratios than the surrounding fibers.Two types of crystals are identified in the coral skeleton: aggregates of sub-micron granular material and bundles of elongate (fibrous) crystals that radiate out from the aggregates. The granular materials are found in “centers of calcification” and in fine bands that transect the fiber bundles. They have significantly higher Mg/Ca and Ba/Ca ratios than the surrounding fibers.The observed relationship between seawater saturation state and crystal morphology and composition in the synthetic aragonites was used as a framework to interpret observations of the coral skeleton. We propose that coral skeletal growth can be viewed as a cyclical process driven by changes in the saturation state of the coral’s calcifying fluids. When saturation state is high, granular crystals precipitate at the tips of the existing skeletal elements forming the centers of calcification. As the saturation state decreases, aragonitic fibres grow in bundles that radiate out from the centers of calcification.     

Element partitioning during precipitation of aragonite from seawater: A framework for understanding paleoproxies

This study presents the results from precipitation experiments carried out to investigate the partitioning of the alkaline earth cations Mg²⁺, Ca²⁺, Sr²⁺, and Ba²⁺ between abiogenic aragonite and seawater as a function of temperature. Experiments were carried out at 5 to 75 °C, using the protocol of Kinsman and Holland [Kinsman, D.J.J., Holland, H.D., 1969. The coprecipitation of cations with CaCO₃ IV. The coprecipitation of Sr²⁺ with aragonite between 16 and 96 °C. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta33, 1-17.] The concentrations of Mg Sr and Ba were determined in the fluid from each experiment by inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry, and in individual aragonite grains by secondary ion mass spectrometry. The experimentally produced aragonite grains are enriched in trace components (“impurities”) relative to the concentrations expected from crystal-fluid equilibrium, indicating that kinetic processes are controlling element distribution. Our data are not consistent with fractionations produced kinetically in a boundary layer adjacent to the growing crystal because Sr²⁺, a compatible element, is enriched rather than depleted in the aragonite. Element compatibilities, and the systematic change in partitioning with temperature, can be explained by the process of surface entrapment proposed by Watson and Liang [Watson, E.B., Liang, Y., 1995. A simple model for sector zoning in slowly grown crystals: implications for growth rate and lattice diffusion, with emphasis on accessory minerals in crustal rocks. Am. Mineral.80, 1179-1187] and Watson [Watson, E.B., 1996. Surface enrichment and trace-element uptake during crystal growth. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta60, 5013-5020; Watson, E.B., 2004. A conceptual model for near-surface kinetic controls on the trace-element and stable isotope composition of abiogenic calcite crystals. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta68, 1473-1488]. This process is thought to operate in regimes where the competition between crystal growth rate and diffusivity in the near-surface region limits the extent to which the solid can achieve partitioning equilibrium with the fluid. A comparison of the skeletal composition of Diploria labyrinthiformis (brain coral) collected on Bermuda with results from precipitation calculations carried out using our experimentally determined partition coefficients indicate that the fluid from which coral skeleton precipitates has a Sr/Ca ratio comparable to that of seawater, but is depleted in Mg and Ba, and that there are seasonal fluctuations in the mass fraction of aragonite precipitated from the calcifying fluid (“precipitation efficiency”). The combined effects of surface entrapment during aragonite growth and seasonal fluctuations in “precipitation efficiency” likely forms the basis for the temperature information recorded in the aragonite skeletons of Scleractinian corals.