Kinetic mechanism of oxygen isotope disequilibrium in precipitated witherite and aragonite at low temperatures: an experimental study

To study what dictates oxygen isotope equilibrium fractionation between inorganic carbonate and water during carbonate precipitation from aqueous solutions, a direct precipitation approach was used to synthesize witherite, and an overgrowth technique was used to synthesize aragonite. The experiments were conducted at 50 and 70°C by one- and two-step approaches, respectively, with a difference in the time of oxygen isotope exchange between dissolved carbonate and water before carbonate precipitation. The two-step approach involved sufficient time to achieve oxygen isotope equilibrium between dissolved carbonate and water, whereas the one-step approach did not. The measured witherite-water fractionations are systematically lower than the aragonite-water fractionations regardless of exchange time between dissolved carbonate and water, pointing to cation effect on oxygen isotope partitioning between the barium and calcium carbonates when precipitating them from the solutions. The two-step approach experiments provide the equilibrium fractionations between the precipitated carbonates and water, whereas the one-step experiments do not. The present experiments show that approaching equilibrium oxygen isotope fractionation between precipitated carbonate and water proceeds via the following two processes:

1.

Oxygen isotope exchange between CO₃]²⁻ and H₂O:

(1)