Low energy electrons and protons in the magnetosphere

Observations made by HEOS-2 of low energy electrons and protons in the high latitude magnetosphere are presented. Plasma in the magnetosphere is observed in the cusp (which extend down to low altitudes) and over large areas adjacent to the high latitude magnetopause both on the dayside and on the nightside (the entry layer and the plasma mantle respectively).A comparative study of the plasma properties in the various parts of the magnetosphere is performed. An ion bulk motion directed tailward along the geomagnetic field lines is observed both in the entry layer and in the plasma mantle; in the cusp, on the contrary, the bulk motion is practically absent. Moreover the electron thermal anisotropy is parallel to the magnetic field in the magnetosheath, and perpendicular to it in the plasma mantle. One possible explanation (suggested by Rosenbauer et al., 1975) of the origin of these populations is that plasma, penetrated from the magnetosheath in the entry layer, flows tailward along the field lines, is then reflected in the cusp region and convected in the plasma mantle.     

Evidence for the heating of thermal electrons at the magnetopause boundary layer

The suprathermal plasma analyser on the geostationary satellite Geos-2 can identify magnetospheric, boundary layer and magnetosheath electron distributions around the dayside equatorial magnetopause. As examples, data from two days when magnetopause crossings occurred, 28 August 1978 and 12 November 1978, are discussed. The boundary layer electrons are intermediate in temperature and density between those in the ring current and the magnetosheath but cannot be a simple admixture of the two populations. The transition from boundary layer to magnetosheath electrons is often sudden. We believe it to be coincident with the magnetopause where the magnetic field changes from terrestrial to interplanetary.     

Observations of penetrated solar wind plasma elements in the plasma mantle

PROGNOZ-7 observations of intense “magnetosheath-like” plasma deep inside the high latitude boundary layer, the plasma mantle, indicates that solar wind plasma elements may occasionally penetrate the magnetopause and form high density regions in the plasma mantle. These “magnetosheath-like” regions are usually associated with strong flow of solar wind ions (e.g. H⁺ and He²⁺) and the presence of terrestrial ions (e.g. O⁺). The magnetosheath-like structures may roughly be classified as “newly injected” or “stagnant”. The newly injected structures have characteristics very similar to those found in the magnetosheath, i.e. strong antisunward flow and magnetosheath ion composition and density. The magnetic field characteristics may, however, differ considerably from those found further out in the magnetosheath. The “stagnant” structures are characterized by a reduced plasma flow, a lower density and a different ion composition as compared to that in the magnetosheath. In a few cases newly injected structures were even found in the innermost part of the mantle (i.e. forming a “boundary region” adjacent to the lobe). These cases were also associated with fairly strong fluxes of O⁺ ions in the outer mantle. Whilst the newly injected type of magnetosheath-like structure contained almost no O⁺ ions, the stagnant regions were intermixed by an appreciable amount of ionospheric ions. The newly injected and stagnant penetration regions had both in common a diamagnetic decrease of the ambient magnetic field. The newly injected structures, however, were also associated with a considerable reorientation of the magnetic field vector. A common feature for penetration regions well separated from the magnetopause is that they are mainly observed for a southward IMF. A third category of plasma mantle penetrated events, denoted “open magnetopause” events, usually occurred when the IMF was away and northward. Characteristics for these events were a smooth transition/rotation of the magnetic field vector near the magnetopause, and fairly high ion densities in the mantle and the transition region.     

Solar wind access to the plasma sheet along the flanks of the magnetotail

Low-energy particle trajectories in an idealized magnetotail magnetic field are investigated to determine the accessibility of magnetosheath protons and electrons to the plasma sheet along the flanks of the tail magnetopause. The drift motion of the positively (negatively) charged particles incident on the dawn (dusk) magnetotail flank causes such particles to penetrate deeper into the magnetotail. For certain combinations of particle energy, incident velocity vector and initial penetration point on the tail magnetopause, the incident particles can become trapped in the plasma sheet, after which their net drift motion then provides a current capable of supporting the entire observed magnetotail field. The results further indicate that the bulk of the solar wind plasma just outside the distant tail boundary, which streams preferentially in a direction along the magnetopause away from the Earth at velocities around 400 km s^?1, can be caught up in the tail if the initial penetration point is within about 2R_E, of the quasi-neutral sheet. It is suggested that a large fraction of the magnetotail plasma is composed of former solar wind particles which have penetrated the magnetospheric boundary at the tail flanks.     

Interpretation of magnetic field perturbations in the earth's magnetopause boundary layers

Studies of the boundary layers in the vicinity of the Earth's dayside magnetopause are important in determining the nature of the processes which couple the magnetosphere to the flowing solar wind, thereby driving magnetospheric convection. In this paper we examine theoretically the magnetic field and plasma properties expected in the boundary regions for various models involving either diffusion or reconnection at the boundary. For diffusion models the transport of magnetosheath momentum across the magnetopause will result in field shears on either side of the boundary, the field rotations being in opposite senses on either side relative to the undisturbed fields. The directions of these rotations depend upon location at the magnetopause relative to the momentum transfer region and to the noon meridian. In reconnection models the effect of the tension of the open boundary layer field lines must be taken into account in addition to the magnetosheath flow, but on the super-Alfvénic flanks of the magnetosphere the latter still dominates, so that qualitatively similar effects will occur in the two models. More detailed, quantitative or statistical studies are then required to distinguish the two models in this regime. In the sub-Alfvénic dayside region, however, open field tension effects will dominate in reconnection models such that boundary layer field and plasma properties will then be determined mainly by the magnetosheath magnetic field configuration. In particular the East-West flow in the magnetospheric boundary layer will be controlled largely by the East-West field in the magnetosheath, leading to flow reversals across the magnetopause in some quadrants of the magnetopause. This behaviour is directly related to the Svalgaard-Mansurov effect and is a signature unique to reconnection models. The boundary layer fields are also expected to tilt towards the field on the opposite side of the boundary in these models on the dayside. “Toward” tilting can also occur in this regime in diffusion models, but “away” tilting, a signature unique to dayside diffusion, should also occur equally frequently. Finally, we briefly discuss previously published high-resolution ISEE 1 and 2 data from the boundary regions in the light of our results. We find that “toward” tilting generally occurs in boundary region crossings previously identified as being reconnection-associated and we present some examples in which the above unique reconnection signature has been observed. During impulsive FTE-like events, however, the field may tilt in either direction, possibly as a result of field line twists, thus complicating our simple picture in this case. We also show that the “reverse draping” observations presented by Hones et al. (1982) approximately satisfy the open magnetopause stress balance conditions.     

Solar wind energy transfer regions inside the dayside magnetopause—I. Evidence for magnetosheath plasma penetration

PROGNOZ-7 high temporal resolution measurements of the ion composition and hot plasma distribution in the dayside high latitude boundary layer near noon have revealed that magnetosheath plasma may penetrate the dayside magnetopause and form high density, high β, magnetosheath-like regions inside the magnetopause. We will from these measurements demonstrate that the magnetosheath injection regions most probably play an important role in transferring solar wind energy into the magnetosphere. The transfer regions are characterized by a strong perpendicular flow towards dawn or dusk (depending on local time) but are also observed to expand rapidly along the boundary layer field lines. This increased flow component transverse to the local magnetic field corresponds to a predominantly radial electric field of up to several mV m^?1, which indicates that the injected magnetosheath plasma causes an enhanced polarization of the boundary layer. Polarization of the boundary layer can therefore be considered a result of a local MHD-process where magnetosheath plasma excess momentum is converted into electromagnetic energy (electric field), i.e. we have primarily an MHD-generator there. We state primarily because we also observe acceleration of “cold” ions inside the magnetopause as a result of this radial electric field. A few cases of polarity reversals suggest that the polarization is sometimes quite localized.The perhaps most significant finding is that the boundary layer is observed to be charged up to tens of kilovolts, a potential which may be highly variable depending on e.g. the presence of a momentum exchange by the energy transfer regions.     

Electron precipitation equatorward of the auroral oval and the mantle aurora in the midday sector

In the midday sector, the hard electron precipitation and the associated patchy aurora at geomagnetic latitude ～65° are the only auroral features (? 20 keV) located equatorward of the dayside auroral oval during intense and moderately disturbed geomagnetic conditions. We identify the patchy luminosity in the midday and late morning sectors as the active mantle aurora. The mantle aurora was found by Sanford (1964) using the IGY-IGC auroral patrol spectrographs and which was thought to be non-visual. The precipitating electrons reside mostly at energies greater than several keV with an energy flux of ? 0.1 erg cm^?2 s^?1 sr^?1 during geomagnetic active periods. This hard precipitation occurs in a region which is asymmetric in L.T. with respect to the noon meridian. The region extends from the morning sector to only early afternoon (13–14 M.L.T.) along the geomagnetic latitude circle of about 65–70°. The model calculation indicates that the mantle aurora is produced by the precipitation of the energetic electrons which drift azimuthally from the plasma sheet at the midnight sector to the dayside magnetopause during magnetospheric substorms.     

Energetic electrons in the cusp and in the high latitude plasma sheet: Evidence for source regions

HEOS-2 has observed energetic electrons (> 40 keV) in the high latitude magnetosphere appearing as one or more peaks outside and often well separated from the trapping boundary. Most of the observations are between 70° and 80° invariant latitudes both in the day and nightside. The peaks are located in the dayside adjacent to the polar cusp and coincide in the nightside with the edge of the plasma sheet. The electron peak intensity on the nightside shows a clear correlation with AE. The electron peak intensities on the dayside exceed those on the nightside and are generally higher in the pre-noon than in the afternoon sector. Observations on the dayside in the distant cusp region and in the adjacent magnetosheath show high and fluctuating intensities of energetic electronswith an energy spectrum much harder than in the outermost trapping region.

This observational evidence suggests different source regions for these energetic electrons: one in the distant geomagnetic tail and another one around the dayside cusp indentation.     

Solar wind energy transfer regions inside the dayside magnetopause: Accelerated heavy ions as tracers for MHD-processes in the dayside boundary layer

Plasma and magnetic field data from PROGNOZ-7 have revealed that solar wind (magnetosheath) plasma elements may penetrate the dayside magnetopause surface and form high density regions with enhanced cross-field flow in the boundary layer.The injected magnetosheath plasma is observed to have an excess drift velocity as compared to the local boundary layer plasma, comprising both “cold” plasma of terrestrial origin and a hot ring current component. A differential drift between two plasma components can be understood in terms of a momentum transfer process driven by an injected magnetosheath plasma population. The braking action of the injected plasma may be described as a dynamo process where particle kinetic energy is transferred into electromagnetic energy (electric field). The generated electric field will force the local plasma to $\text{ε×}\text{B}\text{-drift}$, and the dynamo region therefore also constitutes an accelerator region for the local plasma. Whenever energy is dissipated from the energy transfer process (a net current is flowing through a load), there will also be a difference between the induced electric field and the $\text{v}\text{×}\text{B}$ term of the generator plasma. Thus, the local plasma will drift more slowly than the injected generator plasma.We will present observations showing that a relation between the momentum transferred, the injected plasma and the momentum taken up by the local plasma exists. For instance, if the local plasma density is sufficiently high, the differential drift velocity of the injected and local plasma will be small. A large fraction of the excess momentum is then transferred to the local plasma. Conversely, a low local plasma density results in a high velocity difference and a low fraction of local momentum transfer.In our study cases the “cold” plasma component was frequently found to dominate the local magnetospheric plasma density in the boundary layer. Accordingly, this component may have the largest influence on the local momentum transfer process. We will demonstrate that this also seems to be the case. Moreover we show that the accelerated “cold” plasma component may be used as a tracer element reflecting both the momentum and energy transfer and the penetration process in the dayside boundary layer.The high He⁺ percentage of the accelerated “cold” plasma indicates a plasmaspheric origin. Considering the quite high densities of energetic He⁺ found in the boundary layer, the overall low abundance of He⁺ (as compared to e.g. O⁺) found in the plasma sheet and outer ring current evidently reduces the importance of the dayside boundary layer as a plasma source in the large scale magnetospheric circulation system.     

Two spacecraft observation of particle bursts at the distant magnetopause and in the magnetotail boundary layer

Bursts of energetic particles have been observed simultaneously by IMP-6 (≈ 24 R_E, R_p ? 0.21 MeV) and IMP-8 (≈ 29.7 R_E, E_p ? 0.29 MeV, E_e ? 0.22 MeV) in the distant magnetotail on Nov. 26, 1973 at a time when the auroral electrojet showed significant intensification. During one of the bursts IMP-6 was briefly in the duskside plasma sheet and IMP-8 was only a few R_E away at the magnetopause/boundary layer, as revealed from magnetic field and plasma measurements. The time behaviour of the proton intensities and anisotropies indicate that the particles have their origin in the plasma sheet. Measurements of the energy spectra during one of the bursts in the boundary layer/magnetosheath show significant variation of the differential exponent and suggest a rigidity-dependent escape of energetic particles from the plasma sheet into the magnetosheath. With the high temporal resolution of IMP-8 data intensity peaks of relativistic electrons and/or energetic protons could be detected at the magnetopause when Bx ≈ 0 γ. They appear superimposed on the general intensity time profile of the burst and last 2–3 min. It is concluded that some of the relativistic electrons can escape from the plasma sheet very fast and form a temporally-varying layer at the magnetopause.     

Boundary layer plasmas as a source for high-latitude, early afternoon, auroral arcs

Simultaneous measurements of hot boundary layer plasma from PROGNOZ-7 and particle precipitation from the TIROS/NOAA satellite in nearly magnetically conjugate regions have been used to study the dynamo process responsible for the formation of high latitude, early afternoon, auroral arcs.

Characteristic for the PROGNOZ-7 observations in the dayside boundary layer at high latitudes is the frequent occurrence of regions with injected magnetosheath plasma embedded in a “halo” of antisunward flowing magnetosphere plasma. The injected magnetosheath plasma have several features which indicate that it also acts as a local source of EMF in the boundary layer. The process resembles that of a local MHD dynamo driven by the excess drift velocity of the injected magnetosheath plasma relative to the background magnetospheric plasma.

The dynamo region is capable of driving field-aligned currents that couple to the ionosphere, where the upward current is associated with the high latitude auroral arcs.

We demonstrate that the large-scale morphology as well as the detailed data intercomparison between PROGNOZ-7 and TIROS-N both agree well with a local injection of magnetosheath plasma into the dayside boundary layer as the main dynamo process powering the high-latitude, early afternoon auroral arcs.     

Solar wind energy transfer regions inside the dayside magnetopause—II. Evidence for an MHD generator process

In this paper a quantitative analysis of magnetosheath injection regions observed by PROGNOZ-7 in the dayside high latitude boundary layer is performed. Particular emphasis is laid on describing the consequences of the observed excess transverse momentum of solar wind ions (H⁺ and He²⁺) as compared to the magnetospheric ions (e.g. He⁺ and O⁺) in the magnetosheath injection regions, hereafter referred to as energy transfer regions.An important result of this study is that the observed excess drift velocity of the solar wind ions as compared to the magnetospheric ions can be interpreted as a negative inertia current being present in the boundary layer. This means that the inertia current goes against the local electric field and that particle kinetic energy is converted into electric energy there. The dayside high-latitude boundary layer therefore constitutes a voltage generator (at least with respect to the injected magnetosheath plasma).The MHD-theory predicts a strong coupling of the energy transfer process in the boundary layer and the ionosphere, both regions being connected by field aligned currents. The rate of decay of the inertia current in the injected plasma element is in the range of a few minutes, a value which is directly proportional to the ionospheric resistance. By taking into account both the Hall and the Pedersen conductivities in the ionosphere, the theory also predicts a strong coupling between ionospheric East/West and North/South currents. A considerable part of the inertia current may actually flow in the tangential (East/West) direction due to this coupling. Thus, a consequence of the boundary layer energy transfer process is that it may generate currents, powering other magnetospheric plasma processes, down to ionospheric heights.     

Interball contribution to the high-altitude cusp observations

The polar cusps have traditionally been described as narrow funnel-shaped regions of magnetospheric magnetic field lines directly connected to magnetosheath, allowing the magnetosheath plasma to precipitate into the ionosphere. However, recent observations and theoretical considerations revealed that the formation of the cusp cannot be treated separately from the processes along the whole dayside magnetopause and that the plasma in regions like cleft or low-latitude boundary layer is of the same origin. Our review of statistical results as well as numerous case studies identified the anti-parallel merging at the magnetopause as the principal source of the magnetosheath plasma in all altitudes. Since effective merging requires a low plasma speed at the reconnection spot, we have found that the magnetopause shape and especially its indentation at the outer cusp is a very important part of the whole process. The plasma is slowed down in this indentation and arising multiscale turbulent processes enhance the reconnection rate.     

The dawn polar cap boundary at high altitude

Comparison of hot plasma data from ATS-6 and GEOS-1 when the satellites were near dawn L.T. conjunction reveals the presence of strong gradients separating plasmas differing by more than two orders of magnitude in keV particle fluxes. These gradients are observed at off-equatorial geomagnetic latitudes of 25–30° on field lines outside the synchronous orbit. They are associated with magnetic storms and are distinct from magnetopause crossings. Interpretation of these events in terms of a boundary between magnetospheric and polar-cap plasma leads to the following conclusions: (1) the polar cap/lobe region is essentially devoid of keV plasma at these times; (2) the field lines defining this boundary are significantly distorted from a dipolar to a more stretched form consistent with the presence of a storm-ring current, (3) smaller substorm-scale motions are superposed on the gross motion of the boundary with some evidence present for structure in the plasma spatial profile, and (4) magnetosheath-like plasma finds access to the inner magnetosphere at dawn L.T., much as it does near noon, along polar-cap boundary-layer field lines which close through the low latitude magnetospheric boundary layer.     

Plasma properties in the dayside cusp region

A statistical study of the cusp plasma has been performed using mainly electron data from the LPS, Rome, plasma experiment flown onboard HEOS-2. We have located the cusp by means of 35–50 eV electrons, from 1.5 to 2.5R_E (south pole) and from 3R_E up to 11R_E (north pole) at 60–70° SM latitude within ±60° of SM longitude from the noon meridan plane. The average cusp thickness is 4.2° of invariant latitude. The location of the cusp in invariant latitude around the noon meridian plane depends on the IMF component B_zGSM according to the linear best fit: Λ = 78.7° + 0.48B_zGSM(γ). Away from the noon meridian plane the invariant latitude of the cusp decreases from 79–84° to 70–74° (at ±50° SM Longitude). At the equatorward edge of the north pole cusp, at all radial distances and at all SM longitudes, we have found a population of electrons with a harder energy spectrum than in the cusp itself. These electrons show a peak at 170–280 eV in our data. They are not the cusp (35–50 eV) electrons and are easily distinguishable from the 1 keV magnetospheric electrons. In the south pole auroral oval they are found at any SM longitude mainly poleward of the 1 keV electrons. The cusp electrons (35–50 eV) and protons have anisotropies that vary with radial distance and SM latitude, both flowing earthward more or less along the magnetic field.     

A mathematical magnetospheric field model with independent physical parameters

A quantitative magnetospheric magnetic field model has been calculated in three dimensions. The model is based on an analytical solution of the Chapman-Ferraro problem. For this solution, the magnetopause was assumed to be an infinitesimally thin discontinuity with given geometry. The shape of the dayside magnetopause is in agreement with measurements derived from spacecraft boundary crossings.The magnetic field of the magnetopause currents can be derived from scalar potentials. The scalar potentials result from solutions of Laplace's equation with Neumann's boundary conditions. The boundary values and the magnetic flux through the magnetopause are determined by all magnetic sources which are located inside and outside the magnetospheric cavity. They include the Earth's dipole field, the fields of the equatorial ring current and tail current systems, and the homogeneous interplanetary magnetic field. In addition, the flux through the magnetopause depends on two constants of interconnection which provide the possibility of calculating static interconnection between magnetospheric and interplanetary field lines. Realistic numerical values for both constants have been derived empirically from observed displacements of the polar cusps which are due to changes in the orientation of the interplanetary field. The transition from a closed to an open magnetosphere and vice versa can be computed in terms of a change of the magnetic boundary conditions on the magnetopause. The magnetic field configuration of the closed magnetosphere is independent of the amount and orientation of the interplanetary field. In contrast, the configuration of the open magnetosphere confirms the observational finding that field line interconnection occurs primarily in the polar cusp and high latitude tail regions.The tail current system reflects explicitly the effect of dayside magnetospheric compression which is caused by the solar wind. In addition, the position of the plasma sheet relative to the ecliptic plane depends explicitly on the tilt angle of the Earth's dipole. Near the tail axis, the tail field is approximately in a self-consistent equilibrium with the tail currents and the isotropic thermal plasma.The models for the equatorial ring current depend on the D_st-parameter. They are self-consistent with respect to measured energy distributions of ring current protons and the axially symmetric part of the magnetospheric field.     

On solar wind interaction with the earth's magnetosphere

Hydrodynamic and electrodynamic problems of solar wind interaction with the Earth's magnetosphere on the day-side are investigated.The initial fact, well established, is that the density of the magnetic field energy in the solar wind is rather small. Magnetic field intensity and orientation are shown to determine the character of the solar wind flow around the magnetosphere. For mean parameters of the wind, if the tangential component of the magnetic field is more or equal 5γ, the flow in the magneto-sheath will be laminar. For other cases the flow is of a turbulent type.For turbulent flow, typical plasma parameters are estimated: mean free path, internal scale of inhomogeneities and dissipated energy. The results obtained are compared with experimental data.For the case of laminar flow, special attention is paid to the situation when magnetic fields of the solar wind and Earth are antiparallel. It is suggested, on the basis of solid arguments, that the southward interplanetary field diffuses from the magnetosheath into the Earth's magnetosphere. These ideas are used for the estimation of the distance to the magnetopause subsolar point. A detailed comparison with results of observation is made. The coincidence is satisfactory. Theoretical investigation has been made to a great extent for thin magnetopause with thickness δ ～ R_He-gyroradius of an electron.It is shown that during magnetospheric substorms relaxation oscillations with the period τ = 100–300 sec must appear. A theorem is proved about the appearance of a westward electrical field during the substorm development, when the magnetosphere's day-side boundary moves Earthward and about the recovery phase, when the magnetopause motion is away from the Earth, when there is an eastward electrical field.In the Appendix, plasma wave exitation in the magnetopause is considered and conductivity magnitudes are calculated, including the reduction due to the scattering by plasma turbulence.     

Influence of the magnetosheath on solar proton penetration into the magnetosphere

The observation of solar protons (1–9 MeV) aboard HEOS-2 in the high-latitude magnetotail and magnetosheath on 9 June 1972, and their comparison with simultaneous measurements on Explorers 41 and 43, both in interplanetary space, indicate the existence of a distinct region of the inner magnetosheath (about 3 Earth radii thick) near the high-latitude magnetopause in which the solar particle flow is almost reversed with respect to the flow observed in interplanetary space. The region can also be seen by comparing magnetic field measurements on the three spacecraft. The observations in the outer layer of the magnetotail show solar protons predominantly entering the magnetosphere somewhere near the Earth, perhaps the cusp region.     

Monitoring of energy spectra of particle bursts in the plasma sheet and magnetosheath

Energetic ion (E ? 290 keV) and electron (E_e ? 220 keV) burst intensities were simultaneously monitored at various regions of the plasma sheet and magnetosheath by the CPME JHU/APL instruments on board the IMP-7 and 8 s/c during an extended period from day 250, 1975 to day 250, 1976 when the two spacecraft were closely trailing each other in crossing the geomagnetotail. The energy spectra of the energetic particle populations of different regions in the magnetotail were also computed and monitored simultaneously at the positions of the two spacecraft. The results indicate that the energetic particle intensities are higher and the energy spectra in general considerably softer inside the plasma sheet than the adjacent magnetosheath. The spectral index γ of a power law fit in the computed energy spectrum inside the plasma sheet occasionally exceeds γ > 10 for the ions and γ > 6 for the electrons. Furthermore simultaneous monitoring of particle intensities in the vicinity of the neutral sheet and the high latitude plasma sheet shows higher intensities in the former region. The observations suggest that the energetic particles escape to the magnetosheath from their source inside the plasma sheet by a rigidity dependent process. A dawn-dusk asymmetry in the particle acceleration and escape processes is implied in the observations and discussed in detail.