Thermodynamic and kinetic constraints on reaction rates among minerals and aqueous solutions. III. Activated complexes and the pH-dependence of the rates of feldspar,pyroxene, wollastonite,and olivine hydrolysis

The stoichiometries of activated complexes responsible for controlling the kinetics of mineral dissolution can be inferred from experimental rate data. Constraints are provided by adsorption equilibria, surface ion exchange reactions, and the pH-dependence of the steady-state rates of surface detachment. Adsorption equilibria may lead to accelerated or decelerated rates of hydrolysis due to formation of surface species. They may also result in pH-independent dissolution rates at low pH as a consequence of hydrogen ion surface saturation. Surface exchange reactions of H⁺ or H₃O⁺ for M(2) site cations in pyroxenes, Ca²⁺ in wollastonite, and alkali cations in feldspars go essentially to completion for dissolution in solutions that are appreciably undersaturated with respect to the reactant mineral. The rate of surface exchange is proportional to the fraction of exchangeable cations on the reacting surface, which leads to an integrated exponential relation for mass transfer as a function of time. The independence of detachment rates on the degree of surface exchange indicates approximately equivalent formation of activated complexes at both exchanged and unexchanged sites. The degree of hydration or protonation of activated complexes formed from surface species at active sites can be inferred from the dependence of the steady-state hydrolysis rates on pH.     

Association of dissolved aluminum with silica: Connecting molecular structure to surface reactivity using NMR

We studied uptake mechanisms for dissolved Al on amorphous silica by combining bulk-solution chemistry experiments with solid-state Nuclear Magnetic Resonance techniques (²⁷Al magic-angle spinning (MAS) NMR, ²⁷Al{¹H} cross-polarization (CP) MAS NMR and ²⁹Si{¹H} CP-MAS NMR). We find that reaction of Al (1 mM) with amorphous silica consists of at least three reaction pathways; (1) adsorption of Al to surface silanol sites, (2) surface-enhanced precipitation of an aluminum hydroxide, and (3) bulk precipitation of an aluminosilicate phase. From the NMR speciation and water chemistry data, we calculate that 0.20 (±0.04) tetrahedral Al atoms nm⁻² sorb to the silica surface. Once the surface has sorbed roughly half of the total dissolved Al (∼8% site coverage), aluminum hydroxides and aluminosilicates precipitate from solution. These precipitation reactions are dependent upon solution pH and total dissolved silica concentration. We find that the Si:Al stoichiometry of the aluminosilicate precipitate is roughly 1:1 and suggest a chemical formula of NaAlSiO₄ in which Na⁺ acts as the charge compensating cation. For the adsorption of Al, we propose a surface-controlled reaction mechanism where Al sorbs as an inner-sphere coordination complex at the silica surface. Analogous to the hydrolysis of , we suggest that rapid deprotonation by surface hydroxyls followed by dehydration of ligated waters results in four-coordinate (>SiOH)₂Al(OH)₂ sites at the surface of amorphous silica.     

The effect of Al(OH)4 on the dissolution rate of quartz

The influence of Al(OH)₄⁻ on the dissolution rate of quartz at pH 10-13 and 59-89 °C was determined using batch experiments. Al(OH)₄⁻ at concentrations below gibbsite solubility depressed the dissolution rate by as much as 85%, and this effect was greater at lower pH and higher Al(OH)₄⁻ concentration. Dissolution rates increased with increasing temperature; however, the percent decrease in rate due to the presence of Al(OH)₄⁻ was invariant with temperature for a given H⁺ activity and Al(OH)₄⁻ concentration. These data, along with what is known about Al-Si interactions at high pH, are consistent with Al(OH)₄⁻ and Na⁺ co-adsorbing on silanol sites and passivating the surrounding quartz surface. The observed pH dependence, and lack of temperature dependence, of inferred Al(OH)₄⁻ sorption also supports the assumption that the acid-base behavior of the surface silanol groups has only a small temperature dependence in this range. A Langmuir-type adsorption model was used to express the degree of rate depression for a given in situ pH and Al(OH)₄⁻ concentration. Incorporation of the rate data in the absence of aluminate into models that assume a first-order dependence of the rate on the fraction of deprotonated silanol sites was unsuccessful. However, the data are consistent with the hypothesis proposed in the literature that two dissolution mechanisms may be operative in alkaline solutions: nucleophilic attack of water on siloxane bonds catalyzed by the presence of a deprotonated silanol group and OH⁻ attack catalyzed by the presence of a neutral silanol group. The data support the dominance of the second mechanism at higher pH and temperature.     

B NMR investigation of boron interaction with mineral surfaces: Results for boehmite, silica gel and illite

Boron is an important micronutrient for plants but is toxic at high pore solution concentrations. Its mobility and migration in many geochemical environments is often controlled by reactions with mineral surfaces, and thus its speciation on mineral surfaces has been extensively investigated. Most previous studies have used IR spectroscopy to characterize the surface B-environments. We present here the first ¹¹B MAS NMR study of surface sorbed boron on minerals. The results demonstrate the capability of this method to effectively probe the local structure of the sorption sites at total B-concentrations in the samples as small as 0.03 wt% and to provide insight into the mechanisms of sorption. Signal is readily resolved for both trigonal (B(3)) and tetrahedral (B(4)) boron exchanged onto boehmite, silica gel and illite, and the resonances are readily assigned on the basis of chemical shift and quadrupole coupling constant. Boron surface densities on illite are approximately order of magnitude greater than on silica gel or boehmite. For boehmite, both B(3) and B(4) occur dominantly as inner-sphere complexes formed by ligand exchange reaction with surface aluminol sites. The B(3)/[B(3) + B(4)] ratio of approximately 0.87 does not vary significantly with pH from 3 to 11, with solution B-concentration, or with washing. The occurrence of B(3) and B(4) as inner-sphere complexes is in agreement with previous suggestions from IR studies of B-sorption on iron hydroxide, allophone, kaolinite, and hydrous ferric oxide. For silica gel, B(3) and B(4) occur principally as outer-sphere complexes or as residual precipitate from un-removed solution. The B(3)/B(4) ratio decreases with increasing pH paralleling the speciation in solution, but the relative abundance of B(4) is greater than in solution. A small fraction of the B(4) occurs as inner-sphere complexes with B(4)-O-Si linkages formed by ligand exchange reaction with silanol sites. For illite, surface boron occurs as outer-sphere B(3) and B(4), as for silica gel, and as inner-sphere B(3) and B(4), as for boehmite. Outer-sphere B(3) and B(4) are dominant at pH 3 and 5, whereas inner-sphere B(3) and B(4) are dominant at pH 9 and 11. The inner-sphere complexes probably form dominantly by ligand exchange reactions involving sites on the broken edges of illite layers.     

Solid-liquid interfacial reaction of Zn ions on the surface of amorphous aluminosilicates with various Al/Si ratios

The adsorption behavior of Zn²⁺ ions onto the surface of amorphous aluminosilicates was studied using both potentiometric and spectroscopic methods (XANES: X-ray Absorption Near-Edge Structure). The aluminosilicates were prepared with different Al/Si ratios in order to compare the reactivities of surface aluminol and silanol groups toward Zn²⁺ ions. Potentiometric experiments were performed by maintaining the reacting suspensions at constant pH, ionic strength, and solid concentration, while Zn concentration was increased by stepwise addition. Our results showed that the surface aluminol and silanol groups possess significantly different reactivities toward Zn²⁺ ions. The reaction of Zn²⁺ ions with aluminol groups occurs through three processes: (i) surface complexation, (ii) dissolution, and (iii) re-sorption. A stoichiometric relationship was confirmed for the surface complexation between the aluminol groups and Zn²⁺ ions: two moles of H⁺ ions were released for one mole of Zn²⁺ ion adsorption. Following the surface complexation process, measurable amounts of zinc and aluminum ions were found to be mobilized from the surface of the solid to the liquid phase; subsequently, these ions precipitated on the solid surface, and possibly formed a co-precipitate with the hydrotalcite-type structure. On the other hand, a stoichiometric relationship was not obtained for the sorption of Zn²⁺ ions on silanol groups, and therefore, it was concluded that Zn²⁺ ions are retained on the surface of amorphous aluminosilicates by two different reactions. One reaction involves the surface complexation between Zn²⁺ ions and surface aluminol groups, which proceeds rapidly. The other reaction is the slow retention of Zn²⁺ ions onto silanol and/or aluminol groups, which could be the surface precipitation of Zn(OH)₂ or the co-precipitation of Zn²⁺-Al³⁺ hydroxides. It can be suggested that the total sorption behavior of Zn²⁺ ions on amorphous aluminosilicates with different Al/Si ratios can be represented as the sum of the individual reactions of Zn²⁺ ions toward the aluminol and silanol groups. The potentiometric results were confirmed by XANES data. It was clearly evident that only the aluminol groups were responsible for surface complexation of Zn²⁺ ions. An equilibrium constant was calculated for this reaction.     

Mechanism of pyroxene and amphibole weathering—I. Experimental studies of iron-free minerals

The short term (2–40 days) dissolution of enstatite, diopside, and tremolite in aqueous solution at low temperatures (20–60°C) and pH 1–6 has been studied in the laboratory by means of chemical analyses of reacting solutions for Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺, and Si(OH)₄ and by the use of X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) for detecting changes in surface chemistry of the minerals. All three minerals were found to release silica at a constant rate (linear kinetics) providing that ultrafine particles, produced by grinding, were removed initially by HF treatment. All three also underwent incongruent dissolution with preferential release of Ca and/or Mg relative to Si from their outermost surfaces. The preferential release of Ca, but not Mg for diopside at pH 6 was found by both XPS and solution chemistry verifying the theoretical prediction of greater mobility of cations located in M₂ structural sites. Loss mainly from M₂ sites also explains the degree of preferential loss of Mg from enstatite at pH 6; similar structural arguments apply to the loss of Ca and Mg from the surface of tremolite. In the case of diopside and tremolite initial incongruency was followed by essentially congruent cation-plus-silica dissolution indicating rapid formation of a constant-thickness, cation-depleted surface layer. Cation depletion at elevated temperature and low pH (~ 1) for enstatite and diopside was much greater than at low temperature and neutral pH, and continued reaction resulted in the formation of a surface precipitate of pure silica as indicated by solubility calculations, XPS analyses, and scanning electron microscopy.From XPS results at pH 6, model calculations indicate a cation-depleted altered surface layer of only a few atoms thickness in all three minerals. Also, lack of shifts in XPS peak energies for Si, Ca, and Mg, along with undersaturation of solutions with respect to all known Mg and Ca silicate minerals, suggest that cation depletion results from the substitution of hydrogen ion for Ca²⁺ and/or Mg²⁺ in a modified silicate structure and not from the precipitation of a new, radically different surface phase. These results, combined with findings of high activation energies for dissolution, a non-linear dependence on a_H⁺ for silica release from enstatite and diopside, and the occurrence of etch pitting, all point to surface chemical reaction and not bulk diffusion (either in solution or through altered surface layers) as the rate controlling mechanism of iron-free pyroxene and amphibole dissolution at earth surface temperatures.     

The dissolution rates of gibbsite in the presence of chloride, nitrate, silica, sulfate, and citrate in open and closed systems at 20°C

The dissolution of well crystallized gibbsite far at from equilibrium was studied in batch and mixed flow through reactors. The dissolution experiments were carried out between pH 2 and 6 in the presence of 10 mmol L⁻¹ citrate, at pH 2 and 3 in the presence of 10 mmol L⁻¹ chloride, nitrate, and sulfate, and at pH 2 and 3 in the presence of 1.5 mmol L⁻¹ silica at 20°C. The dissolution rate of gibbsite, R_Al (mol m⁻² s⁻¹), increases in the order of chloride ≈ nitrate < silica < sulfate ≈ citrate. In presence of silica, sulphate, and citrate dissolution is catalysed by the formation of aluminium complexes at the gibbsite surface (pH 2 and 3). From pH 2 to 3 no effect of R_Al on hydrogen activity is predicted as singly coordinated surface sites at the edges of the platy gibbsite crystals, [≡AlOH₂^+0.5] ≈ [≡AlOH], are almost saturated with protons. However at pH >3 dissolution is slowed by a decrease of [≡AlOH₂^+0.5].Gibbsite dissolution rates measured in closed and open systems were identical within the experimental and analytical uncertainty. This observation indicates that gibbsite dissolution is a surface controlled process. If dissolution of gibbsite occurs close to equilibrium R_Al values may be predicted by an approximately linear function of ΔG_r.     

Modification to the crystal structure of chlorite during early stages of its dissolution

Early stage processes of Mg-rich chlorite (clinochlore) dissolution were examined, focusing especially on the structural modification at grain edges during dissolution. Focused ion beam transmission electron microscopy sample preparation was applied to crystals dissolved in a flow-through reaction system at pH 3.0 and 25°C for 31 days. The obtained Si and Mg dissolution rates are −11.49 and −11.14 (logR, mol/(m²/s)), respectively, implying dissolution is non-stoichiometric. TEM-EDX analyses of dissolved samples reveal the development of 20–50-nm thick amorphous zone at an outermost rim with a chemical gradient of Mg, lower towards the solid surface, and Si enrichment in this amorphous zone. Crystalline material is partially interwoven with amorphous one at the interface between the amorphous and crystalline regions. These results indicate that the amorphous zone was produced by selective leaching of cations except for Si. Chlorite dissolution may proceed via the formation and thickening of leached layer as a by-product of release to solution of Si at slightly slower rate than Mg.     

Surface complexation model for strontium sorption to amorphous silica and goethite

Strontium sorption to amorphous silica and goethite was measured as a function of pH and dissolved strontium and carbonate concentrations at 25°C. Strontium sorption gradually increases from 0 to 100% from pH 6 to 10 for both phases and requires multiple outer-sphere surface complexes to fit the data. All data are modeled using the triple layer model and the site-occupancy standard state; unless stated otherwise all strontium complexes are mononuclear. Strontium sorption to amorphous silica in the presence and absence of dissolved carbonate can be fit with tetradentate Sr²⁺ and SrOH⁺ complexes on the β-plane and a monodentate Sr²⁺complex on the diffuse plane to account for strontium sorption at low ionic strength. Strontium sorption to goethite in the absence of dissolved carbonate can be fit with monodentate and tetradentate SrOH⁺ complexes and a tetradentate binuclear Sr²⁺ species on the β-plane. The binuclear complex is needed to account for enhanced sorption at hgh strontium surface loadings. In the presence of dissolved carbonate additional monodentate Sr²⁺ and SrOH⁺ carbonate surface complexes on the β-plane are needed to fit strontium sorption to goethite. Modeling strontium sorption as outer-sphere complexes is consistent with quantitative analysis of extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) on selected sorption samples that show a single first shell of oxygen atoms around strontium indicating hydrated surface complexes at the amorphous silica and goethite surfaces.     

Surface Charge Concentrations on Silica in Different 1.0 M Metal-Chloride Background Electrolytes and Implications for Dissolution Rates

The empirical rate laws formulated to describe the dissolution rates of oxide minerals include the surface charge concentration that results from the protonation and deprotonation of surface functional groups. Previous experiments on quartz and silica have shown that dissolution rates vary as a function of different background electrolyte solutions, however, such experiments are often conducted at elevated temperatures where it is difficult to estimate surface charge along with the dissolution rates. In the present study we measuresurface charge concentrations for silica in different electrolyte solutions at 298 K in order to quantify the extent to which the different counterions could affect the dissolution rates through their influence on the surface charge concentrations. The experimental solutions in the electrolyte series: LiCl, NaCl, KCl, RbCl, CaCl₂, SrCl₂ and BaCl₂ were prepared to maintain a constant metal concentration of 1.0 M. For the alkali-metal chlorides, the surface charge concentrations correlate with the size of the hydrated alkali metal, consistent with the idea that these counterions affect charge via outer-sphere coordination that shield proton surface complexes from one another. The reactivity trend for alkaline-earth cations is less clear, but the data demonstrate distinct differences in the acid-base propertiesof the silica surface in these different electrolytes. We then discuss how these trends are manifested in the rate equations used to interpret dissolution experiments.     

Solubility mechanisms of fluorine in peralkaline and meta-aluminous silicate glasses and in melts to magmatic temperatures

Structural interaction between dissolved fluorine and silicate glass (25°C) and melt (to 1400°C) has been examined with ¹⁹F and ²⁹Si MAS NMR and with Raman spectroscopy in the system Na₂O-Al₂O₃-SiO₂ as a function of Al₂O₃ content. Approximately 3 mol.% F calculated as NaF dissolved in these glasses and melts. From ¹⁹F NMR spectroscopy, four different fluoride complexes were identified. These are (1) Na-F complexes (NF), (2) Na-Al-F complexes with Al in 4-fold coordination (NAF), (3) Na-Al-F complexes with Al in 6-fold coordination with F (CF), and (4) Al-F complexes with Al in 6-fold, and possibly also 4-fold coordination (TF). The latter three types of complexes may be linked to the aluminosilicate network via Al-O-Si bridges.The abundance of sodium fluoride complexes (NF) decreases with increasing Al/(Al + Si) of the glasses and melts. The NF complexes were not detected in meta-aluminosilicate glasses and melts. The NAF, CF, and TF complexes coexist in peralkaline and meta-aluminosilicate glasses and melts.From ²⁹Si-NMR spectra of glasses and Raman spectra of glasses and melts, the silicate structure of Al-free and Al-poor compositions becomes polymerized by dissolution of F because NF complexes scavenge network-modifying Na from the silicate. Solution of F in Al-rich peralkaline and meta-aluminous glasses and melts results in Al-F bonding and aluminosilicate depolymerization.Temperature (above that of the glass transition) affects the Qⁿ-speciation reaction in the melts, 2Q³ ⇔ Q⁴ + Q², in a manner similar to other alkali silicate and alkali aluminosilicate melts. Dissolved F at the concentration level used in this study does not affect the temperature-dependence of this speciation reaction.     

Extent of diagenetic transformations in severely altered biogenic silica deposits from Tunisia: new insights from mineralogy and geochemistry

Sedimentary biogenic silica from Redeyef in Gafsa basin (southern Tunisia) was analysed for its ²⁹Si and ²⁷Al magic angle spinning nuclear magnetic resonance (MAS NMR) spectra and complemented by X-ray diffraction and SEM observations. The ²⁹Si MAS NMR spectrum is characterized by the abundance of hydroxylated silicon, displayed in resonance intensities and reflects a clear tendency towards dissolution of diatomaceous amorphous silica and the occurrence of the hydrated silica, which is the main component that ensures the diagenetic transition via the mechanism of dissolution–precipitation to other more crystalline silica phases, after the lost of its hydroxyls groups (water) by heating (burial). ²⁷Al MAS NMR reveals two coordinations of Al; the octahedrally coordinated Al suggests the presence of clay relics trapped during crystal growth or a microcrystalline zeolite (clinoptilolite detected by SEM observations), while the tetrahedrally coordinated Al suggests the presence of minor quantities of minerals with tetrahedral Al, such as an Al-rich fluid and/or minerals such as feldspars.     

Dissolution kinetics and the weathering of mafic minerals

Fayalite, hypersthene, basalt, and obsidian were dissolved in buffered solutions (25°C; pH 4.5 and 5.5) under air, N₂ or O₂ atmospheres, in order to follow the kinetics of dissolution. Each dissolved more rapidly at lower pH values, dissolving most rapidly in the initial few days, followed by slower dissolution for periods up to six months. Dissolution was more rapid when air was excluded. In oxygen atmospheres an Fe(OH)₃ precipitate armors mineral surfaces, thus inhibiting further dissolution, and further affects the solution by scavenging dissolved silica and cations. Dissolution reactions include initial exchange between cations and H⁺, incongruent dissolution of silicate structures, oxidation of Fe²⁺ in solution, precipitation of Fe(OH)₃, and scavenging of dissolved silica and cations by Fe(OH)₃. Dissolution kinetics may explain weathering of mafic rocks and minerals at the Earth's surface, the formation of Fe-oxide coatings on mineral grains, weathering of submarine mafic rocks and intrastratal solution of mafic minerals in buried sandstones. Early Precambrian weathering would have been more rapid before the appearance of large amounts of oxygen in the atmosphere, and continental denudation rates may have been higher than at present because of this effect and the predominance of mafic igneous rocks at an early stage of continent formation and growth.     

Reaction rate-surface area relationships during the early stages of weathering—I. Initial observations

It has commonly been assumed that the weathering rates of feldspars are proportional to their exposed surface areas. However, weathering does not affect the whole surface of a grain uniformily; preferential dissolution occurs at highly localized sites, which are determined by the location of crystalline defects. To examine the importance of reactions at these sites relative to those occurring on bulk surfaces, we compared the rates of dissolution of 5 different size fractions of an alkali feldspar, whose specific surface areas (m²/g) spanned a range of a factor of twenty.At any given pH value, the bulk dissolution rates (moles/g/h) for the five fractions varied by less than a factor of two. The results suggest that reactions at crystalline defects dominate weathering processes during the early stages of dissolution. Furthermore, the exposure of these defects is not simply or easily related to total surface area. These findings strongly suggest that care must be taken to distinguish between the surface reaction controlled mechanism and a surface area controlled model which is frequently—and incorrectly—assumed to be equivalent. The data presented here are consistent with the former mechanism but strongly dispute the latter.     

Interaction between dissolved silica and calcium carbonate: 1. Spontaneous precipitation of calcium carbonate in the presence of dissolved silica

The kinetics of spontaneous precipitation of CaCO₃ from aqueous solution in the presence of dissolved silica was investigated by recording pH as a function of time. The presence of dissolved silica, at concentrations below saturation with respect to the amorphous phase, decreases induction time for CaCO₃ nucleation, but does not affect CaCO₃ polymorphism. For a “pure” system without silica, the surface free energy, σ, determined from classical nucleation theory is 42 mJ m⁻². This agrees well with values reported in the literature for vaterite and indicates some degree of heterogeneous nucleation, which can occur because of the relatively low degree of supersaturation used for the experiments. In the presence of 1 and 2 mM silica, σ is 37 and 34 mJ m⁻², indicating an increasing degree of heterogeneous nucleation as the amount of polymeric silica increases. The ratio of Ca²⁺ to CO₃²⁻ activity was a governing parameter for determining which CaCO₃ polymorph precipitated. At high Ca²⁺ to CO₃²⁻ activity ratios, almost all initial solid was vaterite, whereas at low ratios, a mixture of vaterite and calcite was observed. In solutions with low Ca²⁺ to CO₃²⁻ activity ratios, the presence of silica at concentrations above saturation with respect to amorphous silica led to formation of only calcite and strongly influenced the crystalline structure and morphology of the precipitates. At high Ca²⁺ to CO₃²⁻ ratios, system behaviour did not differ from that without silica.     

Magnesium inhibition of calcite dissolution kinetics

We present evidence of inhibition of calcite dissolution by dissolved magnesium through direct observations of the (104) surface using atomic force microscopy (AFM) and vertical scanning interferometry (VSI). Far from equilibrium, the pattern of magnesium inhibition is dependent on solution composition and specific to surface step geometry. In CO₂-free solutions (pH 8.8), dissolved magnesium brings about little inhibition even at concentrations of 0.8 × 10⁻³ molal. At the same pH, magnesium concentrations of less than 0.05 × 10⁻³ molal in carbonate-buffered solutions generate significant inhibition, although no changes in surface and etch pit morphology are observed. As concentrations exceed magnesite saturation, the dissolution rate shows little additional decrease; however, selective pinning of step edges results in unique etch pit profiles, seen in both AFM and VSI datasets. Despite the decreases in step velocity, magnesium addition in carbonated solutions also appears to activate the surface by increasing the nucleation rate of new defects. These relationships suggest that the modest depression of the bulk rate measured by VSI reflects a balance between competing reaction mechanisms that simultaneously depress the rate through selective inhibition of step movement, but also enhance reactivity on terraces by lowering the energy barrier to new etch pit formation.     

The kinetics and mechanisms of simulated British Magnox waste glass dissolution as a function of pH,silicic acid activity and time in low temperature aqueous systems

Dissolution of a simulated British Magnox waste glass is governed by two pH-dependent processes. At low pH, dissolution is governed by reactions occurring predominantly at non-Si sites and residual Si-rich gels develop at the glass surface as B, Al and modifier cations are selectively leached. Here, extensive proton promoted hydrolysis of BO and AlO bonds is coupled with hydration and ion exchange processes. Hydrolysis of siloxane bonds governs the rate of dissolution at high pH and the glass dissolves congruently as the silicate network breaks down extensively. Differences in the surface chemistries and morphologies of glass samples reacted in strongly acidic and highly alkaline media reflect the net effects of these processes. The rate of the congruent dissolution process is influenced by the activity of silicic acid. The results are compared with published data for other glass formulations and are discussed in the context of proposed kinetic dissolution models.     

Probing the molecular-level control of aluminosilicate dissolution: A sensitive solid-state NMR proxy for reactive surface area

For two suites of volcanic aluminosilicate glasses, the accessible and reactive sites for covalent attachment of the fluorine-containing (3,3,3-trifluoropropyl)dimethylchlorosilane (TFS) probe molecule were measured by quantitative ¹⁹F nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The first set of samples consists of six rhyolitic and dacitic glasses originating from volcanic activity in Iceland and one rhyolitic glass from the Bishop Tuff, CA. Due to differences in the reactive species present on the surfaces of these glasses, variations in the rate of acid-mediated dissolution (pH 4) for samples in this suite cannot be explained by variations in geometric or BET-measured surface area. In contrast, the rates scale directly with the surface density of TFS-reactive sites as measured by solid-state NMR. These data are consistent with the inference that the TFS-reactive M-OH species on the glass surface, which are known to be non-hydrogen-bonded Q³ groups, represent loci accessible to and affected by proton-mediated dissolution. The second suite of samples, originating from a chronosequence in Kozushima, Japan, is comprised of four rhyolites that have been weathered for 1.1, 1.8, 26, and 52 ka. The number of TFS-reactive sites per gram increases with duration of weathering in the laboratory for the “Icelandic” samples and with duration of field weathering for both “Icelandic” and Japanese samples. One hypothesis is consistent with these and published modeling, laboratory, and field observations: over short timescales, dissolution is controlled by fast-dissolving sites, but over long timescales, dissolution is controlled by slower-dissolving sites, the surface density of which is proportional to the number of TFS-reactive Q³ sites. These latter sites are not part of a hydrogen-bonded network on the surface of the glasses, and measurement of their surface site density allows predictions of trends in reactive surface area. The TFS treatment method, which is easily monitored by quantitative ¹⁹F solid-state NMR, therefore provides a chemically specific and quantifiable proxy to understand the nature of how sites on dissolving silicates control dissolution. Furthermore, ²⁷Al NMR techniques are shown here to be useful in identifying clays on the glass surfaces, and these methods are therefore effective for quantifying concentrations of weathering impurities. Our interpretations offer a testable hypothesis for the mechanism of proton-promoted dissolution for low-iron aluminosilicate minerals and glasses and suggest that future investigations of reactive surfaces with high-sensitivity NMR techniques are warranted.     

Mg2+ removal in the system Mg2+—amorphous SiO2—H2O by adsorption and Mg-hydroxysilicate precipitation

Two chemical processes can remove Mg²⁺ from suspensions containing amorphous silica (am-SiO₂) at low temperatures: adsorption and precipitation of a Mg-hydroxysilicate resembling sepiolite. Mg²⁺ removal from am-SiO₂ suspensions was investigated, and the relative role of the two removal processes evaluated, as a function of: pH, ionic strength, Mg²⁺ concentration, and temperature.The extent of Mg²⁺ adsorption onto am-SiO₂ decreases with increasing NaCl concentration due to displacement of Mg²⁺ by Na⁺. At NaCl concentrations of 0.05 M and above, adsorption occurs only at pH values above 8.5, where rapid dissolution of am-SiO₂ gives rise to high concentrations of dissolved silica, resulting in supersaturation with respect to sepiolite. Removal of Mg²⁺, at concentrations of 40 to 650 μM, from am-SiO₂ suspensions in 0.70 M NaCl at 25 °C occurs at pH 9.0 and above. Experiments show that under these conditions adsorption and Mg-hydroxysilicate precipitation remove Mg²⁺ at similar rates. For 0.05 M Mg²⁺, at 0.70 M ionic strength and 25 °C, measurable Mg²⁺ removal occurs down to ca. pH 7.5 but is primarily due to Mg-hydroxysilicate precipitation. For the same solution conditions at 5°C, Mg²⁺ removal occurs above pH 8.0 and is primarily due to adsorption.Assuming that increasing pressure does not greatly enhance adsorption, Mg²⁺ adsorption onto am-SiO₂ is an insignificant process in sea water. The surface charge of pristine am-SiO₂ in sea water is primarily controlled by interactions with Na⁺. The principal reaction between Mg²⁺ and am-SiO₂ in marine sediments is sepiolite precipitation.The age distribution of sepiolite in siliceous pelagic sediments is influenced by temperatures of bottom waters and by geothermal gradients.     

Chlorite dissolution in the acid ph-range: a combined microscopic and macroscopic approach

The dissolution of chlorite with intermediate Fe-content was studied macroscopically via mixed flow experiments as well as microscopically via atomic force microscopy (AFM). BET surface area normalized steady state dissolution rates at 25 °C for pH 2 to 5 vary between 10⁻¹² and 10⁻¹³ mol/m^2.s. The order of the dissolution reaction with respect to protons was calculated to be about 0.29. For pH 2 to 4, chlorite was found to dissolve non-stoichiometrically, with a preferred release of the octahedrally coordinated cations. The additional release of octahedrally coordinated cations may be due to the transformation of chlorite to interstratified chlorite/vermiculite from the grain edges inward.In-situ atomic force microscopy performed on the basal surfaces of a chlorite sample, which has been preconditioned at pH 2 for several months, indicated a defect controlled dissolution mechanism. Molecular steps with height differences which correspond to the different subunits of chlorite, e.g. TOT sheet and brucite like layer, originated at surface defects such or compositional inhomogenities or cracks, which may be due to the deformation history of the chlorite sample. In contrast to other sheet silicates, at pH 2 nanoscale etch pits occur on the chlorite basal surfaces within flat terraces terminated by a TOT-sheet as well as within the brucite like layer. The chlorite basal surface dissolves layer by layer, because most of the surface defects are only expressed through single TOT or brucite-like layers. The defect controlled dissolution mechanism favours dissolution of molecular steps on the basal surfaces compared to dissolution of the grain edges. At pH 2 the dissolution of the chlorite basal surface is dominated by the retreat of 14 Å steps, representing one chlorite unit cell.The macroscopic and microscopic chlorite dissolution rates can be linked via the reactive surface area as identified by AFM. The reactive surface area with respect to dissolution consists of only 0.2% of the BET-surface area. A dissolution rate of 2.5 × 10⁻⁹ mol/m²s was calculated from macroscopic and microscopic dissolution experiments at pH 2, when normalized to the reactive surface area.