A two-dimensional model for a solar prominence: Effect of an external magnetic field

Using analytical approximations we study the effects of different external magnetic configurations on the half-width, mass, and internal magnetic structure of a quiescent solar prominence, modelled as a thin vertical sheet of cool plasma. Firstly, we build up a zeroth-order model and analyse the effects produced by a potential coronal field or a constant- force-free field. This model allows us to obtain the half-width and mass of the prominence for different values of the external field, pressure and shear angle. Secondly, the effects of these external magnetic configurations on a two-dimensional model proposed by Ballester and Priest (1987) are studied. The main effects are a change of the half-width with height, an increase of the mass, a decrease of the magnetic field strength with height and a change in the shape of the magnetic field lines.     

A theoretical prediction of ion plasma oscillations in a neutral sheet

Starting from the Vlasov equation the steady state and stability properties of the electron sheet in the Cowley neutral sheet model of the geomagnetic tail are considered. Electrostatic ion plasma oscillations propagating from dusk to dawn are found to be unstable provided the thermal spread normal to the current is sufficiently large. Assuming the population of the neutral sheet to be supplied by the polar wind it is shown how a localisation of the cross tail electric field could lead to the instability first appearing around midnight. It is conjectured that the localisation of the cross tail electric field could continually feed the instability, so leading to enough turbulence to give enhanced reconnection of the magnetic field.List of symbols f distribution function - B magnetic field strength far from the neutral sheet - a sheet half thickness - total potential drop across the tail which is localised to the dusk end of the tail in Cowley's model - potential for the steady state electric field normal to the electron current sheet. This potential exists in that region of the tail that excludes the localised region of cross tail electric field - average velocity across the tail of electrons in the current sheet - v average velocity of the electrons normal to the current sheet - p canonical momentum of a particle - energy of a particle - KT electron energy normal to the sheet (1/2m ^e v ² ) - KT ⁱ ion energy (1/2m ⁱ V ² ) - electron gyrofrequency far from the neutral sheet - ⁱ ion gyrofrequency far from the neutral sheet - Ay steady state vector potential for the magnetic field - A –Ay/aB ₀ (normalised vector potential) When perturbing the steady state, dashes have been used to denote the time dependent first order quantities. Where no confusion could arise the dashes are dropped, e.g.Ey=Ey since there is no zero orderEy in the region considered in the stability analysis.     

External and internal solutions for the twisted,flux-tube,prominence model

In this paper the twisted flux-tube model for the support of a prominence sheet with constant axial current density, given by Ridgway, Priest, and Amari (1991), is considered.The model is extended in Section 2 to incorporate a current sheet of finite height. The sheet is supported in a constant current density force-free field in the configuration of a twisted flux tube. The mass of the prominence sheet, using a typical height and field strength, is computed. Outside the flux tube the background magnetic field is assumed to be potential but the matching of the flux tube onto this background field is not considered here.Instead our attention is focussed, in Section 3, on the interior of the prominence. An expanded scale is used to stretch the prominence sheet to a finite width. We analytically select solutions for the internal magnetic field in this region which match smoothly onto the external force-free solutions at the prominence edge.The force balance equation applied inside the prominence then yields expressions for the pressure and density and a corresponding temperature may be computed.     

A method to calculate electric currents in quiescent prominences

A 2-dimensional model of the magnetic field associated with quiescent prominences is presented. The coronal field is assumed to be current-free, currents are only allowed in the photosphere and inside the prominence. The prominence is taken to be infinitely thin. For this model a method is given to calculate the field configuration from the observed normal component of the field both in the photosphere and the prominence. The normal field components are inferred from disc observations and H limb observations. The sheet currents inside the prominence are calculated and the resulting Lorentz force is compared with the gravitational force. Within the range of uncertainty in the total hydrogen density of quiescent prominences it is possible to give models where the gravity is balanced by the Lorentz force.     

The formation of solar prominences by magnetic reconnection and condensation

A model for solar quiescent prominences nested in a Figure 8 magnetic field topology is developed. This topology is argued to be the natural consequence of the distention of bipolar regions upward into the corona. If this distention is slow enough so that hydrostatic equilibrium holds approximately along the field lines, the transverse gas pressure forces fall exponentially with height whereas the inward Lorentz forces fall as a power law. At a low height in the corona, the pressure forces cannot balance the Lorentz forces provided the field lines remain tied to the photosphere and an inward collapse with subsequent reconnection at the point of closest approach should occur. Because of initial shear in the magnetic field, the reconnection would produce isolated helices above the point of reconnection since field lines would not interact with themselves but with their neighbors. This resulting topology produces a field above the elevated neutral line which is opposite in polarity to that of the photospheric field as in the current sheet models of Kuperus and Tandberg-Hanssen (1967). Raadu and Kuperus (1973), Kuperus and Raadu (1974), and Raadu (1979) and in agreement with recent observations of Leroy (1982), and Leroy et al. (1983).Assuming the isolated helices formed by reconnection are insulated from coronal thermal conduction and heating, the radiative cooling process and condensation is considered for the temperature range of 10⁴-6000 K. This condensation results in a steady downflow to the bottom of the helices as the temperature scale-height falls, thus forming a dense, cool, prominence at the bottom of the helical configuration resting on the elevated neutral line with the remainder of the helix being essentially evacuated of material. We identify this neutral line at the bottom of the prominence with the sharp lower edge often seen when viewing quiescent prominences side-on and the evacuated helix with the coronal cavity observed around prominences when seen during total eclipses.Downflow speeds associated with the condensation process are calculated for prominence temperatures and yield velocities in the range of the observed downflows of about 1 km s^–1.The National Center for Atmospheric Research is sponsored by the National Science Foundation.     

Complete determination of the magnetic field vector and of the electron density in 14 prominences from linear polarizaton measurements in the HeI D3 and Hα lines

The present paper is devoted to the interpretation of linear polarization data obtained in 14 quiescent prominences with the Pic-du-Midi coronagraph-polarimeter by J. L. Leroy, in the two lines Hei D₃ andH quasi-simultaneously. The linear polarization of the lines is due to scattering of the anisotropic photospheric radiation, modified by the Hanle effect due to the local magnetic field. The interpretation of the polarization data in the two lines is able to provide the 3 components of the magnetic field vector, and one extra parameter, namely the electron density, because the linear polarization of H is also sensitive to the depolarizing effect of collisions with the electrons and protons of the medium. Moreover, by using two lines with different optical thicknesses, namely Hei D₃, which is optically thin, and H, which is optically thick ( = 1), it is possible to solve the fundamental ambiguity, each line providing two field vector solutions that are symmetrical in direction with respect to the line of sight in the case of the optically thin line, and which have a different symmetry in the case of the optically thick line.It is then possible to determine without ambiguity the polarity of the prominence magnetic field with respect to that of the photospheric field: 12 prominences are found to be Inverse polarity prominences, whereas 2 prominences are found to be Normal polarity prominences. It must be noticed that in 12 of the 14 cases, the line-of-sight component of the magnetic field vector has a Normal polarity (to the extent that the notion of polarity of a vector component is meaningful; no polarity can be derived in the 2 remaining cases); this may explain the controversy between the results obtained with methods based on the Hanle effect with results obtained through the Zeeman effect. A dip of the magnetic field lines across the prominence has been assumed, to which the optically thick H line is sensitive, and the optically thin Hei D₃ line is insensitive.For the Inverse prominences, the average field strength is 7.5±1.2 G, the average angle,, between the field vector and the prominence long axis is 36° ± 15°, the average angle, , between the outgoing field lines and the solar surface at the prominence boundary is 29° ± 20°, and the average electron density is 2.1 × 10¹⁰ ± 0.7 × 10¹⁰ cm^–3. For the Normal prominences, the average field strength is 13.2±2.0 G, the average angle,, between the field vector and the prominence long axis is 53° ± 15°, the average angle, , between the outgoing field lines and the solar surface at the prominence boundary is 0° ± 20° (horizontal field), and the average electron density is 8.7 × 10⁹ ± 3.0 × 10⁹ cm^–3.     

Evolution of helically twisted prominence structures of March 11, 1979

Helical structures are generally associated with many eruptive solar prominences. Thus, study of their evolution in the solar atmosphere assumes importance. We present a study of a flare-associated erupting prominence of March 11, 1979, with conspicuous helically twisted structure, observed in H line center. We have attempted to understand the role played by twisted force-free magnetic fields in this event. In the analysis, we have assumed that the helical structures visible in H outline the field lines in which prominence tubes are embedded. Untwisting of observed prominence tubes and later, formation of open prominence structures provide evidence of restructuring of the magnetic field configuration over the active region during the course of prominence eruption. Temporal evolution of the force-free parameter is obtained for two main prominence tubes observed to be intertwined in a rope-like structure. Axial electric currents associated with the prominence tubes are estimated to be of the order of 10¹¹ A which decreased with time. Correspondingly, it is estimated that the rate of energy release was 10²⁸ erg s^–1 during the prominence eruption.     

Prominence condensation and magnetic levitation in a coronal loop

We describe the results of a model dynamic simulation of the formation and support of a narrow prominence at the apex of a coronal magnetic loop or arcade. The condensation process proceeds via an initial radiative cooling and pressure drop, and a secondary siphon flow from the dense chromospheric ends. The anti-buoyancy effect as the prominence forms causes a bending of the confining magnetic field, which propagates toward the semi-rigid ends of the magnetic loop. Thus, a wide magnetic hammock or well (of the normal-polarity Kippenhahn-Schlüter-type) is formed, which supports the prominence at or near the field apex. The simplicity of this 1.5-dimensional model, with its accompanying diagnostics, allows one to comprehend the various contributions to the nonlinear dynamics of prominence condensation and levitation.     

Eruption of a helically twisted prominence

In this paper we analyze the eruption of a prominence, characterized by a helical-like structure and by a non-linear rising motion. We approximated the prominence as a cylindrical curved flux tube and estimated the behaviour of several geometrical parameters during the activation and the eruption phases. We determined that, at the onset of the activation, the number N of turns of a magnetic field line over the whole length of the prominence was 5.0, while the value of the ratio P/r ₀ between the pitch of the magnetic field lines and the prominence width was 0.45. These values are in good agreement with those predicted by the kink-mode instability. Moreover, we found a decrease of the total twist of one helical thread from 10 to 2 during the prominence eruption, indicating a relaxation of the magnetic field towards a less twisted configuration. We conclude that the prominence was initially destabilized by the kink-mode instability and, not succeeding in finding a new equilibrium configuration, it erupted.     

Some calculations bearing on the heating and cooling of quiescent prominences

We discuss the evolution of pulses of heat both along and perpendicular to magnetic fields threading quiescent prominences. We show that while heating of prominence material can take place on a time scale of the order 10³ s (of the same order as the observed winking of H light from prominences and also of the same order as the dynamical Alfvén time scale across a prominence sheet) individual flux tubes are effectively thermally insulated from neighboring tubes, since the transverse (to the ambient supporting magnetic field) heat conduction time scale is of order 10⁴ yr. The exact solution to the one-dimensional parallel heat conduction problem is shown to differ significantly from the approximate solution reported by Ioshpa (1965). We also suggest that uneven heating of a quiescent prominence by the surrounding solar corona may be a contributory mechanism for surges and/or the observed winking phenomenon - both of which are recorded in many quiescent prominences. The signature of such a temperature pulse would be a sharp (10³ s) brightening of continuum radiation with a correlated decrease in the free-bound emission, followed by a slow (10⁴ s) recovery of both to their pre-heat pulse levels.     

Magnetic reconnection in the temperature minimum region and prominence formation

Magnetic reconnection at the photospheric boundary is an essential part of some theories for prominence formation. We consider a simple model for reconnection in this region. Parameters of the reconnecting current sheet are expressed in terms of the concentration and temperature of the outside dense and cold plasma, magnetic field intensity, and velocity of convective flows at the photosphere. The reconnection process is shown to be most efficient in a layer several hundred kilometers thick coinciding with the temperature minimum region of the solar atmosphere. The calculated upward flux of matter through the current sheet ( 10¹¹–10¹² g s^–1) is amply sufficient for prominence formation in the upper chromosphere or lower corona.     

Flare-like energy release by flux pile-up reconnection

Flux pile-up magnetic merging solutions are discussed using the simple robust arguments of traditional steady-state reconnection theory. These arguments determine a unique scaling for the field strength and thickness of the current layer, namely B _s^–1/3, l^2/3, which are consistent with a variety of plasma inflow conditions. Next we demonstrate that flux pile-up merging can also be understood in terms of exact magnetic annihilation solutions. Although simple annihilation models cannot provide unique reconnection scalings, we show that the previous current sheet scalings derive from an optimized solution in which the peak dynamic and magnetic pressures balance in the reconnection region. The build-up of magnetic field in the current sheet implicit in flux pile-up solutions naturally leads to the idea of saturation. Hydromagnetic pressure effects limit the magnetic field in the sheet, yielding an upper limit on the reconnection rate for such solutions. This rate is still far superior to the Sweet–Parker merging rate, which can be derived by seeking solutions that avoid all forms of saturation. Finally we compare time dependent numerical simulations of the coalescence instability with the optimized flux pile-up models. This comparison suggests that merging driven by the relatively slow approach of large flux systems may be favored in practice.     

The structure of the turbulent shock wave propagating in the solar atmosphere across the magnetic field

A consistent account of plasma turbulence in magnetohydrodynamics equations describing transport processes across the magnetic field is presented. The structure of the perpendicular shock wave generated in the solar atmosphere, as a result of either local disturbance of the magnetic field or dense plasma cloud motion with a frozen-in magnetic field, has been investigated. The region of parameters in the solar atmosphere at which the electron-ion relative drift velocity u exceeds the electron thermal velocity V _eand generation of radio emission becomes possible, has been determined. The plasma turbulence inside the front has been shown, under conditions of solar corona, not to cause the oscillation structure of shock front to break down. Under chromospheric conditions, the shock profile is aperiodical. Then, the condition u > V_ecan be satisfied and shock waves having an Alfvén Mach number M which exceeds the critical value M _c 3.3 for aperiodical shock waves can exist (Eselevich et al., 1971a). Arguments are given in favour of the fact that perpendicular shock waves are generated in the Sun's atmosphere when dense plasma clouds, with a frozen-in magnetic field, are expanded.     

Physics of solar prominences

Summary Conclusion This colloquium on solar prominences - the first ever held - has shown that a major part of activity in prominence research in recent years concentrated on both observation and computation of the magnetic conditions which were found to play a crucial role for the development and the maintainance of prominences. Remarkable progress was made in fine-scale measurements of photospheric magnetic fields around filaments and in internal field measurements in prominences. In addition, important information on the structure of the magnetic fields in the chromosphere adjacent to the filaments may be derived from high resolution photographs of the H fine structure around filaments which have become available recently; unfortunately, an unambiguous determination of the vector field in the chromosphere is not yet possible.It is quite clear, now, that stable filaments extend along neutral lines which divide regions of opposite longitudinal magnetic fields. Different types of neutral lines are possible, depending on the history and relationship of the opposite field regions. There is convincing evidence that the magnetic field in the neighbouring chromosphere may run nearly parallel to the filament axis and that there are two field components in stable prominences: an axial field dominant in the lower parts and a transverse field dominant in the higher parts.Methods for the computation of possible prominence field configurations from measured longitudinal photospheric fields were developed in recent years. In a number of cases (e.g. for loop prominences) the observed configuration could be perfectly represented by a force-free or even a potential field; poor agreement was found between computed and measured field strengths in quiescent prominences. In order to reconcile both of them it is necessary to assume electric currents. Unambiguous solutions will not be found until measurements of the vector field in the photosphere and in the prominences are available.The two-dimensional Kippenhahn-Schlüter model is still considered a useful tool for the study of prominence support and stability. However, a more refined model taking into account both field components and considering also thermal stability conditions is available now. It was proposed that quiescent prominences may form in magnetically neutral sheets in the corona where fields of opposite directions meet.As for the problem of the origin of the dense prominence material there are still two opposite processes under discussion. The injection of material from below, which was mainly applied to loop prominences, has recently been considered also a possible mechanism for the formation of quiescent prominences. On the other hand, the main objections against the condensation mechanism could be removed: it was shown that (1) sufficient material is available in the surrounding corona, and that (2) coronal matter can be condensed to prominence densities and cooled to prominence temperatures in a sufficiently short time.The energy balance in prominences is largely dependent on their fine structure. It seems that a much better radiative loss function for optically thin matter is now available. The problem of the heat conduction can only be treated properly if the field configuration is known. Very little is known on the heating of the corona and the prominence in a complicated field configuration. For the optically thick prominences the energy balance becomes a complicated radiative transfer problem.Still little is known on the first days of prominence development and on the mechanism of first formation which, both, are crucial for the unterstanding of the prominence phenomenon. As a first important step, it was shown in high resolution H photographs that the chromospheric fine structure becomes aligned along the direction of the neutral line already before first filament appearance. More H studies and magnetic field measurements are badly needed.Recent studies have shown that even in stable prominences strong small-scale internal rotational or helical motions exist; they are not yet understood. On the other hand, no generally agreed interpretation of large-scale motions of prominences seems to exist. A first attempt to explain the ascendance of prominences, the Disparitions Brusques, as the result of a kink instability was made recently.New opportunities in prominence research are offered by the study of invisible radiations: X-rays and meterwaves provide important information, not available otherwise, on physical conditions in the coronal surroundings of prominences; EUV observations will provide data on the thin transition layer between the cool prominence and the hot coronal plasma.Mitt. aus dem Fraunhofer Institut No. 111.     

Current sheet models of solar flares

Current sheets have been suggested as the site for flare energy release because they can convert magnetic energy very rapidly into both heat and directed plasma energy. Also they contain electric fields with the potential of accelerating particles to high energies.The basic properties of current sheets are first reviewed. For instance, magnetic flux may be carried into a current sheet and annihilated. An exact solution for such a process in an infinitely long sheet has been found; it describes the annihilation of fields which are inclined at any angle, not just 180°. Moreover, field lines which are expelled from the ends of a current sheet can be described as having been reconnected. The only workable model for fast reconnection in the solar atmosphere, namely Petschek's mechanism, has recently been put on a firm foundation; it gives a reconnection rate which depends on the electrical conductivity but is typically a tenth or a hundredth of the Alfvén speed. A current sheet may be formed when the sources of an initially potential field start to move; a simple analytic technique for finding the position and shape of such a sheet in two dimensions now exists. Finally, a sheet with no transverse magnetic field component is subject to the tearing-mode instability, which rapidly produces a series of loops in the field.The main ways in which current sheets have been used for solar flare models is described. Syrovatskii's mechanism relies on the increase of the electric current density during the formation of a sheet, to a value in excess of the critical value j ^* for the onset of microinstabilities. But Anzer has recently demonstrated that the critical value is most unlikely to be reached during the initial formation process. Sturrock, on the other hand, has advocated the occurrence of the tearing-mode instability in an open streamer-like configuration (which may result from the eruption of a force-free field). But recent observations do not point to that as the relevant configuration. Rather, they suggest that flares are triggered by the emergence of new magnetic flux from below the solar photosphere. This has led Heyvaerts, Priest, and Rust (1976) to propose a new emerging flux model, according to which, as more and more flux emerges, so reconnection occurs, producing some preflare heating. When the current sheet reaches such a height (around the transition region) that its current density exceeds j ^*, then the impulsive phase of the flare is triggered. The main phase is caused by an enhanced level of magnetic energy conversion in a turbulent current sheet. The type of flare depends on the magnetic environment in which the emerging flux finds itself. A surge flare results if the flux appears near a strong unipolar region such as a simple sunspot, whereas a two ribbon flare may be produced by flux emergence near an active region filament, in which case the main phase energy is released from the field that surrounds the filament.     

Steady magnetic reconnection in three dimensions

The concepts of magnetic reconnection that have been developed in two dimensions need to be generalised to three-dimensional configurations. Reconnection may be defined to occur when there is an electric field (E) parallel to field lines (known as potential singular lines) which are potential reconnection locations and near which the field has an X-type topology in a plane normal to that field line. In general there is a continuum of neighbouring potential singular lines, and which one supports reconnection depends on the imposed flow or electric field. For steady reconnection the nearby flow and electric field are severely constrained in the ideal region by the condition that E = 0 there. Potential singular lines may occur in twisted prominence fields or in the complex magnetic configuration above sources of mixed polarity of an active region or a supergranulation cell. When reconnection occurs there is dynamic MHD behaviour with current concentration and strong plasma jetting along the singular line and the singular surfaces which map onto them.     

On neutral sheets in the solar wind

The structure and dynamics of neutral sheets in the solar wind is examined. The internal magnetic topology of the sheet is argued to be that of thin magnetic tongues greatly distended outward by the expansion inside the sheet. Due to finite conductivity effects, outward flow takes place across field lines but is retarded relative to the ambient solar wind by the reverse J×B force. The sheet thickness as well as the internal transverse magnetic field are found to be proportional to the electrical conductivity to the inverse one third power. Estimating a conductivity appropriate for a current carried largely by the ions perpendicular to the magnetic field, we find sheet dimensions of the order of 500km representative for the inner solar corona. For a radial field of strength 1/2G at 2R , the transverse field there is about 2 × 10^–3G and decreases outward rapidly.The energy release in the form of Joulean dissipation inside the sheet is estimated. It is concluded that ohmic heating in current sheets is not a significant source of energy for the overall solar wind expansion, mainly because these structures occupy only a small percentage of the total coronal volume. However, the local energy release through this mechanism is found to be large - in fact, over 7 times that expected to be supplied by thermal conduction. Therefore, ohmic heating is probably a dominant energy source for the dynamical conditions within the sheet itself.The National Center for Atmospheric Research is sponsored by the National Science Foundation.     

Current sheet model of a normal prominence in which the background magnetic lines show a ‘dip structure’

We propose a simple 2D current sheet model of a normal prominence, in which the lines of the background magnetic field have the dip structure which seems to be required for such an object to form and to be stably supported.     

A model of the supergranulation network and of active-region plages

Analysis of magnetograph recordings made simultaneously in different spectral lines have shown that the quiet-region network and active-region plages with average field strengths less than about 100 G are made up by the same type of elementary structures, each having the same physical properties. Magnetograph data are used together with continuum, line profile, and EUV data to derive a model of these subarcsec, spatially unresolved elementary structures. The field strength at the center of each basic element is about 2 kG. The temperature enhancement starts at a height of about 180 km (above the level ₀ = 1 in HSRA), and increases rapidly with height. The brightness structures are coarser than the magnetic-field structures.The magnetic field cannot be contained by either gas pressure or dynamic pressure. The magnetic pressure must be balanced by the constricting force of strong electric currents along the magnetic filaments (pinch effect). A mechanism is proposed for the amplification of the field, involving vortex motions around the downdrafts in the network and plages. Efficient heating by hydromagnetic waves builds up an excess gas pressure inside the twisted fluxropes. The excess pressure is released by the ejection of spicules, which have to move out along the helically shaped field lines and thereby will acquire a spinning motion.The continuum emission in the fluxropes, which are located in the intergranular lanes, washes out the contrast between cell interiors and cell boundaries and creates an abnormal granulation pattern. When more and more magnetic flux is brought into a given area, the interaction between the fluxropes and the granulation starts to change the physical structure of the fluxropes. This begins at an average field B _obs 100 G, with a gradual transition to pores and sunspots as b _obs is increased.     

Current sheet models for inverse polarity prominences in twisted flux tubes

This paper treats the prominence model of Low (1993) to examine more complicated sheet currents than those used in the original model. Nonlinear force-free field solutions, in Cartesian coordinates, invariant in a given direction, are presented to show the possibility of an inverse-polarity prominence embedded in a large twisted flux tube. The force-free solution is matched to an external, unsheared, potential coronal magnetic field. These new solutions are mathematically interesting and allow an investigation of different profiles of the current intensity, magnetic field vector and mass density in the sheet. These prominence models show a general increase in magnetic field strength with height in agreement with observations. Other prominence properties are shown to match the observed values.