Measuring Ω0 using cluster evolution

The evolution of the abundance of galaxy clusters depends sensitively on the value of the cosmological density parameter, Ω₀. Recent ASCA data are used to quantify this evolution as measured by the cluster X-ray temperature function. A χ² minimization fit to the cumulative temperature function, as well as a maximum-likelihood estimate (which requires additional assumptions about cluster luminosities), leads to the estimate Ω₀ ≈ 0.45 ± 0.25 (1σ statistical error). Various systematic uncertainties are considered, none of which significantly enhances the probability that Ω₀ = 1. These conclusions hold for models with or without a cosmological constant, i.e., with Λ₀ = 0 or Λ₀ = 1 − Ω₀. The statistical uncertainties are at least as large as any of the individual systematic errors that have been considered here, suggesting that additional temperature measurements of distant clusters will allow an improvement in this estimate. An alternative method that uses the highest redshift clusters to place an upper limit on Ω₀ is also presented and tentatively applied, with the result that Ω₀  1 can be ruled out at the 98 per cent confidence level. Whilst this method does not require a well-defined statistical sample of distant clusters, there are still modelling uncertainties that preclude a firmer conclusion at this time.     

Revisiting the baryon fractions of galaxy clusters: a comparison with WMAP 3-yr results

The universal baryonic mass fraction  (Ω_b/Ω_m)  can be sensitively constrained using X-ray observations of galaxy clusters. In this paper, we compare the baryonic mass fraction inferred from measurements of the cosmic microwave background with the gas mass fractions ( f _gas) of a large sample of clusters taken from the recent literature. In systems cooler than 4 keV, f _gas declines as the system temperature decreases. However, in higher temperature systems, f _gas( r ₅₀₀) converges to  ≈(0.12 ± 0.02)( h /0.72)^−1.5  , where the uncertainty reflects the systematic variations between clusters at r ₅₀₀. This is significantly lower than the maximum-likelihood value of the baryon fraction from the recently released Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe ( WMAP ) 3-yr results. We investigate possible reasons for this discrepancy, including the effects of radiative cooling and non-gravitational heating, and conclude that the most likely solution is that Ω_m is higher than the best-fitting WMAP value (we find  Ω_m= 0.36^+0.11_−0.08  ), but consistent at the 2σ level. Degeneracies within the WMAP data require that σ₈ must also be greater than the maximum likelihood value for consistency between the data sets.     

The WARPS survey – IV. The X-ray luminosity–temperature relation of high-redshift galaxy clusters

We present a measurement of the cluster X-ray luminosity–temperature ( L – T ) relation out to high redshift ( z ∼0.8). Combined ROSAT PSPC spectra of 91 galaxy clusters detected in the Wide Angle ROSAT Pointed Survey (WARPS) are simultaneously fitted in redshift and luminosity bins. The resulting temperature and luminosity measurements of these bins, which occupy a region of the high-redshift L – T relation not previously sampled, are compared with existing measurements at low redshift in order to constrain the evolution of the L – T relation. We find the best fit to low-redshift ( z <0.2) cluster data, at T >1 keV, to be L ∝ T ^3.15±0.06. Our data are consistent with no evolution in the normalization of the L – T relation up to z ∼0.8. Combining our results with ASCA measurements taken from the literature, we find η =0.19±0.38 (for Ω₀=1, with 1 σ errors) where L _Bol∝(1+ z ) ^η T ^3.15, or η =0.60±0.38 for Ω₀=0.3. This lack of evolution is considered in terms of the entropy-driven evolution of clusters. Further implications for cosmological constraints are also discussed.     

Measuring Ω0 from the entropy evolution of clusters

In this paper we have extended the entropy-driven model of cluster evolution developed by Bower in order to be able to predict the evolution of galaxy clusters for a range of cosmological scenarios. We have applied this model to recent measurements of the evolution of the L _x− T normalization and X-ray luminosity function in order to place constraints on cosmological parameters. We find that these measurements alone do not select a particular cosmological framework. An additional constraint is required on the effective slope of the power spectrum to break the degeneracy that exists between this and the background cosmology. We therefore include a theoretical calculation of the Ω₀ dependence on the power spectrum, based on the cold dark matter paradigm, which infers Ω₀<0.55 (0.1<Ω₀<0.7 for Ω₀+Λ₀=1), at the 95 per cent confidence level. Alternatively, an independent measurement of the slope of the power spectrum from galaxy clustering requires Ω₀<0.6 (Ω₀<0.65 for Ω₀+Λ₀=1), again to 95 per cent confidence. The rate of entropy evolution is insensitive to the values of Ω₀ considered, although it is sensitive to changes in the distribution of the intracluster medium.     

Towards a precision cosmology from starburst galaxies at z > 2

This work investigates the use of a well-known empirical correlation between the velocity dispersion, metallicity and luminosity in Hβ of nearby H  ii galaxies to measure the distances to H  ii -like starburst galaxies at high redshifts. This correlation is applied to a sample of 15 starburst galaxies with redshifts between   z = 2.17  and   z = 3.39  to constrain  Ω_m  , using data available from the literature. A best-fitting value of  Ω_m= 0.21^+0.30_−0.12  in a Λ-dominated universe and of  Ω_m= 0.11^+0.37_−0.19  in an open universe is obtained. A detailed analysis of systematic errors, their causes and their effects on the values derived for the distance moduli and  Ω_m  is carried out. A discussion of how future work will improve constraints on  Ω_m  by reducing the errors is also presented.     

Constraints on cosmological and biasing models using active galactic nucleus clustering

We attempt to put constraints on different cosmological and biasing models by combining the recent clustering results of X-ray sources in the local ( z ≤0.1) and distant Universe ( z ∼1) . To this end we compare the measured angular correlation function for bright (Akylas et al.) and faint (Vikhlinin & Forman) ROSAT X-ray sources respectively with those expected in three spatially flat cosmological models. Taking into account the different functional forms of the bias evolution, we find that there are two cosmological models which match the data well. In particular, low-Ω_○ cosmological models (Ω_Λ=1−Ω_○=0.7) that contain either (i) high σ ₈^mass=1.13 value with galaxy merging bias, b ( z )∝(1+ z )^1.8 or (ii) low σ ₈^mass=0.9 with non-bias, b ( z ) ≡ 1 best reproduce the AGN clustering results, while τ CDM models with different bias behaviour are ruled out at a high significance level.     

Observations of the Sunyaev–Zel'dovich effect in the z=0.78 cluster MS 1137.5+6625

We have observed the   z =0.78  cluster MS 1137.5+6625 with the Ryle Telescope (RT) at 15 GHz. After subtraction of contaminating radio sources in the field, we find a Sunyaev–Zel'dovich flux decrement of  -421±60 μJy  on the ≈0.65 k λ baseline of the RT, spatially coincident with the optical and X-ray positions for the cluster core.
For a spherical King-profile cluster model, the best fit to our flux measurement has a core radius   θ _C=20 arcsec  , consistent with previous X-ray observations, and a central temperature decrement  Δ T =650±92 μK  .
Using this model, we calculate that the cluster has a gas mass inside a     radius of  2.9×10¹³ M_⊙  for an  Ω _M =1  universe and  1.6×10¹³ M_⊙  for  Ω _M =0.3  ,  Ω_Λ=0.7  . We compare this model with existing measurements of the total mass of the cluster, based on gravitational lensing, and estimate a gas fraction for MS 1137.5+6625 of ≈8 per cent.     

The Sunyaev–Zel'dovich effect contribution to WMAP: a cross-correlation between WMAP and ROSAT

We cross-correlate WMAP and ROSAT diffuse X-ray background maps and look for common features in both data sets. We use the power spectrum of the product maps and the cross-power spectrum to highlight a possible correlation. The power spectrum of the product maps does not detect any correlation and the cross-power spectrum does not show any significant deviation from zero. We explore different explanations for this lack of correlation. A universe with a low value of  σ₈  could naturally explain the lack of correlation. We also discuss the systematic effects that can affect this result, in particular the subtraction of some cluster signal from the ROSAT diffuse maps, which could significantly suppress the correlation signal. These systematic effects considerably reduce the significance of our constraints on the cosmological model. When we include the systematic effects, we find a weaker constraint on  σ₈  , allowing models with values as large as  σ₈= 1  (for  Ω_m= 0.3  ) to be consistent with the lack of correlation. To illustrate the capabilities of the method with future high-quality data, we show how from the correlation signal it should be possible to predict the level of contamination of the Sunyaev–Zel'dovich effect on the power spectrum of the cosmic microwave background. Within the systematic errors, we find evidence that this contribution is negligible for WMAP and is expected to be small in experiments like ACBAR or CBI, but can be important for future high-resolution experiments.     

Power-spectrum normalization from the local abundance of rich clusters of galaxies

The number density of rich galaxy clusters still provides the most robust way of normalizing the power spectrum of dark matter perturbations on scales relevant to large-scale structure. We revisit this constraint in the light of several recent developments: (1) the availability of well-defined samples of local clusters with relatively accurate X-ray temperatures; (2) new theoretical mass functions for dark matter haloes, which provide a good fit to large numerical simulations; (3) more accurate mass–temperature relations from larger catalogues of hydrodynamical simulations; (4) the requirement to consider closed as well as open and flat cosmologies to obtain full multiparameter likelihood constraints for CMB and SNe studies. We present a new sample of clusters drawn from the literature and use this sample to obtain improved results on σ ₈, the normalization of the matter power spectrum on scales of 8  h ⁻¹ Mpc, as a function of the matter density and cosmological constant in a universe with general curvature. We discuss our differences with previous work, and the remaining major sources of uncertainty. Final results on the normalization, approximately independent of power spectrum shape, can be expressed as constraints on σ at an appropriate cluster normalization scale R _Cl. We provide fitting formulas for R _Cl and σ ( R _Cl) for general cosmologies, as well as for σ ₈ as a function of cosmology and shape parameter Γ. For flat models we find approximately σ ₈≃(0.495_−0.037^+0.034)Ω_M^−0.60 for Γ=0.23, where the error bar is dominated by uncertainty in the mass–temperature relation.     

Constraining our Universe with X-ray and optical cluster data

We have used recent X-ray and optical data in order to impose some constraints on the cosmology and cluster scaling relations.
Generically, two kinds of hypotheses define our model. First, we consider that the cluster population is well described by the standard Press–Schechter (PS) formalism, and secondly, these clusters are assumed to follow scaling relations with mass: temperature–mass ( T – M ) and X-ray luminosity–mass ( L _x– M ) .
In contrast with many other authors we do not assume specific scaling relations to model cluster properties such as the usual T – M virial relation or an observational relation or an observational determination of the L _x– T relation. Instead we consider general unconstrained parameter scaling relations.
With the previous model (PS plus scalings) we fit our free parameters to several X-ray and optical data sets with the advantage over preceding works that we consider all the data sets at the same time. This prevents us from being inconsistent with some of the available observations. Among other interesting conclusions, we find that only low-density universes are compatible with all the data considered and that the degeneracy between Ω_m and σ ₈ is broken. Also we obtain interesting limits on the parameters characterizing the scaling relations.     

On the distribution of haloes, galaxies and mass

The stochasticity in the distribution of dark haloes in the cosmic density field is reflected in the distribution function   P _V ( N _h| δ _m)  , which gives the probability of finding N _h haloes in a volume V with mass density contrast δ _m. We study the properties of this function using high-resolution N -body simulations, and find that   P _V ( N _h| δ _m)  is significantly non-Poisson. The ratio between the variance and the mean goes from ∼1 (Poisson) at  1+ δ _m≪1  to <1 (sub-Poisson) at  1+ δ _m∼1  to >1 (super-Poisson) at  1+ δ _m≫1  . The mean bias relation is found to be well described by halo bias models based on the Press–Schechter formalism. The sub-Poisson variance can be explained as a result of halo exclusion, while the super-Poisson variance at high δ _m may be explained as a result of halo clustering. A simple phenomenological model is proposed to describe the behaviour of the variance as a function of δ _m. Galaxy distribution in the cosmic density field predicted by semi-analytic models of galaxy formation shows similar stochastic behaviour. We discuss the implications of the stochasticity in halo bias to the modelling of higher order moments of dark haloes and of galaxies.     

Peculiar velocities and the mean density parameter

We study the peculiar velocity field inferred from the Mark III spirals using a new method of analysis. We estimate optimal values of Tully–Fisher scatter and zero-point offset, and we derive the three-dimensional rms peculiar velocity ( σ _v ) of the galaxies in the samples analysed. We check our statistical analysis using mock catalogues derived from numerical simulations of cold dark matter (CDM) models considering measurement uncertainties and sampling variations. Our best determination for the observations is σ _v =(660±50) km s⁻¹. We use the linear theory relation between σ _v , the density parameter Ω, and the galaxy correlation function ξ ( r ) to infer the quantity     , where b is the linear bias parameter of optical galaxies and the uncertainties correspond to bootstrap resampling and an estimated cosmic variance added in quadrature. Our findings are consistent with the results of cluster abundances and redshift-space distortion of the two-point correlation function. These statistical measurements suggest a low value of the density parameter Ω∼0.4 if optical galaxies are not strongly biased tracers of mass.     

Bulk flow and shear moments of the SFI++ survey

We find the nine bulk flow and shear moments from the SFI++ survey, as well as for subsamples of group and field galaxies. We constrain the velocity power spectrum shape parameter Γ in linear theory using these moments. A likelihood function for Γ was found after marginalizing over the power spectrum amplitude  σ₈Ω^0.6_m  using constraints obtained from comparisons between redshift surveys and peculiar velocity data. We have estimated the velocity noise  σ_*  from the data since without it our results may be biased. We also performed a statistical analysis of the difference between the field and group catalogues and found that the results from each reflect the same underlying large-scale flows. We found that we can constrain the power spectrum shape parameter to be  Γ= 0.15^+0.18_−0.08  for the groups catalogue and  Γ= 0.09^+0.04_−0.04  for the field galaxy catalogue in fair agreement with the value from Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe .     

On the errors on Ω0: Monte Carlo simulations of the EMSS cluster sample

We perform Monte Carlo simulations of synthetic EMSS cluster samples, to quantify the systematic errors and the statistical uncertainties on the estimate of Ω₀ derived from fits to the cluster number density evolution and to the X-ray temperature distribution up to z =0.83 . We identify the scatter around the relation between cluster X-ray luminosity and temperature to be a source of systematic error, of the order of Δ_systΩ₀=0.09 , if not properly taken into account in the modelling. After correcting for this bias, our best Ω₀ is 0.66. The uncertainties on the shape and normalization of the power spectrum of matter fluctuations imply relatively large uncertainties on this estimate of Ω₀, of the order of Δ_statΩ₀=0.1 at the 1 σ level. On the other hand, the statistical uncertainties due to the finite size of the high-redshift sample are twice as small. Therefore, what is needed in order to improve the accuracy of Ω₀ estimates based on cluster number density evolution is a more reliable measure of the local temperature function and a better understanding of the cluster observed properties both in the local Universe and at high redshift, that is the relation between cluster mass, temperature and luminosity. This requires detailed observations of X-ray selected cluster samples, in comparison with hydrodynamic simulations including refined physics.     

Detection of OH and wide H i absorption toward B0218+357

Large-scale polarization of the cosmic microwave background measured by the WMAP satellite requires a mean optical depth to Thomson scattering,  τ_e∼ 0.17  . The reionization of the Universe must therefore have begun at relatively high redshift. We have studied the reionization process using supercomputer simulations of a large and representative region of a universe which has cosmological parameters consistent with the WMAP results (  Ω_m= 0.3, Ω_Λ= 0.7, h = 0.7, Ω_b= 0.04, n = 1  and  σ₈= 0.9  ). Our simulations follow both the radiative transfer of ionizing photons and the formation and evolution of the galaxy population which produces them. A previously published model with ionizing photon production as expected for zero-metallicity stars distributed according to a standard stellar initial mass function (IMF) (10⁶¹ photons per unit solar mass of formed stars) and with a moderate photon escape fraction from galaxies (5 per cent), produces  τ_e= 0.104  , which is within 1.0 to  1.5σ  of the 'best' WMAP value. Values of up to 0.16 can be produced by taking larger escape fractions or a top-heavy IMF. The data do not require a separate populations of 'miniquasars' or of stars forming in objects with total masses below  10⁹ M_⊙  . Reconciling such early reionization with the observed Gunn–Peterson troughs in   z > 6  quasars may be challenging. Possible resolutions of this problem are discussed.     

The black hole mass–stellar velocity dispersion correlation: bulges versus pseudo-bulges

We investigate the correlation between the supermassive black holes (SMBHs) mass ( M _bh) and the stellar velocity dispersion  (σ_*)  in two types of host galaxies: the early-type bulges (disc galaxies with classical bulges or elliptical galaxies) and pseudo-bulges. In the form  log ( M _bh/M_⊙) =α+β log (σ_*/200 km s⁻¹)  , the best-fitting results for the 39 early-type bulges are the slope  β= 4.06 ± 0.28  and the normalization  α= 8.28 ± 0.05  ; the best-fitting results for the nine pseudo-bulges are  β= 4.5 ± 1.3  and  α= 7.50 ± 0.18  . Both relations have intrinsic scatter in  log  M _bh  of ≲0.27 dex. The   M _bh–σ_*  relation for pseudo-bulges is different from the relation in the early-type bulges over the 3σ significance level. The contrasting relations indicate the formation and growth histories of SMBHs depend on their host type. The discrepancy between the slope of the   M _bh–σ_*  relations using different definition of velocity dispersion vanishes in our sample, a uniform slope will constrain the coevolution theories of the SMBHs and their host galaxies more effectively. We also find the slope for the 'core' elliptical galaxies at the high-mass range of the relation appears steeper  (β≃ 5–6)  , which may be the imprint of their origin of dissipationless mergers.     

H 0 from an orientation-unbiased sample of Sunyaev–Zel'dovich and X-ray clusters

We have observed the Sunyaev–Zel'dovich (SZ) effect in a sample of five moderate-redshift clusters with the Ryle Telescope, and used them in conjunction with X-ray imaging and spectral data from ROSAT and ASCA to measure the Hubble constant. This sample was chosen with a strict X-ray flux limit using both the Bright Cluster Sample and the Northern ROSAT All-Sky Survey (RASS) cluster catalogues to be well above the surface brightness limit of the RASS, and hence to be unbiased with respect to the orientation of the cluster. This controls a major potential systematic effect in the SZ/X-ray method of measuring H ₀. Taking the weighted geometric mean of the results and including the main sources of error, namely the noise in the SZ measurement, the uncertainty in the X-ray temperatures and the unknown ellipticity and substructure of the clusters, we find   H ₀= 59⁺¹⁰₋₉ (random)⁺⁸₋₇(systematic) km s⁻¹ Mpc⁻¹  assuming a standard cold dark matter model with  Ω_M= 1.0, Ω_Λ= 0.0  or   H ₀= 66⁺¹¹₋₁₀ ⁺⁹₋₈ km  s⁻¹ Mpc⁻¹  if  Ω_M= 0.3, Ω_Λ= 0.7  .     

Cosmological parameters from velocities, cosmic microwave background and supernovae

We compare and combine likelihood functions of the cosmological parameters Ω_m, h and σ ₈, from peculiar velocities, cosmic microwave background (CMB) and type Ia supernovae. These three data sets directly probe the mass in the Universe, without the need to relate the galaxy distribution to the underlying mass via a 'biasing' relation. We include the recent results from the CMB experiments BOOMERANG and MAXIMA-1. Our analysis assumes a flat Λ cold dark matter (ΛCDM) cosmology with a scale-invariant adiabatic initial power spectrum and baryonic fraction as inferred from big-bang nucleosynthesis. We find that all three data sets agree well, overlapping significantly at the 2 σ level. This therefore justifies a joint analysis, in which we find a joint best-fitting point and 95 per cent confidence limits of     (0.17,0.39),     (0.64,0.86) and     (0.98,1.37). In terms of the natural parameter combinations for these data     (0.40,0.73),     (0.16,0.27). Also for the best-fitting point,     and the age of the Universe is 13.2 Gyr.     

Cosmological parameters and cosmic topology

Geometry constrains but does not dictate the topology of the three-dimensional space. In a locally spatially homogeneous and isotropic universe, however, the topology of its spatial section dictates its geometry. We show that, besides determining the geometry, the knowledge of the spatial topology through the circles-in-the-sky offers an effective way of setting constraints on the density parameters associated with dark matter (Ω_m) and dark energy  (Ω_Λ)  . By assuming the Poincaré dodecahedral space as the circles-in-the-sky detectable topology of the spatial sections of the Universe, we re-analyse the constraints on the density parametric plane  Ω_m–Ω_Λ  from the current Type Ia supernova plus X-ray gas mass fraction data, and show that a circles-in-the sky detection of the dodecahedral space topology gives rise to strong and complementary constraints on the region of the density parameter plane currently allowed by these observational data sets.