CaAl ratio and composition of the Earth's upper mantle

Undifferentiated meteorites (chondrites) have the same relative abundances of refractory lithophile elements (Ca, Al, Ti, Sc, REE, etc.), despite variable absolute concentrations. The reasonable assumption of chondritic ratios among refractory elements in the bulk Earth is used to constrain the chemical composition of the upper mantle in the following way: Correlations of the compatible refractory elements Ca, Al, Ti, Sc and Yb with MgO are worldwide very similar in suites of spinel-lherzolite xenoliths from basaltic rocks. Such suites represent upper mantle material depleted to differing degrees by extraction of partial melts. From these refractory elements vs. MgO correlations, ratios of pairs of refractory elements were calculated at various MgO contents. Chondritic $\text{Al}\text{Ti}$ and $\text{Sc}\text{Ti}$ ratios were only obtained for MgO contents below 36%. A chrondritic $\text{Sc}\text{Yb}$ ratio requires an MgO content above 35%. We therefore accept 35.5% as the most reasonable MgO content of undepleted upper mantle. This MgO content is slightly below the spinel-lherzolite with the lowest measured MgO content (36.22%). The corresponding Al₂O₃ content of 4.75% is higher than in previous estimates of upper mantle composition. The concentrations of other elements were obtained from similar correlations at a MgO content of 35.5%. The resulting present upper mantle composition is enriched in refractory elements by a factor of 1.49 relative to Si and Cl and by a factor of 1.12 for Mg relative to Si and Cl. These enrichments are in the same range as those for the Vigarano type carbonaceous chondrites. The Mg/Mg + Fe ratio of 89 is slightly lower than previous estimates.The $\text{Ca}\text{Al}$ ratio in spinel lherzolite suites is, however, uniformly higher worldwide than the chondritic ratio by about 15%. Orogenic peridotites as well as komatiites appear to have similar non-chondritic $\text{Ca}\text{Al}$ ratios. It is therefore suggested that this non-chondritic $\text{Ca}\text{Al}$ ratio is a characteristic of the upper mantle, possibly since the Archean. A minor fractionation of about 4% of garnet in an early, global melting event (deep magma ocean?) is presented as the most likely cause for the high $\text{Ca}\text{Al}\text{-}\text{ratio}$. In this case the addition of 4% of such a garnet component to the undepleted present upper mantle would be required to obtain the composition of the primordial upper mantle. The $\text{Ca}\text{Al}\text{-}\text{ratio}$ of this primordial mantle would be 15% higher than that of the undepleted present upper mantle, resulting in an enrichment of refractory elements of 1.70 ($\text{Al}\text{Si}$ relative to Cl) for the primordial upper mantle.