Isotopic composition of lead and strontium in lavas and coarse-grained blocks from Ascension Island,South Atlantic—an addendum

Natural marokite (CaMn₂O₄) has been studied at high pressures and temperatures using a diamond-anvil press coupled with laser heating in the pressure range 100–250 kbar. A mixture of marokite, CaMnO₃ (perovskite) and MnO (rocksalt) has been observed in all runs in the above pressure range by X-ray diffraction study of the quenched samples. It was interpreted that marokite disproportionates into the mixture CaMnO₃ (perovskite) + MnO (rocksalt) at pressures below 100 kbar. A general comparison of the molar volume for all known compounds having the marokite-related structures (including CaFe₂O₄ and CaTi₂O₄) with those for a mixture of perovskite plus rocksalt structures suggested that the mixture is more stable than the marokite-related structures at high pressures, as confirmed by the present experimental result. The CaFe₂O₄-modification of common nepheline (NaAlSiO₄) is also suggested to be unstable relative to the component oxides of α-NaAlO₂ + SiO₂ (stishovite) at high pressures.     

Post-ilmenite phases of silicates and germanates

MgSiO₃, ZnSiO₃, MgGeO₃, MnGeO₃, and ZnGeO₃ are the only silicates and germanates known to crystallize in the ilmenite-like structure at high pressures and high temperatures. With the exception of the zinc compounds, the above-mentioned ilmenites have all been found to transform to the orthorhombic modification of the perovskite structure at higher pressures. The ilmenite phase of ZnSiO₃, on the other hand, transforms to its component oxide mixture with the rocksalt and rutile structures, whereas ZnGeO₃ (ilmenite) transforms first to an as yet undetermined orthorhombic phase and then to its component oxide mixture. The direct transformation from the ilmenite to perovskite structures observed in the metasilicates and metagermanates is consistent with all other reported high-pressure post-ilmenite phases (CdTiO₃, CdSnO₃, MnVO₃, and (Fe,Mg)TiO₃). The observation of the ilmenite-perovskite transformation in MgSiO₃ and its solid solutions towards Al₂O₃ suggests that MgO (rocksalt) + SiO₂ (rutile) + Al₂O₃ (corundum) is not a stable mineral assemblage for the earth's lower mantle.     

The high-pressure phases of MgSiO3

The high-pressure and temperature phase transformations of MgSiO₃ have been investigated in a diamond-anvil cell coupled with laser heating from 150 to 300 kbar at 1000–1400°C. X-ray diffraction study of the quenched samples reveals that the sequence of phase transformations for this compound is clinoenstatite → β-Mg₂SiO₄ plus stishovite → Mg₂SiO₄(spinel) plus stishovite → ilmenite phase → perovskite phase with increasing pressure. The hexagonal form of MgSiO₃ observed by Kawai et al. is demonstrated to have the ilmenite structure and the “hexagonal form” of MgSiO₃ observed by Ming and Bassett is shown to be predominantly the orthorhombic perovskite phase plus the ilmenite phase. The mixture of oxides, periclase plus stishovite, reported by Ming and Bassett was not observed in this study. The very wide stability field for the ilmenite phase of MgSiO₃ found in this study suggests that this phase is of importance in connection with the observed rapid increase of velocity in the transition zone of the earth's mantle. On the basis of the extremely dense-packed structure of the perovskite phase of MgSiO₃, this phase should be the most important component for the lower mantle.     

High-pressure disproportionation of Co2SiO4 spinel and implications for Mg2SiO4 spinel

Co₂SiO₄ spinel has been found to disproportionate into its isochemically mixed oxides with rocksalt and rutile structures at pressures between 170 and 190 kbar and temperatures between 1400 and 1800°C in a diamond-anvil press. The exact disproportionation pressure is not certain due to transient increases in pressure during the local and rapid heating by a continuous YAG laser. The slope of the phase boundary between the spinel phase and the mixed oxides is calculated to be?33 ± 20bar/deg. This negative slope is consistent with the observed anomalously large entropy of CoO (relative to its isostructural oxides) in entropy vs.(MV)^?1/2 systematics, whereM is the formula weight andV the molar volume. The sign of the slope for a phase boundary in the disproportionation of spinel depends on the values of entropy of the rocksalt oxides as well as the inverse character exhibited in the spinel phases. The normal entropy of MgO suggests that the phase boundary for the disproportionation of Mg₂SiO₄ spinel has positive slope.     

Calorimetric study of the stability of high pressure phases in the systems CoOSiO2 and “FeO”SiO2, and calculation of phase diagrams in MOSiO2 systems

High temperature calorimetric measurements of the enthalpies of solution in molten if2 PbO · B₂O₃ of α- and γ-Fe₂SiO₄ and α-, β-, and γ-Co₂SiO₄ permit the calculation of phase relations at high pressure and temperature. The reported triple point involving α-, β-, and γ-Co₂SiO₄ is confirmed to represent stable equilibrium. The curvature in the α?β phase boundary in Co₂SiO₄ and of an α?γ boundary in Fe₂SiO₄ at high temperature is explained in part by the effects of compressibility and thermal expansion, but better agreement with the observed phase diagram is obtained when one considers the effect of small amounts of cation disorder in the spinel and/or modified spinel phases. The calculated ΔH⁰ and ΔS⁰ values for the α?β, α?γ, and β?γ transitions show that enthalpy and en changes both vary strongly in the series Mg, Fe, Co, and Ni, and are of equal importance in determining the stability relations. The disproportionation of Fe₂SiO₄ and Co₂SiO₄ spinel to rocksalt plus stishovite is calculated to occur in the 170–190 kbar region; cation disorder and/or changes in wüstite stoichiometry can affect the P?T slope. The calorimetric data for CoSiO₃ and FeSiO₃ are in good agreement with the observed phase boundary for pyroxene formation from olivine and quartz. The decomposition of pyroxene to spinel and stishovite at pressures near the coesite-stishovite transition is predicted in both iron and cobalt systems. The use of calorimetric data, obtained from small samples of high pressure phases, is very useful in predicting equilibrium phase diagrams in the 50–300 kbar range.     

Oxygen isotope fractionation in mantle minerals

The increment method is adopted to calculate oxygen isotope fractionation factors for mantle minerals, particularly for the polymorphic phases of MgSiO₃ and Mg₂SiO₄. The results predict the following sequence of¹⁸O-enrichment:pyroxene (Mg, Fe, Ca)₂Si₂O₆>olivine (Mg, Fe)₂SiO₄ > spinel (Mg, Fe)₂SiO₄> ilmenite (Mg, Fe, Ca) SiO₃>perovskite (Mg, Fe, Ca) SiO₃. The calculated fractionations for the calcite-perovskite (CaTiO₃) System are in excellent agreement with the experimental calibrations. If there would be complete isotopic equilibration in the mantle, the spinel-structured silicates in the transition zone are predicted to be enriched in¹⁸O relative to the perovskite-structured silicates in the lower mantle but depleted in¹⁸O relative to olivines and pyroxenes in the upper mantle. The oxygen isotope layering of the mantle might result from differences in the chemical composition and crystal structure of mineral phases at different mantle depths. Assuming isotopic equilibrium on a whole earth scale, the chemical structure of the Earth’s interior can be described by the following sequence of¹⁸O-enrichment:upper crust>lower crust>upper mantle>transition zone>lower mantle>core. Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China and the Chinese Academy of Sciences.     

High-pressure decomposition of Ca2GeO4 and Ca2MnO4 with the K2NiF4-type structures

By using the diamond-anvil pressure cell coupled with laser heating, Ca₂GeO₄ in the K₂NiF₄-type structure has been found to decompose into the mixture Ca₃Ge₂O₇ plus CaO at pressures greater than 200 kbar and at about 1000°C, and the same type of structure for Ca₂MnO₄ has been found to decompose into the mixture CaMnO₃ (perovskite) plus CaO at pressures greater than 100 kbar and at about 1400°C. The decomposition product of Ca₃Ge₂O₇ is a new compound which is isostructural with Sr₃Ti₂O₇ and has the lattice parameters of a = 3.72 ± 0.01 and $\text{c = 19.32 ± 0.05}\text{A}\text{?}$ at room temperature and 1 bar pressure. The results of the study of Ca₂GeO₄ and Ca₂MnO₄ (both with the K₂NiF₄-type structure) strongly support the view that compounds possessing the K₂NiF₄-type structure are unstable relative to corresponding mixtures possessing the perovskite and rocksalt structures. It is concluded that, in the earth's mantle, the K₂NiF₄-type Ca₂SiO₄ would ultimately decompose into the mixture CaSiO₃ (perovskite) + CaO or would otherwise transform to other as-yet-unknown phase(s), and that the mixture of MgSiO₃ (perovskite) + MgO (the post-spinel phase of Mg₂SiO₄) would not adopt the K₂NiF₄-type structure.     

High-pressure phase transformations in the system of MgSiO3-FeSiO3

Two synthetic pyroxenes (FeSiO₃, MgSiO₃) and five natural pyroxenes with compositions of about Fs₈₀En₂₀, Fs₆₀En₄₀, Fs₅₀En₅₀, Fs₄₀En₆₀, and Fs₂₀En₈₀ have been subjected to pressures up to250 ± 50kbars at a temperature of about1500 ± 200°C in a diamond anvil cell heated by an infrared laser beam. After quenching and unloading X-ray data analysis indicates that (1) those with Mg less than 50% undergo the following reactions: 2(Mg,Fe)SiO₃ (pyroxene) → (Mg,Fe)₂SiO₄ (spinel) + SiO₂ (stishovite) → 2(Mg,Fe)O (magnesiowu¨stite) + SiO₂ (stishovite) with increase of pressure, and (2) those with Mg higher than 60%, undergo the following reactions: 2(Mg,Fe)SiO₃ (pyroxene) → (Mg,Fe)₂SiO₄ (spinel) + SiO₂ (stishovite) → 2(Mg,Fe)SiO₃ (hexagonal phase) → 2(Mg,Fe)O (magnesiowu¨stite) + SiO₂ (stishovite) with increase of pressure.     

High-pressure phases of Co2GeO4, Ni2GeO4, Mn2GeO4 and MnGeO3: implications for the germanate-silicate modeling scheme and the Earth's mantle

In a diamond-anvil press coupled with YAG laser heating, the spinels of Co₂GeO₄ and Ni₂GeO₄ have been found to disproportionate into their isochemical oxide mixtures at about 250 kbar and 1400–1800°C in the same manner as their silicate analogues. At about the same P-T conditions MnGeO₃ transforms to the orthorhombic perovskite structure (space group Pbnm); the lattice parameters at room temperature and 1 bar are a₀ = 5.084 ± 0.002, b₀ = 5.214 ± 0.002, and c₀ = 7.323 ± 0.003Å with Z = 4 for the perovskite phase. The zero-pressure volume change associated with the ilmenite-perovskite phase transition in MnGeO₃ is ?6.6%. Mn₂GeO₄ disproportionates into a mixture of the perovskite phase of MnGeO₃ plus the rocksalt phase of MnO at P = 250kbar and T = 1400–1800°C. The concept of utilizing germanates as high-pressure models for silicates is valid in general. The results of this study support the previous conclusion that the lower mantle comprises predominantly the orthorhombic perovskite phase of ferromagnesian silicate.     

High-pressure phase transformations and compressions of ilmenite and rutile,I. Experimental results

Natural ilmenite (Fe,Mg)TiO₃ has been found to transform to the perovskite structure and then to disproportionate into its component oxides, (Fe,Mg)O plus a cubic phase of TiO₂, at loading pressures of 140 and 250 kbar respectively, and at temperatures of 1,400 to 1,800°C. Samples were compressed in a diamond-anvil press and heated by irradiation with a YAG laser. The lattice parameters of the perovskite phase of (Fe,Mg)TiO₃ at room temperature and 1 bar are $\text{a}{}_0\text{= 4.471 ± 0.004, b}{}_0\text{= 5.753 ± 0.005,}\text{and}\text{c}{}_0\text{= 7.429 ± 0.006}\text{A}\text{?}$ with 4 molecules per cell. The zero-pressure volume change is 8.0% for the ilmenite-perovskite transition, 13.3% for the perovskite-mixed-oxides transition, and 20.2% for the ilmenite-mixed-oxides transition. The cubic phase of TiO₂ can be indexed on the basis of space group Fm3m with $\text{Z = 4}\text{and}\text{a}{}_0\text{= 4.455 ± 0.008}\text{A}\text{?}$ at room temperature and 1 bar, which corresponds to a decrease in zero-pressure volume of 29.2% for the rutile-cubic-phase transition. An isentropic bulk modulus at zero pressure of 5.75 ± 0.30 Mbar and a pressure derivative greater than 8 were calculated for the high-pressure cubic phase. The calculated bulk modulus for the mixture of (Fe,Mg)O and cubic TiO₂ is 2.48 ± 0.25 Mbar. All the phase transformations, the calculated lattice parameters, and the bulk moduli observed in this study are in good agreement with published shock-Hugoniot data for ilmenite and rutile.     

Some geophysical constraints on the chemical composition of the earth's lower mantle

The physical properties(?, K, K′) of the adiabatically decompressed lower mantle are interpreted in terms of an (Mg,Fe)SiO₃ perovskite + magnesiowüstite mineralogy. The approach employed in this paper involves the removal of the relatively better characterised magnesiowüstite component from the two-phase mixture in order to highlight the physical properties required of the perovskite phase for consistency between the seismological data and any proposed compositional model. It is concluded that a wide tradeoff (emphasized by Davies [1]) between composition, temperature and the physical properties (especially thermal expansion) of the perovskite phase accommodates most recently proposed compositional models including Ringwood's [2] pyrolite and the more silicic models of Burdick and Anderson [3], Anderson [4], Sawamoto [5], Butler and Anderson [6], Liu [7,8] and Watt and Ahrens [9].     

Disproportionation of Ni2SiO4 to stishovite plus bunsenite at high pressures and temperatures

Samples of Ni₂SiO₄ in both olivine and spinel phases have been compressed to pressures above 140 kbar in a diamond-anvil cell and heated to temperatures of 1400–1800°C using a continuous YAG laser. After quenching and releasing pressure, X-ray diffraction examination indicates that the samples disproportionate to a mixture of stishovite (SiO₂) and bunsenite (NiO) at pressures between 140 and 190 kbar. The exact disproportionation pressure is not certain due to transient increases in pressure during the local and rapid heating. However, thermodynamic calculations suggest that the transition pressure is about 192 ± 4 kbar at 1545°C and that the equation of the spinel-mixed oxides phase boundary isP(kbar) = 121 + (0.046 ± 0.020) T (°C).     

High-pressure decompositions in cobalt and nickel silicates

High-pressure stability relations in cobalt and nickel silicates have been studied over the pressure range 130–330 kbar employing a double-staged split-sphere-type high-pressure apparatus.γ-Co₂SiO₄ and γ-Ni₂SiO₄ decompose directly into their constituent oxide mixtures (rocksalt plus stishovite) 175 kbar and 280 kbar, respectively. The result that γ-Ni₂SiO₄ has a wider stability field in pressure than γ-Co₂SiO₄, is consistent with simple crystal-field theory.The experimental precision is high enough to show that the decomposition boundary of γ-Co₂SiO₄ has a positive slope (dP/dT > 0) and a preliminary determination of the boundary curve is P(kbar) = 0.065 T (°C) + 110.No positive evidence for the existence of high-pressure forms of CoSiO₃ and NiSiO₃ has been obtained in these quenching experiments, and they finally decompose into constituent oxide mixtures as in the cases of orthosilicates.     

Stability relation of (Mg,Fe)SiO3 garnets, major constituents in the Earth's interior

High-pressure and high temperature experiments at 20 GPa on (Mg,Fe)SiO₃ have revealed stability fields of two types of aluminium-free ferromagnesian garnets; non-cubic garnet and cubic garnet (majorite). Majorite garnet is stable only within a limited compositional variation, 0.2 < Fe/(Mg + Fe)< 0.4, and in the narrow temperature interval of 200°C around 2000°C, while the stability of non-cubic garnet with more iron-deficient compositions persists up to higher temperatures. These two garnets show fractional melting into iron-deficient garnet and iron-rich liquid, and the crystallization field of cubic garnet extends over Fe/(Mg + Fe)= 0.5. The assemblage silicate spinel and stishovite is a low-temperature phase, which also occurs in the iron-rich portion of the MgSiO₃—FeSiO₃ system. The sequence as given by the Fe/(Mg + Fe) value for the coexisting phases with the two garnets at 2000°C and 20 GPa is: silicate modified spinel aluminium-free garnets silicate spinel.Natural majorite in shock-metamorphosed chondrites is clarified to be produced at pressures above 20 GPa and temperatures around 2000°C. Similar shock events may cause the occurrence of non-cubic garnet in iron-deficient meteorites. Non-cubic garnet could be a stable phase in the Earth's mantle if a sufficiently low concentration of aluminium is present in the layer corresponding to the stable pressure range of non-cubic garnet. The chemical differentiation by melting in the deep mantle is also discussed on the basis of the present experimental results and the observed coexistence of majorite garnet with magnesiowüstite in chondrites.     

Iron oxidation state in lower mantle mineral assemblages: I. Empirical relations derived from high-pressure experiments

The oxidation state of iron can significantly influence the physical and chemical properties of lower mantle minerals. To improve methods for estimation of Fe³⁺/∑Fe, synthetic assemblages of (Mg,Fe)(Si,Al)O₃ perovskite and (Mg,Fe)O ferropericlase were synthesised from oxide starting mixtures in Re or Fe capsules at 26 GPa and 1650-1850 °C using a multianvil press. (Mg,Fe)(Si,Al)O₃ majorite was also present in some of the run products. Both electron energy loss spectra (EELS) and Mössbauer spectra were measured for each run product, and a robust fitting method was developed for Mössbauer spectra using EELS results as a standard that enabled Fe³⁺/∑Fe of (Mg,Fe)(Si,Al)O₃ perovskite to be determined from Mössbauer spectra of multiphase assemblages. There is a close to linear variation between Fe³⁺/∑Fe and Al concentration in (Mg,Fe)(Si,Al)O₃ perovskite, independent of oxygen fugacity. The concentration of Fe³⁺ in (Mg,Fe)O increases with increasing iron concentration along curves of constant oxygen fugacity, where higher oxygen fugacity stabilises greater Fe³⁺ concentrations. Fe²⁺/Mg partition coefficients calculated from chemical composition data corrected for measured Fe³⁺/∑Fe showed values nearly identical within experimental error for all samples, and independent of Al concentration and oxygen fugacity. Simple empirical relations were derived to calculate Fe³⁺/∑Fe in (Mg,Fe)(Si,Al)O₃ perovskite and (Mg,Fe)O ferropericlase samples for which no Mössbauer or EELS data were available, and tested by applying them to calculation of Fe²⁺/Mg partition coefficients from literature data for (Mg,Fe)(Si,Al)O₃ perovskite-(Mg,Fe)O assemblages where only total iron concentrations had been measured. Results showed Fe²⁺/Mg partition coefficients that were equal to existing values within experimental error, hence confirming the validity of the empirical relations.     

The system enstatite-pyrope at high pressures and temperatures and the mineralogy of the earth's mantle

In a diamond-anvil pressure cell coupled with laser heating, the system enstatite (MgSiO₃)-pyrope (3 MgSiO₃ · Al₂O₃) has been studied in the pressure region between about 100 and 300 kbar at about 1000°C using glass starting materials. The high-pressure phase behavior of the intermediate compositions of the system contrasts greatly with that of the two end-members. Differences between MgSiO₃ and 95% MgSiO₃ · 5% Al₂O₃ are especially remarkable. The phase assemblages β-Mg₂SiO₄ + stishovite and γ-Mg₂SiO₄ (spinel) + stishovite displayed by MgSiO₃ were not observed in 95% MgSiO₃ · 5% Al₂O₃, and the garnet phase, which was observed in 95% MgSiO₃ · 5% Al₂O₃ at high pressure, was not detected in MgSiO₃. These results suggest that the high-pressure phase transformations found in pure MgSiO₃ would be inhibited under mantle conditions by the presence even of small amounts of Al₂O₃ (?4% by weight). On the other hand, pyrope displays a wide stability field, finally transforming at 240–250 kbar directly to an ilmenite-type modification of the same stoichiometry. The two-phase region, within which orthopyroxene and garnet solid solutions coexist, is very broad. The structure of the earth's mantle is discussed in terms of the phase transformations to be expected in a simple mixture of 90% MgSiO₃ · 10% Al₂O₃ and Mg₂SiO₄. The seismic discontinuity at a depth of 400 km in the earth's mantle is probably due entirely to the olivine → β-phase transition in Mg₂SiO₄, with the progressive solution of pyroxene in garnet (displayed in 90% MgSiO₃ · 10% Al₂O₃) occurring at shallower depths. The inferred discontinuity at 650 km is due to the combination of the phase changes spinel → perovskite + rocksalt in Mg₂SiO₄ and garnet → ilmenite in 90% MgSiO₃ · 10% Al₂O₃. The 650-km discontinuity is thus characterized by an increase in the primary coordination of silicon from 4 to 6. A further discontinuity in the density and seismic wave velocities at greater depth associated with the ilmenite-perovskite phase transformation in 90% MgSiO₃ · 10% Al₂O₃ is expected.     

The nature and significance of stacking faults in wadsleyite,natural β-(Mg,Fe)2SiO4 from the Peace River meteorite

The β-phase, spinelloid polymorph of (Mg, Fe)₂SiO₄ makes up a major part of the transition of the Earth's mantle. Naturally occurring β-(Mg, Fe)₂SiO₄ wadsleyite, from the Peace River meteorite was found to carry a variety of stacking faults, the nature of which have been studied using high resolution transmission electron microscopy. The faults lie on (010) and are generally of a complex nature, best described in terms of various stacking sequences of the component spinelloid units. The stacking faults locally transform the cation distribution, so that in the plane of the fault the structure is that of spinel. The development of such stacking faults is consequently a significant feature of the martensitic transformation of spinel to β-phase. The possible occurrence of transformation enhanced plasticity associated with this inversion is discussed, and the probable deformation mechanisms of β-(Mg, Fe)₂SiO₄ are outlined.     

On the 650-km seismic discontinuity

The pressure-temperature conditions and the variations of both density and bulk sound velocity in the vicinity of the 650-km discontinuity have been compared with those calculated for the phase transitions in both the olivine and the pyroxene-garnet components of the mantle material. These studies suggest that the mantle below about 650 km is composed primarily of perovskite phase, as distinct from the olivine-rich upper mantle. Thus, the “650-km” discontinuity is not likely to be associated with any of the equilibrium phase boundaries observed in olivine, pyroxene, and garnet, and is proposed instead to be a chemical change. It is suggested that the following factors may be responsible for chemical separation: the pyroxene-garnet component transforms to much denser phases possessing the ilmenite and perovskite structures before the breakdown of the spinel phase into a mixture of perovskite plus rocksalt phases. The perovskite phase is also much denser than the rocksalt phase and the two phases may not form a gravitationally stable mixture. Thus, the denser phases may tend to sink to or stay at the deep part of the mantle, causing chemical separation. Possible separation processes are discussed and the supporting observations are presented.     

A new high-pressure phase of spinel

A new phase which is much denser than the component oxides of spinel (MgAl₂O₄) was synthesised at loading pressures greater than 250 kbar and at about 1000°C in a diamond-anvil press coupled with laser heating. The new phase (ε-MgAl₂O₄) was indexed on the basis of an orthorhombic cell with a = 8.507 ± 0.004, b = 2.740 ± 0.003, c = 9.407 ± 0.005Å, and Z = 4 at room temperature and 1 bar pressure. Thus the molar volume for ε-MgAl₂O₄ at the above conditions was calculated to be 33.01 ± 0.07 cm³, which is 10.3% less than that of the mixture corundum plus periclase. The dense phase of spinel found in shock-wave experiments can be reasonably interpreted as ε-MgAl₂O₄, and this may be a potentially important mineral component of the earth's lower mantle. The new structure may also provide a possible candidate for the dense phases of Fe₃O₄ and Mg₂SiO₄ which were found by shock experiments.     

Spinel disproportionation at high pressure: calorimetric determination of enthalpy of formation of Mg2SnO4 and Co2SnO4 and some implications for silicates

The enthalpies of formation from the oxides of Mg₂SnO₄ and Co₂SnO₄ were found by oxide melt solution calorimetry to be +1.13 ± 0.48 kcal/mol and ?2.31 ± 0.28 kcal/mol, respectively. Using these data, the slopes, ?P/?T, for disproportionation of these spinels to the component oxides at high pressure were calculated to be +30.4 ± 4.2 bar/K for Mg₂SnO₄ and ?10.3 ± 2.4 bar/K for Co₂SnO₄, in general agreement with the data of Jackson et al. (1974a,b). Using thermochemical data for the formation of olivines, for olivine-spinel transitions and for the transformation of quartz to stishovite, we calculate pressures for the disproportionation of silicate spinels to be in the range 150–200 kbar. Calculated slopes ?P/?T for the disproportionation reactions are ?10.7, ?24.9, ?11.2, and +7.6 bar/K for Mg₂SiO₄, Fe₂SiO₄, Co₂SiO₄, and Ni₂SiO₄. The large negative slope calculated for Fe₂SiO₄ results from a surprisingly large positive slope reported for the olivine-spinel transition in that compound (Akimoto et al., 1969). Further consideration of the systematic trends in the thermodynamics of spinel formation from the oxides suggests that the silicate spinels should have entropies of formation close to zero, resulting in values of ?P/?T which are zero or at most only slightly negative. This confirms the conclusion of Jackson, Liebermann, and Ringwood that values of ?P/?T for spinel disproportionation are unlikely to be more negative than ?10 bar/K and may well be slightly positive. Reaction of spinels to form other post-spinel phases, particularly ilmenite and perovskite, are discussed in terms of available thermochemical data.