Magnesian calcite stabilities: A reevaluation

Equilibrium constants at stoichiometric saturation with respect to various magnesian calcite compositions were measured using free-drift dissolution rate data and inverse time plots to estimate equilibrium pH. The equilibrium constants determined for two ultrasonically cleaned and annealed biogenic magnesian calcites (12 and 18 mole % MgCO₃) in CaCl₂ + MgCl₂ media at two Mg:Ca molar ratios (1:5 and 5:1) are about three times smaller than those previously reported by Plummer and Mackenzie (1974). These equilibrium constants are not affected by changes in initial pH value, solid:solution ratio, or solution Mg:Ca molar ratio when the ion activity product is expressed in the fractional exponent form. Other models for expression of the equilibrium ion activity product fail to yield consistent values in solutions of different Mg:Ca molar ratios.Experiments performed using crushed samples not ultrasonically cleaned and annealed yield equilibrium constants which vary with solid:solution ratio. Those performed at high solid:solution ratios yield values which approach those previously reported. Submicron size particles and crystal strain induced by crushing the biogenic carbonates may cause more rapid dissolution rates and, hence, overestimation of the solubility of samples not prepared so as to minimize these effects. Thus, the large range in reported solubilities of magnesium calcites may be a result of differences in sample preparation procedure.The results of these measurements shift the thermodynamic equivalence point of aragonite and magnesian calcite from 7.5 mole % MgCO₃ up to 12 mole % MgCO₃ and prompt a reassessment of models for carbonate diagenetic reactions in natural environments.     

The solubility of calcite in seawater solutions of various magnesium concentration, It = 0.697 m at 25 °C and one atmosphere total pressure

Stoichiometric solubility constants of calcite in initially supersaturated solutions of various magnesium to calcium concentration ratios but identical ionic strength were determined at 25°C and one atmosphere total pressure.The thermodynamic solubility constant of calcite is used with ion pairing equations to interpret the data reported in this study. Results indicate that even though magnesian calcites, rather than pure calcite, precipitate from seawater solutions containing magnesium ions, the incorporation of MgCO₃ in the calcite crystal lattice does not extensively alter the equilibrium calcium carbonate activity product.The equilibrium activity of the ionic species in solution and the composition of magnesian calcite overgrowths precipitated from solutions of similar composition are used to calculate the solubility of magnesian calcites. The values for magnesian calcite solubilities obtained by this approach are lower than those obtained from the dissolution kinetics of biogenic carbonates.     

The role of magnesium in the crystal growth of calcite and aragonite from sea water

The seeded precipitation (crystal growth) of aragonite and calcite from sea water, magnesium-depleted sea water, and magnesium-free sea water has been studied by means of the steady-state disequilibrium initial rate method. Dissolved magnesium at sea water levels appears to have no effect on the rate of crystal growth of aragonite, but a strong retarding effect on that of calcite. By contrast, at levels less than about 5 per cent of the sea water level, Mg has little or no effect on calcite growth. Extended crystal growth on pure calcite seeds in sea water of normal Mg content resulted in the crystallization of magnesium calcite overgrowths, containing 7–10 mole % MgCO₃ in solid solution. This suggests that the rate inhibition by Mg is due to its incorporation within the calcite crystal structure during growth, which causes the resulting magnesian calcite to be considerably more soluble than pure calcite. The standard free energy of formation of 8.5 mole% Mg calcite calculated on this assumption is in good agreement with independent estimates of magnesian calcite stability.From the work of Katz (Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta37, 1563–1586, 1973), Plummer and Mackenzie (Amer. J. Sci. 273, 515–522, 1974), and the present paper, it can be predicted that the most stable calcite in Ca-Mg exchange equilibrium with sea water contains between 2 and 7 mole%MgCO₃ in solid solution. Likewise, calcites containing more than 8.5 mole% MgCO₃ are less stable, and those containing less than 8.5 mole% MgCO₃ are more stable than aragonite plus Ca and Mg in sea water.     

Pressure effect on magnesian calcite coating calcite and synthetic magnesian calcite seeds added to seawater in a closed system

When pure crystalline calcite seeds are added to supersaturated seawater, precipitation results in a coating which with time equilibrates at atmospheric pressure with seawater and corresponds to a calcite containing probably only 2 or 3% of MgCO₃ (mole fraction).If synthetic crystalline magnesian calcite is added, the surface layer equilibrates not only with respect to seawater but also in relation with the crystalline sites initiating precipitation. Adding Mg_0.03Ca_0.97CO₃ results in a coating with a solubility close to that of calcite. This confirms that the surface coating on pure calcite seeds contains about 2 or 3% MgCO₃ (K'_sp = 10?6.30).The surface layer precipitated on a synthetic Mg_0.08Ca_0.92CO₃ equilibrates finally with a carbonate more soluble than calcite (K'_sp = 10?5.94) corresponding to the seeds composition.Experiments at 1000 kg cm t-2 imply that when magnesian calcites are precipitated at the surface of calcite or magnesian calcite seeds, the precipitate must be hydrated, otherwise pressure accelerated recrystallization or rearrangement with loss of Mg would thermodynamically be impossible.By changing the pressure of a seawater sample originally saturated with a solid carbonate phase, changes in pH result from the effect of pressure on the dissociation constants of carbonic acid and boric acid causing either undersaturation or supersaturation with respect to the solid. By changing pressure we can show whether precipitation, dissolution and recrystallization are reversible processes if pH is taken as criteria of reversibility.     

The dissolution kinetics of shallow marine carbonates in seawater: A laboratory study

The dissolution kinetics of shallow water marine carbonates (low-Mg calcite, aragonite and Mg-calcites) were investigated in seawater (S = 35) at 25°C and a P_CO2 of 10^?2.5 atm. using the pH-stat method. Carbonate dissoluton rates (μmoles g^?1 hr^?1) fit the empirical kinetic expression, R = k(1 - Ω)ⁿ, where R = dissolution rate, k = rate constant, Ω = saturation state, and n = order of reaction. Reaction orders were near 2.9 for low-Mg calcites, 2.5 for aragonites and 3.4 for Mg-calcites.The rate constant, k, expressed as μmoles g^?1 hr^?1, varied by nearly a factor of ten for the different samples, reflecting differences in amount of reactive surface area. Reactive surface area of the biogenic phases ranged from 0.3% to 66% of the total surface area determined by the BET gas adsorption method. The discrepancy between reactive and total surface area was greatest for samples with high BET surface areas (> 1 m² g^?1) and delicate microstructures.Relative dissolution rates of the various biogenic carbonates as a function of seawater calcium carbonate ion molal product (IMP) were related to both mineral stability and grain microstructure. In seawater undersaturated with respect to aragonite, finely crystalline aragonites dissolved more rapidly than thermodynamically less stable high Mg-calcites (15–18 mole% MgCO₃) with lower reactive surface areas. Therefore, under certain conditions, differences in grain microstructural complexity can override thermodynamic constraints and lead to selective dissolution of a thermodynamically more stable mineral phase.     

Effect of orthophosphate on the dissolution kinetics of biogenic magnesian calcites

The dissolution behavior of two biogenic Mg-calcites, the echinoid, Tripneustes (12 mol% MgCO₃), and the red alga, Neogoniolithon (18 mol% MgCO₃ plus brucite), was studied using free-drift methods in distilled water and phosphate-spiked solutions at 25°C and P_CO2 = 1 atm. Small concentrations of phosphate strongly inhibit dissolution rates. Inhibition increases with increased phosphate levels and with approach toward saturation. Near saturation, dissolution rates are reduced by 10³ by the presence of 0.6 μmol adsorbed-P/m². The magnitude of phosphate inhibition is similar to that observed for low-Mg calcite, and like calcite, the mechanism of inhibition is probably by adsorption of P at surface kink sites. Phosphate appears to inhibit removal of Mg and Ca equally during Mg-calcite dissolution. Rates of brucite dissolution are unaffected by phosphate.Mg-calcites containing >8.5 mol% MgCO₃ should be thermodynamically unstable relative to aragonite in most natural waters. Recent work, however, shows that in contrast to its effect on the behavior of Mg-calcites. phosphate does not inhibit aragonite dissolution. The presence of phosphate might thus reverse the relative stability of these two minerals during diagenesis of shallow marine carbonate sediments.     

The dolomitization of CaCO3: an experimental study at 252–295°C

The results of experiments on the hydrothermal dolomitization of calcite (between 252 and 295°C) and aragonite (at 252°C) by a 2 M CaCl₂-MgCl₂ aqueous solution are reported and discussed. Dolomitization of calcite proceeds via an intermediate high (ca. 35 mole %) magnesian calcite, whereas that of aragonite is carried out through the conversion of the reactant into a low (5.6 mole %) magnesian calcite which in turn transforms into a high (39.6 mole %) magnesian calcite. Both the intermediate phases and dolomite crystallize through a dissolution-precipitation reaction. The intermediate phases form under local equilibrium within a reaction zone surrounding the dissolving reactant grains. The volume of the reaction zone solution can be estimated from Sr²⁺ and Mg²⁺ partitioning equations. In the case of low magnesian calcite growing at the expense of aragonite at 252°C, the total volume of these zones is in the range of 2 × 10^?5 to 2 × 10^?4 1., out of 5 × 10^?3 1., the volume of the bulk solution.The apparent activation energies for the initial crystallization of high magnesian calcite and dolomite are 48 and 49 kcal/mole, respectively.Calcite transforms completely into dolomite within 100 hr at 252°C. The overall reaction time is reduced to approximately 4 hr at 295°C. The transformation of aragonite to dolomite at 252°C occurs within 24 hr. The nature of the reactant dictates the relative rates of crystallization of the intermediate phases and dolomite. With calcite as reactant, dolomite growth is faster than that of magnesian calcite; this situation is reversed when aragonite is dolomitized.Coprecipitation of Sr²⁺ with dolomite is independent of temperature (within analytical error) between 252 and 295°C. Its partitioning, with respect to calcium, between dolomite and solution results in distribution coefficients in the range of 2.31 × 10^?2 to 2.78 × 10^?2.     

Bank-derived carbonate sediment transport and dissolution in the Hawaiian Archipelago

This investigation used two approaches to examine the flux of bank-derived carbonate particles and determine the potential influence of benthic carbonate particle dissolution on the carbon chemistry of the waters around the Hawaiian Archipelago. First, the particle flux near several representative carbonate banks in the Hawaiian Archipelago was measured and compared with the flux at a distal site (ALOHA) approximately 100 km north of Oahu, Hawaii. The results of four sediment trap deployments on three carbonate banks in the Hawaiian Archipelago demonstrate that the flux of bank-derived carbonate particles are consistently one to two orders of magnitude higher than the fluxes at the distal station. Furthermore, the mineralogy of the carbonate flux near the banks, which includes very soluble bank-derived aragonite and magnesian calcite particles, is distinctly different from that of the distal fluxes. Second, the chemistry of the waters at each bank station along the archipelago was characterized and compared with the chemistry of the distal waters to determine if differences in the particle flux were reflected in the carbon chemistry. Higher alkalinity and carbonate ion concentrations were observed around all of the banks studied. The saturation state of these waters suggests that the dissolution of some magnesian calcite and aragonite phases could explain the higher alkalinity values. Calculations suggest that the dissolution of benthically-derived aragonite and magnesian calcite may be an important component of the North Pacific alkalinity budget and a potential sink for anthropogenic CO₂.     

Cathodoluminescent bimineralic ooids from the Pleistocene of the Florida continental shelf

A bored and encrusted late Pleistocene ooid grainstone was recovered from the seafloor at a depth of approximately 40 m on the outer continental shelf of eastern Florida. Ooid cortices are dominantly bimineralic, generally consisting of inner layers of radial magnesian calcite and outer layers of tangential aragonite. Ooid nuclei are dominantly rounded cryptocrystalline grains, although quartz grains and a variety of skeletal grains also occur as nuclei. Ooids are partially cemented by blocky calcite, and interparticle porosity is partially filled by micrite. Radial cortex layers are composed of brightly cathodoluminescent magnesian calcite having a composition of approximately 12 mol% MgCO₃ and 1000 ppm strontium. The iron and manganese concentrations in radial cortex layers are generally in the range of 500–1000 ppm and 100–250 ppm, respectively. Tangential cortex layers are composed of noncathodoluminescent aragonite containing approximately 11 500 ppm strontium and less than 0.5 mol% MgCO₃. Iron concentrations in tangential cortex layers are generally in the range of 150–400 ppm, and manganese concentrations are generally below the detection limit of 100 ppm. Echinoderm skeletal fragments, which are present as accessory grains, are composed of brightly cathodoluminescent magnesian calcite. Some ooid nuclei and the thin outer edges of some blocky calcite cement are cathodoluminescent; micrite matrix and the bulk of blocky calcite cement are noncathodoluminescent. Ooids do not exhibit textural evidence of recrystallization. The ooid grainstone underwent an episode of meteoric diagenesis. but ooid cortices were not affected by the event. We propose a previously unrecognized process by which the magnesian calcite cortex layers underwent diagenetic alteration in oxygen-depleted seawater. During this diagenesis, magnesium was lost and manganese was incorporated without apparent textural alteration and without mineralogical stabilization. Thus, we Suggest that cathodoluminescence may result from diagenetic alteration on the sea-floor.     

Aragonite crystallization from strained calcite at reduced pressures and its bearing on aragonite in low-grade metamorphism

Aragonite, the dense form of CaCO₃, grew hydrothermally at 100–300° C and dry at 300–400° C at very low pressures from calcite strained by grinding. Nearly complete inversion to aragonite occurred in some runs with Ca-Mg chloride solutions at 0–2.4 kb and 100–200° C on strained calcite having a (10¯14) reflection with a half-width of 0.48° 2 Cu K. A little aragonite grew dry at one atm. from the ground calcite at 300–400° C in a few hrs. Simultaneous shear during recrystallization of calcite in a rotating squeezer resulted in significant aragonite at 300–400° C several kb. below the stability field. No inversion occurred in any ground calcite when previously annealed in CO₂ at 500° C for a few hrs. Thermochemical data show that at least 200 cal/mole of strain energy can be produced in calcite by mild deformation. This much stored energy would lower the pressure requirements of aragonite, relative to the strained calcite by more than 3 kb, and our observation that aragonite growth was faster than strain recovery of calcite indicates that aragonite can grow in nature at reduced pressures from strained calcite.Some experiments were also carried out on highly magnesian calcites with the thought that aragonite might also form at the expense of this metastable material. No aragonite was produced, but the possibility that this mechanism could be operative in nature cannot be discounted.The microtexture of aragonitic deformed marbles from NW Washington (prehnite-pumpellyite facies rocks, courtesy of J. A. Vance) as well as electron probe microanalysis of these rocks indicates that aragonite selectively replaced highly strained calcite. The calcite-aragonite transition is thus a questionable indicator of high-pressure in certain metamorphic rocks.     

Low-magnesian calcite limestones forming at the deep-sea floor, Tongue of the Ocean, Bahamas

Carbonate ooze in the deep troughs between the Bahama Banks is a mixture of pelagic and bank-derived material. It consists of aragonite, calcite and magnesium calcite in a ratio of about 3:2:1. Where exposed in erosional cuts at the sea floor, this ooze lithifies within 100,000 years and is transformed into calcite micrite of only 3.5-5 mol % MgCO₃. Where buried, the ooze maintains its original composition for at least 200,000-400,000 years and remains unlithified for tens of millions of years. Quite unexpectedly, the path of sea-floor diagenesis of peri-platform ooze was found to be the same as that of freshwater diagenesis. Most of the aragonite is leached, pteropod shells often leaving cement-lined moulds behind; magnesian calcite recrystallizes and loses magnesium; polyhedral calcite of 2-4 μm size appears as cement. The setting and the carbon-oxygen isotope ratios rule out any freshwater influence. Carbon isotope ratios remain heavy, oxygen ratios shift towards equilibrium with the cold bottom water. The calcite cement has 3.5-5 mol % MgCO₃ and can be interpreted as the least soluble form of calcite emerging from alteration at the sea floor or, alternatively, as a direct precipitate from cold sea water. The change in the composition of calcite cements with water depth supports the second interpretation. In the Bahamas and elsewhere in the world ocean, magnesium in calcite cements decreases from the warm surface waters down to 700-1200 m, i.e. the boundary between intermediate and cold deep-water masses. Below this level, calcite prevails and magnesian calcite and aragonite cements are restricted to semi-enclosed seas with exceptionally warm bottom waters.     

Kinetic and thermodynamic factors controlling the distribution of SO32− and Na+ in calcites and selected aragonites

Significant amounts of SO₄^2?, Na⁺, and OH^? are incorporated in marine biogenic calcites. Biogenic high Mg-calcites average about 1 mole percent SO₄^2?. Aragonites and most biogenic low Mg-calcites contain significant amounts of Na⁺, but very low concentrations of SO₄^2?. The SO₄^2? content of non-biogenic calcites and aragonites investigated was below 100 ppm. The presence of Na⁺ and SO₄^2? increases the unit cell size of calcites. The solid-solutions show a solubility minimum at about 0.5 mole percent SO₄^2? beyond which the solubility rapidly increases. The solubility product of calcites containing 3 mole percent SO₄^2? is the same as that of aragonite. Na⁺ appears to have very little effect on the solubility product of calcites. The amounts of Na⁺ and SO₄^2? incorporated in calcites vary as a function of the rate of crystal growth. The variation of the distribution coefficient ($\text{D}$) of SO₄^2? in calcite at 25.0°C and 0.50 molal NaCl is described by the equation $\text{D = k}{}_0\text{+ k}{}_1\text{R}$ where $\text{k}{}_0$ and $\text{k}{}_1$ are constants equal to $\text{6.16 × 10}{}^{\mathrm{?6}}$ and $\text{3.941 × 10}{}^{\mathrm{?6}}$, respectively, and $\text{R}$ is the rate of crystal growth of calcite in mg·min^?1·g^?1 of seed. The data on Na⁺ are consistent with the hypothesis that a significant amount of Na⁺ occupies interstitial positions in the calcite structure. The distribution of Na⁺ follows a Freundlich isotherm and not the Berthelot-Nernst distribution law. The numerical value of the Na⁺ distribution coefficient in calcite is probably dependent on the number of defects in the calcite structure. The Na⁺ contents of calcites are not very accurate indicators of environmental salinities.     

Temperature Dependence of Mineral Precipitation Rates Along the CaCO3–MgCO3 Join

The large variation in precipitation rate and abundance of mineralscomprising the CaCO₃–MgCO₃ binary join can be understood in terms of their large differences in activation energy. Following the treatment of Lippmann (1973), activation energy isextrapolated along the join as a linear function of mole percentmagnesium. For the dolomite-type carbonates, the predicted activationenergy is compatible with recent measurements of calcian protodolomitekinetics; cation ordering in ideal dolomite can thus be seen as anadditional contribution to activation energy. Although no activationenergies are available for magnesian calcites, treatment of rate datafor these phases using the formalism of stoichiometric saturationsuggests a possible change in mechanism or rate-limiting step astemperature is decreased from 25 to 5 °C.     

The solubility of calcite and aragonite in seawater of 35%. salinity at 25°C and atmospheric pressure

The solubilities of synthetic, natural and biogenic aragonite and calcite, in natural seawater of 35%. salinity at 25°C and 1 atm pressure, were measured using a closed system technique. Equilibration times ranged up to several months. The apparent solubility constant determined for calcite of 4.39(±0.20) × 10^?7 mol² kg^?2 is in good agreement with other recent solubility measurements and is constant after 5 days equilibration. When we measured aragonite solubility we observed that it decreased with increasing time of equilibration. The value of 6.65(±0.12) × 10^?7 mol² kg^?2, determined for equilibration times in excess of 2 months, is significantly less than that found in other recent measurements, which employed equilibration times of only a few hours to days. No statistically significant difference was found among the synthetic, natural and biogenic material. Solid to solution ratio, contamination of aragonite with up to 10 wt% calcite and recycling of the aragonite made no statistically significant difference in solubility when long equilibration times were used.Measured apparent solubility constants of aragonite and calcite are respectively 22( ± 3)% and 20( ± 2)% less than apparent solubility constants calculated from thermodynamic equilibrium constants and seawater total activity coefficients. These large differences in measured and calculated apparent solubility constants may be the result of the formation of surface layers of lower solubility than the bulk solid.     

Shallow subsurface diagenesis of Pleistocene periplatform ooze: northern Bahamas

Previous studies on early submarine diagenesis of periplatform carbonates have implied that these originally polymineralic (aragonite, magnesian calcite, calcite) sediments are susceptible to early diagenesis only in current-swept open seaways or where surficially exposed by erosion on the seafloor. It has also been proposed that while in the shallow subsurface, periplatform oozes retain their original mineralogy for at least 200,000–400,000 yr and remain unlithified for tens of millions of years. Evidence is reported here for extensive calcitization and selective lithification of periplatform oozes of late Pleistocene age in two piston cores collected from water depths of ～ 1,000 m north of Little Bahama Bank. It is shown that shallow (<30 m) subsurface diagenesis can significantly alter the original mineralogy of periplatform oozes to predominantly calcite in less than 440,000 yr, and that cementation by calcite can produce chalk-ooze sequences within the same time-frame. Periplatform oozes that originally contain a high percentage of bank-derived magnesian calcite appear to have a higher diagenetic potential than those originally low in magnesian calcite. Shallow subsurface calcitization and fithification greatly reduce the diagenetic potential of periplatform carbonates, and chalk-ooze sequences apparently can persist for tens of millions of years and to burial depths of at least 300 m. Shallow subsurface diagenesis, at water depths > 1,000 m, proceeds via dissolution of magnesian calcite and aragonite and reprecipitation of calcite as allochem fillings, exterior overgrowths and cement. It is speculated that density-driven ‘Kohout convection‘, where seawaters under-saturated with respect to magnesian calcite and aragonite and saturated/supersaturated with respect to calcite flow through the margins of carbonate platforms, is the primary driving mechanism for shallow subsurface diagenesis. Removal of Mg during early stages of deep seafloor and shallow subsurface diagenesis should increase the Mg content of interstitial waters which is likely to increase the ‘dolomitizing potential’ of Kohout convection fluid flow.     

Effect of pH on boron coprecipitation by calcite: further evidence for nonequilibrium partitioning of trace elements

The influence of pH and concentration on boron coprecipitation by calcite were evaluated under near-equilibrium conditions at 25°C. Calcite was precipitated by adding a metastable polymorph (vaterite or aragonite) to a solution of known boron concentration. This method maintains a nearly constant solution composition during the slow conversion of the metastable polymorph to calcite.Boron uptake in calcite was found to be strongly pH-dependent, increasing two orders of magnitude from pH 8.5 to pH 10.5. Boron incorporation into calcites precipitated from vaterite-saturated solutions was five times greater than in calcites precipitated from aragonite-saturated solutions. Ostensibly, these results suggest that the calcite precipitation rates were not low enough to attain equilibrium partitioning of boron into calcite. However, scanning electron micrograph analyses showed that the prevalent crystal forms of calcite generated from aragonite and those generated from vaterite were distinctly different. The different quantities of boron incorporated into these calcites may reflect different crystal growth mechanisms, consistent with face-dependent, nonequilibrium partitioning of trace elements in calcite.At a constant pH of 9.0, boron uptake increased from less than 15 to over 290 mg/kg CaCO₃ as the solution boron concentration was increased from 5 to 100 mg/kg. Our results agree with those of other investigators, despite differences in solution composition, and calcite precipitation techniques used. The agreement between the studies may be because the crystal growth morphology of the calcite was rhombohedral in both cases.     

Formation of low‐magnesium calcite at cold seeps in an aragonite sea

This study investigates the conditions of occurrence and petrographic characteristics of low‐Mg calcite (LMC) from cold seeps of the Gulf of Mexico at a water depth of 2340 m. Such LMC mineral phases should precipitate in calcite seas rather than today's aragonite sea. The ¹³C‐depleted carbonates formed as a consequence of anaerobic oxidation of hydrocarbons in shallow subsurface cold seep environments. The occurrence of LMC may result from brine fluid flows. Brines are relatively Ca²⁺‐enriched and Mg²⁺‐depleted (Mg/Ca mole ratio <0.7) relative to seawater, where the Mg/Ca mole ratio is ~5, which drives high‐Mg calcite and aragonite precipitation. The dissolution of aragonitic mollusk shells, grains and cements was observed. Aerobic oxidation of hydrocarbons and H₂S is the most likely mechanism to explain carbonate dissolution. These findings have important implications for understanding the occurrence of LMC in deep water marine settings and consequently their counterparts in the geological record.     

Dissolution Enthalpies of Magnesian Calcites

A series of synthetic and biogenicmagnesian calcites was dissolved in weak acetic acidsolutions to measure the enthalpies of dissolution at25°C. For the synthetic phases, heat releasedwas 33.5 kJ/mol for calcite, decreasing to 33 kJ/molfor a phase of 2 mol % MgCO3, and increasing to35 kJ/mol for a phase of 15 mol %. Values of excessenthalpies, ΔHxs, calculated using calciteand magnesite end-members, average about -1 kJ/mol forthe synthetic phases. Total entropies of solidsolution formation, ΔSSS, also werecalculated using available data on Gibbs free energiesof formation and these excess enthalpies. Values ofΔSSS range from -2 J/(mol-K) at 2 mol % to-5 J/(mol-K) at 15 mol % MgCO3. These negativevalues of ΔHxs and ΔSSSsuggest that some form of ordering (cation?) isobtained in the synthetic phases, and that vibrationalentropies of the solid solution are diminished incomparison to the end-members. In contrast, biogenic samples generally have positivevalues of ΔHxs, increasing from +1 kJ/molat 5 mol % to +3 kJ/mol at 20 mol % MgCO3. Mostvalues of ΔSSS are equal (within errors)to values expected from configurational enthalpyalone. Thus, in most biogenic materials cationordering probably is not obtained, and most phases aremore typical of equivalent-site solid solutions.     

The stability of CaCO3·6H2O (ikaite)

Experimental runs were made in cold-seal pressure vessels using synthetic CaCO₈·6H₂O, calcite and aragonite as starting materials. The reaction CaCO₃·6H₂O (ikaite) ? CaCO₃ (calcite I) + 6H₂O was reversed across its metastable extension into the aragonite stability field and the phase boundary is defined by brackets at 4.14kb, 14.3°C and 2.96 kb, ?3.0°C. An invariant point for CaCO₃·6H₂O, calcite I, aragonite and water thus occurs at about 3.02 kb and ?2.0°C. No other reaction could be reversed. Calculations based on the equilibrium phase boundary between calcite and ikaite and the available thermochemical data for calcite and water yield the stadard free energy of formation, standard enthalpy of formation and third law entropy of CaCO₃·6H₂O at 25°C and 1 bar total pressure; ?607.3 kcal/mole, ?705.8 kcal/mole, and 88.4 cal/deg mole, respectively.     

How do mineral coatings affect dissolution rates? An experimental study of coupled CaCO3 dissolution—CdCO3 precipitation

Coupled CaCO₃ dissolution-otavite (CdCO₃) precipitation experiments have been performed to 1) quantify the effect of mineral coatings on dissolution rates, and 2) to explore the possible application of this coupled process to the remediation of polluted waters. All experiments were performed at 25°C in mixed-flow reactors. Various CaCO₃ solids were used in the experiments including calcite, aragonite, and ground clam, mussel, and cockle shells. Precipitation was induced by the presence of Cd(NO₃)₂ in the inlet solution, which combined with aqueous carbonate liberated by CaCO₃ dissolution to supersaturate otavite. The precipitation of an otavite layer of less than 0.01 μm in thickness on calcite surfaces decreases its dissolution rate by close to two orders of magnitude. This decrease in calcite dissolution rates lowers aqueous carbonate concentrations in the reactor such that the mixed-flow reactor experiments attain a steady-state where the reactive fluid is approximately in equilibrium with otavite, arresting its precipitation. In contrast, otavite coatings are far less efficient in lowering aragonite, and ground clam, mussel, and cockle shell dissolution rates, which are comprised primarily of aragonite. A steady-state is only attained after the precipitation of an otavite layer of 3-10 μm thick; the steady state CaCO₃ dissolution rate is 1-2 orders of magnitude lower than that in the absence of otavite coatings. The difference in behavior is interpreted to stem from the relative crystallographic structures of the dissolving and precipitating minerals. As otavite is isostructural with respect to calcite, it precipitates by epitaxial growth directly on the calcite, efficiently slowing dissolution. In contrast, otavite’s structure is appreciably different from that of aragonite. Thus, it will precipitate by random three dimensional heterogeneous nucleation, leaving some pore space at the otavite-aragonite interface. This pore space allows aragonite dissolution to continue relatively unaffected by thin layers of precipitated otavite. Due to the inefficiency of otavite coatings to slow aragonite and ground aragonite shell dissolution, aragonite appears to be a far better Cd scavenging material for cleaning polluted waste waters.