碳酸酐酶对碳酸盐岩溶解的催化作用及其在大气CO2沉降中的意义

CO2向H^ 和HCO3^－的转换是一相对慢速过程。因此，其动力学可能决定碳酸盐岩的溶解速率。在灰岩和白云岩的溶解实验中，使用了自然界普遍存在的碳酸酐酶（CA）来催化这一CO2转换反应，结果发现，对灰岩而言，加入CA后，其溶解速率在高CO2分层时可增加10倍，而对白云岩，其溶解速率增加主要在低CO2分压时，可达3倍左右。这一发现表明，化学风化（包括碳酸盐岩溶解和硅酸盐风化）作用在大气CO2沉降和全球碳循环里的所谓丢失的汇中的重要性需要重新评价。毫无疑问，已往的研究由于未认识到CA在风化中的催化作用，因此低估了风化作用的速率，同时也低估了风化作用对大气CO2沉降的贡献。另一方面，也表明了研究自然界不同水体中CA分布及其活度和CA在自然界风化作用中的作用的必要性。     

珠江流域碳酸盐岩与硅酸盐岩风化对大气CO_2汇的效应

对珠江流域11个测站的河水1个水文年4次取样进行水化学和同位素测试分析,揭示无论是碳酸盐岩区还是硅酸盐岩区,岩石风化均使河流的离子成分以HCO3-、Ca2+、Mg2+为主,碳酸盐岩风化溶蚀速率和由碳酸盐岩风化溶蚀引起的大气CO2消耗量分别为27.60 mm/ka和540.21x103mol/(km2·a-1),是硅酸盐岩风化速率和由硅酸盐岩风化引起的大气CO2消耗量的10.8倍和6.7倍,说明碳酸盐岩风化是流域碳汇过程及效应的主体。由于有利的水热条件和高的碳酸盐岩面积比例,珠江流域平均岩石风化速率和由岩石风化作用引起的大气CO2消耗量分别为30.15mm/ka和620.36×103mol/(km2·a-1),为全球60条河流平均值的2.6倍。     

硫酸型酸雨参与碳酸盐岩溶蚀的研究进展

碳酸盐岩的H2CO3溶蚀产生岩溶碳汇,占整个岩石风化碳汇的 94%。西南岩溶区硫酸型酸雨严重,硫酸型酸雨广泛参与碳酸盐岩的溶蚀。H2SO4参与的碳酸盐岩风化是一个大气CO2净释放过程,具有减汇作用巨大。另一方面,岩溶区石灰土壤和地下水具有较高的pH值及盐基饱和度,对H+有巨大的缓冲作用,大气酸沉降在碳酸盐岩地区可能并不会造成地下水的HCO3-和pH降低;相反,较高浓度的SO42-所产生的盐效应和SO2-4与各种阳离子形成的离子对会增大方解石、白云石溶解度,可增强H2CO3对碳酸盐的溶蚀,这可能会使岩溶作用产生更大的碳汇效应。因此,硫酸型酸雨参与碳酸盐岩风化的减汇效应不仅可能被高估,硫酸型酸雨还可能增强碳酸盐岩的H2CO3溶蚀,具有增加岩溶碳汇效应的作用。应结合石灰土壤对大气酸沉降的缓冲容量和阈值及大气酸沉降的H+与土壤中盐基离子的交换量,并综合考虑盐效应、离子对作用、同离子效应,客观评价硫酸型酸雨流经石灰土壤层后对碳酸盐岩溶蚀吸收大气/土壤CO2的影响      

Comparative study of dissolution rate-determining mechanisms of limestone and dolomite

The dissolution rate-determining processes of carbonate rocks include: (1) heterogeneous reactions on rock surfaces; (2) mass transport of ions into solution from rock surfaces via diffusion; and (3) the conversion reaction of CO₂ into H⁺ and HCO ₃ ⁻ . Generally, it is the slowest of these three processes that limits the dissolution rate of carbonate rock. However, from experiment and theoretical analysis under similar conditions not only were the initial dissolution rates of dolomite lower by a factor of 3–60 than those of limestone, but also there are different dissolution rate-determining mechanisms between limestone and dolomite. For example, for limestone under the condition of CO₂ partial pressures dissolution rates increased significantly by a factor of about ten after addition of carbonic anhydrase (CA) into solution, which catalysed the conversation reaction of CO₂, whereas CA had little influence on dolomite dissolution. For dolomite, the increase of dissolution rate after addition of CA into solution appeared at Moreover, the enhancement factor of CA on dolomite dissolution rate was much lower (by a factor of about 3). In addition, when dissolution of both limestone and dolomite was determined by hydrodynamics (rotation speed or flow speed), especially under the dissolution of limestone was more sensitive to hydrodynamic change than that of dolomite. These findings are of significance in understanding the differences in karstification and relevant problems of resource and environment in dolomite and limestone areas.     

Effect of Farmyard Manure Application on Dissolution of Carbonate Rocks and Its Eco-environmental Impact

A much improved understanding of how farmyard manure application may affect carbonate rock dissolution is needed in order to predict possible feedbacks between the rock carbon cycle and the global climate system. Two carbonate mineral rock tablets; dolomite and limestone were buried at six depths between 0 and 110 cm in a soil typical of the subtropical karst area in Guiyang City, Guizhou Province. The extent of tablet dissolution, soil CO2, soil pH, soil water content, soil mineral and chemical composition, and chemical composition of soil water were tested in order to assess the degree of dissolution under manure application over the course of one year. The results show that manure addition decreases the dissolution rate of carbonate rocks; limestone and dolomite by between 11.7%-116.9% and 25.0%-65.69% respectively, with the dissolution rate of limestone consistently exceeding that of dolomite under the same conditions. Our data indicates that the rate of pedogenesis of the dolomite and limestone rocks is decreased as much as 35.77% and 59.41% respectively, as a result of manure application. Moreover, the results suggest that manure application accelerated the generation of soil CO2, with soil CO2 concentration increasing on average by 93.94%, and the CO2 flux increasing by 67.64% compared with the control profile. Finally, the data also indicates that manure decreases CO2 uptake by dissolution of carbonate rocks by 25.50%-39.45% on a Guiyang city scale. The counteraction of the CO2 sink contributed by karst water due to farmyard manure utilization in general karst area (both dolomite and limestone) however was 59.41%-62.72%, indicating the application of manure successfully reduces both dissolution and CO2 release to the atmosphere.

     

我国南方岩溶区和北方黄土区的大气CO2效应

我国南方岩溶区与北方黄土区都是巨大的碳库。碳酸盐的溶蚀及再结晶是两个碳库与大气ＣＯ２交换的重要过程;碳的区域平衡是评价化学风化消耗或逸散ＣＯ２的基础,岩溶区与黄土区在地球化学风化的环境背景。溶蚀过程,产物运移和归宿等差异很大。黄土区化学风化消耗大气ＣＯ２通量较岩溶区小。目前评价两类地区土壤与大气ＣＯ２的源汇关系尚不成熟,需要定量认识土壤ＣＯ２与下伏碳酸盐岩溶蚀或与下伏黄土次生碳酸盐化作用。岩溶区湖     

Impact of animal manure addition on the weathering of agricultural lime in acidic soils: The agent of carbonate weathering

Fertilization and aglime (agricultural lime) application, as important agricultural activities in acid soil, exert an influence on the fluxes of carbon both between and within ecosystems. Animal manure added to soil can elevate the soil CO2 and release organic acid due to microbial decomposition of the high organic matter content of animal manure. Additionally, the elevated CO2 can accelerate carbonate weathering in alkaline soil, such as lime soil. However, in acidic soil, it is unclear whether the chemical weathering of additive aglime can be quickened by the elevated CO2 due to animal manure addition. Thus, to ascertain the impact of animal manure addition on aglime weathering in acidic soil and to understand the weathering agent of aglime or underlying carbonate in the acidic soil profile, we established two contrasting profiles (control profile and manurial profile) in a cabbage-corn or capsicum-corn rotation in a field experiment site located in the HuaXi district of Guiyang, China, and buried carbonate rock tablets at different depths of soil profiles to calculate the dissolution rate of carbonate rock by monitoring the weights of the tablets. The results indicated that soil CO2 increased due to animal manure addition, but the rate of dissolution of the carbonate rock tablets was reduced, which was attributed to the increase in the pH in acidic soil after animal manure addition because the relationship between the dissolution rate of carbonate rock and soil pH indicated that the weathering rate of carbonate rock was controlled by pH and not by CO2 in acidic soil. Thus, the contribution of H+ ions (mainly exchangeable acid) in acid soil as a weathering agent to the weathering of underlying carbonate (and/or aglime) may lead to the overestimation of the CO2 consumption through chemical weathering at the regional/global scale using hydro-chemical methods.     

Contribution of carbonate rock weathering to the atmospheric CO2 sink

To accurately predict future CO₂ levels in the atmosphere, which is crucial in predicting global climate change, the sources and sinks of the atmospheric CO₂ and their change over time must be determined. In this paper, some typical cases are examined using published and unpublished data. Firstly, the sensitivity of carbonate rock weathering (including the effects by both dissolution and reprecipitation of carbonate) to the change of soil CO₂ and runoff will be discussed, and then the net amount of CO₂ removed from the atmosphere in the carbonate rock areas of mainland China and the world will be determined by the hydrochem-discharge and carbonate-rock-tablet methods, to obtain an estimate of the contribution of carbonate rock weathering to the atmospheric CO₂ sink. These contributions are about 0.018 billion metric tons of carbon/a and 0.11 billion metric tons of carbon/a for China and the world, respectively. Further, by the DBL (Diffusion Boundary Layer)-model calculation, the potential CO₂ sink by carbonate rock dissolution is estimated to be 0.41 billion metric tons of carbon/a for the world. Therefore, the potential CO₂ source by carbonate reprecipitation is 0.3 billion metric tons of carbon/a. Received: 12 May 1999 · Accepted: 16 August 1999     

施用农肥对岩溶溶蚀作用的影响及其生态环境意义

土壤下伏碳酸盐岩溶蚀作用研究对岩溶区成土作用及大气中CO_2影响意义重大.施肥改变了土壤的生物地球化学场,进而会影响岩溶区的岩溶动力学过程及碳循环.本文在贵州贵阳碳酸盐岩土壤剖面不同深度,埋设白云石、石灰石试片,进行了野外溶蚀试验,观测了试片溶蚀量、土壤CO_2、土壤pH及其他如土壤含水量、土壤矿物与化学成分、土壤水化学成分等影响凶素.结果表明:(1)施用农家肥降低了碳酸盐岩的溶蚀速率:石灰石的溶蚀速率降低了10.48%～53.90%.平均25.51%;白云石的溶蚀速率降低了25.0%～65.69%,平均39.45%.同样条件下土壤中石灰石溶蚀量比白云石大.(2)施用农家肥降低了当地的碳酸盐岩成土速度,降低了35.77%～37.27%.(3)施肥土壤更利于CO_2的产生:施肥剖面土壤中CO_2浓度比空白剖面CO_2浓度高22.52%～198.87%,平均高93.94%;施肥剖面地面CO_2通量比空白剖面地面CO_通量高67.64%.(4)施用农家肥减少了土壤对大气CO_2的沉降量,在贵州贵阳地区,减少的大气CO_2沉降量为25.50%～39.45%;间接地对岩溶水CO_2汇的作用产生了抵消作用,在贵州贵阳地区,抵消作用为59.41%～62.73%.     

岩溶试片的岩性差异对估算岩溶速率和碳通量的影响

研究岩性差异对溶蚀速率的影响有助于提高溶蚀试片法估算岩溶碳汇强度的精确度。本文以贵州省普定县为研究区,将埋放地的主要基岩类型（石灰岩与白云岩）制成标准尺寸的试片,并将其埋设于不同土地利用类型和土壤深度下,经过4个水文年的监测后将估算的结果与前人在同一区域使用标准溶蚀试片的研究结果进行对比分析,结果表明:（1）在相同气候和土壤环境条件下,岩性对溶蚀试片的溶蚀速率有显著影响,且溶蚀速率与岩石中CaO含量呈正相关关系,与MgO含量呈负相关关系;（2）石灰岩与白云岩试片溶蚀速率的差异程度受土地利用及埋放深度的调控,整体上石灰岩溶蚀速率比白云岩溶蚀速率大14%;（3）不同岩性试片估算的岩溶碳汇强度相差较大,标准溶蚀试片估算的结果比埋放地基岩试片估算的结果高。故使用溶蚀试片法估算区域岩溶碳通量时应考虑埋放地基岩的岩性,或者对基于标准溶蚀试片的估算结果进行校正,才能准确反映区域尺度真实的岩溶碳通量大小。      

Dissolution and Deformation Characteristics of Limestones Containing Different Calcite and Dolomite Content Induced by CO2-Water-Rock Interaction

To investigate the impacts of mineral composition on physical and mechanical properties of carbonate rocks, limestone specimens containing different contents in calcite and dolomite are selected to perform CO2-water-rock reaction experiments. The X-ray Diffraction (XRD) and Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) are carried out to examine the change characteristics of mineral dissolution and pore structure after reaction. The core flooding experiments with Fiber Bragg gratings are implemented to examine the stress sensitivity of carbonate rocks. The results show that the limestones containing pure calcite are more susceptible to acid dissolution compared to limestone containing impure dolomite. The calcite content in pure limestone decreases as the reaction undergoes. The dissolution of dolomite leads to the formation of calcite in impure limestone. Calcite dissolution leads to the formation of macropore and flow channels in pure limestone, while the effects of impure dolomite in impure limestone results in mesopore formation. When confining pressure is lower than 12 MPa, pure limestones demonstrate higher strain sensitivity coefficients compared to impure limestone containing dolomite after reaction. When confining pressure exceeds 12 MPa, the strain sensitivity coefficients of both pure and impure limestones become almost equal.     

土地利用变化对典型碳酸盐岩流域风化碳汇的影响——以云南小江岩溶流域研究为例

地球陆地岩石的风化过程要消耗大气或土壤中的CO2,成为大气CO2巨大的汇。以中国云南小江流域为例,研究了典型岩溶地区碳酸盐岩风化吸收CO2(碳汇)强度与土地利用变化之间的关系。选择了有代表性的12块土地及其利用变化的25个地下水监测点,分析了1982年、2003年这些监测点的600多组地下水化学监测数据。12块土地利用变化中,有4块为林地变耕地,3块未利用地变耕地,4块未利用地变林地,1块为林地变建设用地。研究结果表明:首先,土地利用变化后,地下水化学成分变化极大;第二,将风化过程中吸收大气或土壤中CO2的那部分C(用HCO3-表示)与整个风化过程中参与风化的全部C的百分比,定义为碳酸盐岩化学风化对土壤或大气CO2吸收强度(简写为CIS,%),推出了计算式子为CIS(%)=100×[1-(Ca2++Mg2+)total waters)/HCO3-total waters]。估算了4种土地利用类型从1982年到2003年22年间CIS的变化值。结果是,(1)林地的CIS比未利用地高,前者为48.84%,后者47.66%;(2)未利用地转变为耕地后,CIS平均减少了7.85%;林地转变为耕地后,CIS平均减少了8.59%;林地转变为建设用地后,CIS平均减少了1.66%,而未利用地转变为林地后,CIS平均增加了1.74%。(3)讨论了土地利用变化对CIS的影响机理,如未利用地或林地变为耕地后,(NH4)2PO4、CO(NH2)2、NH4NO3、(NH4)2SO4等氮肥的大量使用,硝化后产生的硝酸等干扰或抵消了碳酸对碳酸盐岩化学风化作用,导致了岩溶地下水中Ca2+,Mg2+离子的相对增多,HCO3-离子相对减少,促使CIS减小。     

外源水和外源酸对万华岩地下河系统岩溶碳汇效应的影响

流域的岩石化学风化过程是全球碳循环中的重要环节。近年来流域水化学碳汇通量估算已越来越多地关注到外源水(硅酸盐风化)及外源酸对全球碳循环的影响。文章选取万华岩地下河流域为研究区,流域硅酸盐岩和碳酸盐岩分布面积占比为64%和36%,于2017年对洞口进行为期一年的取样监测,并分别于4月和9月对万华岩地下河系统内13个水点的离子组成进行监测,利用水化学平衡法和Galy模型,对流域岩石化学风化速率和CO2消耗通量进行了计算,对万华岩地下河系统的岩石风化和碳循环过程进行了分析。结果表明,万华岩地下河系统岩石风化消耗CO2的速率为31.02 t·(km2·a)-1;以碳酸岩风化为主,其风化速率为硅酸盐溶蚀的20倍;流域内碳酸盐岩风化对CO2消耗量占到整个流域的92.16%;不同岩石风化类型对碳通量的贡献率以碳酸溶解碳酸盐岩最大,为87.06%;流域上游的外源水对岩溶碳汇具有巨大的促进作用,外源水汇入后碳酸盐岩碳汇速率可以达到无外源水汇入流域的2倍;硫酸溶解碳酸盐岩次之,为9.24%;碳酸风化硅酸盐岩最小,为3.7%,在计算流域碳汇量的时候应将硫酸参与岩石风化的影响去除。     

龙门石窟碳酸盐岩体文物风化作用模拟试验研究

为了研究凝结水对龙门石窟碳酸盐岩表面的风化作用机理,在现场进行凝结水观测、CO2浓度监测的基础上,利用自行研制、能模拟现场温湿度环境、能提供CO2外部来源,并能对反应过程进行监控的室内模拟试验装置系统对石窟碳酸盐岩风化作用进行模拟实验。实验结果表明,凝结水会造成碳酸盐岩表面的溶解,在CO2加入的条件下风化效果加剧,岩石的质量损失和孔隙率同时增大。经过78次的模拟试验后,灰岩岩样质量损失率为0.077%~0.088%,孔隙率由实验前的0.39%~0.40%增长到0.71%~0.74%;白云岩岩样的质量损失率为0.032%~0.038%,孔隙率由实验前的0.61%~0.68%增长为0.77%~0.85%;灰岩和白云岩的平均溶蚀深度分别为89.475μm和36.865μm,溶蚀速度分别为0.0956μm/h和0.0575μm/h,风化溶蚀作用对龙门石窟文物的影响破坏较大。      

重庆南山老龙洞地下河流域岩溶地下水DIC和δ13CDIC及其流域碳汇变化特征

以重庆南山老龙洞岩溶地下河流域为例,通过分析地下河水DIC变化特征与来源,估算了流域岩溶碳汇通量,并探讨了自然条件和人类活动对岩溶碳汇的影响。研究结果表明,老龙洞地下河的水化学类型为Ca-HCO3-SO4型,显示其形成过程中受碳酸盐岩碳酸溶蚀和硫酸溶蚀共同控制。地下河水DIC浓度为3.1~6.3mmol/L,其中夏季因受降雨稀释作用影响DIC较冬季的低;地下河水δ13CDIC值介于-3.8‰~-13.1‰之间,且夏季比冬季偏高约2‰。根据地下河水DIC浓度和流域径流量计算出流域岩溶净碳汇通量均值约为167.31×103mol/(km2?a)。降雨条件下,流域岩溶碳汇通量随流域径流量的迅速增加而增加。另外,流域碳酸盐岩溶蚀还受到人类活动产生的硫酸型酸雨影响,使得地下水δ13CDIC值相对偏高,它在一定程度上减少了流域碳汇通量。      

Atmospheric CO2 sink: Silicate weathering or carbonate weathering?

It is widely accepted that chemical weathering of Ca–silicate rocks could potentially control long-term climate change by providing feedback interaction with atmospheric CO₂ drawdown by means of precipitation of carbonate, and that in contrast weathering of carbonate rocks has not an equivalent impact because all of the CO₂ consumed in the weathering process is returned to the atmosphere by the comparatively rapid precipitation of carbonates in the oceans. Here, it is shown that the rapid kinetics of carbonate dissolution and the importance of small amounts of carbonate minerals in controlling the dissolved inorganic C (DIC) of silicate watersheds, coupled with aquatic photosynthetic uptake of the weathering-related DIC and burial of some of the resulting organic C, suggest that the atmospheric CO₂ sink from carbonate weathering may previously have been underestimated by a factor of about 3, amounting to 0.477 Pg C/a. This indicates that the contribution of silicate weathering to the atmospheric CO₂ sink may be only 6%, while the other 94% is by carbonate weathering. Therefore, the atmospheric CO₂ sink by carbonate weathering might be significant in controlling both the short-term and long-term climate changes. This questions the traditional point of view that only chemical weathering of Ca–silicate rocks potentially controls long-term climate change.     

碳酸盐岩的声波特性研究及其应用

基于岩溶地区碳酸盐岩试样室内声波测试分析发现: ( 1)泥质灰岩和角砾状灰岩的波速比普通灰岩、灰质白云岩比一般白云岩和角砾白云岩的高。( 2)灰岩的声波、密度略大于白云岩的声波、密度,灰岩的动弹性模量、剪切模量和体积模量也比白云岩大。( 3)溶蚀程度和微小结构面对碳酸盐岩中波的传播速度影响较大,灰岩波速随风化程度的提高而降低。( 4)纵、横波速与岩石的密度具有线性关系,利用密度、波速、纵横波速比或泊松比可初步判断碳酸盐岩在岩性上的差别。( 5)声波测试和单轴抗压强度试验求得的岩石的弹性模量具有一定的相关性,利用声波测试结果可以推求实际工程中计算、设计所需的力学参数。      

碳酸盐风化碳汇与森林碳汇的对比——碳汇研究思路和方法变革的必要性

目前,全球碳循环研究主要集中在海洋碳汇以及陆地土壤和植被碳汇,而对岩石风化碳汇仅考虑地质长时间尺度的硅酸盐风化作用,而认为碳酸盐风化在长时间尺度上对碳汇无贡献。然而,碳酸盐相对于硅酸盐有快得多的溶解速度,且对全球变化(特别是气候和CO2变化)的响应迅速,同时由于生物作用和人为活动的影响,使得碳酸盐风化碳汇的能力需要重新评价。最新的研究发现,由碳酸盐溶解、全球水循环及水生生物光合利用溶解无机碳共同作用,即水-岩-气-生相互作用形成的大气碳汇,远远大于之前只估计了河流输运的无机碳汇,其量级与森林碳汇量相当,因此有必要对传统的碳汇研究思路和方法进行某些变革,这有可能为解决所谓的全球“碳失汇”问题找到一条出路。      

不同土地利用类型下土壤碳酸酐酶剖面分异特征研究

利用pH计法来研究西南岩溶区4类土地利用类型11个样地20cm、40cm和60cm土层碳酸酐酶(Carbonic Anhydrase,CA)的剖面分异特征,并与非岩溶样地进行对比。结果表明:西南岩溶区不同土地利用类型不同土层的CA活性存在较大差异。在林地中,40cm和60cm土层的CA活性明显高于20cm土层;而在乔灌丛、灌丛和耕地中,土壤CA活性表现出60cm土层处最高,20cm土层处最低,并与弃耕地不同土壤层CA活性变化趋势截然相反,这是因为弃耕地受人类活动干扰导致土壤CA活性出现逆转。进一步分析还可以看出林地、乔灌丛、灌丛和耕地4种土地利用类型下土壤CA活性总体呈现出随植物根系深度增加而增加的变化趋势,从而说明土地利用类型是导致土壤碳酸酐酶剖面产生分异的主要因素,并为进一步研究土壤CA在自然界碳酸盐岩风化过程中的作用提供了科学依据。     

基于室内试验的四川峨眉—汉源高速廖山隧道碳酸盐岩溶蚀特征分析

廖山隧道是峨汉高速的控制性工程之一,隧址区岩溶地质条件复杂,为了深入研究隧址区碳酸盐岩的溶蚀特征,文章以隧址区中生界三叠系中统雷口坡组典型白云质灰岩、灰岩及钙质泥岩试样为研究对象,开展静态溶蚀试验,定量分析了碳酸盐岩溶蚀速率特征及相关影响因素,最后定性探讨了扫描电镜下试样溶蚀过程的微观结构变化。结果表明:（1）试验条件下（20 ℃、1 atm、乙酸溶液、pH=5.30、静态溶蚀）,隧址区雷口坡组灰岩溶蚀速率约3.48 mm/a,白云质灰岩溶蚀速率约1.57 mm/a,钙质泥岩溶蚀速率约0.90 mm/a;（2）碳酸盐岩的溶蚀受矿物组分及溶蚀环境控制,相同溶蚀环境下,溶蚀速率与方解石含量呈正相关,与白云石含量及溶蚀介质PH值呈负相关,总体上具有灰岩>白云质灰岩>钙质泥岩的特征;（3）有机酸与无机酸环境下灰岩溶蚀速率差异不大,总体趋势相同,而中性盐溶液与碱性环境则对灰岩溶蚀起到不同程度的抑制作用;（4）碳酸盐岩具有优先沿矿物成分、岩石微结构选择性溶蚀的特征,主要矿物含量的不同也使得碳酸盐岩的微观溶蚀过程存在一定差异。