Geochemical constraints on the stability of zeolites and C-S-H in the high pH reaction of bentonite

Cement-bentonite interactions will occur in deep geological repositories for high level radioactive waste. We performed laboratory experiments in order to constrain some previous geochemical and mineralogical uncertainties in the formation of secondary minerals in the high pH reaction of FEBEX bentonite at moderate temperatures.The reactivity of a Mg-homoionic FEBEX bentonite was studied at 25, 60 and 90 °C in batch reactors using two solutions representative of short and long time evolution stages of cement degradation. These solutions were periodically renewed in order to maintain a constant pH regime for a period of almost 2 years.Chabazite and merlinoite were observed to be the main zeolites that formed at 60 °C, while merlinoite was the dominant zeolite formed at 90 °C with the hyperalkaline (K-Na-OH) solution. The alkaline experiments (Ca-OH solution) showed minor reactivity and negligible mineralogical alteration, but the overall results suggest that the reaction tends to equilibrium conditions between C-S-H and montmorillonite at high temperature and metastable conditions at low temperature. The montmorillonite dissolution rates were calculated for all experiments, showing good agreement with previous calculations.     

THM analysis of a large‐scale heating test incorporating material fabric changes

Engineered barriers are basic elements in the design of repositories for the isolation of high‐level radioactive waste. This paper presents the thermo‐hydro‐mechanical (THM) analysis of a clay barrier subjected to heating and hydration. The study focuses on an ongoing large‐scale heating test, at almost full scale, which is being carried out at the CIEMAT laboratory under well‐controlled boundary conditions. The test is intensely instrumented and it has provided the opportunity to study in detail the evolution of the main THM variables over a long period of time. Comprehensive laboratory tests carried out in the context of the FEBEX and NF‐PRO projects have allowed the identification of the model parameters to describe the THM behaviour of the compacted expansive clay. A conventional THM approach that assumes the swelling clay as a single porosity medium has been initially adopted to analyse the evolution of the test. The model was able to predict correctly the global THM behaviour of the clay barrier in the short term (i.e. for times shorter than three years), but some model limitations were detected concerning the prediction of the long‐term hydration rate. An additional analysis of the test has been carried out using a double structure model to describe the actual behaviour of expansive clays. The double structure model explicitly considers the two dominant pore levels that actually exist in the FEBEX bentonite and it is able to account for the evolution of the material fabric. The simulation of the experiment using this enhanced model provides a more satisfactory reproduction of the long‐term experimental results. It also contributes to a better understanding of the observed test behaviour and it provides a physically based explanation for the very slow hydration of the barrier. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Modification of physical, mechanical and hydraulic properties of bentonite by thermo-hydraulic gradients

The conditions of the bentonite in an engineered barrier for high-level radioactive waste disposal have been simulated in a series of tests. Cylindrical cells with an inner length of 60 cm and a diameter of 7 cm have been constructed. Inside the cells, six blocks of FEBEX bentonite have been piled-up, giving rise to a total length similar to the thickness of the clay barrier in a repository according to the Spanish concept. To obtain the blocks, the clay with its hygroscopic water content has been uniaxially compacted at a dry density of 1.65 g/cm³. The bottom surface of the material was heated at 100 °C and the top surface was injected with granitic water. The duration of the tests was 6, 12 and 24 months. The temperatures inside the clay and the water intake were measured during the tests and, at the end, the cells were dismounted and the dry density, water content and some hydro-mechanical properties of the clay (permeability, swelling pressure and swelling under load) were measured at different positions. The values obtained are compared to those of the untreated FEBEX bentonite. The injection of water provokes in the vicinity of the hydration surface an increase of the water content and a decrease of the dry density due to the swelling of the clay, while heating gives rise to an increase of the dry density and a reduction of the water content in the 18 cm closest to the heater, even after 2 years of thermo-hydraulic (TH) treatment. The swelling capacity and the hydraulic conductivity after TH treatment are mainly related to the dry density and water content attained during it. No major irreversible modifications of these properties with respect to those of the untreated clay have been detected.     

Modelling of bentonite–granite solutes transfer from an in situ full-scale experiment to simulate a deep geological repository (Grimsel Test Site, Switzerland)

The FEBEX experiment is a 1:1 simulation of a high level waste disposal facility in crystalline rock according to the Spanish radwaste disposal concept. This experiment has been performed in a gallery drilled in the underground laboratory Grimsel Test Site (Switzerland). Two boreholes parallel to the FEBEX drift were drilled 20 and 60 cm away from the granite–bentonite interface to provide data on potential bentonite–granite solutes transfer. Periodic sampling and analysis of the major ions showed: (a) the existence of solutes transfer from the bentonite porewater towards the granite groundwater, explaining the Cl⁻ and Na⁺ contents of the latter; (b) that the concentration of the natural tracers coming into the granite groundwater from the bentonite porewater increased over time. This bentonite–granite solutes transfer was modelled in order to predict the increase in the Cl⁻ and Na⁺ concentrations of the granite groundwater. The modelled results seem to confirm that the mechanism of solute migration in this scenario is that of diffusive transport. An effective diffusion coefficient of D_e = 5 × 10⁻¹¹ m²/s was that which best fitted the data obtained.     

Research on water retention and microstructure characteristics of compacted GMZ bentonite under free swelling conditions

In this study, water retention tests under free swelling conditions were performed to investigate the water intake (or loss) behaviour of compacted GMZ bentonite. First, the water retention characteristics were investigated, and then the microscopic pore structure was observed by environmental scanning electron microscope (ESEM). The results indicate that GMZ bentonite has a strong swelling (or a limited shrinkage ability) due to water intake (loss). The suction behaviour of GMZ bentonite is similar to MX80 bentonite and FEBEX bentonite. We also find that the confinement conditions can affect the suction behaviour of the material, especially at high relative humidity (RH). Additionally, a mathematic model can fit the mass change data very well. Microscopic tests show that the granular sensation of GMZ bentonite is obvious for a sample at low RH. With the increase in RH, the surface of GMZ bentonite becomes more smooth. The differences in the porosities calculated by the macroscopic and microscopic tests can be attributed to image resolution. The inter-laminar pores and intra-aggregate pores cannot be observed by the ESEM method. In addition, ESEM observation can provide an intuitive basis for the further research of the seepage property of GMZ bentonite.     

Large scale buffer material test: Mock-up experiment at CIEMAT

FEBEX is a demonstration and research project, which is being carried out by an international consortium led by the Spanish agency ENRESA and simulates components of the engineering barrier system in accordance with the ENRESA's AGP (Deep Geological Disposal) Granite reference disposal concept. The project includes tests on three scales: an “in situ” test at full scale in natural conditions; a “mock-up” test at almost full scale in controlled conditions; and a series of laboratory test to complement the information from the two large-scale test.The components of the mock-up test are similar to those of the “in situ” test: two electric heaters, a clay barrier consisting of highly compacted bentonite blocks, instrumentation, automatic control of heaters, and a data acquisition system for the data generated. The heterogeneities of the natural system (granite formation) are avoided, the hydration process is controlled with unlimited amount of water at constant pressure, and the boundary conditions are better defined than in the “in situ” test.The operational phase -hydration and heating- started in February 1997. It was initially planned to last for three years, but it has been decided to extend the operational phase to get as close as possible complete saturation of the buffer.Fifty-five months after the start of the operational phase, it can be concluded that the synergy achieved from the simultaneous, integrated performance of tests at different scales, is a valuable approach to establishing the viability of the reference concept, and making progress in the understanding and evaluation of the behaviour in the near field, especially the clay barrier.     

Modeling coupled THM processes of geological porous media with multiphase flow: Theory and validation against laboratory and field scale experiments

A FEM model for analysis of fully coupled multiphase flow, thermal transport and stress/deformation in geological porous media was developed based on the momentum, mass and energy conservation laws of the continuum mechanics and the averaging approach of the mixture theory over a three phase (solid–liquid–gas) system. Six processes (i.e. stress–strain, water flow, gas flow, vapor flow, heat transport and porosity evolution processes) and their coupling effects are considered, which not only makes the problem well-defined, but renders the governing PDEs closed, complete, compact and compatible. Displacements, pore water pressure, pore gas pressure, pore vapor pressure, temperature and porosity are selected as basic unknowns. The physical phenomena such as phase transition, gas solubility in liquid, thermo-osmosis, moisture transfer and moisture swelling are modeled. As a result, the relative humidity and other related variables in porous media can be evaluated on a sounder physical basis. A three dimensional computer code, THYME3D, was developed, with eight degrees of freedom at each node. The laboratory CEA Mock-up test and the field scale FEBEX benchmark test on bentonite performance assessment for underground nuclear waste repositories were used to validate the numerical model and the software. The coupled THM behaviors of the bentonite barriers were satisfactorily simulated, and the effects and impacts of the governing equations, constitutive relations and property parameters on the coupled THM processes were understood in terms of more straightforward interpretation of physical processes at microscopic scale of the porous media. The work developed enables further in-depth research on fully coupled THM or THMC processes in porous media.     

Thermo-hydro-mechanical behaviour of two heavily overconsolidated clays

An experimental study on the thermo-hydro-mechanical behaviour of two heavily overconsolidated clays is presented. Laboratory tests have been conducted on a Spanish bentonite (FEBEX bentonite) and a Belgian kaolinitic/illitic clay (Boom clay), statically compacted at different initial dry densities and water contents. Volume change behaviour of the soils during suction reduction paths at different temperatures and during heating-cooling cycles at constant water content or suction have been investigated through the use of suction and temperature controlled oedometer cells. In addition, the volume change response under unconfined conditions and constant water content has been measured to determine thermal expansion coefficients. The results show similarities and differences between the observed behaviour of the two types of clays that have been interpreted on the basis of their different structures and regarding their proportion of intra-aggregate water.     

Modeling of Coupled Thermo-Hydro-Mechanical Processes with Links to Geochemistry Associated with Bentonite-Backfilled Repository Tunnels in Clay Formations

This paper presents simulation results related to coupled thermal–hydraulic–mechanical (THM) processes in engineered barrier systems (EBS) and clay host rock, in one case considering a possible link to geochemistry. This study is part of the US DOE Office of Nuclear Energy’s used fuel disposition campaign, to investigate current modeling capabilities and to identify issues and knowledge gaps associated with coupled THMC processes and EBS–rock interactions associated with repositories hosted in clay rock. In this study, we simulated a generic repository case assuming an EBS design with waste emplacement in horizontal tunnels that are back-filled with bentonite-based swelling clay as a protective buffer and heat load, derived for one type of US reactor spent fuel. We adopted the Barcelona basic model (BBM) for modeling of the geomechanical behavior of the bentonite, using properties corresponding to the FEBEX bentonite, and we used clay host rock properties derived from the Opalinus clay at Mont Terri, Switzerland. We present results related to EBS host–rock interactions and geomechanical performance in general, as well as studies related to peak temperature, buffer resaturation and thermally induced pressurization of host rock pore water, and swelling pressure change owing to variation of chemical composition in the EBS. Our initial THM modeling results show strong THM-driven interactions between the bentonite buffer and the low-permeability host rock. The resaturation of the buffer is delayed as a result of the low rock permeability, and the fluid pressure in the host rock is strongly coupled with the temperature changes, which under certain circumstances could result in a significant increase in pore pressure. Moreover, using the BBM, the bentonite buffer was found to have a rather complex geomechanical behavior that eventually leads to a slightly nonuniform density distribution. Nevertheless, the simulation shows that the swelling of the buffer is functioning to provide an adequate increase in confining stress on the tunnel wall, leading to a stabilization of any failure that may occur during the tunnel excavation. Finally, we describe the application of a possible approach for linking THM processes with chemistry, focusing on the evolution of primary and secondary swelling, in which the secondary swelling is caused by changes in ionic concentration, which in turn is evaluated using a transport simulation model.     

A water retention model accounting for void ratio changes in double porosity clays

This paper presents a constitutive model that predicts the water retention behaviour of compacted clays with evolving bimodal pore size distributions. In line with previous research, the model differentiates between the water present inside the saturated pores of the clay aggregates (the microstructure) and the water present inside the pores between clay aggregates (the macrostructure). A new formulation is then introduced to account for the effect of the macrostructural porosity changes on the retention behaviour of the soil, which results in a consistent evolution of the air-entry value of suction with volumetric deformations. Data from wetting tests on three different active clays (i.e. MX-80 bentonite, FEBEX bentonite, and Boom clay), subjected to distinct mechanical restraints, were used to formulate, calibrate, and validate the proposed model. Results from free swelling tests were also modelled by using both the proposed double porosity model and a published single porosity model, which confirmed the improvement in the predictions of degree of saturation by the present approach. The proposed retention model might be applied, for example, to the simulation of the hydromechanical behaviour of engineered bentonite barriers in underground nuclear waste repositories, where compacted active clays are subjected to changes of both suction and porosity structure under restrained volume conditions.

     

Effect of wetting–drying cycles on swelling behavior of lime stabilized sand–bentonite mixtures

In the present study, influence of wetting–drying cycles on swelling pressures of sand–bentonite mixtures used in the construction of sanitary landfills to have an impermeable liner was investigated before and after lime treatment of the mixtures. Swelling pressure tests were conducted to see if the swelling pressures were affected by wetting–drying cycles. First series of specimens were prepared as a mixture of sand and bentonite only. In the first series of specimens, sand was mixed with bentonite in various proportions with their optimum water contents and compacted by using standard proctor energy. In the second series of the specimens, lime in various proportions was added to the mixtures of sand–bentonite. Then, the sand–bentonite mixtures stabilized by lime were compacted with the standard proctor energy at their optimum moisture contents. Five wetting–drying cycles were performed on each specimen and values of swelling pressures were measured at the end of each cycle. Results of swelling pressure tests indicated that the swelling pressure is decreased when lime is added to the mixtures. In addition, decrements were observed on swelling pressures by wetting–drying cycles. The results of the experiments of this investigation showed that the beneficial effect of lime stabilization to control the swelling pressures was partly lost by the wetting–drying cycles. However, the test results indicated that the swelling pressures of the specimens made of sand–bentonite mixtures stabilized by lime were lower than the swelling pressures of the specimens made of only sand–bentonite mixtures.     

Hydromechanical Behaviour of Rock-Bentonite Interfaces Under Compression

Summary Interfaces between geomaterials may be critical for the long term confinement of the engineered barriers of nuclear waste disposals, particularly if there is water flow. Hydromechanical compression tests have been performed on rock-bentonite interfaces representing the contact between a host rock (toarcian argillite) and an engineered barrier within a nuclear waste repository. The results show that there is no major influence of the bentonite fraction or the nature of the additive as long as the additive is inert (sand or crushed rock): all the interfaces are closed for low values of normal stress (about 4 MPa). On the other hand, the hydromechanical behaviour of the interfaces changes when a high fraction of cement is used. Moreover, it has been shown that bentonite is very sensitive to hydraulic erosion, producing flow channels within the interface zone. A numerical study confirms the importance of erosion for the hydromechanical behaviour of the interface. Authors’ address: Olivier Buzzi, Laboratoire Sols, Solides, Structures, Université Joseph Fourier, BP 53, 38041 Grenoble, Cedex 9, France     

Minimal alteration of montmorillonite following long-term interaction with natural alkaline groundwater: Implications for geological disposal of radioactive waste

Bentonite is one of the more safety-critical components of the engineered barrier system in the disposal concepts developed for many types of radioactive waste. Bentonite is utilised because of its favourable properties which include plasticity, swelling capacity, colloid filtration, low hydraulic conductivity, high retardation of key radionuclides and stability in geological environments of relevance to waste disposal. However, bentonite is unstable under the highly alkaline conditions induced by Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC: initial porewater pH > 13) and this has driven interest in using low alkali cements (initial porewater pH9-11) as an alternative to OPC. To build a robust safety case for a repository for radioactive wastes, it is important to have supporting natural analogue data to confirm understanding of the likely long-term performance of bentonite in these lower alkali conditions. In Cyprus, the presence of natural bentonite in association with natural alkaline groundwater permits the zones of potential bentonite/alkaline water reaction to be studied as an analogy of the potential reaction between low alkali cement leachates and the bentonite buffer in the repository. Here, the results indicate that a cation diffusion front has moved some metres into the bentonite whereas the bentonite reaction front is restricted to a few millimetres into the clay. This reaction front shows minimal reaction of the bentonite (volumetrically, less than 1% of the bentonite), with production of a palygorskite secondary phase following reaction of the primary smectites over time periods of 10⁵–10⁶ years.     

Sorption reversibility kinetics in the ternary system radionuclide–bentonite colloids/nanoparticles–granite fracture filling material

The kinetics of radionuclide desorption from bentonite colloids and subsequent sorption onto fracture filling material can influence colloid-facilitated radionuclide migration in ground water. To shed light on the significance of these issues batch-type experiments using a cocktail of strong and weak sorbing radionuclides as well as FEBEX bentonite colloids in the presence of fracture filling material from Grimsel (Switzerland) under Grimsel ground water conditions have been conducted. Results show that tri- and tetravalent radionuclides, ²³²Th(IV), ²⁴²Pu(IV) and ²⁴³Am(III) are clearly colloid associated in contrast to ²³³U(VI), ²³⁷Np(V) and ⁹⁹Tc(VII). Concentrations of colloid-borne ²³²Th(IV), ²⁴²Pu(IV) and ²⁴³Am(III) decrease after ∼100 h showing desorption from bentonite colloids while ²³³U(VI) and ⁹⁹Tc(VII) concentrations remain constant over the entire experimental time of 7500 h thus showing no interaction either to colloids or to the fracture filling material. ²³²Th(IV) and ²⁴²Pu(IV) data yield a slower dissociation from colloids compared to ²⁴³Am(III) indicating stronger RN–colloid interaction. In the case of ²³⁷Np(V), a decrease in concentration after ∼300 h is observed which can be explained either by slow reduction to Np(IV) and subsequent sorption to mineral surfaces in accordance with the evolution of pe/pH and/or by a slow sorption onto the fracture filling material. No influence of the different fracture filling material size fractions (0.25–0.5 mm, 0.5–1 mm and 1–2 mm) can be observed implying reaction independence of the mineral surface area and mineralogical composition. The driving force of the observed metal ion desorption from colloids is binding to fracture filling material surfaces being in excess of the available colloid surface area (76:1, 55:1 and 44:1 for the 0.25–0.5 mm, 0.5–1 mm and 1–2 mm size fraction of the FFM, respectively).     

Mechanisms and Models for Bentonite Erosion Used for Geologic Disposal of High Level Radioactive Waste: A Review

The performance of the bentonite buffer in nuclear waste repository concept relies to a great extent on the buffer surrounding the canister having sufficient dry density. Loss of buffer material caused by erosion remains as the most significant process reducing the density of the buffer. In the worst case, the process is assumed to last as long as the free volume between the pellets in the pellets filled regions is filled with groundwater. Erosion rate and mass erosion are calculated based on the erosion model, and the measures are presented to prevent the geological disaster due to bentonite erosion. The groundwaters may solubilise the smectite particles in the bentonite and carry them away as colloidal particles. A dynamic model is developed for sodium gel expansion in fractures where the gel soaks up groundwater as it expands. The model is based on a force balance between and on smectite particles, which move in the water. Attractive van der Waals forces, repulsive electric diffuse layer (DDL) forces, gravity and buoyancy forces and forces caused by the gradient of chemical potential of the particles act to move the particle in the water. The effect of the fracture width and the frictions between particles and water and surrouding rock is analysed based on erosion model. The DDL forces strongly depend on the type of clay minerals and the type of ion and concentration in the water surrounding the particles. In the designed safe use of nuclear waste disposal (tens of thousands of years to hundreds of thousands of years), the safety of nuclear waste disposal is affected by the hydrodynamic and chemical effects, and bentonite erosion. Due to the bentonite erosion, the buffer/backfill layers become loose, and their permeability increases, which causes the nuclear element diffusion and convection, and even the nuclear disaster. In this paper, the mechanisms, models, experiments and control measures of bentonite erosion were systematically summarized. The current deficiencies of bentonite erosion were pointed out, and new methods were put forward to carry out the research for bentonite erosion. The measures were presented to prevent the geological disaster due to bentonite erosion through changes. The project is not only academic innovation, but also has a large practical significance. The research results of this project can be widely applied to the design, construction and maintenance of the bentonite buffer in nuclear waste repository.     

无水砂层大断面矩形管廊顶管施工渣土改良试验

大断面矩形管廊在无水砂层中顶进施工时,由于砂土流塑性差,掌子面易出现“闭塞”、“喷涌”和“结饼”等不良现象,进而影响施工进度。本文以北京市通州区畅和西路(兆善大街-潞阳大街)大断面矩形顶管施工为工程依托,开展了掌子面渣土改良试验研究。以不同配比的钠基膨润土、聚丙烯酰胺(PAM)和水作为砂土改良的添加剂,并通过黏度试验和滤失试验对不同配比的改良剂(膨润土添加聚丙烯酰胺)的性能进行了研究,结合改良后渣土的坍落度试验、直剪试验与压缩试验,评价了掌子面渣土的改良效果。研究表明:膨润土添加聚丙烯酰胺对无水砂层的改良效果显著。通过改良剂性能试验,初步筛选出膨润土: PAM: 水为60:2:1000,70:1.5:1000,70:2:1000和80:1.5:1000等4种性能优良的改良剂配比;通过渣土改良效果试验得出,改良剂最优配比膨润土: PAM: 水为70:2:1000,改良剂最优注入比为15%;通过添加改良剂使得改良后渣土的坍落度降低30 mm,黏聚力增加9.3 kPa,内摩擦角降低6.5°,压缩系数增加0.090 MPa-1,达到了无水砂层土体处于流塑性状态的预期效果,有效降低了大断面矩形管廊侧壁阻力,提高了顶进效率。     

膨润土膨胀变形的分形模型

Xu等[1] 提出基于膨润土表面分形模型的膨胀变形计算方法 Vw／Vm=kPDs-3(式1),并得到了Tsukinuno膨润土、Wyoming膨润土和MX-80膨润土的膨胀变形和膨胀压力(统称膨胀变形)的膨胀试验数据的验证。当时由于条件限制,存在两个问题:(1)膨润土的表面分维一般采用氮吸附法测量,由膨胀变形试验数据反算得到的膨润土表面分维没有得到氮吸附试验数据的验证; (2)在归一化吸水体积与压力的分形模型(式1)中,K是膨润土的物性常数,没有给出理论表达式,只是经验系数。本文采用氮吸附方法测量了高庙子Na基膨润土、高庙子Ca基膨润土、商用膨润土和Tsukinuno膨润土的表面分维,根据式(1)由表面分维计算膨胀变形,并与膨胀试验数据比较,验证膨胀变形的分形模型; 根据双电层理论,导出用双电层参数表示式(1)中K值的理论表达式,用于膨胀变形的计算,并与膨胀变形试验结果进行比较验证。     

Non-isothermal flow in low permeable porous media: a comparison of Richards’ and two-phase flow approaches

The present work compares the performance of two alternative flow models for the simulation of thermal-hydraulic coupled processes in low permeable porous media: non-isothermal Richards’ and two-phase flow concepts. Both models take vaporization processes into account: however, the Richards’ model neglects dynamic pressure variations and bulk flow of the gaseous phase. For the comparison of the two approaches first published, data from a laboratory experiment are studied involving thermally driven moisture flow in a partially saturated bentonite sample. Then a benchmark test of longer-term thermal-hydraulic behavior in the engineered barrier system of a geological nuclear waste repository is analyzed (DECOVALEX project). It was found that both models can be used to reproduce the vaporization process if the intrinsic permeability is relative high. However, when a thermal-hydraulic coupled problem has the same low intrinsic permeability, only the two-phase flow approach provides reasonable results.     

高压密封舱与磁场传感器的综合频响变异及其实验验证

大地电磁测深在陆地上的方法技术成熟, 但将其移植到海洋中却遇到了较多的技术问题.其中之一是如何将磁场传感器运抵海底实施测量.为抵御海水的侵蚀和抗衡海下的环境压力, 需要研发装载磁场传感器的密封舱.该舱体需满足测磁的技术要求, 即制造材料的非磁性, 且兼顾海洋作业设备轻便的特点.LC4超硬铝合金在可选的材料中性价比居高, 然而用它制成的高压密封舱并非十分完美.因它的弱磁性, 使得磁场传感器装入舱体后, 整体频率响应发生了部分变异.这种变异虽不影响磁场传感器的使用, 但要对其规律特征予以测定, 方能剔除由此产生的对磁场测量的不良影响.在所构思的实验装置中, 通过人为产生扫频磁场, 对密封和非密封条件下的磁场传感器进行激励.在响应输出端, 测取幅频特性和相频特性, 获得归一化的对比资料和频响异常曲线, 从而对密封前后磁场传感器的性能变化有较清楚的认识.实验结果揭示, 由高压密封舱引起的频响变异发生在中高频区段.实验数据可作为标定资料, 对海底大地电磁探测的实测信号进行校正后, 即可还原出真实的海底场源信息.