Observations of suprathermal electrons in Mercury's magnetosphere during the three MESSENGER flybys

In 2008 the MESSENGER spacecraft made the first direct observation of Mercury's magnetosphere in the more than 30 years since the Mariner 10 encounters. During MESSENGER's first flyby on 14 January 2008, the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) was northward immediately prior to and following MESSENGER's equatorial passage through this small magnetosphere. The Energetic Particle Spectrometer (EPS), one of two sensors on the Energetic Particle and Plasma Spectrometer instrument that responds to electrons from ∼35 keV to 1 MeV and ions from ∼35 keV to 2.75 MeV, saw no increases in particle intensity above instrumental background (∼5 particles/cm²/sr/s/keV at 45 keV) at any time during the probe's magnetospheric passage. During MESSENGER's second flyby on 6 October 2008, there was a steady southward IMF, and intense reconnection was observed between the planet's magnetic field and the IMF. However, once again EPS did not observe bursts of energetic particles similar to those reported by Mariner 10 from its March 1974 encounter. On 29 September 2009, MESSENGER flew by Mercury for the third and final time before orbit insertion in March 2011. Although a spacecraft safe-hold event stopped science measurements prior to the outbound portion of the flyby, all instruments recorded full observations until a few minutes before the closest approach. In particular, the MESSENGER Magnetometer documented several substorm-like signatures of extreme loading of Mercury's magnetotail, but again EPS measured no energetic ions or electrons above instrument background during the inbound portion of the flyby. MESSENGER's X-Ray Spectrometer (XRS) nonetheless observed photons resulting from low-energy (∼10 keV) electrons impinging on its detectors during each of the three flybys. We infer that suprathermal plasma electrons below the EPS energy threshold caused the bremsstrahlung seen by XRS. In this paper, we summarize the energetic particle observations made by EPS and XRS during MESSENGER's three Mercury flybys, and we revisit the observations reported by Mariner 10 in the context of these new results.     

Particle populations in Mercury's magnetosphere

Observations by Mariner 10 during its first and third flybys showed that Mercury possesses an intrinsic magnetic field resulting in a small magnetosphere that can keep the solar wind from directly interacting with the planet's surface under usual conditions. Since Mercury occupies a large fraction of its magnetosphere, regions of trapped charged particles in the inner magnetosphere, the plasmasphere and the energetic radiation belts, would all be absent. During the first flyby, energetic particle bursts were detected and interpreted as hermean substroms analogous to the terrestrial magnetosphere. Moreover, during this flyby, ULF waves and field-aligned currents were detected in the data. Earth-based observations of Na, K, and Ca populations in the exosphere strongly suggest the existence of dynamic magnetospheric processes at high latitudes interacting with the planet's surface.     

Dust in jupiter''s magnetosphere: Effect on magnetospheric electrons and ions

The interaction of the Jovian energetic radiation belt electrons, and the Jovian plasma, with an ambient dust population is examined. Firstly the distribution of dust, ejected from Io, in the inner magnetosphere is calculated. Using the mass loss in submicron particles of ~13g/sec, which is required to model the intensity and shape of the Jovian ring in the model of Morfill etal. (1980b), it is possible to quantitatively calculate losses of magnetospheric ions and electrons due to direct collisions with charged dust particles as well as multiple Coulomb scattering with resultant losses in the Jovian atmosphere. It is shown that the magnitude and radial dependence of the losses are sufficient to explain the electron measurements, although the possibility that some other process may be more effective cannot be ruled out. The same dust population has, on the other hand, no significant effect on the plasma, which should therefore be transported essentially loss free, except within the Jovian ring, if there are no other processes involved. Comparison with the data shows that loss free transport outside the ring does indeed satisfy the measurement constraints.     

Mercury's exosphere origins and relations to its magnetosphere and surface

Mariner 10, the only spacecraft that ever passed close to Mercury, revealed several unexpected characteristics: an intrinsic magnetosphere, the highest mean density of any Solar System terrestrial planet and a very thin non-collisional atmosphere. Mercury's atmosphere is very poorly explored since only three atomic elements, H, He and O, were observed during the three flybys of Mariner 10. The measurements done by radio and solar occultations provided upper limits on the neutral and ion densities. These measurements pointed out the close connection between species in Mercury's exosphere and its surface, which is also the case for the Moon. Mariner 10 observations also characterized the vertical distributions and the day to night contrasts of Mercury's exosphere for its lightest components H and He (Broadfoot, A.L., et al., 1976. Mariner 10: Mercury atmosphere. Geophys. Res. Lett. 3, 577–580).More than a decade later, the first observation from a ground-based observatory of Mercury's sodium (Na) exospheric component was reported (Potter, A.E., Morgan, T.H., 1985. Discovery of sodium in the atmosphere of Mercury. Science 229, 651–653). Since then, potassium and more recently calcium have been identified in Mercury's exosphere. The bright Na resonant scattering emission has been often observed since 1985. This large set of observations is now the best source of information on Mercury's exospheric mechanisms of ejection, dynamics, sources and sinks. In particular, several of these observations provided evidence of prompt and delayed effects, both localized and global, for the very inhomogeneous Mercury's Na exosphere. These inhomogenities have been interpreted as the trace of Mercury's magnetosphere–solar wind interaction and have highlighted some of the main sources of exospheric material. Some of these features have been also interpreted as the trace of a global dayside to night side circulation of Mercury's exosphere and therefore have highlighted also the relation between exospheric production and upper surface composition.Hopefully, new sets of in situ measurements will be obtained within the next decade thanks to Messenger and Bepi-Colombo missions. Until then, ground-based observations and modelling will remain the only approaches to resolve questions on Mercury's exosphere. Mercury's exospheric composition and structure as they are presently known are described in this paper. The principal models for the main short and long times terms variations and local and global variations of Mercury's exosphere are described. The mechanisms of production and their characteristics are also given. Mercury's exosphere can also be seen as part of the coupled magnetosphere–upper surface–exosphere system and several of the links between these elements are essential to the interpretation of most of the ground-based observations. The relation between Mercury's planet composition and its exospheric composition is also considered, as is the global recycling, sources and sinks of Mercury's exosphere.     

Low energy electrons and protons in the magnetosphere

Observations made by HEOS-2 of low energy electrons and protons in the high latitude magnetosphere are presented. Plasma in the magnetosphere is observed in the cusp (which extend down to low altitudes) and over large areas adjacent to the high latitude magnetopause both on the dayside and on the nightside (the entry layer and the plasma mantle respectively).A comparative study of the plasma properties in the various parts of the magnetosphere is performed. An ion bulk motion directed tailward along the geomagnetic field lines is observed both in the entry layer and in the plasma mantle; in the cusp, on the contrary, the bulk motion is practically absent. Moreover the electron thermal anisotropy is parallel to the magnetic field in the magnetosheath, and perpendicular to it in the plasma mantle. One possible explanation (suggested by Rosenbauer et al., 1975) of the origin of these populations is that plasma, penetrated from the magnetosheath in the entry layer, flows tailward along the field lines, is then reflected in the cusp region and convected in the plasma mantle.     

Energetic neutral atom imaging of Mercury's magnetosphere 3. Simulated images and instrument requirements

The paper presents simulations of the energetic neutral atom (ENA) production in the Mercury magnetosphere and the obtained ENA images for the equatorial and polar vantage points. The ENA fluxes are found to be 10²–10³ (cm² srskeV)⁻¹ and up to 10⁴–10⁵ (cm² srskeV)⁻¹ in the energy range 10–50 keV. Due to the small size of the magnetosphere, the particles injected in the tail can fill up the entire dayside magnetosphere making possible ENA imaging of the magnetospheric shape. The high variability of the Hermean magnetosphere gives rise to pulsating ENA emissions (ENA “flashes”) which can be used to study the global dynamics. The ENA instrument requirements, 10°×10° angular resolution and 20 s accumulation time, can be easily met by modern ENA instrumentation. Therefore, ENA imaging of the Mercury magnetosphere is feasible.     

Global MHD modeling of Mercury's magnetosphere with applications to the MESSENGER mission and dynamo theory

We use a global magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) model to simulate Mercury's space environment for several solar wind and interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) conditions in anticipation of the magnetic field measurements by the MESSENGER spacecraft. The main goal of our study is to assess what characteristics of the internally generated field of Mercury can be inferred from the MESSENGER observations, and to what extent they will be able to constrain various models of Mercury's magnetic field generation. Based on the results of our simulations, we argue that it should be possible to infer not only the dipole component, but also the quadrupole and possibly even higher harmonics of the Mercury's planetary magnetic field. We furthermore expect that some of the crucial measurements for specifying the Hermean internal field will be acquired during the initial fly-bys of the planet, before MESSENGER goes into orbit around Mercury.     

Non-IO-related radio emissions and the modulation of relativistic electrons in the Jovian magnetosphere

The modulations of the non-Io-related radio emissions in hectometric and decametric wave frequencies are examined, and compared with the observed variation of the MeV electron fluxes in the morning sector of the Jovian magnetosphere. It is suggested that these radio emissions are controlled by the behaviour of these electrons in this sector.     

Energetic neutral atom imaging of Mercury's magnetosphere 1. Distribution of neutral particles in an axially symmetrical exosphere

We have developed a simple analytical model to obtain density distributions of neutral particles in an axially symmetrical exosphere. Correction due to the finite lifetime of exosphere neutral particles has been introduced. The model developed will be utilised in the simulations of energetic neutral atom production via charge-exchange reaction in Mercury's magnetosphere. As examples, we have calculated density profiles of helium and oxygen in Mercury's exosphere. We have also calculated the day side distribution of sodium atoms to demonstrate the effect of the finite lifetime.     

The acceleration of electrons and ions in solar flares

We find that gamma-ray line (GRL) emissions start later than the hard X-ray (HXR) emissions during impulsive and extended solar flares. Starting delay is more in the case of extended solar flares suggesting a slow acceleration of electrons and ions, in comparison to impulsive solar flares which indicate different acceleration mechanism for impulsive and extended solar flares. We further infer that during solar flares, electrons and ions are accelerated simultaneously and the delay between HXR and GRL emissions results mainly due to differences in acceleration times of electrons and ions to attain energies required for producing HXR emissions for electrons and GRL emissions for ions. Therefore, we are of view that a single step acceleration mechanism may work in solar flares.     

On the origin of the hot ions in the disturbed dayside magnetosphere

On the basis of observations in the dayside magnetosphere of the O⁺ and H⁺ ion densities as function of radial distance under fairly undisturbed and under storm conditions it is argued that acceleration of the hot magnetospheric ions of ionospheric origin cannot be limited to the outer parts of the field tubes. The extraction process seems to work below 1000 km altitude in storm conditions and to have a fairly small extension in altitude. The acceleration mechanism(s) do(es) not affect only one ion species. Variation in the altitude of the extraction of ionospheric ions is the most likely reason for the observed variations in the n(O⁺)/n(H⁺) ratio. Extraction of ionospheric ions into the magnetosphere does not seem to be a main cause of the storm time density decrease of the ionosphere.     

Evolution of Mercury's obliquity

Mercury has a near-zero obliquity, i.e. its spin axis is nearly perpendicular to its orbital plane. The value of the obliquity must be known precisely in order to constrain the size of the planet's core within the framework suggested by Peale [Peale, S.J., 1976. Nature 262, 765-766]. Rambaux and Bois [Rambaux, N., Bois, E., 2004. Astron. Astrophys. 413, 381-393] have suggested that Mercury's obliquity varies on thousand-year timescales due to planetary perturbations, potentially ruining the feasibility of Peale's experiment. We use a Hamiltonian approach (free of energy dissipation) to study the spin-orbit evolution of Mercury subject to secular planetary perturbations. We can reproduce an obliquity evolution similar to that of Rambaux and Bois [Rambaux, N., Bois, E., 2004. Astron. Astrophys. 413, 381-393] if we integrate the system with a set of initial conditions that differs from the Cassini state. However the thousand-year oscillations in the obliquity disappear if we use initial conditions corresponding to the equilibrium position of the Cassini state. This result indicates that planetary perturbations do not force short-period, large amplitude oscillations in the obliquity of Mercury. In the absence of excitation processes on short timescales, Mercury's obliquity will remain quasi-constant, suggesting that one of the important conditions for the success of Peale's experiment is realized. We show that interpretation of data obtained in support of this experiment will require a precise knowledge of the spin-orbit configuration, and we provide estimates for two of the critical parameters, the instantaneous Laplace plane orientation and the orbital precession rate from numerical fits to ephemeris data. Finally we provide geometrical relationships and a scheme for identifying the correct initial conditions required in numerical integrations involving a Cassini state configuration subject to planetary perturbations.     

The spatial distribution of energetic ions and electrons in the magnetotail

The spatial distributions of energetic ion and electron bursts observed on the IMP 7 and 8 satellites in the Earth's magnetotail were studied. It was found that the ion bursts were more frequently detected in the dusk than in the dawn quarter of the neutral sheet whereas the electron bursts, more frequently in the dawn than the dusk quarter. The degree of dawn-dusk asymmetry is however energy dependent; the distribution for higher energy particle bursts exhibits higher degree of asymmetry. The morphologies of the distributions manifest themselves as seasonal variations of the most probable solar ecliptic latitudes at which the ion and electron bursts were observed. The amplitudes of the variations are about 25° with the seasonal variation for ions leading that for electrons by about 2 months.     

A possible method of accelerating relativistic electrons in the neutral sheet in the Jovian outer magnetosphere

It is suggested that the periodic modulation of Mev electron fluxes observed by Pioneer 10 in its outbound orbit was due to crossing the magnetically neutral sheet in the Jovian outer magnetosphere. It is pointed out that these electrons are continually generated in this sheet formed in the outer magnetosphere beyond about 20 Jupiter radii from the planet.     

Dynamics and abundance of ions in coronal holes

This paper discusses the outflow of ions in an open magnetic field region in the solar corona. The model is polytropic and assumes that the ions do not affect the motion of the protons; treatment of large openings of the flux tubes is included.It is found that a large variety of topologies in the velocity-heliocentric distance plane occurs, by varying the funnelling factor and the proton density. While for low proton densities the topology is characterized by a single critical point, above some value of the density and of the funnelling factor multiple critical points appear, causing the ion velocity to become large in the low corona. All the ions studied (He iii, Fe xv, Si xii, Mg x) show the same general trend, although their sensitivity to the proton density is different.The abundance increase in the low corona, with respect to interplanetary space, is depressed if the opening of the flux tubes increases; however, for some extreme values of the acceleration due to large openings of the flux tubes, the theory predicts, on the contrary, very large increases of the coronal abundances.     

Dust drift solitary waves with superthermal electrons and ions

Linear and nonlinear dust drift waves are investigated in the presence of kappa distributed electrons and ions. The dispersion characteristics of linear waves show that the phase velocity decreases with the inclusion of highly energetic particles in the tail of the distribution. In the nonlinear regime, a nonlinear partial differential equation is obtained in the long wave length limit. A stationary solution of this equation in the form of solitary waves is discussed and noticed that the amplitude of the solitary pulse decreases with the increase of superthermal particle’s effect, and its width expands. Further, it is found that speed limit of the nonlinear structures is also modified in the non-Maxwellian plasma. Theoretically obtained results are applied to Saturn’s’ dusty plasma environment. It is also pointed out that the present results can be helpful for further understanding of space plasmas.     

Dust-acoustic soliton in a plasma with multi-species ions and kappa-distributed electrons

In this work, we consider the formation of electrostatic, dust-acoustic solitary structure in a unmagnetized plasma with Lorentzian electrons (kappa-distributed) and more than one species of thermal ions (Maxwellian). The work is inspired by results of different space-based observations of electrostatic solitary waves (ESW) in the near-earth and magnetospheric plasmas and recent experimental realization of existence of superthermal electron component in various space plasmas. We have, in this work, shown that existence of compressive potential structure is possible only with more than one species of thermal ions. Besides, formation of compressive double layers is also possible which depends on the amount of deviation of the electron thermal velocities from a Maxwellian distribution. We show that both dust-temperature and super-thermal electrons lead to a decrease in the soliton amplitude.     

Parallel electric fields accelerating ions and electrons in the same direction

In this contribution we present Viking observations of electrons and positive ions which move upward along the magnetic field lines with energies of the same order of magnitude. We propose that both ions and electrons are accelerated by an electric field which has low-frequency temporal variations such that the ions experience an average electrostatic potential drop along the magnetic field lines whereas the upward streaming electrons are accelerated in periods of downward pointing electric field which is quasi-static for the electrons and forces them to beam out of the field region before the field changes direction.Paper dedicated to Professor Hannes Alfvén on the occasion of his 80th birthday, 30 May 1988.     

Impulsive bursts of relativistic electrons discovered during Ulysses' traversal of Jupiter's dusk-side magnetosphere

During its flyby of Jupiter in February 1992, the Ulysses spacecraft passed through the Southern Hemisphere dusk-side Jovian magnetosphere, a region not previously explored by spacecraft. Among the new findings in this region were numerous, sometimes periodic, bursts of high energy electrons with energies extending from less than 1.5 MeV to beyond 16 MeV. These bursts were discovered by the High Energy Telescope (HET) and the Kiel Electron Telescope (KET) of the COSPIN Consortium. In this paper we provide a detailed analysis of observations related to the bursts using HET measurements. At the onset of bursts, the intensity of > 16 MeV electrons often rose by a factor of > 100 within 1 min, and multiple, pulsed injections were sometimes observed. The electron energy spectrum also hardened significantly at the onset of a burst. In most bursts anisotropy measurements indicated initial strong outward streaming of electrons along magnetic field lines that connect to the southern polar regions of Jupiter, suggesting that the acceleration and/or injection region for the electrons lies at low altitudes near the South Pole. The initial strong outward anisotropies relaxed to strong field-aligned bidirectional anisotropies later in the events. The bursts sometimes appeared as isolated events, but at other times appeared in quasi-periodic series with a period of 40 min. For smaller events shorter periods of the order 2–3 min were also observed in a few cases. For large events, multiple injections were sometimes observed in the first few minutes of the event. Radio bursts identified by the Ulysses URAP experiment in the frequency range 1–50 kHz were correlated with many of the electron bursts, and comparison of the time-intensity profiles for radio and electrons shows that the radio emission typically started several minutes before the electron intensity increase was observed. For the strongest electron bursts, small increases in the low energy (> 0.3 MeV) proton counting rates were also observed. Using a computerized identification algorithm to pick out bursts from the data record using a consistent set of criteria, 121 events were identified as electron bursts during the outbound pass, compared to only three events that satisfied the same criteria during the inbound pass through the day-side magnetosphere. No similar electron burst events have been found outside the magnetopause. Estimates of the electron content of a typical large burst (> 10²⁷ electrons) suggest that these bursts may make significant contributions to the fluxes of electrons observed in Jupiter's outer magnetosphere, and in interplanetary space.