Reply to comment by J. Trampert

Books Reviewed in this Article:
Seismic tomography and mantle circulation Eds O'Nions, R. K. & Parsons, B., Royal Society of London Special Publication , 1989, ISBN 0854 033823.     

Reply to comment by J. L. Mateos, O. Novaro, T. H. Seligman and J. Flores on 'Can horizontal P waves be trapped and resonate in a shallow sedimentary basin?'

Using a complete mathematical formulation, we show that the trapping of horizontal P waves in a very soft shallow alluvial layer is a minor effect. These waves do not have a stable way of propagation since in order to exist they require an incident wave and are therefore incapable of resonating in the lateral direction when confined in a basin of limited extent.