Comparison of the earthquake detection abilities of PhaseNet and EQTransformer with the Yangbi and Maduo earthquakes |
| |
Authors: | Ce Jiang Lihua Fang Liping Fan Boren Li |
| |
Institution: | Institute of Geophysics,China Earthquake Administration,Beijing 100081,China;Guangdong Earthquake Agency,Guangzhou 510070,China;Institute of Geophysics,China Earthquake Administration,Beijing 100081,China;Key Laboratory of Earthquake Source Physics,China Earthquake Administration,Beijing 100081,China;Institute of Disaster Prevention,Sanhe 065201,China;Institute of Geophysics,China Earthquake Administration,Beijing 100081,China |
| |
Abstract: | PhaseNet and EQTransformer are two state-of-the-art earthquake detection methods that have been increasingly applied worldwide. To evaluate the generalization ability of the two models and provide insights for the development of new models, this study took the sequences of the Yunnan Yangbi M6.4 earthquake and Qinghai Maduo M7.4 earthquake as examples to compare the earthquake detection effects of the two abovementioned models as well as their abilities to process dense seismic sequences. It has been demonstrated from the corresponding research that due to the differences in seismic waveforms found in different geographical regions, the picking performance is reduced when the two models are applied directly to the detection of the Yangbi and Maduo earthquakes. PhaseNet has a higher recall than EQTransformer, but the recall of both models is reduced by 13%–56% when compared with the results reported in the original papers. The analysis results indicate that neural networks with deeper layers and complex structures may not necessarily enhance earthquake detection performance. In designing earthquake detection models, attention should be paid to not only the balance of depth, width, and architecture but also to the quality and quantity of the training datasets. In addition, noise datasets should be incorporated during training. According to the continuous waveforms detected 21 days before the Yangbi and Maduo earthquakes, the Yangbi earthquake exhibited foreshock, while the Maduo earthquake showed no foreshock activity, indicating that the two earthquakes’ nucleation processes were different. |
| |
Keywords: | earthquake detection deep learning PhaseNet EQTransformer Yangbi earthquake Maduo earthquake |
本文献已被 万方数据 ScienceDirect 等数据库收录! |
| 点击此处可从《Earthquake Science》浏览原始摘要信息 |
| 点击此处可从《Earthquake Science》下载免费的PDF全文 |
|