Chemical processes and migration of elements during retrogression of a staurolite-zone assemblage in western North Carolina

A detailed study of retrograde alteration of a staurolite porphyroblast and its surrounding matrix of mica schist has made use of petrographic, modal, and microprobe analysis. Retrogression was to the garnet zone of metamorphism and apparently occurred largely after a temperature decline of 70–100° C. The event caused metasomatic removal of Zn but may have been isochemical relative to other analyzed elements. The best estimate of the overall reaction is: 1 staurolite+3.018 biotite+3.550 quartz+0.629 albite +0.014 anorthite+0.678 NaCl+14.004 H₂O =3.274 Na-rich muscovite+3.561 chlorite +0.273 ilmenite+0.110 chloritoid+0.039 garnet +0.339 ZnCl₂.Non-systematic variation in composition of analyzed minerals is revealed by statistical treatment of replicate analyses. Such variation involves monovalent and divalent cations within many minerals, but is most pronounced within retrograde muscovite. Muscovite variation involves Si and Al as well as FM and alkalis and does not follow a phengite law of charge-coupled substitution.Relative to the core of the retrograded staurolite crystal, zoning is seen in averaged muscovite compositions and in development of incompatible mineral assemblages, which include chloritoid well within retrograded staurolite but biotite within the matrix. A local gradient in the chemical potential of an Al-bearing component was likely present during retrogression.Alteration of staurolite was probably accomplished by reaction and diffusion through the medium of an intergranular fluid phase. Relative to staurolite, migration of elements involved immigration of considerable amounts of Mg, Na, K, and H and expulsion of Al, Fe, Zn, and O. It is inferred that concentration of Al within the fluid phase was considerably lower than those of monovalent and divalent cations.Preservation of considerable staurolite and evidence for a local concentration gradient of Al in the fluid phase suggest that limited amounts of H₂O were available. Expulsion of Zn suggests that much water was not consumed locally but exited the terrane. An attempt at resolution of this dilemna involves fracture-channelized infiltration of H₂O into the rock. A more regional petrographic study of retrogression suggests that H₂O which entered the rock may have been liberated initially by prograde dehydration at a moderately greater depth of 2–3 km.Results of this study, especially the non-phengitic nature of crystal-chemical substitution within muscovite, indicate chemical reaction under conditions of disequilibrium. Apparently, extent of retrogression was controlled by availability of H₂O rather than by thermochemical equilibria.